Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Author Message
jacksfan29! Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,444
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Jackrabbits, Army, CU
Location: Colorado
Post: #101
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 12:15 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:55 AM)ken d Wrote:  What is clear to me is that FCS teams have no business playing P4 teams except as preseason exhibitions.

Why? Some spend nearly as much as G6 programs.

Some spend more...
09-15-2026 12:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,437
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #102
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 07:27 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  Through this week:

P4 vs FCS 37 - 0
P4 vs G6 43 - 2
G6 vs FCS 48 - 4

The FCS vs G6 is closer than G6 vs P4. I also don't believe in playing down two divisions.

Agree that P4 schools shouldn’t be playing FCS programs. There are now 138 FBS programs (68 P4 plus 70 G6) that play with comparable, larger rosters and commit more resources to football. I imagine that playing FCS programs now results from conference mandates (e.g., the P4 conference doesn’t want G6 away games) and school financials (e.g., lower cost for buy games).

Similar to the proposed 10 game minimum requirement for P4 versus P4 games, the CFP expansion compromise should try to discourage FCS games for the P4. This new collegiate model works better with standardized schedules.
09-15-2026 01:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
army56mike Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 12,787
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 429
I Root For: Liberty & UofL
Location: Shepherdsville, KY
Post: #103
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 08:51 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 07:27 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  Through this week:

P4 vs FCS 37 - 0
P4 vs G6 43 - 2
G6 vs FCS 48 - 4

The FCS vs G6 is closer than G6 vs P4. I also don't believe in playing down two divisions.

Well FCS needs P4 money/bodybag games to survive. If the P4 stops playing them a lot of programs dry up and fade away.

This! This is true.
09-15-2026 01:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #104
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

I like, and have liked, the approach of South Florida to growth. You accomplished a major feat that has been recognized and watched. You improved your academic standing prior to seeking athletic improvement.

Your enrollment is approaching numbers which can sustain a growing athletic budget.

Your athletics has had past success.

Your location is unique, being the only potentially major school on the Gulf side of Florida.

The only mistake, and this is just my opinion, that the school has made was in underbuilding its new stadium. If it is a boost up in conference status that you are seeking, and you should be seeking one, then building a stadium in the 75,000 or 80,000 capacity range would have sent a much stronger signal to P conferences. Even if you lack the crowd to fill it, the several P games you could schedule a year would help to fill it, pay for it, and help your appeal to television audience which is one hurdle you have yet to clear.

I've repeatedly said that USF was 10 years away and that started 3 years ago.

Now to address what has been said thus far in this thread, the P4 don't have to break away to put even more distance between them and the G6. 10 P games is what we are looking at now. Does anyone know why? Each contract period the P conferences earn more revenue by agreeing to another P game on the schedule. Next contract period (think 2031-36) they might wind up selling another or selling both remaining games if they can get a preseason game that counts as the 7th home game in their season ticket books. The P conferences are on course to eliminate not only FCS games from their schedules, but G games as well. And it has nothing to do with the desire to harm either of those but only the self-interest of making more money from their media contracts. That's the handwriting on the wall that is ignored here. A breakaway is not about media contracts for football. That separation is underway and by contractual agreement. If a breakaway from the NCAA happens it will be to fully monetize basketball.

Now back to USF's issues and your question, if the PCSA passes with its 19-member cap and 5-year restriction on the movement of P schools to another conference, USF becomes the #1 prospect among G schools for promotion. You have the academics, you have the location with potential great market reach, and you would be available immediately. The problem is you don't have a travel partner with the same plusses, and no conference likes odd numbers of members.

Your best bet for near term advancement was an ACC raid opening a slot if one or both of their Florida schools were taken. And your weakness that impacts the SEC and Big Ten is that currently you don't generate enough viewership within your great market or have facilities for football that meet their mean attendance numbers for member schools which impacts your revenue generation for athletics. But at least there if you got into either of the SEC or Big Ten your viewership numbers would improve overnight. So, the capacity of the stadium and revenue generation are what you need to improve, IMO.

What you don't want to be is the best G candidate when the P4 move to 12 P games.
09-15-2026 02:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #105
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 11:01 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:47 AM)UCBearcatlawjd2 Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

Add that group to a power conference and they will be fine.

We have 2-3 years of ratings for SMU, UCF, BYU, Houston and Cincinnati. Only BYU’s ratings are “fine”. The rest have been lacking. Additionally, I think Houston is still struggling with attendance.

Well also those 4 had significantly higher ratings than any of these schools while still a G school:
BYU 1.651
UCF 1.629
Cincinnati 1.557
Houston 1.409
09-15-2026 02:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
celldweller7 Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 469
Joined: Mar 2024
Reputation: 110
I Root For: Oklahoma State
Location:
Post: #106
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 02:12 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

I like, and have liked, the approach of South Florida to growth. You accomplished a major feat that has been recognized and watched. You improved your academic standing prior to seeking athletic improvement.

Your enrollment is approaching numbers which can sustain a growing athletic budget.

Your athletics has had past success.

Your location is unique, being the only potentially major school on the Gulf side of Florida.

The only mistake, and this is just my opinion, that the school has made was in underbuilding its new stadium. If it is a boost up in conference status that you are seeking, and you should be seeking one, then building a stadium in the 75,000 or 80,000 capacity range would have sent a much stronger signal to P conferences. Even if you lack the crowd to fill it, the several P games you could schedule a year would help to fill it, pay for it, and help your appeal to television audience which is one hurdle you have yet to clear.

I've repeatedly said that USF was 10 years away and that started 3 years ago.

Now to address what has been said thus far in this thread, the P4 don't have to break away to put even more distance between them and the G6. 10 P games is what we are looking at now. Does anyone know why? Each contract period the P conferences earn more revenue by agreeing to another P game on the schedule. Next contract period (think 2031-36) they might wind up selling another or selling both remaining games if they can get a preseason game that counts as the 7th home game in their season ticket books. The P conferences are on course to eliminate not only FCS games from their schedules, but G games as well. And it has nothing to do with the desire to harm either of those but only the self-interest of making more money from their media contracts. That's the handwriting on the wall that is ignored here. A breakaway is not about media contracts for football. That separation is underway and by contractual agreement. If a breakaway from the NCAA happens it will be to fully monetize basketball.

Now back to USF's issues and your question, if the PCSA passes with its 19-member cap and 5-year restriction on the movement of P schools to another conference, USF becomes the #1 prospect among G schools for promotion. You have the academics, you have the location with potential great market reach, and you would be available immediately. The problem is you don't have a travel partner with the same plusses, and no conference likes odd numbers of members.

Your best bet for near term advancement was an ACC raid opening a slot if one or both of their Florida schools were taken. And your weakness that impacts the SEC and Big Ten is that currently you don't generate enough viewership within your great market or have facilities for football that meet their mean attendance numbers for member schools which impacts your revenue generation for athletics. But at least there if you got into either of the SEC or Big Ten your viewership numbers would improve overnight. So, the capacity of the stadium and revenue generation are what you need to improve, IMO.

What you don't want to be is the best G candidate when the P4 move to 12 P games.

Who is building a 75,000 seat stadium that didn't already have one in the last decade? OU is dropping below that capacity with their new remodel.
09-15-2026 02:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #107
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 02:39 PM)celldweller7 Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 02:12 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

I like, and have liked, the approach of South Florida to growth. You accomplished a major feat that has been recognized and watched. You improved your academic standing prior to seeking athletic improvement.

Your enrollment is approaching numbers which can sustain a growing athletic budget.

Your athletics has had past success.

Your location is unique, being the only potentially major school on the Gulf side of Florida.

The only mistake, and this is just my opinion, that the school has made was in underbuilding its new stadium. If it is a boost up in conference status that you are seeking, and you should be seeking one, then building a stadium in the 75,000 or 80,000 capacity range would have sent a much stronger signal to P conferences. Even if you lack the crowd to fill it, the several P games you could schedule a year would help to fill it, pay for it, and help your appeal to television audience which is one hurdle you have yet to clear.

I've repeatedly said that USF was 10 years away and that started 3 years ago.

Now to address what has been said thus far in this thread, the P4 don't have to break away to put even more distance between them and the G6. 10 P games is what we are looking at now. Does anyone know why? Each contract period the P conferences earn more revenue by agreeing to another P game on the schedule. Next contract period (think 2031-36) they might wind up selling another or selling both remaining games if they can get a preseason game that counts as the 7th home game in their season ticket books. The P conferences are on course to eliminate not only FCS games from their schedules, but G games as well. And it has nothing to do with the desire to harm either of those but only the self-interest of making more money from their media contracts. That's the handwriting on the wall that is ignored here. A breakaway is not about media contracts for football. That separation is underway and by contractual agreement. If a breakaway from the NCAA happens it will be to fully monetize basketball.

Now back to USF's issues and your question, if the PCSA passes with its 19-member cap and 5-year restriction on the movement of P schools to another conference, USF becomes the #1 prospect among G schools for promotion. You have the academics, you have the location with potential great market reach, and you would be available immediately. The problem is you don't have a travel partner with the same plusses, and no conference likes odd numbers of members.

Your best bet for near term advancement was an ACC raid opening a slot if one or both of their Florida schools were taken. And your weakness that impacts the SEC and Big Ten is that currently you don't generate enough viewership within your great market or have facilities for football that meet their mean attendance numbers for member schools which impacts your revenue generation for athletics. But at least there if you got into either of the SEC or Big Ten your viewership numbers would improve overnight. So, the capacity of the stadium and revenue generation are what you need to improve, IMO.

What you don't want to be is the best G candidate when the P4 move to 12 P games.

Who is building a 75,000 seat stadium that didn't already have one in the last decade? OU is dropping below that capacity with their new remodel.

In the history of humanity, the concept of building or reconstructing to attract the elite has been an off and on fad that always ends poorly. Public institutions should be built for the public and their facilities for the same. Look at the wealthiest schools in term of annual revenue and they all have the same thing in common. They sell out their very large venues. It's the public who supports athletics. The super wealthy only do so when it suits them. Didn't like sky boxes but it allowed schools to do both at the same time (enlarge their capacity & cater to super wealthy donors).
09-15-2026 03:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
SFLFB Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 836
Joined: Sep 2023
Reputation: 245
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #108
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 02:12 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

I like, and have liked, the approach of South Florida to growth. You accomplished a major feat that has been recognized and watched. You improved your academic standing prior to seeking athletic improvement.

Your enrollment is approaching numbers which can sustain a growing athletic budget.

Your athletics has had past success.

Your location is unique, being the only potentially major school on the Gulf side of Florida.

The only mistake, and this is just my opinion, that the school has made was in underbuilding its new stadium. If it is a boost up in conference status that you are seeking, and you should be seeking one, then building a stadium in the 75,000 or 80,000 capacity range would have sent a much stronger signal to P conferences. Even if you lack the crowd to fill it, the several P games you could schedule a year would help to fill it, pay for it, and help your appeal to television audience which is one hurdle you have yet to clear.

I've repeatedly said that USF was 10 years away and that started 3 years ago.

Now to address what has been said thus far in this thread, the P4 don't have to break away to put even more distance between them and the G6. 10 P games is what we are looking at now. Does anyone know why? Each contract period the P conferences earn more revenue by agreeing to another P game on the schedule. Next contract period (think 2031-36) they might wind up selling another or selling both remaining games if they can get a preseason game that counts as the 7th home game in their season ticket books. The P conferences are on course to eliminate not only FCS games from their schedules, but G games as well. And it has nothing to do with the desire to harm either of those but only the self-interest of making more money from their media contracts. That's the handwriting on the wall that is ignored here. A breakaway is not about media contracts for football. That separation is underway and by contractual agreement. If a breakaway from the NCAA happens it will be to fully monetize basketball.

Now back to USF's issues and your question, if the PCSA passes with its 19-member cap and 5-year restriction on the movement of P schools to another conference, USF becomes the #1 prospect among G schools for promotion. You have the academics, you have the location with potential great market reach, and you would be available immediately. The problem is you don't have a travel partner with the same plusses, and no conference likes odd numbers of members.

Your best bet for near term advancement was an ACC raid opening a slot if one or both of their Florida schools were taken. And your weakness that impacts the SEC and Big Ten is that currently you don't generate enough viewership within your great market or have facilities for football that meet their mean attendance numbers for member schools which impacts your revenue generation for athletics. But at least there if you got into either of the SEC or Big Ten your viewership numbers would improve overnight. So, the capacity of the stadium and revenue generation are what you need to improve, IMO.

What you don't want to be is the best G candidate when the P4 move to 12 P games.

Unfortunately construction costs were severely limiting. There are plans for expansion to ~50,000, but our stadium was built prioritizing premium seating, so the revenue (for us) will be significantly more than our RJS contract (peanuts). We also built the performance facility in conjunction with the OCS, so it was a 2 for 1 construction project. It will not be long before we expand, but that will probably be contingent on a new conference, or at least a few years of selling out the OCS first.
09-15-2026 04:13 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #109
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 04:13 PM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 02:12 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:41 AM)SFLFB Wrote:  
(09-15-2026 09:15 AM)bullet Wrote:  The problem with adding more than a handful of G schools into the 3rd and 4th conference is that it drags down the average TV ratings which drags down the value.

These are the Sic-em calculation of TV ratings for 2013-2021 and revenues for 23-24 compared to the Big 12 and ACC for some of these schools. (I didn't update for 24-25, but only Tulane and Boise had significant increases). It shows the big gap. And this doesn't even consider the amount of subsidy involved. I've also listed SMU's numbers, the last one in.

rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games (rated) rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
West
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
40 Oregon St 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Col St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
East
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina0.56 37,057 65,211,957
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494


None match the median Big 12 or ACC in any of those categories. Only Washington St., Oregon St., Boise St., Memphis, USF and Temple even beat SMU in ratings. Only those 6 and ECU got on rated channels the 4 times a year to qualify in the Sic-em rankings. TV just wasn't that interested. Only Oregon St. who was in the Pac 12 at the time beats SMU's revenues. San Diego St. seems to have been considered solely because of market/recruiting and their recent basketball success. Their ratings were pretty low.

Which comes first?

A. The attendance, the revenue (conference distribution), the preferred matchups (conference and OOC home games) and conference-secured TV slots

or

B. A different conference

I like, and have liked, the approach of South Florida to growth. You accomplished a major feat that has been recognized and watched. You improved your academic standing prior to seeking athletic improvement.

Your enrollment is approaching numbers which can sustain a growing athletic budget.

Your athletics has had past success.

Your location is unique, being the only potentially major school on the Gulf side of Florida.

The only mistake, and this is just my opinion, that the school has made was in underbuilding its new stadium. If it is a boost up in conference status that you are seeking, and you should be seeking one, then building a stadium in the 75,000 or 80,000 capacity range would have sent a much stronger signal to P conferences. Even if you lack the crowd to fill it, the several P games you could schedule a year would help to fill it, pay for it, and help your appeal to television audience which is one hurdle you have yet to clear.

I've repeatedly said that USF was 10 years away and that started 3 years ago.

Now to address what has been said thus far in this thread, the P4 don't have to break away to put even more distance between them and the G6. 10 P games is what we are looking at now. Does anyone know why? Each contract period the P conferences earn more revenue by agreeing to another P game on the schedule. Next contract period (think 2031-36) they might wind up selling another or selling both remaining games if they can get a preseason game that counts as the 7th home game in their season ticket books. The P conferences are on course to eliminate not only FCS games from their schedules, but G games as well. And it has nothing to do with the desire to harm either of those but only the self-interest of making more money from their media contracts. That's the handwriting on the wall that is ignored here. A breakaway is not about media contracts for football. That separation is underway and by contractual agreement. If a breakaway from the NCAA happens it will be to fully monetize basketball.

Now back to USF's issues and your question, if the PCSA passes with its 19-member cap and 5-year restriction on the movement of P schools to another conference, USF becomes the #1 prospect among G schools for promotion. You have the academics, you have the location with potential great market reach, and you would be available immediately. The problem is you don't have a travel partner with the same plusses, and no conference likes odd numbers of members.

Your best bet for near term advancement was an ACC raid opening a slot if one or both of their Florida schools were taken. And your weakness that impacts the SEC and Big Ten is that currently you don't generate enough viewership within your great market or have facilities for football that meet their mean attendance numbers for member schools which impacts your revenue generation for athletics. But at least there if you got into either of the SEC or Big Ten your viewership numbers would improve overnight. So, the capacity of the stadium and revenue generation are what you need to improve, IMO.

What you don't want to be is the best G candidate when the P4 move to 12 P games.

Unfortunately construction costs were severely limiting. There are plans for expansion to ~50,000, but our stadium was built prioritizing premium seating, so the revenue (for us) will be significantly more than our RJS contract (peanuts). We also built the performance facility in conjunction with the OCS, so it was a 2 for 1 construction project. It will not be long before we expand, but that will probably be contingent on a new conference, or at least a few years of selling out the OCS first.

USF needed to build what they could fill on most Saturdays. And provide for a reasonable way to expand it. That both maximizes what they can charge and encourages people to buy season tickets instead of waiting till game day when life gets in the way and they end up not going.

Although 40k is really kind of a minimum to build and be taken seriously. Only Duke, Wake Forest, SMU and soon, Northwestern are below 40k. There are a number in the 40s. By contrast, only 11 G schools play in 40k+ stadiums and 2 of those are in pro stadiums.
(This post was last modified: 09-15-2026 05:40 PM by bullet.)
09-15-2026 05:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
sigke Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 513
Joined: Dec 2025
Reputation: 45
I Root For: Delaware
Location: Philly suburbs
Post: #110
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:55 AM)ken d Wrote:  Rather than a G6 playoff, I would like to see them classified as a level below the P4, and the only level below P4 that counts toward bowl eligibility. What is clear to me is that FCS teams have no business playing P4 teams except as preseason exhibitions.

So schools like Rutgers are too good to play G6 teams....?
09-15-2026 06:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #111
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 08:43 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 03:01 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:07 PM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 01:47 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  Nobody within the G6 draws 40,000 to their games. None of them bring value to the P4 except UConn with their BB. The majority of P4 fans on here for whatever reason think the answer is moving 8-10 G6 programs (fan favorite Tulane) into the P4.

Those 8-10 belong where they are in a G6 conference. Most belong in a high G6 conference like the PAC or AC. SBC and MWC have some big ones too.

So the 45,600 for Arkansas State @ Memphis, the 41,800 for FIU @ South Florida, the 40,000 for App State @ ECU don't exist?

Not hard to believe either that App State, JMU, or Boise St (among others) could get to 40,000 if their stadiums held that much. Both App and JMU have stadium expansion projects in different phases underway.

I was talking about averaging 40,000 for the season. None of the G6 do that.

At Boise the attenance has trended down not up the last 10 to 15 seasons.

Not consistently. But USF, UTEP, ECU and Fresno have at times had seasons over 40k. USF had about 6 in a row, even over 50k, when they were in the Big East. ECU had about a 10 years streak over 40k before their program hit a bad spell.

It was back before those programs were reduced to existing in the current era of greater stratification of the haves over the have nots.
09-15-2026 06:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
sigke Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 513
Joined: Dec 2025
Reputation: 45
I Root For: Delaware
Location: Philly suburbs
Post: #112
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 02:58 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:39 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:36 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 12:15 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  Why? Some spend nearly as much as G6 programs.

99-0 in the past two seasons.

So what are you arguing, that 128 schools should just drop the sport?

No, they should compete against their peers.

Here is my problem with this..... the door should be open for programs to move up. If "complete against their peers" means schools don't have a path to move up, then I have a problem.

I would love to see the 10 FBS conferences merged into 5 groups with with relegation.

For example:
  • B1G and MAC + 3 CUSA schools merged into 1 group with two conferences
  • SEC and SunBelt + 3 CUSA schools merged into 1 group with 2 conferences
  • ACC & American + 3 CUSA schools merged into 1 group with 2 conferences
  • XII, PAC 12, MW & 1 CUSA merged into 1 group with 2 conferences

OR restore the PAC 12 to Power Level and do:
  • B1G and MAC
  • SEC and SunBelt
  • ACC & American
  • XII & CUSA
  • Pac12 & MW

The revenue sharing is at the "group level." Then you have relegation and promotion between the two conferences in each group BY SPORT.

The reason promotion and relegation currently doesn't work is because of the money. But if you merge the Power schools with their regional G league, then you can share money and implement promotion & relegation without relegated programs taking a pay cut.
09-15-2026 06:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,343
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #113
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 06:51 PM)sigke Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:58 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:39 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:36 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 12:15 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  Why? Some spend nearly as much as G6 programs.

99-0 in the past two seasons.

So what are you arguing, that 128 schools should just drop the sport?

No, they should compete against their peers.

Here is my problem with this..... the door should be open for programs to move up. If "complete against their peers" means schools don't have a path to move up, then I have a problem.

I would love to see the 10 FBS conferences merged into 5 groups with with relegation.

For example:
  • B1G and MAC + 3 CUSA schools merged into 1 group with two conferences
  • SEC and SunBelt + 3 CUSA schools merged into 1 group with 2 conferences
  • ACC & American + 3 CUSA schools merged into 1 group with 2 conferences
  • XII, PAC 12, MW & 1 CUSA merged into 1 group with 2 conferences

OR restore the PAC 12 to Power Level and do:
  • B1G and MAC
  • SEC and SunBelt
  • ACC & American
  • XII & CUSA
  • Pac12 & MW

The revenue sharing is at the "group level." Then you have relegation and promotion between the two conferences in each group BY SPORT.

The reason promotion and relegation currently doesn't work is because of the money. But if you merge the Power schools with their regional G league, then you can share money and implement promotion & relegation without relegated programs taking a pay cut.
If it comes down to that we'll just boot you all out instead.
09-15-2026 11:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
4x4hokies Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,045
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 182
I Root For: VT
Location:
Post: #114
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
The things I've seen like "remember that game 16 years ago" or "sometimes a team wins" aren't the arguments you think they are. You can remember that singular game 16 years ago that is even more rare now.

The schools are generally smaller, the programs generally less funded, the games generally less attended, and the ratings are generally lower. These are by orders of magnitude as well.

So pointing out an occasional exception doesn't mean they are competing on the same level. They should be separate divisions for fairness.

The FCS is closer to G5 funding and competition than the G5 is to the P4. It isn't an anti trust thing. It's how competitive divisions have evolved since the invention of the NCAA.
09-16-2026 12:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
46566 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,623
Joined: Dec 2019
Reputation: 25
I Root For: Gonzaga
Location: California
Post: #115
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-15-2026 12:09 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 11:50 PM)46566 Wrote:  I think G6 seems closer because the bottom of G6 seems lower. I think this is due to expansion of G6 into FCS callups. Though all but 1 FCS win was top 25 FCS teams. I think FCS as a whole is weaker then the bottom of the G6. Purely as more top FCS programs are called up. We expect at least UC Davis is a FBS potential upgrade. I think FCS now has a bigger drop off then it used to have.

Davis isn't a top 10 program this year and in the past 20, has rarely been considered a top 10 program. Davis has size, money and for some it is about being in CA though it seems outside of Fresno, CA doesn't really care about college football.

I was saying they're a top 25 FCS team. What they are is a team that already has their Olympic sports in a FBS conference. That alone gives them a leg up on other FCS teams. As long as they're somewhat decent and the sports upgrades are done they get a invite.
09-16-2026 12:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TerryD Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 16,979
Joined: Feb 2006
Reputation: 1269
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location: Grayson Highlands
Post: #116
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Here may be the real divisions, in the FBS, anyway:



[Image: HSVkLIMacAAcHll?format=jpg&name=small]
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2026 11:36 AM by TerryD.)
09-16-2026 11:36 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #117
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Terry, I saw that graphic in The Times this morning as well. It seems like you have to spend money to contend. Nobody is IMO winning the title with a roster outside the top twenty in spending.

Some surprises to me was Ole Miss isn't playing around, they are like 9th overall, ahead of traditional powers like Alabama, Penn State, Michigan and Georgia. LSU will not be facing a low-talent roster in Oxford this week. Of course I was pleased to see ND comfortably in the top ten.

Also, as a Bulls fan, I noted that UCF was down near the bottom, at around $18m. I've read reports that USF is spending over $20m on its roster this year, so we appear to be out-spending them, which doesn't bother me at all, LOL.

And also the ballooning effect. As the article notes, just two years ago Ohio State led the nation with a $20m roster. This year, that would put them in the bottom twenty among A4, down with UCF/West Virginia type schools. So costs just keep spiraling in a free market.

I wonder if the "Protect College Sports Act", which seems to be inching towards passage, would put the brakes on this, or no?
09-16-2026 11:45 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #118
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-16-2026 11:45 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Terry, I saw that graphic in The Times this morning as well. It seems like you have to spend money to contend. Nobody is IMO winning the title with a roster outside the top twenty in spending.

Some surprises to me was Ole Miss isn't playing around, they are like 9th overall, ahead of traditional powers like Alabama, Penn State, Michigan and Georgia. LSU will not be facing a low-talent roster in Oxford this week. Of course I was pleased to see ND comfortably in the top ten.

Also, as a Bulls fan, I noted that UCF was down near the bottom, at around $18m. I've read reports that USF is spending over $20m on its roster this year, so we appear to be out-spending them, which doesn't bother me at all, LOL.

And also the ballooning effect. As the article notes, just two years ago Ohio State led the nation with a $20m roster. This year, that would put them in the bottom twenty among A4, down with UCF/West Virginia type schools. So costs just keep spiraling in a free market.

I wonder if the "Protect College Sports Act", which seems to be inching towards passage, would put the brakes on this, or no?

Actually its increasing allowable revenue share from 22 million to close to 49 million. The existing 50 million numbers of the top schools then would bump up another 25 to 30 million.

It does seem however without being in the Top 20 of spending forget about winning a title. That is why for most other schools the goal should be a home playoff game on national TV. Which is why for the G6 outside the autobid I like the idea of an 8 team tournament with the Top 4 seeds hosting as opposed to just farming those schools out to random G6 bowl games. It would put some of the lower tier bowl games out of business but who wants those anyways.
09-16-2026 12:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #119
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-16-2026 12:11 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-16-2026 11:45 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Terry, I saw that graphic in The Times this morning as well. It seems like you have to spend money to contend. Nobody is IMO winning the title with a roster outside the top twenty in spending.

Some surprises to me was Ole Miss isn't playing around, they are like 9th overall, ahead of traditional powers like Alabama, Penn State, Michigan and Georgia. LSU will not be facing a low-talent roster in Oxford this week. Of course I was pleased to see ND comfortably in the top ten.

Also, as a Bulls fan, I noted that UCF was down near the bottom, at around $18m. I've read reports that USF is spending over $20m on its roster this year, so we appear to be out-spending them, which doesn't bother me at all, LOL.

And also the ballooning effect. As the article notes, just two years ago Ohio State led the nation with a $20m roster. This year, that would put them in the bottom twenty among A4, down with UCF/West Virginia type schools. So costs just keep spiraling in a free market.

I wonder if the "Protect College Sports Act", which seems to be inching towards passage, would put the brakes on this, or no?

Actually its increasing allowable revenue share from 22 million to close to 49 million. The existing 50 million numbers of the top schools then would bump up another 25 to 30 million.

It does seem however without being in the Top 20 of spending forget about winning a title. That is why for most other schools the goal should be a home playoff game on national TV. Which is why for the G6 outside the autobid I like the idea of an 8 team tournament with the Top 4 seeds hosting as opposed to just farming those schools out to random G6 bowl games. It would put some of the lower tier bowl games out of business but who wants those anyways.

I think what the ballooning payrolls has done has created a kind of starker grey area between the bottom of the A4 and the G6. Used to be that sure, schools like Georgia had more revenue than schools like Wake Forest, but the former we handcuffed on what they could spend it on. It gave the Wake Forests of the world a sliver of a chance that with a stroke of luck coaching hire, they could make some noise. But now, the top schools are really unleashed with their spending power, and it is putting a squeeze on the lower tier of A4, IMHO.
09-16-2026 01:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Stugray2 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,340
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 975
I Root For: tOSU SJSU Stan'
Location: South Bay Area CA
Post: #120
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 07:27 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  Through this week:

P4 vs FCS 37 - 0
P4 vs G6 43 - 2
G6 vs FCS 48 - 4

The FCS vs G6 is closer than G6 vs P4. I also don't believe in playing down two divisions.

I agree with this assessment, except that the gap from G6 to FCS is pretty similar to the gap from A4 to G6. This is demonstrated in the NFL draft numbers:

* 240 A4 players, including 97 of the first 100 (rounds 1-3) and 109 of 116 from rounds 4-6

* 13 G6 players, but only 3 of the first 100 (one each in rounds 1-3), and only 3 of the next 116 (all selected in round 4)

* 4 FCS players selected, all in rounds 4 and 5, but 2 of those 4 are from North Dakota State who are in G6 this year in the Mountain West.

* 1 player from the NFL international program was selected in round 7.

The NFL has never skewed more toward the "power" schools as talent pools than it does today, more than cutting in half the Group of and FCS players from even just five years ago. NIL and the transfer portal are the culprits. It used to be that rounds 3 (back end of day 2) and 5-7 had heavy G5 draft representation with some FCS, but that seems to be gone.

The data from many directions says that A4 has effectively separated a level from G6 with the overlap zone largely gone.
09-16-2026 01:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.