Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Author Message
AztecEmpire Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,079
Joined: May 2020
Reputation: 105
I Root For: SDSU
Location:
Post: #41
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:31 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 12:48 AM)DavidSt Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 10:55 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 10:19 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 07:27 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  Through this week:

P4 vs FCS 37 - 0
P4 vs G6 43 - 2
G6 vs FCS 48 - 4

The FCS vs G6 is closer than G6 vs P4. I also don't believe in playing down two divisions.

I’ve been harping on this for years now. G6 needs to be its own thing with its own playoffs. They should still be allowed to play up or down against P2/M2 competition or FCS, but they need their own separate postseason and national title.

In the CFP era with all of the G tier expansion I would say its appeared logical from that time forward.

Back in the BCS era conferences were smaller. You had the PAC and BE in the power club and the MWC usually conference rated #7 was competitive enough to make a serious push to join the club. MAC was winning 5 to 6 games against BCS opponents a year back then.

MWC and WAC both at the time. Each conferences had 3 to 4 teams that have competed good against P6 at the time.

Not really. Only Boise was as competitive as TCU, BYU and Utah. To show how strong those teams were, TCU went 12-2 vs P6 (2005-2011) and Utah was 21-12 from 1999 to 2010. Boise was about .500. Nowadays the top of the G6 is nowhere near as competitive.

Fresno and Hawaii were good before Boise turned into the G6 monster they've been the last 20 years.
09-14-2026 11:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #42
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Once again, I’m not a G6 guy.

However, the whole “Wouldn’t it be nice for the G6 to win against their own level in their own playoff?” argument is just such patronizing bunk. The G6 knows full well that their own playoff would be a downgrade. The P4 completely knows it’s a downgrade. It’s the proverbial “Don’t pee on my leg and tell me it’s raining” idiom whenever I see a P4 fan suggest that a G6-only playoff is somehow better for the G6.

If you don’t want G6 teams in the CFP, then just say that you don’t like them (and also want to violate antitrust law in the process by structurally shutting them out). But don’t come in with some type of argument that this is somehow doing the G6 a favor because they can now win some games. Western Michigan won at Michigan last week and no one can tell me otherwise. Go ahead and own your elitism if that’s the position, but stop with the disingenuous patronizing.
09-14-2026 11:53 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #43
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Rather than a G6 playoff, I would like to see them classified as a level below the P4, and the only level below P4 that counts toward bowl eligibility. What is clear to me is that FCS teams have no business playing P4 teams except as preseason exhibitions.
09-14-2026 11:55 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #44
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:55 AM)ken d Wrote:  What is clear to me is that FCS teams have no business playing P4 teams except as preseason exhibitions.

Why? Some spend nearly as much as G6 programs.
09-14-2026 12:15 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #45
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:31 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 12:48 AM)DavidSt Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 10:55 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 10:19 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 07:27 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  Through this week:

P4 vs FCS 37 - 0
P4 vs G6 43 - 2
G6 vs FCS 48 - 4

The FCS vs G6 is closer than G6 vs P4. I also don't believe in playing down two divisions.

I’ve been harping on this for years now. G6 needs to be its own thing with its own playoffs. They should still be allowed to play up or down against P2/M2 competition or FCS, but they need their own separate postseason and national title.

In the CFP era with all of the G tier expansion I would say its appeared logical from that time forward.

Back in the BCS era conferences were smaller. You had the PAC and BE in the power club and the MWC usually conference rated #7 was competitive enough to make a serious push to join the club. MAC was winning 5 to 6 games against BCS opponents a year back then.

MWC and WAC both at the time. Each conferences had 3 to 4 teams that have competed good against P6 at the time.

Not really. Only Boise was as competitive as TCU, BYU and Utah. To show how strong those teams were, TCU went 12-2 vs P6 (2005-2011) and Utah was 21-12 from 1999 to 2010. Boise was about .500. Nowadays the top of the G6 is nowhere near as competitive.

Logic and passionate arguments have nothing to do with the situation. College football is now a business "officially" by Court ruling. It has of course been unofficially a business essentially controlled by media multi national corporations since the 90's. They pay the money for more P games and realignment.

Now that it is officially a business, especially as that has just happened prior to the enrollment cliff demographic shift is what is pertinent. Why?

As a business it will operate to maximize profits. What are the networks paying for? More content laden schedules under the guise of P vs P matchups as many times on the 4 major conferences schedules as possible. We are now looking at a mandate of 10 being the new standard for judging the CFP participants.

Do we need a 24-school playoff? Hell no! When the BCS moved to the 4-team playoff how many years did we not have 1 blowout in the first two games. The two team BCS was too political and usually left 1 worthy claimant of the national title out, sometimes an undefeated school. The 4-team playoff was likely the most efficient model we could have for determining a national championship as the number of truly top-notch programs on any given year is sparse.

So why 8, 12, 16, or 24? Money. So, let's say the compromise in the immediate future is to 16, will there be more than 3 legit contenders? Odds are no. If the move is therefore made to increase revenue what will be the next request of the networks that bid on those games? Quality of match ups. If advertisers don't want to spend their money on the time slot of a game they believe may be a blowout but rather on games between the top 4 seeds what will the networks want for those other 4 games? They are going to want schools which have the largest national audiences to maximize ad revenue, or they are going to want P schools with large state followings for the same.

The networks know that eventual separation from the NCAA will happen now because the NCAA was set up as an amateur model and the costs of paying athletes will eventually force the NCAA's money sport out of the NCAA so they can maximize their revenue (basketball). The networks will use that break to set up a more profitable tournament if the P conferences don't get there first. But either way the networks will want the top brands, the best teams for that year, and the filler to be schools with large TV audiences. It won't be about inclusion for the tournament any more than it is about inclusion for the CFP. Frank can talk about the kiddie table all he wants, but he knows this is all moving in the direction of what profits the most and what profits the most sure as hell isn't concerned about fairness, or inclusion for smaller schools which they see as being the ultimate victims of the enrollment cliff.

Right now, the networks just want more teams in. That helps them prevent conferences like the SEC and Big Ten from having larger internal playoffs where the conferences bid out those games and keep the bulk of the profit for themselves. And why wouldn't they eventually want to do that? The CFP model gives the participants 50% of the profits and pays them in shares, though unlike the NCAA basketball tourney they do pay a full share out for that year. Because of that what the SEC and Big Ten could make (or the ACC / Big 12) by having their own 4 school internal playoff is significantly more than the conference share (think north of 20 million) and the per school share combined. By getting to 24 first the networks control the CFP and leave no room for the internal conference playoff potential and eliminate the CCGs which are so valuable for the P conferences. If promising 1 or 2 slots to the G6 helps get this passed today, then tomorrow when the networks control it and have eliminated the threat of the SEC / Big Ten doing their own thing to produce a champ, they will pull the same crap that they do with the scheduling now. They'll drop the G6 and demand those slots be filled with schools that have large national followings or are state schools from large states. And they'll do that because that is where their profits reside.

This is why I am for the SEC and Big Ten, the ACC and Big 12 growing to about 20 schools each (which more than covers the most competitive of the G6) and each having their own divisional playoffs to crown a champion and then the 4 champions playing it off.

It's inclusive of a dozen more of the top G6 which is well past just Boise, it includes all of the current P4 likely Oregon State and Washington State after each grows to 20, and it allows the kids to win a Natty having played only 16 games (much less wear and tear on their bodies). But most importantly and at a time when they need it most it keeps most of the playoff money in the hands of the conferences and the networks still cleanup on public interest in the games which spikes the ad revenue.

Basketball can then be handled by the conferences but as an invitational so that the best basketball programs in any given year are in the tournament regardless of whether they are in a P4 football conference or not.

What pisses me off is the level of ignorance about why the networks are pushing the 24-school agenda and nobody is sticking up for the conferences or schools potentially involved. They want to be able to pocket 50% of the profits and lay the costs off on the schools. In a 50/50 split after overhead, which is what we are talking the networks only pay less than 50% of the gross making the schools absorb part of their overhead. Piss on that! Conference commissioners are largely corporate sports rights attorneys. Guess where they look for a job if they lose theirs? Yep, the networks unless they are getting paid enough and are old enough to retire which frankly most are and then they don't care. It's way past time for school presidents and ADs to grow a pair and do what is in their best interests instead of punting the realignment decisions and playoff decisions to their corporate overlords. Slive and Delany were the only two who operated openly in adversarial roles to the networks' wishes. Delany told ESPN to pound sand over a lowball offer and Slive told his presidents that the SEC would not concede a single thing to the networks unless they paid for it.

A network-controlled CFP of 24 schools that is not controlled by the conferences will only bring more subservience to network control. Realignment was a hostile takeover of college sports by networks once they figured out how to play the 1983 SCOTUS ruling of OU/UGa vs the NCAA. When they realized that they could then dictate the terms on how much a team would be worth to a particular conference they started building the model we have now. Schools are separated by value and yet on this forum people still marvel at how the division lines have become more distinct financially. Well hello! We call it realignment. It is not a secret that the Big Ten and SEC have added the most valuable schools from other conferences or that FOX and ESPN have largely paid for it with some help from CBS whether for the SEC or now the Big Ten.

There are 67 schools plus Notre Dame in the P conferences now. A dozen G6 promotions would absolutely include the few best programs remaining in the G6 and some up and comers. Keeping 4 conferences, capping membership in any of them at 20 and moving to a P4 of 80 schools is the compromise that needs to be made and there is no need of 24 teams in a playoff. Each conference has semis and finals and keeps the proceeds for them. Their champs play it off and the 4 conferences still keep the proceeds. The networks make their money on advertising as always, but they bid each year for the games.

If our schools front the overhead to build the teams, then our schools and conferences should keep the proceeds from it in house. We don't owe Disney or FOX a damn thing! If they want to broadcast the best games, they can. But they'll bid for it every year.

But as long as the P4 argue among themselves over bids, or the G6 capable of competing and that is what we are talking about here are in that discussion and all parties are not united we will continue to be the victims of the networks. So, this stupid G vs P debate needs to end. The top 80 should be the 4 P conferences, and we should control our own product and quit playing network games! It's about time we took back our control over sports, and everything else that corporate interests have taken away from us, like our voices in our elections regardless of our parties.
09-14-2026 12:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fighting Muskie Offline
Senior Chief Realignmentologist
*

Posts: 15,080
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
Post: #46
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Not to completely derail this thread (it’s already going that way) but this is why conference playoffs make so much sense—the leagues keep the money their teams earn—

I’d love to see a 7 team Big 10 playoff —give #1 a bye. Play over the first 2 weekends in Dec. Play the Big 10 title at the Rose Bowl.

The CFP could then basically be a single #1 vs #2 after all the conference champs have been crowned.

The conferences keep most of the postseason revenue and the only thing that gets shared in that 1 title game…and obviously whichever conferences are represented should get a sizable appearance bonus.
09-14-2026 01:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
goofus Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,718
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 304
I Root For: Iowa
Location: chicago suburbs
Post: #47
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 08:47 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  There should be three championship races among these tiers. That's my belief.

I actually like this idea. The G6 should have its own 24-team playoff. Any G6 that makes into the top tier CFP would of course sit out the G6FP. I guessing G6FP teams would skip the bowl games.
09-14-2026 01:39 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #48
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
Nobody within the G6 draws 40,000 to their games. None of them bring value to the P4 except UConn with their BB. The majority of P4 fans on here for whatever reason think the answer is moving 8-10 G6 programs (fan favorite Tulane) into the P4.

Those 8-10 belong where they are in a G6 conference. Most belong in a high G6 conference like the PAC or AC. SBC and MWC have some big ones too.
09-14-2026 01:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #49
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 11:05 AM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 06:51 AM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 10:19 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I’ve been harping on this for years now. G6 needs to be its own thing with its own playoffs. They should still be allowed to play up or down against P2/M2 competition or FCS, but they need their own separate postseason and national title.

When Eastern Michigan markets its football program, they don't show off their World's Famous Idaho Potato Bowl victory against San Jose State. They're showing their wins against Arizona State, Illinois, Purdue, Rutgers, etc. I agree that the G6 shouldn't be included in the 12-team CFP, but those G6 vs. Power 4 bowl matchups are their own version of a Super Bowl. They're everything to the G6. The Detroit Bowl got higher attendance than the MAC Championship in 28 of its 29 years, with the lone exception being Western Michigan's unbeaten regular season.

The issue is, the economics don't work out. The TV ratings aren't there. Sponsorships are dropping out. Venues don't want to open their doors to the G6. Vegas (MWC), LA (MWC), and Detroit (MAC) have all shunned the G6 very recently after having a generation of successful games at some of those locations. As a result, the G6 Champions have been relegated to made-for-TV games on a weekday before Christmas break at 11 AM at a destination that requires a connecting flight / multiple hour car ride from the nearest non-stop destination just to get to.

Everything is about money now. I'm just glad that I got to experience a time when it wasn't so obvious. I'll never see a Big Ten school play at a MAC school again. I highly doubt that I'll ever see a Big Ten team play a MAC team in a bowl game, let alone one in the MAC's backyard.

The shear fact that G6 over P2/M2 wins are becoming so rare is a huge argument for the case that they need to be separate levels of the college football pyramid.

A G6 playoff (and I’d argue that eventually probably about the top 4ish FCS conferences would eventually be part of this tier) would actually give them some tangible, attainable hardware to chase.
I don't know if it was in this thread, but someone was pointing out how the revenue differences have massively escalated. Besides all the internally generated revenue from donations and tickets, the conference distributions have gotten much bigger in the P4. So the competitive gap is growing. NIL and the unlimited transfer portal have increased that gap.

I know Big 12, Pac 12 and Big East were under $10 million per school around 2009. The SEC and ACC were around $11 million and the Big Ten only a little higher. In 2011 after some of the new contracts kicked in, it still wasn't that big:
SEC $20.3 million
Big 12 $19.0 million
Big Ten $17.1 million
ACC $16.9 million
Pac $11.1 million

Compare that to $70+ million for the SEC and Big Ten and $40+ million the ACC and Big 12 will distribute this year.

Also found a chart that shows in 2009, the ACC expenditures looked about like today's American Conference. And that had escalated significantly from 2004. Chart shows the 8 public schools from 2004-5 through 2009-10.
https://www.shakinthesouthland.com/2011/...-2009-2010
09-14-2026 01:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Garden_KC Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,000
Joined: Jan 2023
Reputation: 142
I Root For: Landscaping
Location:
Post: #50
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 01:39 PM)goofus Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 08:47 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  There should be three championship races among these tiers. That's my belief.

I actually like this idea. The G6 should have its own 24-team playoff. Any G6 that makes into the top tier CFP would of course sit out the G6FP. I guessing G6FP teams would skip the bowl games.

The plan is an 8 team G6 tournament for those who don't make the CFP.

Have the top 4 teams not in the CFP host at home during current CCG week. Then play the semi's and championship at bowls.
09-14-2026 01:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Just Joe Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,880
Joined: Oct 2020
Reputation: 396
I Root For: Bama
Location:
Post: #51
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 08:56 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 08:51 PM)Just Joe Wrote:  Well FCS needs P4 money/bodybag games to survive. If the P4 stops playing them a lot of programs dry up and fade away.

No they don't. Some don't even schedule FBS games.

How many that provide athletic scholarships didn't schedule an FBS team this year? I have no idea but I'd guess less than 10.
09-14-2026 01:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #52
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 12:17 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:31 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 12:48 AM)DavidSt Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 10:55 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  
(09-13-2026 10:19 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I’ve been harping on this for years now. G6 needs to be its own thing with its own playoffs. They should still be allowed to play up or down against P2/M2 competition or FCS, but they need their own separate postseason and national title.

In the CFP era with all of the G tier expansion I would say its appeared logical from that time forward.

Back in the BCS era conferences were smaller. You had the PAC and BE in the power club and the MWC usually conference rated #7 was competitive enough to make a serious push to join the club. MAC was winning 5 to 6 games against BCS opponents a year back then.

MWC and WAC both at the time. Each conferences had 3 to 4 teams that have competed good against P6 at the time.

Not really. Only Boise was as competitive as TCU, BYU and Utah. To show how strong those teams were, TCU went 12-2 vs P6 (2005-2011) and Utah was 21-12 from 1999 to 2010. Boise was about .500. Nowadays the top of the G6 is nowhere near as competitive.

Logic and passionate arguments have nothing to do with the situation. College football is now a business "officially" by Court ruling. It has of course been unofficially a business essentially controlled by media multi national corporations since the 90's. They pay the money for more P games and realignment.

Now that it is officially a business, especially as that has just happened prior to the enrollment cliff demographic shift is what is pertinent. Why?

As a business it will operate to maximize profits. What are the networks paying for? More content laden schedules under the guise of P vs P matchups as many times on the 4 major conferences schedules as possible. We are now looking at a mandate of 10 being the new standard for judging the CFP participants.

Do we need a 24-school playoff? Hell no! When the BCS moved to the 4-team playoff how many years did we not have 1 blowout in the first two games. The two team BCS was too political and usually left 1 worthy claimant of the national title out, sometimes an undefeated school. The 4-team playoff was likely the most efficient model we could have for determining a national championship as the number of truly top-notch programs on any given year is sparse.

So why 8, 12, 16, or 24? Money. So, let's say the compromise in the immediate future is to 16, will there be more than 3 legit contenders? Odds are no. If the move is therefore made to increase revenue what will be the next request of the networks that bid on those games? Quality of match ups. If advertisers don't want to spend their money on the time slot of a game they believe may be a blowout but rather on games between the top 4 seeds what will the networks want for those other 4 games? They are going to want schools which have the largest national audiences to maximize ad revenue, or they are going to want P schools with large state followings for the same.

The networks know that eventual separation from the NCAA will happen now because the NCAA was set up as an amateur model and the costs of paying athletes will eventually force the NCAA's money sport out of the NCAA so they can maximize their revenue (basketball). The networks will use that break to set up a more profitable tournament if the P conferences don't get there first. But either way the networks will want the top brands, the best teams for that year, and the filler to be schools with large TV audiences. It won't be about inclusion for the tournament any more than it is about inclusion for the CFP. Frank can talk about the kiddie table all he wants, but he knows this is all moving in the direction of what profits the most and what profits the most sure as hell isn't concerned about fairness, or inclusion for smaller schools which they see as being the ultimate victims of the enrollment cliff.

Right now, the networks just want more teams in. That helps them prevent conferences like the SEC and Big Ten from having larger internal playoffs where the conferences bid out those games and keep the bulk of the profit for themselves. And why wouldn't they eventually want to do that? The CFP model gives the participants 50% of the profits and pays them in shares, though unlike the NCAA basketball tourney they do pay a full share out for that year. Because of that what the SEC and Big Ten could make (or the ACC / Big 12) by having their own 4 school internal playoff is significantly more than the conference share (think north of 20 million) and the per school share combined. By getting to 24 first the networks control the CFP and leave no room for the internal conference playoff potential and eliminate the CCGs which are so valuable for the P conferences. If promising 1 or 2 slots to the G6 helps get this passed today, then tomorrow when the networks control it and have eliminated the threat of the SEC / Big Ten doing their own thing to produce a champ, they will pull the same crap that they do with the scheduling now. They'll drop the G6 and demand those slots be filled with schools that have large national followings or are state schools from large states. And they'll do that because that is where their profits reside.

This is why I am for the SEC and Big Ten, the ACC and Big 12 growing to about 20 schools each (which more than covers the most competitive of the G6) and each having their own divisional playoffs to crown a champion and then the 4 champions playing it off.

It's inclusive of a dozen more of the top G6 which is well past just Boise, it includes all of the current P4 likely Oregon State and Washington State after each grows to 20, and it allows the kids to win a Natty having played only 16 games (much less wear and tear on their bodies). But most importantly and at a time when they need it most it keeps most of the playoff money in the hands of the conferences and the networks still cleanup on public interest in the games which spikes the ad revenue.

Basketball can then be handled by the conferences but as an invitational so that the best basketball programs in any given year are in the tournament regardless of whether they are in a P4 football conference or not.

What pisses me off is the level of ignorance about why the networks are pushing the 24-school agenda and nobody is sticking up for the conferences or schools potentially involved. They want to be able to pocket 50% of the profits and lay the costs off on the schools. In a 50/50 split after overhead, which is what we are talking the networks only pay less than 50% of the gross making the schools absorb part of their overhead. Piss on that! Conference commissioners are largely corporate sports rights attorneys. Guess where they look for a job if they lose theirs? Yep, the networks unless they are getting paid enough and are old enough to retire which frankly most are and then they don't care. It's way past time for school presidents and ADs to grow a pair and do what is in their best interests instead of punting the realignment decisions and playoff decisions to their corporate overlords. Slive and Delany were the only two who operated openly in adversarial roles to the networks' wishes. Delany told ESPN to pound sand over a lowball offer and Slive told his presidents that the SEC would not concede a single thing to the networks unless they paid for it.

A network-controlled CFP of 24 schools that is not controlled by the conferences will only bring more subservience to network control. Realignment was a hostile takeover of college sports by networks once they figured out how to play the 1983 SCOTUS ruling of OU/UGa vs the NCAA. When they realized that they could then dictate the terms on how much a team would be worth to a particular conference they started building the model we have now. Schools are separated by value and yet on this forum people still marvel at how the division lines have become more distinct financially. Well hello! We call it realignment. It is not a secret that the Big Ten and SEC have added the most valuable schools from other conferences or that FOX and ESPN have largely paid for it with some help from CBS whether for the SEC or now the Big Ten.

There are 67 schools plus Notre Dame in the P conferences now. A dozen G6 promotions would absolutely include the few best programs remaining in the G6 and some up and comers. Keeping 4 conferences, capping membership in any of them at 20 and moving to a P4 of 80 schools is the compromise that needs to be made and there is no need of 24 teams in a playoff. Each conference has semis and finals and keeps the proceeds for them. Their champs play it off and the 4 conferences still keep the proceeds. The networks make their money on advertising as always, but they bid each year for the games.

If our schools front the overhead to build the teams, then our schools and conferences should keep the proceeds from it in house. We don't owe Disney or FOX a damn thing! If they want to broadcast the best games, they can. But they'll bid for it every year.

But as long as the P4 argue among themselves over bids, or the G6 capable of competing and that is what we are talking about here are in that discussion and all parties are not united we will continue to be the victims of the networks. So, this stupid G vs P debate needs to end. The top 80 should be the 4 P conferences, and we should control our own product and quit playing network games! It's about time we took back our control over sports, and everything else that corporate interests have taken away from us, like our voices in our elections regardless of our parties.

The difference is that the CFP is effectively what you are already talking about, though. It’s a separate organization from the NCAA consisting of only the FBS conferences plus Notre Dame and where the Big Ten and SEC specifically each have de facto veto power where nothing can be approved unless they both agree with each other. This is not like, say, the NCAA Tournament where there are dozens of cooks in the kitchen. The Big Ten and SEC *already* directly control the CFP system.

At the same time, you just can’t cut out the G6 conferences without violating antitrust laws. It’s pretty clear on that front (although I know a lot of fans just want to ignore antitrust laws in every proposal that they have whether it’s about the playoff, conference realignment, or player compensation and transfer rules). It’s the old “Is the juice worth the squeeze?” question. Even if I personally don’t have an issue with what you’ve proposed in concept, it’s just trying to extract an extra couple of percentage of points at great risk of violation antitrust law… all in the name so that one single playoff spot doesn’t need to be granted to the G6. I don’t think that either the Big Ten or SEC want to do that - they HAVE control of the CFP already and how the money is distributed. There’s not really much to be gained by blowing the whole thing up.
09-14-2026 02:02 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bill dazzle Offline
Craft beer and urban living enthusiast
*

Posts: 18,670
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 2038
I Root For: Vanderbilt
Location: Nashville
Post: #53
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 09:17 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 08:22 AM)4x4hokies Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 07:45 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I don’t understand the clamor for a G6-only playoff. It’s the “kids’ table” and everyone knows it. While some G6 fans have delusions of thinking that there ought to be a playoff where all G6 champs get an auto-bid (which will never happen), I’m not sure what the value is for the P4 to just snuff out even a single G6 playoff bid, particularly if there’s expansion to a 24-team playoff. There’s a massive difference between the P4 having a huge advantage over the G6 competitively versus the P4 *structurally* eliminating any G6 playoff presence entirely.

The G6 deserve to play for a championship against programs with similar resources to their own. Nobody wants the FCS to have a playoff spot. So the concept of different divisions playing competitions with similar resourced schools is not foreign.

You do realize VT is closer in resources to JMU than it is to Ohio State. So you are supporting VT being relegated too right?

I'm too lazy to factcheck this but I would not be surprised if you are, in fact, correct. JMU offers a robust athletics budget. I'm impressed. So for football resources ... I see your point.

But I would think the general public perception is that Virginia Tech, in a comprehensive manner, is much more similar to Ohio State (athletics, history, academics, influence, etc.) than James Madison. And that is not a slight, as JMU seemingly is doing tremendous work in many areas (academics and athletics).
09-14-2026 02:03 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dukes_Royals Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,975
Joined: May 2023
Reputation: 84
I Root For: James Madison University
Location: Harrisonburg, VA
Post: #54
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 01:47 PM)Garden_KC Wrote:  Nobody within the G6 draws 40,000 to their games. None of them bring value to the P4 except UConn with their BB. The majority of P4 fans on here for whatever reason think the answer is moving 8-10 G6 programs (fan favorite Tulane) into the P4.

Those 8-10 belong where they are in a G6 conference. Most belong in a high G6 conference like the PAC or AC. SBC and MWC have some big ones too.

So the 45,600 for Arkansas State @ Memphis, the 41,800 for FIU @ South Florida, the 40,000 for App State @ ECU don't exist?

Not hard to believe either that App State, JMU, or Boise St (among others) could get to 40,000 if their stadiums held that much. Both App and JMU have stadium expansion projects in different phases underway.
09-14-2026 02:07 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #55
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 02:03 PM)bill dazzle Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 09:17 AM)Dukes_Royals Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 08:22 AM)4x4hokies Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 07:45 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  I don’t understand the clamor for a G6-only playoff. It’s the “kids’ table” and everyone knows it. While some G6 fans have delusions of thinking that there ought to be a playoff where all G6 champs get an auto-bid (which will never happen), I’m not sure what the value is for the P4 to just snuff out even a single G6 playoff bid, particularly if there’s expansion to a 24-team playoff. There’s a massive difference between the P4 having a huge advantage over the G6 competitively versus the P4 *structurally* eliminating any G6 playoff presence entirely.

The G6 deserve to play for a championship against programs with similar resources to their own. Nobody wants the FCS to have a playoff spot. So the concept of different divisions playing competitions with similar resourced schools is not foreign.

You do realize VT is closer in resources to JMU than it is to Ohio State. So you are supporting VT being relegated too right?

I'm too lazy to factcheck this but I would not be surprised if you are, in fact, correct. JMU offers a robust athletics budget. I'm impressed. So for football resources ... I see your point.

But I would think the general public perception is that Virginia Tech, in a comprehensive manner, is much more similar to Ohio State (athletics, history, academics, influence, etc.) than James Madison. And that is not a slight, as JMU seemingly is doing tremendous work in many areas (academics and athletics).

In % terms, VT is much closer to Ohio St. (2nd highest in the country) on internally generated revenue (ie excluding institution subsidies and student fees). They generate almost all of their $151 million while JMU has a massive subsidy for their $68 million. VT is probably at least 5 times JMU on actual revenue. And Ohio St. at $295 million is behind only Texas. Michigan at $237 million ($86 million more than VT who is $83 million more than JMU) is #7. So VT is close to the vast majority of P4 schools. There are only 15 over $200 million. By contrast, all are over $100 million, more than $32 million ahead of JMU. And JMU is near the top of the G6 at #10 overall.
09-14-2026 02:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
dbackjon Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 14,278
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 989
I Root For: NAU/Illini
Location:
Post: #56
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-13-2026 07:27 PM)4x4hokies Wrote:  Through this week:

P4 vs FCS 37 - 0
P4 vs G6 43 - 2
G6 vs FCS 48 - 4

The FCS vs G6 is closer than G6 vs P4. I also don't believe in playing down two divisions.

FCS has 5 wins over G6:

Week 1
The Citadel over Charlotte
Tarleton State over Bowling Green
Idaho State over Utah State

Week 2
Illinois State over Northern Illinois
Montana State over Nevada

G6 losses by Conference:
MAC - 1
AC - 1
Pac-x - 1
MWC - 2

FCS wins by Conference:
Southern - 1
UAC - 1
MVFC - 1
Big Sky - 2
09-14-2026 02:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #57
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 12:15 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 11:55 AM)ken d Wrote:  What is clear to me is that FCS teams have no business playing P4 teams except as preseason exhibitions.

Why? Some spend nearly as much as G6 programs.

99-0 in the past two seasons. And those G6 programs are trending badly as well. The P4 is 43-2 against them this year, and there's nothing on the horizon to suggest that trend is going to change. But at least some of those 43 losses weren't blowouts.
(This post was last modified: 09-14-2026 02:56 PM by ken d.)
09-14-2026 02:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DFW HOYA Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,299
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
Post: #58
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 02:36 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 12:15 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  Why? Some spend nearly as much as G6 programs.

99-0 in the past two seasons.

So what are you arguing, that 128 schools should just drop the sport?
09-14-2026 02:39 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
thrill_house Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,123
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
Post: #59
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 01:39 PM)goofus Wrote:  I guessing G6FP teams would skip the bowl games.

Guess again.
09-14-2026 02:51 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
ken d Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,300
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 2032
I Root For: college sports
Location: Raleigh
Post: #60
RE: It's becoming apparent that there are three divisions within D1
(09-14-2026 02:39 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 02:36 PM)ken d Wrote:  
(09-14-2026 12:15 PM)DFW HOYA Wrote:  Why? Some spend nearly as much as G6 programs.

99-0 in the past two seasons.

So what are you arguing, that 128 schools should just drop the sport?

No, they should compete against their peers.
09-14-2026 02:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.