(09-14-2026 06:51 PM)JRsec Wrote: (09-14-2026 06:10 PM)Garden_KC Wrote: (09-14-2026 03:02 PM)Akiraptor Wrote: There's a clear divide between about half of the P4 and the G6, but there's very little difference in quality between the lower half of the P4 and the upper echelon of G6 schools. I would argue that those numbers in the OP are skewed in favor of the P4 because most mid-to-lower P4s won't schedule the better G6 teams. There's no benefit for them to do so. They've everything to lose and nothing to gain.
Also, a G6 playoff is a complete nonstarter unless a super league of the top 30 or so schools forms and everyone not in that league is included in the "G6."
Historically the bottom 12 P4 programs and top 12 G6 were relatively even on the FB field but its different now with the massively larger conference payouts in the P4 and revenue sharing.
Before you could move up to a better revenue conference, use the money to level up your coaching staffs and keep the train rolling forward. Today you can move up and struggle as one of the poorest schools in the P4.
The are definitely not 12 schools sitting in the G6 with deep pockets for P4 NIL. I do not understand why JRsec thinks that 12 schools do. I believe its because he doesn't realize that nobody in the G6 can really afford it. UConn and Memphis could survive if they had the invite but no impetus for another 10 schools. The deep pockets just are not there.
Oh I fully realize it. I post the data on it annually. But there are more than just Boise State. South Florida, San Diego State, perhaps Colorado State, Oregon State and Washington State could make the jump. Perhaps you need to improve your reading skills. I said for all 4 P conferences to move to 20. That's 2 for the Big Ten, 4 for the SEC and those six will be backfilled most likely by the ACC. Those being promoted up with the possible exception of USF would likely go to the Big 12 and would be paid Big 12 money. Could you find 12 if you leveled up their revenue even if the Big 12 payouts dropped 5 million it would be a lot more than a G6 school had been making at 28 million. I suggested 20 for round numbers and equal representation and equl chance of making the national semifinals, as I had it set up.
If you are using budget data, the top of the G6 budgets are some of the most inflated in the industry. They include big debt items and massive student fees to pump up those numbers.
Game Revenue
Athletic Debt
Expenditures
Student Fees
Salaries
Institutional Contributions
Donations
Auxillaries to support athletics
Marketing income
Confernce payout
Its an aggregate spending calculation not indicative of having real money. Now the Top 10-12 do pull in probably between 4-5 million more than the average G6 in marketing and game day revenue. But its a logrithimic jump between a G6 averaging 33,000 a game and a P4 that does 60,000 with regard to all of those areas. Large statewide marketing deals.
As to P4 conference payouts helping that money goes fast. 15 million to the FB staff, 8 million to the BB staff. The AD earns 2 million a year. 5 million a year on buy games. Now you are adding to that 22 million to pay the players. PCSA another 27.5 million for a retention pool. That is almost 80 million a P4 is expected to shell out just in those categories.
The make or break in the P4 is whether or not you have a large 3rd party NIL collective which takes massive donor support. These G6 schools simply don't have the donor capacity for it. They can't attract the players either to compete in a P4.
I can see where some of the schools you like to throw out like Kansas, Florida State, Clemson, North Carolina to 20 could add value. They could motivate the SEC to expand. Names like Colorado St, Tulane and Rice are OK if you need the but you do not expand to 20 for them. They lower the per school value of the TV contract not raise it.
SEC: Kansas, FSU, Clemson, North Carolina (to 20)
B1G: Virginia, Miami (to 20)
ACC: Cincinnati, WVU, USF, UConn (to 16)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis (to 16)
ACC/XII would probably rebuild to 16 but I can't see beyond that to 20 which is 8 more G6 programs.
Now if the ACC were to rip apart the XII, in that case the XII would probably stay at 14.
ACC: Utah, ASU, Colorado, Baylor, TCU, UConn (to 18)
XII: Oregon St, SDSU, Memphis, USF (to 14)
Which once again upgrades only 4 G6 programs. The expansion from the G6 into the P4 has always been conservative compared to movement within the G6 tier.