(09-09-2026 12:34 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote: This clearly explains why neither was allowed in the SEC. Downright unacceptable by both schools. Southerners hold grudges! lol jk
The Southern Conference was not formed until 1921, partially over eligibility issues. The Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Association (SIAA) was a large loose agglomeration of schools, more like the ECAC. There was a proposal to impose a one-year rule which would mean freshmen or transfers could not play. This was not because freshmen were considered too immature, but because athletes would be recruited and never really be serious students (e.g. Cooper Flagg). They might go on to other schools and never graduate.
Smaller schools with only a couple hundred students voted the proposal down, because eliminating 1/4 of the students would make it hard to field football and baseball teams.
At the same time college baseball players were permitted to play in Class D summer leagues. Teams had a salary cap of $1200/team/month for a 14-player roster, so they were probably no more lucrative than summer college leagues are today. This was also voted down.
Larger schools broke away to form the Southern Conference: Kentucky, Tennessee, Alabama, Auburn, Mississippi State, Georgia Tech, Georgia, and Clemson joined with North Carolina, North Carolina State, Virginia, Virginia Tech, Washington & Lee, and Maryland (the latter six were not members of the SIAA, and the only SIAA school as far north as North Carolina was Davidson).
Former SIAA members Tulane, LSU, Vanderbilt, Florida, South Carolina, Sewanee later joined, as well as VMI and Trinity (Duke). So the schools left out of the SEC were somewhat peripheral to the SIAA. Maybe 24-team mega-conferences don't work.