CSNbbs
North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. (/thread-1032646.html)

Pages: 1 2


North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - jimrtex - 09-09-2026 12:30 PM

North Carolina and Virginia each accused the other of fielding professionals in their traditional Thanksgiving clash (November 24, 1898). The South's Oldest Rivalry, which was eight games old at that point was not played the next year in 1899.

[Image: GKukta8.jpeg]


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - Fighting Muskie - 09-09-2026 12:34 PM

This clearly explains why neither was allowed in the SEC. Downright unacceptable by both schools. Southerners hold grudges! lol jk


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - Dr Dawgma III - 09-09-2026 12:35 PM

Would be great to get this game back on Thanksgiving. 04-cheers


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - No Bull - 09-09-2026 12:36 PM

Your thread title lured me in. Well played.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - WhidbeyWolf - 09-09-2026 12:50 PM

(09-09-2026 12:35 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Would be great to get this game back on Thanksgiving. 04-cheers

What?? You mean, drop our annual beatdown of unc, a night or two later??
Never happen.04-wine


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - bryanw1995 - 09-09-2026 12:58 PM

(09-09-2026 12:50 PM)WhidbeyWolf Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 12:35 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Would be great to get this game back on Thanksgiving. 04-cheers

What?? You mean, drop our annual beatdown of unc, a night or two later??
Never happen.04-wine

Based upon what we saw in week 0, you should at least be happy that you don't have to play UVA again.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - The Beaver - 09-09-2026 12:59 PM

There were many cases back in the day. Back 1912 (I think?) OSU accused PSU of using ringers and walked off the field late in the fourth, never to return. And then, of course, Michigan was expelled for a time from the Big Ten for similar reasons.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - billybobby777 - 09-09-2026 01:02 PM

(09-09-2026 12:30 PM)jimrtex Wrote:  North Carolina and Virginia each accused the other of fielding professionals in their traditional Thanksgiving clash (November 24, 1898). The South's Oldest Rivalry, which was eight games old at that point was not played the next year in 1899.

[Image: GKukta8.jpeg]

And I had plans to go to that game too…


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - jimrtex - 09-09-2026 01:07 PM

(09-09-2026 12:35 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Would be great to get this game back on Thanksgiving. 04-cheers
When the game was renewed in 1900, it was played on the Saturday before Thanksgiving and moved from Richmond to Norfolk.

On Thanksgiving that year, Virginia played Sewanee and North Carolina played Georgetown (in foot-ball).


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - Dr Dawgma III - 09-09-2026 01:18 PM

(09-09-2026 12:50 PM)WhidbeyWolf Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 12:35 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Would be great to get this game back on Thanksgiving. 04-cheers

What?? You mean, drop our annual beatdown of unc, a night or two later??
Never happen.04-wine

Awww, do you need some attention?


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - WhidbeyWolf - 09-09-2026 03:25 PM

(09-09-2026 12:58 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 12:50 PM)WhidbeyWolf Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 12:35 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Would be great to get this game back on Thanksgiving. 04-cheers

What?? You mean, drop our annual beatdown of unc, a night or two later??
Never happen.04-wine

Based upon what we saw in week 0, you should at least be happy that you don't have to play UVA again.

Yeah, amazing how they held all that experience together, as others will find out, as well.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - WhidbeyWolf - 09-09-2026 03:27 PM

(09-09-2026 01:18 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 12:50 PM)WhidbeyWolf Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 12:35 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Would be great to get this game back on Thanksgiving. 04-cheers

What?? You mean, drop our annual beatdown of unc, a night or two later??
Never happen.04-wine

Awww, do you need some attention?
Gee, I thought using your favorite emoji would help.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - OdinFrigg - 09-09-2026 04:48 PM

In the 1900 Clemson vs. South Carolina football game, Clemson defeated South Carolina by a score of 51–0, still the largest margin of victory by either team in the series.

Perhaps some csnbbs posters remember watching that game?


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - Bronco'14 - 09-09-2026 05:19 PM

Eh, rules are meant to not be followed


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - Garrettabc - 09-09-2026 05:42 PM

I’m more inclined to take UVA’s side.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - Fresno St. Alum - 09-10-2026 12:37 AM

Professional at what, some pro league none of us have heard of? CFL started in 1909 and NFL in 1920. Like business men not enrolled in college?


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - bryanw1995 - 09-10-2026 02:49 AM

(09-10-2026 12:37 AM)Fresno St. Alum Wrote:  Professional at what, some pro league none of us have heard of? CFL started in 1909 and NFL in 1920. Like business men not enrolled in college?

They weren’t as good at disguising the Car Dealer NIL back in those days, considering that there were no car dealerships.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - The Beaver - 09-10-2026 04:17 AM

(09-10-2026 12:37 AM)Fresno St. Alum Wrote:  Professional at what, some pro league none of us have heard of? CFL started in 1909 and NFL in 1920. Like business men not enrolled in college?

Random sportsmen that were convinced to put on a jersey and maybe enrolled in a single non-attendance course, mostly. It was a lot easier when things like student rosters couldn't just be looked up on a computer.

Heck, PSU's bringing that single BS course option back this year! Hooray for our fake QB.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - jimrtex - 09-10-2026 09:31 AM

(09-09-2026 12:34 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  This clearly explains why neither was allowed in the SEC. Downright unacceptable by both schools. Southerners hold grudges! lol jk
The Southern Conference was not formed until 1921, partially over eligibility issues. The Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Association (SIAA) was a large loose agglomeration of schools, more like the ECAC. There was a proposal to impose a one-year rule which would mean freshmen or transfers could not play. This was not because freshmen were considered too immature, but because athletes would be recruited and never really be serious students (e.g. Cooper Flagg). They might go on to other schools and never graduate.

Smaller schools with only a couple hundred students voted the proposal down, because eliminating 1/4 of the students would make it hard to field football and baseball teams.

At the same time college baseball players were permitted to play in Class D summer leagues. Teams had a salary cap of $1200/team/month for a 14-player roster, so they were probably no more lucrative than summer college leagues are today. This was also voted down.

Larger schools broke away to form the Southern Conference: Kentucky, Tennessee, Alabama, Auburn, Mississippi State, Georgia Tech, Georgia, and Clemson joined with North Carolina, North Carolina State, Virginia, Virginia Tech, Washington & Lee, and Maryland (the latter six were not members of the SIAA, and the only SIAA school as far north as North Carolina was Davidson).

Former SIAA members Tulane, LSU, Vanderbilt, Florida, South Carolina, Sewanee later joined, as well as VMI and Trinity (Duke). So the schools left out of the SEC were somewhat peripheral to the SIAA. Maybe 24-team mega-conferences don't work.


RE: North Carolina - Virginia accused of using professionals. Game cancelled. - jdgaucho - 09-10-2026 09:41 AM

(09-09-2026 04:48 PM)OdinFrigg Wrote:  In the 1900 Clemson vs. South Carolina football game, Clemson defeated South Carolina by a score of 51–0, still the largest margin of victory by either team in the series.

Perhaps some csnbbs posters remember watching that game?

Yes. President McKinley and I kicked back in the stands with smoked cigars.