JMUNation
Heisman

Posts: 5,315
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 98
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 12:42 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:13 PM)Purplehazed Wrote: Maiden looked pretty good to me, big, runs well, canon for an arm.
There were a few tough passes thrown well last sat
He did. I thought he'd be a good QB. But perhaps Evans and Coleman have been better from the spring to the start of the season.
One game against our weakest opponent in garbage time doesn't mean the staff has misjudged the QB room.
Another good point. I do trust the coaches to get it right. They have the most to lose if they don’t. That being said, I wonder if Saturday’s performance had an impact on them? Some people elevate their play in game. As Iverson once said, “We talkin about practice here”. Some guys just don’t practice well others are great practice players.
We fans do need to heavily consider the opponent too. Maiden wasn’t playing at App. St. on Saturday.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 12:51 PM |
|
JMad03
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,426
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 172
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Radford, VA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 12:51 PM)JMUNation Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:42 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:13 PM)Purplehazed Wrote: Maiden looked pretty good to me, big, runs well, canon for an arm.
There were a few tough passes thrown well last sat
He did. I thought he'd be a good QB. But perhaps Evans and Coleman have been better from the spring to the start of the season.
One game against our weakest opponent in garbage time doesn't mean the staff has misjudged the QB room.
Another good point. I do trust the coaches to get it right. They have the most to lose if they don’t. That being said, I wonder if Saturday’s performance had an impact on them? Some people elevate their play in game. As Iverson once said, “We talkin about practice here”. Some guys just don’t practice well others are great practice players.
We fans do need to heavily consider the opponent too. Maiden wasn’t playing at App. St. on Saturday.
Exactly. They know what's at stake week in and out. Why not put out your best option to win?
We also don't know the ins and outs of what has or hasn't happened in practice. Leadership is also incredibly important to Napier. Let's not forget that Napier was a QB himself.
If there's any position he needs to get right, it's QB. And he knows that.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 01:06 PM |
|
fishingduke12
Heisman

Posts: 5,410
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation: 63
I Root For: JMU
Location: NYC
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 01:06 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:51 PM)JMUNation Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:42 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:13 PM)Purplehazed Wrote: Maiden looked pretty good to me, big, runs well, canon for an arm.
There were a few tough passes thrown well last sat
He did. I thought he'd be a good QB. But perhaps Evans and Coleman have been better from the spring to the start of the season.
One game against our weakest opponent in garbage time doesn't mean the staff has misjudged the QB room.
Another good point. I do trust the coaches to get it right. They have the most to lose if they don’t. That being said, I wonder if Saturday’s performance had an impact on them? Some people elevate their play in game. As Iverson once said, “We talkin about practice here”. Some guys just don’t practice well others are great practice players.
We fans do need to heavily consider the opponent too. Maiden wasn’t playing at App. St. on Saturday.
Exactly. They know what's at stake week in and out. Why not put out your best option to win?
We also don't know the ins and outs of what has or hasn't happened in practice. Leadership is also incredibly important to Napier. Let's not forget that Napier was a QB himself.
If there's any position he needs to get right, it's QB. And he knows that.
Vad Lee/Devlin got into this on their podcast this week. Vad said he thinking Maiden is very much a big play QB. Maybe in practice he struggles with taking what the defense gives him. It worked against wagner because we could just out athlete them but probably doesnt work against peer competition
|
|
| 09-16-2026 01:19 PM |
|
JMad03
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,426
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 172
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Radford, VA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 01:19 PM)fishingduke12 Wrote: (09-16-2026 01:06 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:51 PM)JMUNation Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:42 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-16-2026 12:13 PM)Purplehazed Wrote: Maiden looked pretty good to me, big, runs well, canon for an arm.
There were a few tough passes thrown well last sat
He did. I thought he'd be a good QB. But perhaps Evans and Coleman have been better from the spring to the start of the season.
One game against our weakest opponent in garbage time doesn't mean the staff has misjudged the QB room.
Another good point. I do trust the coaches to get it right. They have the most to lose if they don’t. That being said, I wonder if Saturday’s performance had an impact on them? Some people elevate their play in game. As Iverson once said, “We talkin about practice here”. Some guys just don’t practice well others are great practice players.
We fans do need to heavily consider the opponent too. Maiden wasn’t playing at App. St. on Saturday.
Exactly. They know what's at stake week in and out. Why not put out your best option to win?
We also don't know the ins and outs of what has or hasn't happened in practice. Leadership is also incredibly important to Napier. Let's not forget that Napier was a QB himself.
If there's any position he needs to get right, it's QB. And he knows that.
Vad Lee/Devlin got into this on their podcast this week. Vad said he thinking Maiden is very much a big play QB. Maybe in practice he struggles with taking what the defense gives him. It worked against wagner because we could just out athlete them but probably doesnt work against peer competition
It's entirely possible. I certainly trust Vad's opinion over us. And Napier's.
It's when people here think they know more than the coaching staff is what drives me crazy. As if we were the only ones that saw what we saw and somehow our judgement is more sound than the guy making money as the Head Coach.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 01:37 PM |
|
boozeANDammo
2nd String

Posts: 291
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 8
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Seattle, WA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
Certainly wasn't saying that I (nor anyone else on this thread that I can see) know more than the coaching staff... just a commentary on the raw talent/skills that I saw. Its a message board, so opinions are gonna happen whether or not they align with the HC or not.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 01:53 PM |
|
Purplehazed
Heisman

Posts: 8,817
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 211
I Root For: James Madison Dukes
Location: Virginia
|
RE: QB competition 2026
All I am saying is we have 3 qbs that look capable.
If we go 3 qtrs w/o moving the ball, there willbe chirping to change the qb out
|
|
| 09-16-2026 02:05 PM |
|
JMad03
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,426
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 172
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Radford, VA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 01:53 PM)boozeANDammo Wrote: Certainly wasn't saying that I (nor anyone else on this thread that I can see) know more than the coaching staff... just a commentary on the raw talent/skills that I saw. Its a message board, so opinions are gonna happen whether or not they align with the HC or not.
I know. I didn't mean for my comment to come across that way. In this particular case I don't think anyone was making that assessment.
My comment was just in general that some tend to go that route. Don't have to look much further than last season.
But back to the original comment, I agree. Maiden has a lot of talent and showed some great things last weekend. I think it shows that we may have a pretty deep QB room. I will say I wouldn't be quite as nervous to have Maiden under center as I would have before the Wagner game for what that's worth.
And you're right, opinions are absolutely going to happen whether or not I agree with them. I think it is worth noting that we, as fans, don't see the full picture of what is happening outside of game days. That doesn't always tell the whole story.
(This post was last modified: 09-16-2026 02:09 PM by JMad03.)
|
|
| 09-16-2026 02:07 PM |
|
Dukes84
All American

Posts: 3,238
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 22
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 01:53 PM)boozeANDammo Wrote: Certainly wasn't saying that I (nor anyone else on this thread that I can see) know more than the coaching staff... just a commentary on the raw talent/skills that I saw. Its a message board, so opinions are gonna happen whether or not they align with the HC or not.
When Maiden committed to JMU, I watched a little bit of his HS tape and was very impressed and I've been stunned that he hasn't been in the mix to be the starter. I don't care who JMU was playing last week, Maiden, to me, clearly showed he's the most talented quarterback on the roster. That one touchdown pass in traffic a lot of NFL quarterbacks can't reliably make and he missed only one pass on the day. And even the announcers were in awe of the rope he threw 50 yards on a line where I believe pass interference was called in the endzone. And of course, the long bomb that connected for a TD was a thing of beauty.
And I know I saw someone on here post that there's was a big gap between the top two and Maiden and that's true, but in the opposite direction that was implied.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 02:08 PM |
|
Polish Hammer
King of all Dukes

Posts: 19,436
Joined: Sep 2004
Reputation: 257
I Root For: Kent State/James Madison
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 10:01 AM)JMUNation Wrote: It could be that his deficiencies are not with his athletic abilities. I am fairly sure the coaches see what you see. Some of these guys come to college with an inflated sense of themselves. I recall Cig not starting McCloud because of this. Maybe Maiden isn’t a good team guy, is slow to read defenses, has trouble picking up the playbook or poor practice habits? Hard to know for us fans but I saw all the same things you saw so it makes me wonder how he is 3rd team as well.
Whatever Maiden’s deficiencies are, he has some tools for sure. If he is willing to listen to his coaches, I see a lot of potential in him.
Good observation, from what understand the answer lies right there. The talent is there, hopefully the development/maturity comes around and he fulfills his potential.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 03:35 PM |
|
waterwagen
Special Teams

Posts: 672
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 31
I Root For: JMU
Location: Salt Lake
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 03:35 PM)Polish Hammer Wrote: (09-16-2026 10:01 AM)JMUNation Wrote: It could be that his deficiencies are not with his athletic abilities. I am fairly sure the coaches see what you see. Some of these guys come to college with an inflated sense of themselves. I recall Cig not starting McCloud because of this. Maybe Maiden isn’t a good team guy, is slow to read defenses, has trouble picking up the playbook or poor practice habits? Hard to know for us fans but I saw all the same things you saw so it makes me wonder how he is 3rd team as well.
Whatever Maiden’s deficiencies are, he has some tools for sure. If he is willing to listen to his coaches, I see a lot of potential in him.
Good observation, from what understand the answer lies right there. The talent is there, hopefully the development/maturity comes around and he fulfills his potential.
I posted about how good he looked after the game, but I also trust the coaches to do their jobs, so it makes sense there's a "soft skill" or two that is the issue. Makes me excited for the future though, as maybe he's ready to be the #1 next year.
|
|
| 09-16-2026 05:43 PM |
|
94computerguy
All American

Posts: 3,030
Joined: Sep 2015
Reputation: 106
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 02:08 PM)Dukes84 Wrote: (09-16-2026 01:53 PM)boozeANDammo Wrote: Certainly wasn't saying that I (nor anyone else on this thread that I can see) know more than the coaching staff... just a commentary on the raw talent/skills that I saw. Its a message board, so opinions are gonna happen whether or not they align with the HC or not.
When Maiden committed to JMU, I watched a little bit of his HS tape and was very impressed and I've been stunned that he hasn't been in the mix to be the starter. I don't care who JMU was playing last week, Maiden, to me, clearly showed he's the most talented quarterback on the roster. That one touchdown pass in traffic a lot of NFL quarterbacks can't reliably make and he missed only one pass on the day. And even the announcers were in awe of the rope he threw 50 yards on a line where I believe pass interference was called in the endzone. And of course, the long bomb that connected for a TD was a thing of beauty.
And I know I saw someone on here post that there's was a big gap between the top two and Maiden and that's true, but in the opposite direction that was implied.
In a way, knowing that your third-best QB, apparently by a lot, is that good has to be a great problem to have. In a different world, you extend him now trusting you can coach him up and he'll light the world in fire next year.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 10:03 AM |
|
JMad03
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,426
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 172
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Radford, VA
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-18-2026 10:03 AM)94computerguy Wrote: (09-16-2026 02:08 PM)Dukes84 Wrote: (09-16-2026 01:53 PM)boozeANDammo Wrote: Certainly wasn't saying that I (nor anyone else on this thread that I can see) know more than the coaching staff... just a commentary on the raw talent/skills that I saw. Its a message board, so opinions are gonna happen whether or not they align with the HC or not.
When Maiden committed to JMU, I watched a little bit of his HS tape and was very impressed and I've been stunned that he hasn't been in the mix to be the starter. I don't care who JMU was playing last week, Maiden, to me, clearly showed he's the most talented quarterback on the roster. That one touchdown pass in traffic a lot of NFL quarterbacks can't reliably make and he missed only one pass on the day. And even the announcers were in awe of the rope he threw 50 yards on a line where I believe pass interference was called in the endzone. And of course, the long bomb that connected for a TD was a thing of beauty.
And I know I saw someone on here post that there's was a big gap between the top two and Maiden and that's true, but in the opposite direction that was implied.
In a way, knowing that your third-best QB, apparently by a lot, is that good has to be a great problem to have. In a different world, you extend him now trusting you can coach him up and he'll light the world in fire next year.
Hopefully we won't need to find out this year, but our QB room is deep. This could end up being one of the best QB rooms we've had from a depth standpoint. It seems like all three could do great things under center. Haven't seen much from Vivabul yet and he could potentially be great as well.
While that may be true, if we keep the room intact, Evans could be back to contend to keep his starting spot. Would Coleman be eligible for a 5th or is he done? Regardless, Maiden still may not see the field as the #1 guy.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 10:15 AM |
|
DoubleDogDare
All American

Posts: 4,779
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 147
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-16-2026 02:08 PM)Dukes84 Wrote: (09-16-2026 01:53 PM)boozeANDammo Wrote: Certainly wasn't saying that I (nor anyone else on this thread that I can see) know more than the coaching staff... just a commentary on the raw talent/skills that I saw. Its a message board, so opinions are gonna happen whether or not they align with the HC or not.
When Maiden committed to JMU, I watched a little bit of his HS tape and was very impressed and I've been stunned that he hasn't been in the mix to be the starter. I don't care who JMU was playing last week, Maiden, to me, clearly showed he's the most talented quarterback on the roster. That one touchdown pass in traffic a lot of NFL quarterbacks can't reliably make and he missed only one pass on the day. And even the announcers were in awe of the rope he threw 50 yards on a line where I believe pass interference was called in the endzone. And of course, the long bomb that connected for a TD was a thing of beauty.
And I know I saw someone on here post that there's was a big gap between the top two and Maiden and that's true, but in the opposite direction that was implied.
It is crazy that in back to back years we have had NFL quality QBs sitting on the bench because our starters were even better.
|
|
| 09-18-2026 10:16 AM |
|
McDowell Duke
Special Teams

Posts: 503
Joined: Nov 2017
Reputation: 3
I Root For: W&M in the Patriot Leagu
Location: McDowell, Highland
|
RE: QB competition 2026
Cam Coleman looked good today against ODU. He is an outstanding QB with a quick release. If there weren't so many dropped balls by WRs and TEs, JMU would have added another 20 points.
Coleman puts passes where only our guys can catch them.
He is elusive and effective at hiding the play. I think he has pro potential.
He is a lot better than Evans.
(This post was last modified: 09-26-2026 11:16 PM by McDowell Duke.)
|
|
| 09-26-2026 11:11 PM |
|
Longhorn
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,812
Joined: Oct 2012
Reputation: 113
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
Cam's play today did nothing to promote the idea he should return to the bench so JC can start.
Cam shoulld play all snaps as QB #1 until he's injured or ineffective.
I was always taught you don't try to fix what's not broken.
|
|
| 09-26-2026 11:25 PM |
|
94computerguy
All American

Posts: 3,030
Joined: Sep 2015
Reputation: 106
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-26-2026 11:11 PM)McDowell Duke Wrote: Cam Coleman looked good today against ODU. He is an outstanding QB with a quick release. If there weren't so many dropped balls by WRs and TEs, JMU would have added another 20 points.
Coleman puts passes where only our guys can catch them.
He is elusive and effective at hiding the play. I think he has pro potential.
He is a lot better than Evans.
There were a lot of drops, but there are still WAY too many balls where he doesn't set his feet (and has time to) and he hurls the ball, either wildly or it just bounces short. There are just A LOT of passes that are coming in at knee level or bouncing 2 feet in front of the receiver. That's the product of a rushed delivery, and sometimes it's because you're in trouble, but for Coleman, it's often because he's excited and doesn't set up properly.
|
|
| 09-27-2026 08:31 AM |
|
Longhorn
Hall of Famer

Posts: 13,812
Joined: Oct 2012
Reputation: 113
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-27-2026 08:31 AM)94computerguy Wrote: (09-26-2026 11:11 PM)McDowell Duke Wrote: Cam Coleman looked good today against ODU. He is an outstanding QB with a quick release. If there weren't so many dropped balls by WRs and TEs, JMU would have added another 20 points.
Coleman puts passes where only our guys can catch them.
He is elusive and effective at hiding the play. I think he has pro potential.
He is a lot better than Evans.
There were a lot of drops, but there are still WAY too many balls where he doesn't set his feet (and has time to) and he hurls the ball, either wildly or it just bounces short. There are just A LOT of passes that are coming in at knee level or bouncing 2 feet in front of the receiver. That's the product of a rushed delivery, and sometimes it's because you're in trouble, but for Coleman, it's often because he's excited and doesn't set up properly.
Setting "up properly" and/or rushing his delivery are developmental issues. Playing more should help Cam mature. He throws a nice ball, and has the arm, legs and size to help lead JMU back to a SBC championship.
|
|
| 09-27-2026 10:09 AM |
|
chicagoduke
Special Teams

Posts: 543
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 34
I Root For: Dukes
Location: Chicago
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-26-2026 11:25 PM)Longhorn Wrote: Cam's play today did nothing to promote the idea he should return to the bench so JC can start.
Cam shoulld play all snaps as QB #1 until he's injured or ineffective.
I was always taught you don't try to fix what's not broken.
Define "ineffective".
|
|
| 09-27-2026 10:35 AM |
|
hburg
Moderator

Posts: 13,465
Joined: Mar 2011
Reputation: 522
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Make An Impact...
|
RE: QB competition 2026
I can see JC and Cam sharing the starting position again.
|
|
| 09-27-2026 10:42 AM |
|
chicagoduke
Special Teams

Posts: 543
Joined: Jan 2014
Reputation: 34
I Root For: Dukes
Location: Chicago
|
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-27-2026 10:42 AM)hburg Wrote: I can see JC and Cam sharing the starting position again.
So can I. I think we see a 4th/8th series thing again (JC getting the 4th/8th). It won't be the reason we win or lose a game. But it will keep everyone sharp, give JC a chance to prove he's QB1 like he did in camp, but not mess with the momentum of the team.
|
|
| 09-27-2026 10:46 AM |
|