Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
QB competition 2026
Author Message
Bookmark and Share
fishingduke12 Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,410
Joined: Sep 2018
Reputation: 63
I Root For: JMU
Location: NYC
Post: #221
RE: QB competition 2026
It really is a tough call. I'd say Coleman has been good overall with few complaints but hasn't really lit it up - granted the competition hasnt been great so we never really had to rely on him. The thing with Evans though is that his running ability forces the defense to account for so much so if he's comparable to Coleman throwing the ball, even a touch below him I think he may end up being the better option. Just seems like we havent been able to grind down teams like previous years with the running game which may be why the games have been closer than they should

It's a good problem to have I guess and there's something to be said for if it's not broke don't fix it.
09-28-2026 03:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DoubleDogDare Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,779
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 147
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #222
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 02:30 PM)JMad03 Wrote:  I get that. But Evans was out and Coleman has done a great job in his absence. He doesn't deserve to be taken out IMO.
I just don't quite understand why Napier would take out Coleman in favor of Evans. It's not like Evans played a fantastic game against Liberty. He was far from perfect. Yes, he is a far better athlete than Coleman and far more dynamic. But since Coleman has been in, the offense has been great. Why ruin what is working right now?
If Coleman starts struggling, then by all means bring back Evans. But Coleman doesn't deserve to be pulled right now. Doing so could ruin all the chemistry he's been building with this offense. It just doesn't seem worth the risk.

QB throws for 77% completion with 1 TD 0 INT. He doesn't take a sack despite the RT getting blown up multiple times. He effectively scrambles when needed and ends up with 7.7 YPC. All in his first college start ever......."He was far from perfect."
09-28-2026 03:47 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Purple Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,476
Joined: Sep 2017
Reputation: 245
I Root For: JMU
Location: Earth
Post: #223
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 01:50 PM)Longhorn Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 01:35 PM)POTUS#4 Wrote:  
(09-27-2026 07:28 PM)Longhorn Wrote:  
(09-27-2026 10:42 AM)hburg Wrote:  I can see JC and Cam sharing the starting position again.

That would be a disaster.

I understand why people say this, based on the fiasco during Chesney's time. But I don't think it's a foregone conclusion that it world go poorly now. I like the idea of a couple of scripted series for the QB2 rather than the QB1 wondering whether he would get yanked every time he made a bad throw.

Also, Sluka was kind of a one-trick pony - Chesney trotted him out there on third and two - everyone knew he was running. Not a formula for success. That's not an issue with Coleman and Evans. Coleman looks like a pretty decent scrambler/occasional runner and Evans can throw. If Evans gets healthy, I think he deserves a chance to get back out there and run a couple drives, at a minimum.

It's just my opinion, but I didn't invent the old adage that "if you have two QBs, you don't have a QB"...
How about 3?
09-28-2026 04:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMad03 Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,426
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 172
I Root For: James Madison
Location: Radford, VA
Post: #224
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 03:47 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 02:30 PM)JMad03 Wrote:  I get that. But Evans was out and Coleman has done a great job in his absence. He doesn't deserve to be taken out IMO.
I just don't quite understand why Napier would take out Coleman in favor of Evans. It's not like Evans played a fantastic game against Liberty. He was far from perfect. Yes, he is a far better athlete than Coleman and far more dynamic. But since Coleman has been in, the offense has been great. Why ruin what is working right now?
If Coleman starts struggling, then by all means bring back Evans. But Coleman doesn't deserve to be pulled right now. Doing so could ruin all the chemistry he's been building with this offense. It just doesn't seem worth the risk.

QB throws for 77% completion with 1 TD 0 INT. He doesn't take a sack despite the RT getting blown up multiple times. He effectively scrambles when needed and ends up with 7.7 YPC. All in his first college start ever......."He was far from perfect."

Exactly. And Coleman hadn't started an FBS game either and since has gone 3-0 as a starter.
Does he deserve to lose his starting spot?
Evans got the nod over Coleman over what he had done in fall camp. But since then, Coleman has gone 3-0 as a starter and now has more starts than Evans.
It just feels like a risk that we shouldn't take. Take the role away from a guy that's done everything asked of him because the other guy was given the #1 label in fall camp. Results should matter.

Edit: I do feel like this needs to get said before going any further. I don't have any dislike for Evans. And if Napier does give him back the starter, I'll support him 100%.
(This post was last modified: 09-28-2026 04:10 PM by JMad03.)
09-28-2026 04:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Polish Hammer Offline
King of all Dukes
*

Posts: 19,436
Joined: Sep 2004
Reputation: 257
I Root For: Kent State/James Madison
Location:
Post: #225
RE: QB competition 2026
09-28-2026 04:14 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Purple Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,476
Joined: Sep 2017
Reputation: 245
I Root For: JMU
Location: Earth
Post: #226
RE: QB competition 2026
In the end, Coach will make his decision based upon what is best for the team, and he will be comfortable with that decision, even if some of us disagree.
(This post was last modified: 09-28-2026 04:18 PM by Purple.)
09-28-2026 04:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dukester Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 12,134
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 115
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #227
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 04:17 PM)Purple Wrote:  In the end, Coach will make his decision based upon what he thinks is best for the team, and he will be comfortable with that decision, even if some of us disagree.

FIFY

04-cheers
09-28-2026 04:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dukester Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 12,134
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 115
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #228
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 03:12 PM)chicagoduke Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 03:07 PM)Dukester Wrote:  
(09-27-2026 07:28 PM)Longhorn Wrote:  
(09-27-2026 10:42 AM)hburg Wrote:  I can see JC and Cam sharing the starting position again.

That would be a disaster.

Very possibly.

As you can see this subject divides the board. It could also divide the team.

Also neither QB has a ton of FBS experience. Splitting current playing time would not be preferred.

We won the Liberty game while splitting drives. We can win a bunch more games with this same approach. It didn't seem to break the locker room.


Liberty was different. Neither QB had much experience. We scored 20 points that game, correct? Just about all teams have improved a lot in four weeks. It's a tough situation. Many coaches will say you don't loose your starting position due to injury. One loss/Louisville and we're out of the playoffs.
09-28-2026 04:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DoubleDogDare Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,779
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 147
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #229
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 04:09 PM)JMad03 Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 03:47 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 02:30 PM)JMad03 Wrote:  I get that. But Evans was out and Coleman has done a great job in his absence. He doesn't deserve to be taken out IMO.
I just don't quite understand why Napier would take out Coleman in favor of Evans. It's not like Evans played a fantastic game against Liberty. He was far from perfect. Yes, he is a far better athlete than Coleman and far more dynamic. But since Coleman has been in, the offense has been great. Why ruin what is working right now?
If Coleman starts struggling, then by all means bring back Evans. But Coleman doesn't deserve to be pulled right now. Doing so could ruin all the chemistry he's been building with this offense. It just doesn't seem worth the risk.

QB throws for 77% completion with 1 TD 0 INT. He doesn't take a sack despite the RT getting blown up multiple times. He effectively scrambles when needed and ends up with 7.7 YPC. All in his first college start ever......."He was far from perfect."

Exactly. And Coleman hadn't started an FBS game either and since has gone 3-0 as a starter.
Does he deserve to lose his starting spot?
Evans got the nod over Coleman over what he had done in fall camp. But since then, Coleman has gone 3-0 as a starter and now has more starts than Evans.
It just feels like a risk that we shouldn't take. Take the role away from a guy that's done everything asked of him because the other guy was given the #1 label in fall camp. Results should matter.

Edit: I do feel like this needs to get said before going any further. I don't have any dislike for Evans. And if Napier does give him back the starter, I'll support him 100%.

What Coleman has done is irrelevant to your point that Evan's game was far from perfect. What could Evan's have done to have a good game? What could he have done to hit that "great" treshold?
(This post was last modified: 09-28-2026 04:58 PM by DoubleDogDare.)
09-28-2026 04:55 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMaddy Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,771
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 119
I Root For: JMU
Location: District of Columbia
Post: #230
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 04:55 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 04:09 PM)JMad03 Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 03:47 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 02:30 PM)JMad03 Wrote:  I get that. But Evans was out and Coleman has done a great job in his absence. He doesn't deserve to be taken out IMO.
I just don't quite understand why Napier would take out Coleman in favor of Evans. It's not like Evans played a fantastic game against Liberty. He was far from perfect. Yes, he is a far better athlete than Coleman and far more dynamic. But since Coleman has been in, the offense has been great. Why ruin what is working right now?
If Coleman starts struggling, then by all means bring back Evans. But Coleman doesn't deserve to be pulled right now. Doing so could ruin all the chemistry he's been building with this offense. It just doesn't seem worth the risk.

QB throws for 77% completion with 1 TD 0 INT. He doesn't take a sack despite the RT getting blown up multiple times. He effectively scrambles when needed and ends up with 7.7 YPC. All in his first college start ever......."He was far from perfect."

Exactly. And Coleman hadn't started an FBS game either and since has gone 3-0 as a starter.
Does he deserve to lose his starting spot?
Evans got the nod over Coleman over what he had done in fall camp. But since then, Coleman has gone 3-0 as a starter and now has more starts than Evans.
It just feels like a risk that we shouldn't take. Take the role away from a guy that's done everything asked of him because the other guy was given the #1 label in fall camp. Results should matter.

Edit: I do feel like this needs to get said before going any further. I don't have any dislike for Evans. And if Napier does give him back the starter, I'll support him 100%.

What Coleman has done is irrelevant to your point that Evan's game was far from perfect. What could Evan's have done to have a good game? What could he have done to hit that "great" treshold?

I'll bite.

Evans had one pass over 10 yards (a 30 yard completion) that accounted for half of his 61 total yards. The other eight pass attempts never traveled more than 8 yards in the air. Final Stat line 7 for 9, 61 yards and 1 TD in 7 offensive series.

Coleman went 5 for 9 for 59 yards with four pass completions (18, 15, 11, 11) over 10 yards. He did that in 2 offensive series.

We already have three really good running backs. We don't need our QB to be a fourth. We need to have a QB who can stretch defenses with the long ball. Part of why I'd love to see more of Maiden as he showed the ability to hit some bombs including unloading some 'absolute piss missles', one for a TD one for a PI.
09-28-2026 06:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
waterwagen Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 672
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 31
I Root For: JMU
Location: Salt Lake
Post: #231
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 04:14 PM)Polish Hammer Wrote:  
Why is this reminding me so much of the ABIII, Sluka situation 03-lmfao
09-28-2026 06:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DoubleDogDare Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,779
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 147
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #232
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 06:01 PM)JMaddy Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 04:55 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  What Coleman has done is irrelevant to your point that Evan's game was far from perfect. What could Evan's have done to have a good game? What could he have done to hit that "great" treshold?

I'll bite.

Evans had one pass over 10 yards (a 30 yard completion) that accounted for half of his 61 total yards. The other eight pass attempts never traveled more than 8 yards in the air. Final Stat line 7 for 9, 61 yards and 1 TD in 7 offensive series.

Coleman went 5 for 9 for 59 yards with four pass completions (18, 15, 11, 11) over 10 yards. He did that in 2 offensive series.

We already have three really good running backs. We don't need our QB to be a fourth. We need to have a QB who can stretch defenses with the long ball. Part of why I'd love to see more of Maiden as he showed the ability to hit some bombs including unloading some 'absolute piss missles', one for a TD one for a PI.

Let's have an honest conversation first. You note Evans didn't have another attempt over 8 yards but then give Coleman credit for 4 completions >10 yards. His 15 and a 11 yarder were 5 yard hitches to Grevious in soft coverage (incl. a 5 yard hitch on a 2nd and 25/Goal) thus allowing him to get >10 yards out of them without a single broken tackle. If the WR's had more YAC on short passes, and let's say Evans went 7/9 for 100 yards, that doesn't change his performance from "far from perfect" to "good" or "great" right? No, trying to point out Coleman had 4x more 10 yard completions is a silly take.

Despite being disingenuous on Coleman's completions, I actually think not seeing Evans throw more deep balls is a fair point to bring up. But to not see a QB throw a deep ball and use that as support that he was "far from perfect" when he completed 77% of his passes and didn't turn the ball over is just dumb.

And we can separate a QB and an OC can't we? Evans was given plays and he executed them at a level that was closer to "perfect" than "far from perfect". He opened the game with 17 points in 3 drives - something Coleman has yet to do against FBS competition if we must have his name in every post. On those second half three and outs under Evans, he went 1/2 passing - hardly a reason to blame him for not having more drives ending with passing TDs.

And to be crystal clear, I have no problem with Coleman starting the next three years based on what we have seen. I have a problem with disingenuous, flat out inaccurate, or be complete dumb@$$ takes.
(This post was last modified: 09-28-2026 09:05 PM by DoubleDogDare.)
09-28-2026 08:58 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMaddy Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,771
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 119
I Root For: JMU
Location: District of Columbia
Post: #233
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 08:58 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 06:01 PM)JMaddy Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 04:55 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  What Coleman has done is irrelevant to your point that Evan's game was far from perfect. What could Evan's have done to have a good game? What could he have done to hit that "great" treshold?

I'll bite.

Evans had one pass over 10 yards (a 30 yard completion) that accounted for half of his 61 total yards. The other eight pass attempts never traveled more than 8 yards in the air. Final Stat line 7 for 9, 61 yards and 1 TD in 7 offensive series.

Coleman went 5 for 9 for 59 yards with four pass completions (18, 15, 11, 11) over 10 yards. He did that in 2 offensive series.

We already have three really good running backs. We don't need our QB to be a fourth. We need to have a QB who can stretch defenses with the long ball. Part of why I'd love to see more of Maiden as he showed the ability to hit some bombs including unloading some 'absolute piss missles', one for a TD one for a PI.

Let's have an honest conversation first. You note Evans didn't have another attempt over 8 yards but then give Coleman credit for 4 completions >10 yards. His 15 and a 11 yarder were 5 yard hitches to Grevious in soft coverage (incl. a 5 yard hitch on a 2nd and 25/Goal) thus allowing him to get >10 yards out of them without a single broken tackle. If the WR's had more YAC on short passes, and let's say Evans went 7/9 for 100 yards, that doesn't change his performance from "far from perfect" to "good" or "great" right? No, trying to point out Coleman had 4x more 10 yard completions is a silly take.

Despite being disingenuous on Coleman's completions, I actually think not seeing Evans throw more deep balls is a fair point to bring up. But to not see a QB throw a deep ball and use that as support that he was "far from perfect" when he completed 77% of his passes and didn't turn the ball over is just dumb.

And we can separate a QB and an OC can't we? Evans was given plays and he executed them at a level that was closer to "perfect" than "far from perfect". He opened the game with 17 points in 3 drives - something Coleman has yet to do against FBS competition if we must have his name in every post. On those second half three and outs under Evans, he went 1/2 passing - hardly a reason to blame him for not having more drives ending with passing TDs.

And to be crystal clear, I have no problem with Coleman starting the next three years based on what we have seen. I have a problem with disingenuous, flat out inaccurate, or be complete dumb@$$ takes.

I think you may be missing the point that the OC calls plays for the QB they are dealing with. While I like Evans and think he has potential to be elite, he does have a bit of the Sluka run first mentality which I hate far above anything else in a QB. I want an ABIII, McCloud, Centaio, CJ, DiNucci kind of QB who throws first and runs when they need to. A perfect QB performance is someone who runs twice for every 10-15 dropbacks and hands the ball off for most designed run plays and still gets 65-70% completion and QBR over 100.

Slants that turn into 15 yards means the QB picked the right WR and lead them so they can get YAC. A 2 or 7 yard pass with zero YAC means the QB threw them into a tackle or into tigheter coverage than necessary (which is what happened against Liberty).

Talk about disingenuous takes.
09-28-2026 09:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DoubleDogDare Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,779
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 147
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #234
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 09:12 PM)JMaddy Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 08:58 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote:  Let's have an honest conversation first. You note Evans didn't have another attempt over 8 yards but then give Coleman credit for 4 completions >10 yards. His 15 and a 11 yarder were 5 yard hitches to Grevious in soft coverage (incl. a 5 yard hitch on a 2nd and 25/Goal) thus allowing him to get >10 yards out of them without a single broken tackle. If the WR's had more YAC on short passes, and let's say Evans went 7/9 for 100 yards, that doesn't change his performance from "far from perfect" to "good" or "great" right? No, trying to point out Coleman had 4x more 10 yard completions is a silly take.

Despite being disingenuous on Coleman's completions, I actually think not seeing Evans throw more deep balls is a fair point to bring up. But to not see a QB throw a deep ball and use that as support that he was "far from perfect" when he completed 77% of his passes and didn't turn the ball over is just dumb.

And we can separate a QB and an OC can't we? Evans was given plays and he executed them at a level that was closer to "perfect" than "far from perfect". He opened the game with 17 points in 3 drives - something Coleman has yet to do against FBS competition if we must have his name in every post. On those second half three and outs under Evans, he went 1/2 passing - hardly a reason to blame him for not having more drives ending with passing TDs.

And to be crystal clear, I have no problem with Coleman starting the next three years based on what we have seen. I have a problem with disingenuous, flat out inaccurate, or be complete dumb@$$ takes.

I think you may be missing the point that the OC calls plays for the QB they are dealing with. While I like Evans and think he has potential to be elite, he does have a bit of the Sluka run first mentality which I hate far above anything else in a QB. I want an ABIII, McCloud, Centaio, CJ, DiNucci kind of QB who throws first and runs when they need to. A perfect QB performance is someone who runs twice for every 10-15 dropbacks and hands the ball off for most designed run plays and still gets 65-70% completion and QBR over 100.

Slants that turn into 15 yards means the QB picked the right WR and lead them so they can get YAC. A 2 or 7 yard pass with zero YAC means the QB threw them into a tackle or into tigheter coverage than necessary (which is what happened against Liberty).

Talk about disingenuous takes.

The QB's overall ability and a single game performance are different. Speaking of DiNucci, he was "far from perfect" against UNH, and Evans' game was perfect comparatively. Doesn't mean Evans is a better QB.

So we have 4 criteria for a perfect QB game:
- Runs twice for every 10-15 dropbacks - I think the run/pass percentage is irrelevant for evaluating a QBs game but I'll go with it as neither Coleman nor Evans will be perfect under this metric.
- Hands the ball off for most designed run plays - I don't know what that means. Are we pretending like options don't exist, and if acknowledging that that do exist, are we saying the QB shouldn't make a read but instead just hand it off to be perfect?
- 65-70% completion - I'm guessing you kept low because you want the QB to miss some deep passes? I mean Evan's was 77%, a threshold that Coleman has yet while averaging only 62% (and never landing in the 65-70% range).
- QBR over 100 - Sure. Evans was 88 against Liberty, another threshold Coleman yet to hit while averaging only 62.

So fine, if Evan's was "far from perfect" in your eye's, Coleman has been "far from perfect" at best so far (doing slightly better on runs per dropback while worst on completion % and QBR)? I'm fine with that as at least we are judging on the same basis.

And your point on air yards was that Evans can't throw a deep ball but Coleman can, nothing about receiver selection. Don't move the goal post now, Suarez has been perfect so far.
(This post was last modified: 09-28-2026 09:48 PM by DoubleDogDare.)
09-28-2026 09:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JMaddy Online
All American
*

Posts: 3,771
Joined: Jul 2013
Reputation: 119
I Root For: JMU
Location: District of Columbia
Post: #235
RE: QB competition 2026
Yes I want a verticle passing game. Not much to ask from a QB to be honest. Give me some "Iron" Maiden and rock on brother.
(This post was last modified: 09-28-2026 10:00 PM by JMaddy.)
09-28-2026 10:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bjk3047 Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,935
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 154
I Root For: JMU DUKES.
Location:
Post: #236
RE: QB competition 2026
I don’t think you can escape the reality we’re in.

Coming into the Liberty game, Coleman and Evans both had essentially no FBS experience (I’m throwing out Evan’s bowl game since he threw a single 1 yd play action lob). The coaching staff agreed that Evan’s deserved the start but Coleman deserved time because that’s how close it was.

Let’s say Evans is ready this week. Coleman has 3 successful starts, 3 weeks of practice with the 1s. That’s a significant amount of reps. Evans has 90% of one FBS game under his belt and no meaningful practice time in 3 weeks.

I think time spent getting the offense down with the 1s simply can’t be ignored as the major differentiating factor at this point.
09-28-2026 10:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Longhorn Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 13,812
Joined: Oct 2012
Reputation: 113
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #237
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-28-2026 10:37 PM)bjk3047 Wrote:  I don’t think you can escape the reality we’re in.

Coming into the Liberty game, Coleman and Evans both had essentially no FBS experience (I’m throwing out Evan’s bowl game since he threw a single 1 yd play action lob). The coaching staff agreed that Evan’s deserved the start but Coleman deserved time because that’s how close it was.

Let’s say Evans is ready this week. Coleman has 3 successful starts, 3 weeks of practice with the 1s. That’s a significant amount of reps. Evans has 90% of one FBS game under his belt and no meaningful practice time in 3 weeks.

I think time spent getting the offense down with the 1s simply can’t be ignored as the major differentiating factor at this point.

All very good points. Not to be overlooked is out of Coleman 3 starts and 3 wins...2 of the starts have been on the road.

2 road starts, 1 after flying across the country (only second time in program history) to play against what we collectively thought would be a tough (if not the toughest) opponent on our schedule. Followed by a second consecutive road game (recovering from the cross-country road game), against an in-state opponent hungry to defeat JMU. The result of that 2nd consecutive road game should speak for itself, but let's review just for grins: 4 passing TDs, a blowout win by 26 points rewarded by a SBC Offensive Player of the Week Award.

If Cam doesn't start and play uninterrupted against Marshall this week something is rotten in Denmark. The only way JC should see the field against Marshall is if the game is a 3-4 score blowout in the 4th quarter.
09-29-2026 05:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Purple Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 8,476
Joined: Sep 2017
Reputation: 245
I Root For: JMU
Location: Earth
Post: #238
RE: QB competition 2026
So, we enjoy (or suffer, depending upon your perspective) an abundance of riches at the quarterback position. That's a good thing. I am fine with whoever Coach Bill decides should play every snap or resumes a heretofore-employed snap-share arrangement. Personally, I believe JC is far more physically gifted with true next-level skills, but how do you replace a guy who has done nothing but win? You dance with who brung you, right? Cam is the lunchpail-carrying leader who gets it done. JC is the WOW! factor who can light it up. Such a problem to have. Either would start on just about any G6 team and many P-whatever-the-number-is-today teams.

As Coach so deems it, I have no issue seeing one under center and one on deck as long as the Ws keep coming. The biggest shame is we have a third star in the hole who appears to be, in very limited PT, as talented as (or moreso) both Cam or JC. I expect at least one of the three, and likely two of the three, come season-end, to take their talents to the portal, that blessed clearinghouse that keeps us so rich in talent season to season after transient coaches poach our starting rosters.
(This post was last modified: 09-29-2026 06:34 AM by Purple.)
09-29-2026 06:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JaxDuke Offline
Water Engineer
*

Posts: 17
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 3
I Root For: James Madison
Location:
Post: #239
RE: QB competition 2026
I don't think we've seen enough of JC to really know what type of QB he is but.. Coleman is exactly what we need to beat the competition we've played against and are scheduled to play... that is mediocre at best G6 competition. He is reliable, has excellent command of the offense along with good pocket presence and doesn't make big mistakes. That's a great formula for us at this point.

My question is who gives us the best opportunity to win or be competitive for significantly better opponents? If we should find ourselves in the CFP does Evans provide more potential upside? I don't know but wonder if this is part of the dilemma for the coaches?
09-29-2026 07:51 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dukester Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 12,134
Joined: Apr 2013
Reputation: 115
I Root For: JMU
Location:
Post: #240
RE: QB competition 2026
(09-29-2026 05:49 AM)Longhorn Wrote:  
(09-28-2026 10:37 PM)bjk3047 Wrote:  I don’t think you can escape the reality we’re in.

Coming into the Liberty game, Coleman and Evans both had essentially no FBS experience (I’m throwing out Evan’s bowl game since he threw a single 1 yd play action lob). The coaching staff agreed that Evan’s deserved the start but Coleman deserved time because that’s how close it was.

Let’s say Evans is ready this week. Coleman has 3 successful starts, 3 weeks of practice with the 1s. That’s a significant amount of reps. Evans has 90% of one FBS game under his belt and no meaningful practice time in 3 weeks.

I think time spent getting the offense down with the 1s simply can’t be ignored as the major differentiating factor at this point.

All very good points. Not to be overlooked is out of Coleman 3 starts and 3 wins...2 of the starts have been on the road.

2 road starts, 1 after flying across the country (only second time in program history) to play against what we collectively thought would be a tough (if not the toughest) opponent on our schedule. Followed by a second consecutive road game (recovering from the cross-country road game), against an in-state opponent hungry to defeat JMU. The result of that 2nd consecutive road game should speak for itself, but let's review just for grins: 4 passing TDs, a blowout win by 26 points rewarded by a SBC Offensive Player of the Week Award.

If Cam doesn't start and play uninterrupted against Marshall this week something is rotten in Denmark. The only way JC should see the field against Marshall is if the game is a 3-4 score blowout in the 4th quarter.


Agree.

Big to me is we can't afford a loss. If we slip up in just one game (aka Louisville Special from last year) our playoff chances are shot. I think you can have a few packages to "occasionally" run with JC, but you can't play the switching series thing IMHO. After week one I was happy with moving forward with either, but how do you take a chance with a 4-0 start and what seems to me being an improving QB each week?
09-29-2026 08:09 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.