(09-28-2026 02:30 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-28-2026 02:12 PM)jmu98 Wrote: (09-28-2026 01:48 PM)JMad03 Wrote: (09-28-2026 01:35 PM)POTUS#4 Wrote: (09-27-2026 07:28 PM)Longhorn Wrote: That would be a disaster.
I understand why people say this, based on the fiasco during Chesney's time. But I don't think it's a foregone conclusion that it world go poorly now. I like the idea of a couple of scripted series for the QB2 rather than the QB1 wondering whether he would get yanked every time he made a bad throw.
Also, Sluka was kind of a one-trick pony - Chesney trotted him out there on third and two - everyone knew he was running. Not a formula for success. That's not an issue with Coleman and Evans. Coleman looks like a pretty decent scrambler/occasional runner and Evans can throw. If Evans gets healthy, I think he deserves a chance to get back out there and run a couple drives, at a minimum.
The issue I have is that Coleman hasn't done anything to deserve less time at QB. I get that Evans is a great athlete and it showed at times against Liberty.
At the same time, I am of the belief of "if it ain't broke, don't fix it". Plus I also believe if a guy earns his spot, he shouldn't lose it unless he isn't performing well.
Problem with this is Evans was the starter and did nothing to lose his job other than an unfortunate injury.
Not sure what right answer is but Evans earned his place and Coleman has performed well so my guess is that we see a little bit of both.
I get that. But Evans was out and Coleman has done a great job in his absence. He doesn't deserve to be taken out IMO.
I just don't quite understand why Napier would take out Coleman in favor of Evans. It's not like Evans played a fantastic game against Liberty. He was far from perfect. Yes, he is a far better athlete than Coleman and far more dynamic. But since Coleman has been in, the offense has been great. Why ruin what is working right now?
If Coleman starts struggling, then by all means bring back Evans. But Coleman doesn't deserve to be pulled right now. Doing so could ruin all the chemistry he's been building with this offense. It just doesn't seem worth the risk.
JC got injured while WINNING the game for us vs. Liberty. It is arguably the hardest opponent we've faced, and JC won that game. He did so while posting a higher QBR and completion % than Cam.
Cam's looked good in 3 games, but you have to throw out all of the stats and impression from the Wagner game. We could have put Longhorn under center during that game and still win by 50. Whoever was under center for that game is going to look like a Heisman candidate.
I agree with the "if it ain't broke" logic, but JC's gotta get the same treatment Cam got....4th and 8th series. There are so many benefits from this approach.
First, it keeps JC sharp, which will be important if/when Cam gets dinged up (and history says he likely will).
Second, it shows every member of the team that if you work hard, have the talent, and do what you need to do, you'll get an opportunity. Not giving JC anything beyond garbage time just sends the wrong signal to everyone.
Third, Cam arguably stays sharper knowing that the guy behind him is gunning for the job. He can't be complacent, even for a minute. He's forced to get better every practice.
Finally, since they have slightly different strenghths, opponents will have to prepare for both each week, which could be an advantage.