(09-28-2026 09:12 PM)JMaddy Wrote: (09-28-2026 08:58 PM)DoubleDogDare Wrote: Let's have an honest conversation first. You note Evans didn't have another attempt over 8 yards but then give Coleman credit for 4 completions >10 yards. His 15 and a 11 yarder were 5 yard hitches to Grevious in soft coverage (incl. a 5 yard hitch on a 2nd and 25/Goal) thus allowing him to get >10 yards out of them without a single broken tackle. If the WR's had more YAC on short passes, and let's say Evans went 7/9 for 100 yards, that doesn't change his performance from "far from perfect" to "good" or "great" right? No, trying to point out Coleman had 4x more 10 yard completions is a silly take.
Despite being disingenuous on Coleman's completions, I actually think not seeing Evans throw more deep balls is a fair point to bring up. But to not see a QB throw a deep ball and use that as support that he was "far from perfect" when he completed 77% of his passes and didn't turn the ball over is just dumb.
And we can separate a QB and an OC can't we? Evans was given plays and he executed them at a level that was closer to "perfect" than "far from perfect". He opened the game with 17 points in 3 drives - something Coleman has yet to do against FBS competition if we must have his name in every post. On those second half three and outs under Evans, he went 1/2 passing - hardly a reason to blame him for not having more drives ending with passing TDs.
And to be crystal clear, I have no problem with Coleman starting the next three years based on what we have seen. I have a problem with disingenuous, flat out inaccurate, or be complete dumb@$$ takes.
I think you may be missing the point that the OC calls plays for the QB they are dealing with. While I like Evans and think he has potential to be elite, he does have a bit of the Sluka run first mentality which I hate far above anything else in a QB. I want an ABIII, McCloud, Centaio, CJ, DiNucci kind of QB who throws first and runs when they need to. A perfect QB performance is someone who runs twice for every 10-15 dropbacks and hands the ball off for most designed run plays and still gets 65-70% completion and QBR over 100.
Slants that turn into 15 yards means the QB picked the right WR and lead them so they can get YAC. A 2 or 7 yard pass with zero YAC means the QB threw them into a tackle or into tigheter coverage than necessary (which is what happened against Liberty).
Talk about disingenuous takes.
The QB's overall ability and a single game performance are different. Speaking of DiNucci, he was "far from perfect" against UNH, and Evans' game was perfect comparatively. Doesn't mean Evans is a better QB.
So we have 4 criteria for a perfect QB game:
- Runs twice for every 10-15 dropbacks - I think the run/pass percentage is irrelevant for evaluating a QBs game but I'll go with it as neither Coleman nor Evans will be perfect under this metric.
- Hands the ball off for most designed run plays - I don't know what that means. Are we pretending like options don't exist, and if acknowledging that that do exist, are we saying the QB shouldn't make a read but instead just hand it off to be perfect?
- 65-70% completion - I'm guessing you kept low because you want the QB to miss some deep passes? I mean Evan's was 77%, a threshold that Coleman has yet while averaging only 62% (and never landing in the 65-70% range).
- QBR over 100 - Sure. Evans was 88 against Liberty, another threshold Coleman yet to hit while averaging only 62.
So fine, if Evan's was "far from perfect" in your eye's, Coleman has been "far from perfect" at best so far (doing slightly better on runs per dropback while worst on completion % and QBR)? I'm fine with that as at least we are judging on the same basis.
And your point on air yards was that Evans can't throw a deep ball but Coleman can, nothing about receiver selection. Don't move the goal post now, Suarez has been perfect so far.