Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: A modest CFP compromise proposal
(06-19-2026 10:05 AM)ken d Wrote: (06-17-2026 01:43 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (06-17-2026 12:50 PM)Crayton Wrote: (06-17-2026 11:18 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: I always come back to K.I.S.S.
[…]
I don’t see why it has to be that difficult. Each of the P4 champs plus the top G6 champ (or team or however you want to define it) gets into the playoff and then everyone else is an at-large for the rest of the field
[…]
The SEC doesn’t care about this system format or who gets AQs or anything beyond that if you’re eliminating or devaluing their CCG, then they need to get compensated for it and then some.
Agree that KISS wins the day, but when it comes to compensation everyone is going to want ‘something’ for giving up their CCGs. Even if they make more money, they are losing control of an asset.
That compensation may take the form of AQs or home games or a renegotiation of the CFP revenue split. Everyone makes more money from expansion but the value of different CCGs does not match the current revenue split. If the SEC gets “something” the other CFP members are going to want something too. I would not be surprised if a KISS format morphs into one with special carve outs like this to get it across the finish line.
Maybe we are already at the stage where “24” is agreed to in principle and we are trading horses so that everyone feels they come out ahead. Though Sankey is at least putting out the face that 24 (8 play-ins to a round of 16) has not been vetted enough by his constituents to say it is a valid path.
Understood that there’s horse trading, but I think my issue is that the multiple AQs simply don’t address what the SEC wants with an expanded playoff. They want their cake and eat it, too, meaning both a CCG plus as much of an at-large field as possible (and maybe eliminating all AQs completely). So, it’s sort of like we’re proposing compromises that aren’t really compromises since the SEC, more than anyone, has made it abundantly clear that they don’t want multiple AQs per league.
Therefore, the only real clarity comes from an economic argument: there has to be convincing evidence that expanding the CFP would yield more revenue and, just as importantly, expand the revenue *advantage* that the SEC has over the other leagues outside of the Big Ten. That’s really the economic value of the SEC Championship Game outside of the money itself - only the B1G comes even close to being able to monetize their CCG like the SEC, so the CCG is something that is particularly valuable in that no one else is able to monetize it in the same way. (This is the value of the Rose Bowl tie-in for the Big Ten to a lesser extent - it’s simply a more valuable berth holistically beyond just a normal playoff berth in another bowl or location, albeit not as direct in terms of contractual revenue like the SEC CCG.)
The most compelling argument that Tony Petitti has made if I’m looking at it from the SEC perspective is that even if you just expand the CFP to 16, the CCGs are already going to be devalued beyond the additional revenue from a smaller expansion of the playoff, so everyone is better off by going big with the expansion (if only because that provides a lot more playoff games to go to the open market as opposed to just being allocated to the lower value ESPN CFP contract).
Now, that has to assume that Petitti’s numbers actually pencil out under an objective analysis (which is an open question). The SEC and Sankey certainly have a right to be skeptical about those numbers without that objective analysis that they trust. (This is colored by the fact that the SEC is tied to ESPN and you can’t trust ESPN on this issue at all because they inherently have an interest to deflate the perceived value of an expanded CFP. That analysis needs to come from a trusted source that isn’t tied to either ESPN or Fox.)
In any event, though, this is only getting solved with money. The format is irrelevant without that money part solved. An expanded CFP can’t just be “making more money for everyone”, but rather showing how much more the SEC receives disproportionately compared to any non-B1G party in order to make eliminating a CCG worth it.
just as importantly, expand the revenue *advantage* that the SEC has over the other leagues outside of the Big Ten.
They seem to be pursuing a strategy, not to persuade stakeholders to modify the CFP to their liking, but rather, to produce a stalemate on the CFP format that will ultimately result in the B1G and SEC separating themselves from the rest of the FBS. The desired end game is for each of them to stage a conference owned tournament with the two champions meeting in a "bowl" game, which they will not formally claim to be a national championship.
All of this is to say that the posturing the P2 are engaged in is just theater and not really a debate.
I actually don’t think that’s the case.
Even if we subscribe to a theory that the P2 *want* to break off, the likelihood of that occurring within 5 years is small. It’s probably charitable to think that it could even occur within 10 years even if they started that process right now today.
Yet, the money needs of the schools (including those in the B1G and SEC) can’t wait 5 or 10 years for strategic posturing. They all need money NOW. They need to pay for their football and basketball rosters for next season NOW.
CFP expansion is one of the few avenues besides more drastic measures (such as selling off parts of the athletic department to private equity) to get an immediate cash infusion. That’s why every league besides the Big Ten and SEC essentially doesn’t even care about the playoff format or whether it’s 16 or 24 - they just want to additional money and want any type of expansion in whatever the P2 can agree upon.
It’s akin to a wildfire going through a neighborhood. A lot of schools and leagues already have houses on fire from a financial perspective. Everyone else - even the very wealthiest like Ohio State and Alabama - may not have houses on fire yet, but they can see the wildfire happening down the road. I think we want to believe that the leaders of our schools are being strategic and thoughtful with long-term thinking, but I believe that the psychology of self-preservation is a more powerful force than anything and the urgency is a lot more dire than what a lot of people are giving credit for here. Not even the wealthiest schools can really wait that much longer to cash in any type of CFP expansion.
|
|
| 06-19-2026 10:45 AM |
|