quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-05-2026 11:51 AM)msu35 Wrote: (06-05-2026 10:38 AM)quo vadis Wrote: I have no issue admitting that, in the realignment game, USF has "struggled with checkers". For at least 10 years, from 2012-2022, we made about as many dumb movies as can be imagined that resulted in double- and triple- jumps by our realignment rivals.
But IMO things have improved dramatically. Gaining AAU status was a huge leap forward institutionally and has fired up the USF community. IMO that boost was critical to finally getting moving on the OCS, which I agree is likely (heck, arguably already is) a huge financial white elephant. But also necessary to M2 prospects.
Also, I LOL at the idea that Memphis is playing chess. If USF has any rival for realignment failure and boondogglery, it has to be Memphis. Heck, USF actually was in a "major" conference for eight years. Memphis has tried every desperate trick in the book to get promoted, and yet remains stuck firmly in the AAC. The one time they did seemingly get promoted, to the "Big East" in 2012, that visions melted before their eyes as it became a G-league as soon as Memphis and the other noobs joined. Memphis IMO has had zero track record in terms of reaiignment strategy, and the waiving around of FedEx money to no effect has been an embarrassment, IMO.
Hey, none of us knows for sure about any of this. I could well be wrong and maybe circa 2030 Memphis will finally get that M2 callup while USF purgatory endures. We'll see.
You admitted in your own post that the on-campus stadium is a "financial white elephant" and that you "loathe" the massive fees and academic transfers funding USF athletics. Yet, in the very next breath, you excuse it all because it might help our "M2 prospects" and because gaining AAU status "fired up the community." Thanks for proving my thesis, vibes over competence indeed.
That is the definition of cognitive dissonance. You're pumping sunshine to mask institutional malfeasance, and the math has officially caught up to the vibes. Don't believe for a second that a "power" conference is going to invite a structurally insolvent athletic department, saddling themselves with an irresponsible administration that is destined to become the next charity case dragging the league down. Let's look at the actual reality of your "M2 lottery ticket" as of today.
You're using AAU status as a psychological coping mechanism to justify asset-stripping. AAU status is built entirely on academic metrics: research expenditures, doctoral turnouts, and faculty retention. You can't claim to celebrate AAU status while simultaneously defending a Board of Trustees that is systematically raiding the university's reserves, draining student auxiliary funds, and taking out $22.5 million internal bailout loans to prop up an athletic department that can't cover its debt. You're actively cheering for the degradation of the core academic mission that earned the AAU badge in the first place.
Furthermore, your entire thesis relies on a massive gamble: that an expensive stadium you can't afford will magically secure a "power" conference invite to retroactively bail out the university. Realignment is driven by television market share, viewership numbers, financial stability, and brand equity -- not by how much debt a school can pile onto its central ledger. By wiping out cash reserves, dipping into future foundation donations ($50M), and locking the university into a non-discretionary, $20M annual mortgage to Truist Bank, USF hasn't made itself more attractive to anyone other than the financially illiterate. What it has done is created a highly leveraged, financially unstable risk.
Trashing Memphis's realignment history -- better to get the smoke than to be perpetually ignored like the Bulls -- or their handling of FedEx money is pure cope and completely irrelevant to USF athletics' existential financial crisis. Memphis isn't the entity that just posted an 18.11% drop in donor contributions while staring down a massive $16M increase in student-athlete revenue sharing for the 2026-27 fiscal year. Memphis's perceived shortcomings don't pay Truist Bank for you. The bottom line is that Memphis has a healthy donor ecosystem and will be completing their $0.22B renovations using municipal, private, and local donor funding, completely debt free; something USF wouldn't know anything about, hence the subprime mortgage that will cripple you for decades.
You're aware of the structural debt loop -- you called it a white elephant yourself -- but you're letting cognitive dissonance blind you to the mechanics. The State Division of Bond Finance explicitly warned that the "conservatism has been eliminated" and that operating failures would force academic subsidies. Those warnings are no longer hypothetical. The university is officially playing a high-stakes financial shell game, using student money and internal loans to keep the lights on in the athletic department. No amount of "M2 cope smoking" changes this fact, and it certainly doesn't make you attractive to a "power" conference, AAU or not.
To me, it isn't cognitive dissonance to say that (a) the new stadium is a financial white elephant and also (b) I approve of it anyway as a means to get into an M2 conference. It just means that I think absorbing the costs of the white elephant is worth it if it results in getting an M2 bid. I mean, IIRC, we have been hugely subsidizing our athletics via student fees and transfers for a long time now, basically forever, and yet our institution has grown and thrived. Now, if we don't get such a bid, it will be an abject failure, but the jury is out on that, so no question, taking on huge debt for the stadium is a big gamble, with no guarantee of success. But IMO it is a gamble worth making.
As for Memphis, I think your school is saddled with poor perceptions. You are like someone in the rain who nobody wants tracking their muddy shoes or dripping overcoat into the house unless absolutely necessary. Even a desperation $200m booty-wagging was spurned by a conference that otherwise seems to turn over every rock to get more money.
We'll see.
(This post was last modified: 06-05-2026 05:30 PM by quo vadis.)
|
|