Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
Author Message
UofMemphis Away
Official MT.org Ambassador of Smack
*

Posts: 49,757
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 1239
I Root For: Univ of Memphis
Location: Memphis (Berclair)

Donators
Post: #121
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-05-2026 06:28 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 05:18 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  To me, it isn't cognitive dissonance to say that (a) the new stadium is a financial white elephant and also (b) I approve of it anyway as a means to get into an M2 conference. It just means that I think absorbing the costs of the white elephant is worth it if it results in getting an M2 bid. I mean, IIRC, we have been hugely subsidizing our athletics via student fees and transfers for a long time now, basically forever, and yet our institution has grown and thrived. Now, if we don't get such a bid, it will be an abject failure, but the jury is out on that, so no question, taking on huge debt for the stadium is a big gamble, with no guarantee of success. But IMO it is a gamble worth making.

We'll see.

I appreciate the candor. Moving from fictional corporate finance structures to admitting this is an institutional white elephant is at least honest. But the fatal flaw of the "gamble worth making" defense is that it treats a P4 invite like a charitable intervention. This is textbook risk mispricing where one is assigning upside probabilities that don't exist while ignoring quantifiable downside.

Media executives and conference leaders don't look at a structurally insolvent G6 athletic department bleeding donors, struggling for corporate sponsorship, fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched professional sports monarchy, and think, "Yes, this program represents a stable addition. Let's invite them in to bail out their mortgage." A conference invite isn't a bailout. It's a vetting process, and financial stability is a cornerstone metric. Schools will be evaluated on stability, revenue reliability, market performance, and institutional governance; all areas where compounding debt volatility is an unambiguous negative.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that your public world-view is that you don't want anyone in the AAC to do well aside from the Bulls, but I genuinely want every program in the AAC to be successful. A stronger conference benefits all of us. In a perfect world, both Memphis and USF get the call up. I simply can't support an administration so willing to make catastrophic, and arguably unethical, financial decisions for a low-percentage, high-risk gamble; leveraging institutional health and student experience as collateral. This is de-facto "vibes-based" governance, substituting optimism for stability and solvency.

You guys were great when you were kicking the conference's ass last season in basketball. I was hoping for epic battles this season. Same for football. Unfortunately, the personnel management has been as misguided, if not moreso, than the financing. I don't understand. The athletic director gambled everything on an extreme long shot "vibes" coaching hire who immediately hired one of the least defensible coordinator gambles in the country, and immediately promoted his brother from a low-level, off-field analyst to the on-field quarterbacks coach. Instead of locking in your championship winning coach, you let Providence poach him without even a whimper.

Hopefully everything works out for you, but thus far, everything has been going wrong for the Bulls, regardless of how aggressively the social-media hype machine tries to paper over the cracks.

I would like to see enough ACC teams get poached to allow Memphis, USF, Tulane and UConn to move as a group to a reformed ACC.
06-05-2026 07:55 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #122
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-05-2026 07:55 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:28 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 05:18 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  To me, it isn't cognitive dissonance to say that (a) the new stadium is a financial white elephant and also (b) I approve of it anyway as a means to get into an M2 conference. It just means that I think absorbing the costs of the white elephant is worth it if it results in getting an M2 bid. I mean, IIRC, we have been hugely subsidizing our athletics via student fees and transfers for a long time now, basically forever, and yet our institution has grown and thrived. Now, if we don't get such a bid, it will be an abject failure, but the jury is out on that, so no question, taking on huge debt for the stadium is a big gamble, with no guarantee of success. But IMO it is a gamble worth making.

We'll see.

I appreciate the candor. Moving from fictional corporate finance structures to admitting this is an institutional white elephant is at least honest. But the fatal flaw of the "gamble worth making" defense is that it treats a P4 invite like a charitable intervention. This is textbook risk mispricing where one is assigning upside probabilities that don't exist while ignoring quantifiable downside.

Media executives and conference leaders don't look at a structurally insolvent G6 athletic department bleeding donors, struggling for corporate sponsorship, fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched professional sports monarchy, and think, "Yes, this program represents a stable addition. Let's invite them in to bail out their mortgage." A conference invite isn't a bailout. It's a vetting process, and financial stability is a cornerstone metric. Schools will be evaluated on stability, revenue reliability, market performance, and institutional governance; all areas where compounding debt volatility is an unambiguous negative.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that your public world-view is that you don't want anyone in the AAC to do well aside from the Bulls, but I genuinely want every program in the AAC to be successful. A stronger conference benefits all of us. In a perfect world, both Memphis and USF get the call up. I simply can't support an administration so willing to make catastrophic, and arguably unethical, financial decisions for a low-percentage, high-risk gamble; leveraging institutional health and student experience as collateral. This is de-facto "vibes-based" governance, substituting optimism for stability and solvency.

You guys were great when you were kicking the conference's ass last season in basketball. I was hoping for epic battles this season. Same for football. Unfortunately, the personnel management has been as misguided, if not moreso, than the financing. I don't understand. The athletic director gambled everything on an extreme long shot "vibes" coaching hire who immediately hired one of the least defensible coordinator gambles in the country, and immediately promoted his brother from a low-level, off-field analyst to the on-field quarterbacks coach. Instead of locking in your championship winning coach, you let Providence poach him without even a whimper.

Hopefully everything works out for you, but thus far, everything has been going wrong for the Bulls, regardless of how aggressively the social-media hype machine tries to paper over the cracks.

I would like to see enough ACC teams get poached to allow Memphis, USF, Tulane and UConn to move as a group to a reformed ACC.

Why? You already have Louisville as a rival in the ACC and several like UH and Cincinnati in the Big 12. This is every man for himself, you shouldn’t waste time worrying about the guy next to you while the boat is sinking. If anything, you guys would be better off if the ACC only loses 2 and decides to add one to get back to 16 in fb, as long as Memphis with all that FedEx money is the one.
06-05-2026 09:31 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #123
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-05-2026 07:37 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:16 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 01:41 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 01:24 PM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 01:09 PM)msu35 Wrote:  Ah, smart guy. Tell me again how the school isn't raiding the trust. USF Oracle certainly disagrees with you. You must have graduated before the AAU membership. At the very least, laughing is better than crying.

Bottom line, the STUDENTS rejected paying for the vanity project you can't afford. So what does the school do? They take it anyway. Nice.

Nobody said we weren't utilizing CITF funds for the stadium. It's laughable that you don't realize CITF funds are for exactly this - capital projects including building and renovating academic and athletic projects. It's controlled by the state and utilized by all universities in the state university system. This fund literally exists to help finance large projects like an OCS and over the past few years has spent $50MM/yr across the SUS for dozens of projects statewide. If you think an OCS isn't in the benefit of the students on campus, I can't help you. But, I will continue to laugh.

Keep laughing, because your complete lack of institutional literacy is doing all the work for me.

You trying to frame the CITF as a generic "state pot" is a transparently dishonest attempt to cover up the backdoor tax. Do you know how the Capital Improvement Trust Fund actually works under Florida Statute 1009.24 and BOG regulations?

CITF funds are not generic state dollars. They're built directly from a mandatory fee levied on students per credit hour. Furthermore, by state law, CITF allocations require a joint student-faculty committee where students hold formal voting power to recommend the project list. The fund's explicit, primary purpose is to finance projects that support the daily, general student experience: student unions, campus rec centers, student health clinics, and study spaces.

When your administration used $31M of CITF money for the stadium, they didn't magically "get money from the state." They actively pressured the student allocation process to divert a massive, disproportionate chunk of USF's limited campus-improvement capital away from everyday student infrastructure and dumped it into an athletic project. The university quite literally took $31M in restricted public fees -- statutorily collected per credit hour from everyday students specifically to fund non-revenue campus improvements -- and used it as an equity cushion to lower the borrowing costs on a commercial, auxiliary football stadium whose future revenues are legally pledged to Truist Bank. They used restricted student infrastructure capital to underwrite a private bank note.

The students explicitly voted NO on a direct stadium fee in 2017. So the school waited, bypassed that democratic rejection, and siphoned $31M out of the exact trust fund meant to improve Student Unions and campus life just to bail out an athletic department running a multi-million dollar deficit. USF took money meant for the entire student body's daily campus experience to subsidize a vanity mortgage because your athletic department lacks the donor base and liquidity to pay its own bills.

That isn't "utilizing state funds." That is a literal backdoor raid on student-generated tuition capital to fund a project they already told you they didn't want to pay for. But please, tell me more about how elite your "competence" is while you starve your own campus infrastructure to pay Truist Bank.

Again, keep laughing...

Sounds like how a lot of governments do things. When Texas built their upper deck in the late 60s they included Bellmont Hall which included gym facilities available to the whole student body except when the stadium was being used. Of course on the edge of campus, it wasnt utilized by general students much compared to the two gyms better located. That was what allowed state funding.

The 1960s? If you didn't notice, UT made other arrangements and had OVG cover the construction in the modern era. That's like arguing a modern service station sells leaded fuel.

Texas didn't have unlimited money in the 60s. Neither does anyone in the G6. And a number in the P4.
06-05-2026 11:23 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2229
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #124
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-05-2026 11:23 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:37 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:16 PM)bullet Wrote:  Sounds like how a lot of governments do things. When Texas built their upper deck in the late 60s they included Bellmont Hall which included gym facilities available to the whole student body except when the stadium was being used. Of course on the edge of campus, it wasnt utilized by general students much compared to the two gyms better located. That was what allowed state funding.

The 1960s? If you didn't notice, UT made other arrangements and had OVG cover the construction in the modern era. That's like arguing a modern service station sells leaded fuel.

Texas didn't have unlimited money in the 60s. Neither does anyone in the G6. And a number in the P4.

Nice false equivalence. First, USF isn't some cash-strapped 1960s program; they operate a $100M+ athletic budget that is fundamentally broke because they don't know how to spend within their means. Cosplaying a P4 program is expensive.

Your 1960s Texas comparison is irrelevant, and you're confidently wrong. Texas didn't leverage subprime commercial lending. They didn't raid a student-specific trust, after the students voted "no" to direct stadium support, to satisfy a lack of equity. They also didn't lend their endowment funds to the athletic department, generating internal debt to satisfy the toxic stadium mortgage, creating a structural debt loop. Responsible governance isn't optional.
06-06-2026 01:21 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #125
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-05-2026 09:31 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:55 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:28 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 05:18 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  To me, it isn't cognitive dissonance to say that (a) the new stadium is a financial white elephant and also (b) I approve of it anyway as a means to get into an M2 conference. It just means that I think absorbing the costs of the white elephant is worth it if it results in getting an M2 bid. I mean, IIRC, we have been hugely subsidizing our athletics via student fees and transfers for a long time now, basically forever, and yet our institution has grown and thrived. Now, if we don't get such a bid, it will be an abject failure, but the jury is out on that, so no question, taking on huge debt for the stadium is a big gamble, with no guarantee of success. But IMO it is a gamble worth making.

We'll see.

I appreciate the candor. Moving from fictional corporate finance structures to admitting this is an institutional white elephant is at least honest. But the fatal flaw of the "gamble worth making" defense is that it treats a P4 invite like a charitable intervention. This is textbook risk mispricing where one is assigning upside probabilities that don't exist while ignoring quantifiable downside.

Media executives and conference leaders don't look at a structurally insolvent G6 athletic department bleeding donors, struggling for corporate sponsorship, fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched professional sports monarchy, and think, "Yes, this program represents a stable addition. Let's invite them in to bail out their mortgage." A conference invite isn't a bailout. It's a vetting process, and financial stability is a cornerstone metric. Schools will be evaluated on stability, revenue reliability, market performance, and institutional governance; all areas where compounding debt volatility is an unambiguous negative.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that your public world-view is that you don't want anyone in the AAC to do well aside from the Bulls, but I genuinely want every program in the AAC to be successful. A stronger conference benefits all of us. In a perfect world, both Memphis and USF get the call up. I simply can't support an administration so willing to make catastrophic, and arguably unethical, financial decisions for a low-percentage, high-risk gamble; leveraging institutional health and student experience as collateral. This is de-facto "vibes-based" governance, substituting optimism for stability and solvency.

You guys were great when you were kicking the conference's ass last season in basketball. I was hoping for epic battles this season. Same for football. Unfortunately, the personnel management has been as misguided, if not moreso, than the financing. I don't understand. The athletic director gambled everything on an extreme long shot "vibes" coaching hire who immediately hired one of the least defensible coordinator gambles in the country, and immediately promoted his brother from a low-level, off-field analyst to the on-field quarterbacks coach. Instead of locking in your championship winning coach, you let Providence poach him without even a whimper.

Hopefully everything works out for you, but thus far, everything has been going wrong for the Bulls, regardless of how aggressively the social-media hype machine tries to paper over the cracks.

I would like to see enough ACC teams get poached to allow Memphis, USF, Tulane and UConn to move as a group to a reformed ACC.

Why? You already have Louisville as a rival in the ACC and several like UH and Cincinnati in the Big 12. This is every man for himself, you shouldn’t waste time worrying about the guy next to you while the boat is sinking. If anything, you guys would be better off if the ACC only loses 2 and decides to add one to get back to 16 in fb, as long as Memphis with all that FedEx money is the one.

Well, FWIW I am in favor of any scenario - whether it is USF alone or with three other current AAC schools - that gets USF into an M2 conference. Only caveat being that the M2 conference remains M2 with our joining, unlike say joining the PAC right now would be. I guess if I had my choice I would prefer to be elevated alone among all the current AAC schools, but I would gladly accept a scenario that gets the four schools mentioned by the Memphis fan in as well.
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 06:44 AM by quo vadis.)
06-06-2026 06:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
TIGERCITY Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 21,643
Joined: Feb 2009
Reputation: 581
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
Post: #126
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 01:21 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 11:23 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:37 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:16 PM)bullet Wrote:  Sounds like how a lot of governments do things. When Texas built their upper deck in the late 60s they included Bellmont Hall which included gym facilities available to the whole student body except when the stadium was being used. Of course on the edge of campus, it wasnt utilized by general students much compared to the two gyms better located. That was what allowed state funding.

The 1960s? If you didn't notice, UT made other arrangements and had OVG cover the construction in the modern era. That's like arguing a modern service station sells leaded fuel.

Texas didn't have unlimited money in the 60s. Neither does anyone in the G6. And a number in the P4.

Nice false equivalence. First, USF isn't some cash-strapped 1960s program; they operate a $100M+ athletic budget that is fundamentally broke because they don't know how to spend within their means. Cosplaying a P4 program is expensive.

Your 1960s Texas comparison is irrelevant, and you're confidently wrong. Texas didn't leverage subprime commercial lending. They didn't raid a student-specific trust, after the students voted "no" to direct stadium support, to satisfy a lack of equity. They also didn't lend their endowment funds to the athletic department, generating internal debt to satisfy the toxic stadium mortgage, creating a structural debt loop. Responsible governance isn't optional.

South Florida is betting with a credit card at the casino recognizing that the next few years are all that matter. You win , you're a big winner , you lose , it doesn't matter anyway.
06-06-2026 08:12 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bill dazzle Offline
Craft beer and urban living enthusiast
*

Posts: 18,670
Joined: Aug 2016
Reputation: 2038
I Root For: Vanderbilt
Location: Nashville
Post: #127
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
I would like to see Memphis and USF remain conference mates in either the Big 12 or ACC.

And, as I have noted, I strongly want to see Memphis and Tulane aligned in the same league (just not the American, of course).
06-06-2026 09:24 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #128
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
These schools are all below the ACC and Big 12 averages. Now some are close to SMU, the last one in, in many metrics. But SMU has more millionaires and they are in the 4th largest metro in the US.

W/L football 2014-2024 (not updated for last season)
W L %
SMU 74 63 54.0%

Washington St. 74 58 56.1%
Boise St. 106 36 74.6%
Memphis 99 43 69.7%
Oregon St. 51 79 39.2%
USF 62 72 46.3%
Temple 62 72 46.3%
East Carolina 54 78 40.9%

Fresno St. 64 63 50.4%
Colorado St. 58 71 45.0%
Connecticut 36 87 29.3%
San Diego St. 86 53 61.9%
Tulane 69 71 49.3%
UNLV 49 82 37.4%

Football rankings and NCAA tournaments:
ranked NCAA sweet 16
SMU 2 2 0

Washington St. 2 1 0
Boise St. 5 4 0
Memphis 3 3 0
Oregon St. 2 2 1
USF 0 0 0
Temple 2 2 0
East Carolina 0 0 0

Fresno St. 1 1 0
Colorado St. 0 3 0
Connecticut 0 6 2
San Diego St. 1 7 2
Tulane 1 0 0
UNLV 1 0 0

Average TV rating 2013-2021 (top 36 over 9 years), average 4 year attendance (2021-24) and 2023-24 revenue
Note that TV wasn't that interested in showing UNLV or Colorado St. games with only 20 and 22 over those 9 years, vs. 72 for Boise.
rating 4 yr att revenue
Average B12 2.069 47,269 125,041,940
Median B12 2.031 47,830 121,080,103
Average ACC 2.468 44,808 146,079,157
Median ACC 2.08 41,353 139,458,791
games rating 4 yr att revenue
45 SMU 0.728 25,853 99,506,414
23-24
56 Wash. St. 1.905 24,960 89,041,553
72 Boise St. 1.258 35,726 59,885,466
52 Memphis 1.257 27,956 62,737,618
40 Oregon St. 1.214 33,698 120,225,018
48 USF 1.103 33,122 95,425,212
42 Temple 0.891 16,527 70,320,170
37 E. Carolina 0.56 37,057 65,211,957

33 Fresno St. 0.697 38,256 55,761,420
22 Colorado St. 0.605 28,395 50,262,504
31 Uconn 0.571 21,704 91,800,871
28 SDSU 0.522 22,542 83,949,123
35 Tulane 0.419 20,962 39,305,494
20 UNLV 0.307 25,083 65,376,772
06-06-2026 10:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #129
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
An interesting number is how these schools revenues (expenditures) have changed over the last year:

23-24 24-25 change
USF 95,425,212 122,093,386 26,668,174
Oregon St. 120,225,018 104,767,703 (15,457,315)
Uconn 91,800,871 97,050,998 5,250,127
SDSU 83,949,123 89,827,012 5,877,889
Boise St. 59,885,466 89,699,430 29,813,964
Wash. St. 89,041,553 82,229,485 (6,812,068)
UNLV 65,376,772 77,272,658 11,895,886
Temple 70,320,170 71,198,560 878,390
E. Carolina 65,211,957 68,011,262 2,799,305
Tulane 39,305,494 66,211,945 26,906,451
Memphis 62,737,618 65,857,423 3,119,805
Fresno St. 55,761,420 63,439,685 7,678,265
Colorado St. 50,262,504 55,794,198 5,531,694

Memphis is still relatively low among this group (Rice, JMU and Liberty are the only other G schools over $60 million, so they are pretty high among all G schools). USF, Boise and Tulane have ramped up their spending.

Overall ECU, Fresno St. and Colorado St. look like schools that will need to be content trying to be among the top G schools. UNLV needs to hope casino money is enough to overcome their other metrics looking pretty weak. I don't know that the Big 12 and ACC will take any of these schools if they get raided, but I suspect these 4 don't get a serious look.
06-06-2026 10:41 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Acres Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,156
Joined: Nov 2015
Reputation: 96
I Root For: Houston, Texas Southern
Location:
Post: #130
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
Timing is everything. The big12 added Houston, BYU, Cinci and UCF because its very existence depended on it. This was not by choice. The conference needed to secure a tv deal. Eight schools was not going to do it for Espn or FOX

Presently, I seriously doubt the big12 is going to add a non P4 school. It can’t afford the perception of dilution heading to the market in 5 years for a new tv deal.

The four that got in were very lucky. The door closed behind them, at least for the big12.
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 10:59 AM by Acres.)
06-06-2026 10:49 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #131
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 01:21 AM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 11:23 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:37 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:16 PM)bullet Wrote:  Sounds like how a lot of governments do things. When Texas built their upper deck in the late 60s they included Bellmont Hall which included gym facilities available to the whole student body except when the stadium was being used. Of course on the edge of campus, it wasnt utilized by general students much compared to the two gyms better located. That was what allowed state funding.

The 1960s? If you didn't notice, UT made other arrangements and had OVG cover the construction in the modern era. That's like arguing a modern service station sells leaded fuel.

Texas didn't have unlimited money in the 60s. Neither does anyone in the G6. And a number in the P4.

Nice false equivalence. First, USF isn't some cash-strapped 1960s program; they operate a $100M+ athletic budget that is fundamentally broke because they don't know how to spend within their means. Cosplaying a P4 program is expensive.

Your 1960s Texas comparison is irrelevant, and you're confidently wrong. Texas didn't leverage subprime commercial lending. They didn't raid a student-specific trust, after the students voted "no" to direct stadium support, to satisfy a lack of equity. They also didn't lend their endowment funds to the athletic department, generating internal debt to satisfy the toxic stadium mortgage, creating a structural debt loop. Responsible governance isn't optional.

Didn't Dr Scott say that your current spending is unsustainable, and that you can only keep it up for 3-4 years if you don't get into the P4? It doesn't matter HOW you guys or USF are overspending, it doesn't even matter that you're spending beyond your means at all imo. All that matters is if you get to play conference games and Texas Tech and Louisville in 5 years or against Tulsa and Rice. Everybody who isn't UT (either of them) or an equivalent program is spending well beyond their means these days, including almost all P4 schools. Is it any wonder that USF would be scrambling to keep things rolling? I don't criticize Memphis for spending like you gusy are btw, I think that Dr Scott is an excellent AD and he has you guys on quite possibly the best possible path, but I also see no reason to criticize USF for doing what many others are doing.
06-06-2026 11:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #132
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 10:41 AM)bullet Wrote:  An interesting number is how these schools revenues (expenditures) have changed over the last year:

23-24 24-25 change
USF 95,425,212 122,093,386 26,668,174
Oregon St. 120,225,018 104,767,703 (15,457,315)
Uconn 91,800,871 97,050,998 5,250,127
SDSU 83,949,123 89,827,012 5,877,889
Boise St. 59,885,466 89,699,430 29,813,964
Wash. St. 89,041,553 82,229,485 (6,812,068)
UNLV 65,376,772 77,272,658 11,895,886
Temple 70,320,170 71,198,560 878,390
E. Carolina 65,211,957 68,011,262 2,799,305
Tulane 39,305,494 66,211,945 26,906,451
Memphis 62,737,618 65,857,423 3,119,805
Fresno St. 55,761,420 63,439,685 7,678,265
Colorado St. 50,262,504 55,794,198 5,531,694

Memphis is still relatively low among this group (Rice, JMU and Liberty are the only other G schools over $60 million, so they are pretty high among all G schools). USF, Boise and Tulane have ramped up their spending.

Overall ECU, Fresno St. and Colorado St. look like schools that will need to be content trying to be among the top G schools. UNLV needs to hope casino money is enough to overcome their other metrics looking pretty weak. I don't know that the Big 12 and ACC will take any of these schools if they get raided, but I suspect these 4 don't get a serious look.

One reason to look at areas other than spending when/if there's a breakaway is that spending tends to skyrocket for a few years when you're building a new stadium. Should Kansas be considered a $205m a year program b/c they had one year that high during a huge stadium remodel? Should USF be a $120m a year program when that number is wildly skewed? What about student fees and transfers? That about ASU and that $52m the Academic side just gifted to the AD? There are just so many ways to screw with those numbers if you know that they're being used as an inclusion (or exclusion) measuring stick.
06-06-2026 11:42 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #133
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 10:41 AM)bullet Wrote:  An interesting number is how these schools revenues (expenditures) have changed over the last year:

23-24 24-25 change
USF 95,425,212 122,093,386 26,668,174
Oregon St. 120,225,018 104,767,703 (15,457,315)
Uconn 91,800,871 97,050,998 5,250,127
SDSU 83,949,123 89,827,012 5,877,889
Boise St. 59,885,466 89,699,430 29,813,964
Wash. St. 89,041,553 82,229,485 (6,812,068)
UNLV 65,376,772 77,272,658 11,895,886
Temple 70,320,170 71,198,560 878,390
E. Carolina 65,211,957 68,011,262 2,799,305
Tulane 39,305,494 66,211,945 26,906,451
Memphis 62,737,618 65,857,423 3,119,805
Fresno St. 55,761,420 63,439,685 7,678,265
Colorado St. 50,262,504 55,794,198 5,531,694

Memphis is still relatively low among this group (Rice, JMU and Liberty are the only other G schools over $60 million, so they are pretty high among all G schools). USF, Boise and Tulane have ramped up their spending.

Overall ECU, Fresno St. and Colorado St. look like schools that will need to be content trying to be among the top G schools. UNLV needs to hope casino money is enough to overcome their other metrics looking pretty weak. I don't know that the Big 12 and ACC will take any of these schools if they get raided, but I suspect these 4 don't get a serious look.

I'm not saying that you're wrong but what does this have to do with realignment? Some of us are spending within our means, sustainably, based on what we know to be the case now.

Others are not. Memphis has already stated that their current investment will not be sustained if they do not wind up in a A4 conference. USF has not stated as such but I'm sure the same thing applies to them, at least when it comes to their revenue share (and they will not need a new football stadium anytime soon).

I'm not knocking either Memphis or USF, btw. I just think that sustainable spending matters greatly. Winning and the correpsonding increase in attendence/viewership matters more, or so I would think.
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 12:02 PM by Ned Low.)
06-06-2026 12:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #134
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 11:42 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 10:41 AM)bullet Wrote:  An interesting number is how these schools revenues (expenditures) have changed over the last year:

23-24 24-25 change
USF 95,425,212 122,093,386 26,668,174
Oregon St. 120,225,018 104,767,703 (15,457,315)
Uconn 91,800,871 97,050,998 5,250,127
SDSU 83,949,123 89,827,012 5,877,889
Boise St. 59,885,466 89,699,430 29,813,964
Wash. St. 89,041,553 82,229,485 (6,812,068)
UNLV 65,376,772 77,272,658 11,895,886
Temple 70,320,170 71,198,560 878,390
E. Carolina 65,211,957 68,011,262 2,799,305
Tulane 39,305,494 66,211,945 26,906,451
Memphis 62,737,618 65,857,423 3,119,805
Fresno St. 55,761,420 63,439,685 7,678,265
Colorado St. 50,262,504 55,794,198 5,531,694

Memphis is still relatively low among this group (Rice, JMU and Liberty are the only other G schools over $60 million, so they are pretty high among all G schools). USF, Boise and Tulane have ramped up their spending.

Overall ECU, Fresno St. and Colorado St. look like schools that will need to be content trying to be among the top G schools. UNLV needs to hope casino money is enough to overcome their other metrics looking pretty weak. I don't know that the Big 12 and ACC will take any of these schools if they get raided, but I suspect these 4 don't get a serious look.

One reason to look at areas other than spending when/if there's a breakaway is that spending tends to skyrocket for a few years when you're building a new stadium. Should Kansas be considered a $205m a year program b/c they had one year that high during a huge stadium remodel? Should USF be a $120m a year program when that number is wildly skewed? What about student fees and transfers? That about ASU and that $52m the Academic side just gifted to the AD? There are just so many ways to screw with those numbers if you know that they're being used as an inclusion (or exclusion) measuring stick.

Question: do student fees and institutional support matter at all?

Some paint those expenditures in a negative light. If the students are willinig to pay the fees and the instiution is willing to fund athletics to that level, is that really a bad thing? Do other school presidents frown upon such behavior?

Looking at the Knight-Newhouse data for both Memphis and USF from 2022 to 2024:

Memphis decreased the total percentage of student fees and institutional support from 48.04% to 42.69%.

USF increased the total percentage of student fees and institutional support from 50.85% to 61.48%.

Adding in ECU:

ECU decreased the total percentage of student fees and institutional support from 44.06% to 41.4%.

Of note, all three schools increased total revenues each year from 2022 to 2024.
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 12:18 PM by Ned Low.)
06-06-2026 12:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
random asian guy Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,215
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 652
I Root For: VT, Georgetown
Location: Suburban Hell
Post: #135
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-05-2026 07:55 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:28 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 05:18 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  To me, it isn't cognitive dissonance to say that (a) the new stadium is a financial white elephant and also (b) I approve of it anyway as a means to get into an M2 conference. It just means that I think absorbing the costs of the white elephant is worth it if it results in getting an M2 bid. I mean, IIRC, we have been hugely subsidizing our athletics via student fees and transfers for a long time now, basically forever, and yet our institution has grown and thrived. Now, if we don't get such a bid, it will be an abject failure, but the jury is out on that, so no question, taking on huge debt for the stadium is a big gamble, with no guarantee of success. But IMO it is a gamble worth making.

We'll see.

I appreciate the candor. Moving from fictional corporate finance structures to admitting this is an institutional white elephant is at least honest. But the fatal flaw of the "gamble worth making" defense is that it treats a P4 invite like a charitable intervention. This is textbook risk mispricing where one is assigning upside probabilities that don't exist while ignoring quantifiable downside.

Media executives and conference leaders don't look at a structurally insolvent G6 athletic department bleeding donors, struggling for corporate sponsorship, fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched professional sports monarchy, and think, "Yes, this program represents a stable addition. Let's invite them in to bail out their mortgage." A conference invite isn't a bailout. It's a vetting process, and financial stability is a cornerstone metric. Schools will be evaluated on stability, revenue reliability, market performance, and institutional governance; all areas where compounding debt volatility is an unambiguous negative.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that your public world-view is that you don't want anyone in the AAC to do well aside from the Bulls, but I genuinely want every program in the AAC to be successful. A stronger conference benefits all of us. In a perfect world, both Memphis and USF get the call up. I simply can't support an administration so willing to make catastrophic, and arguably unethical, financial decisions for a low-percentage, high-risk gamble; leveraging institutional health and student experience as collateral. This is de-facto "vibes-based" governance, substituting optimism for stability and solvency.

You guys were great when you were kicking the conference's ass last season in basketball. I was hoping for epic battles this season. Same for football. Unfortunately, the personnel management has been as misguided, if not moreso, than the financing. I don't understand. The athletic director gambled everything on an extreme long shot "vibes" coaching hire who immediately hired one of the least defensible coordinator gambles in the country, and immediately promoted his brother from a low-level, off-field analyst to the on-field quarterbacks coach. Instead of locking in your championship winning coach, you let Providence poach him without even a whimper.

Hopefully everything works out for you, but thus far, everything has been going wrong for the Bulls, regardless of how aggressively the social-media hype machine tries to paper over the cracks.

I would like to see enough ACC teams get poached to allow Memphis, USF, Tulane and UConn to move as a group to a reformed ACC.

I know. That's why many top G6 schools want to see the ACC explode.

I personally think Memphis has a better chance with the B12. If the B12 loses some schools, Memphis would be considered.
06-06-2026 12:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UofMemphis Away
Official MT.org Ambassador of Smack
*

Posts: 49,757
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 1239
I Root For: Univ of Memphis
Location: Memphis (Berclair)

Donators
Post: #136
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 12:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:55 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:28 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 05:18 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  To me, it isn't cognitive dissonance to say that (a) the new stadium is a financial white elephant and also (b) I approve of it anyway as a means to get into an M2 conference. It just means that I think absorbing the costs of the white elephant is worth it if it results in getting an M2 bid. I mean, IIRC, we have been hugely subsidizing our athletics via student fees and transfers for a long time now, basically forever, and yet our institution has grown and thrived. Now, if we don't get such a bid, it will be an abject failure, but the jury is out on that, so no question, taking on huge debt for the stadium is a big gamble, with no guarantee of success. But IMO it is a gamble worth making.

We'll see.

I appreciate the candor. Moving from fictional corporate finance structures to admitting this is an institutional white elephant is at least honest. But the fatal flaw of the "gamble worth making" defense is that it treats a P4 invite like a charitable intervention. This is textbook risk mispricing where one is assigning upside probabilities that don't exist while ignoring quantifiable downside.

Media executives and conference leaders don't look at a structurally insolvent G6 athletic department bleeding donors, struggling for corporate sponsorship, fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched professional sports monarchy, and think, "Yes, this program represents a stable addition. Let's invite them in to bail out their mortgage." A conference invite isn't a bailout. It's a vetting process, and financial stability is a cornerstone metric. Schools will be evaluated on stability, revenue reliability, market performance, and institutional governance; all areas where compounding debt volatility is an unambiguous negative.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that your public world-view is that you don't want anyone in the AAC to do well aside from the Bulls, but I genuinely want every program in the AAC to be successful. A stronger conference benefits all of us. In a perfect world, both Memphis and USF get the call up. I simply can't support an administration so willing to make catastrophic, and arguably unethical, financial decisions for a low-percentage, high-risk gamble; leveraging institutional health and student experience as collateral. This is de-facto "vibes-based" governance, substituting optimism for stability and solvency.

You guys were great when you were kicking the conference's ass last season in basketball. I was hoping for epic battles this season. Same for football. Unfortunately, the personnel management has been as misguided, if not moreso, than the financing. I don't understand. The athletic director gambled everything on an extreme long shot "vibes" coaching hire who immediately hired one of the least defensible coordinator gambles in the country, and immediately promoted his brother from a low-level, off-field analyst to the on-field quarterbacks coach. Instead of locking in your championship winning coach, you let Providence poach him without even a whimper.

Hopefully everything works out for you, but thus far, everything has been going wrong for the Bulls, regardless of how aggressively the social-media hype machine tries to paper over the cracks.

I would like to see enough ACC teams get poached to allow Memphis, USF, Tulane and UConn to move as a group to a reformed ACC.

I know. That's why many top G6 schools want to see the ACC explode.

I personally think Memphis has a better chance with the B12. If the B12 loses some schools, Memphis would be considered.

I hate that chaos has become our only hope. I only want to see the ACC damaged and in need. Louisville, Tulane, VATech, USF, UConn, SMU, etc...there would be enough programs we have history with for true fan (and TV) interest again IMHO.
(This post was last modified: 06-06-2026 12:18 PM by UofMemphis.)
06-06-2026 12:16 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
random asian guy Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,215
Joined: Aug 2014
Reputation: 652
I Root For: VT, Georgetown
Location: Suburban Hell
Post: #137
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 12:16 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 12:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:55 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:28 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 05:18 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  To me, it isn't cognitive dissonance to say that (a) the new stadium is a financial white elephant and also (b) I approve of it anyway as a means to get into an M2 conference. It just means that I think absorbing the costs of the white elephant is worth it if it results in getting an M2 bid. I mean, IIRC, we have been hugely subsidizing our athletics via student fees and transfers for a long time now, basically forever, and yet our institution has grown and thrived. Now, if we don't get such a bid, it will be an abject failure, but the jury is out on that, so no question, taking on huge debt for the stadium is a big gamble, with no guarantee of success. But IMO it is a gamble worth making.

We'll see.

I appreciate the candor. Moving from fictional corporate finance structures to admitting this is an institutional white elephant is at least honest. But the fatal flaw of the "gamble worth making" defense is that it treats a P4 invite like a charitable intervention. This is textbook risk mispricing where one is assigning upside probabilities that don't exist while ignoring quantifiable downside.

Media executives and conference leaders don't look at a structurally insolvent G6 athletic department bleeding donors, struggling for corporate sponsorship, fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched professional sports monarchy, and think, "Yes, this program represents a stable addition. Let's invite them in to bail out their mortgage." A conference invite isn't a bailout. It's a vetting process, and financial stability is a cornerstone metric. Schools will be evaluated on stability, revenue reliability, market performance, and institutional governance; all areas where compounding debt volatility is an unambiguous negative.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that your public world-view is that you don't want anyone in the AAC to do well aside from the Bulls, but I genuinely want every program in the AAC to be successful. A stronger conference benefits all of us. In a perfect world, both Memphis and USF get the call up. I simply can't support an administration so willing to make catastrophic, and arguably unethical, financial decisions for a low-percentage, high-risk gamble; leveraging institutional health and student experience as collateral. This is de-facto "vibes-based" governance, substituting optimism for stability and solvency.

You guys were great when you were kicking the conference's ass last season in basketball. I was hoping for epic battles this season. Same for football. Unfortunately, the personnel management has been as misguided, if not moreso, than the financing. I don't understand. The athletic director gambled everything on an extreme long shot "vibes" coaching hire who immediately hired one of the least defensible coordinator gambles in the country, and immediately promoted his brother from a low-level, off-field analyst to the on-field quarterbacks coach. Instead of locking in your championship winning coach, you let Providence poach him without even a whimper.

Hopefully everything works out for you, but thus far, everything has been going wrong for the Bulls, regardless of how aggressively the social-media hype machine tries to paper over the cracks.

I would like to see enough ACC teams get poached to allow Memphis, USF, Tulane and UConn to move as a group to a reformed ACC.

I know. That's why many top G6 schools want to see the ACC explode.

I personally think Memphis has a better chance with the B12. If the B12 loses some schools, Memphis would be considered.

I hate that chaos has become our only hope. I only want to see the ACC damaged and in need. Louisville, Tulane, VATech, USF, UConn, SMU, etc...there would be enough programs we have history with for true fan (and TV) interest again IMHO.

That would not be in your best interest. Even if the ACC loses schools, the academics would still matter for that conference.
06-06-2026 12:29 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #138
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 12:00 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 10:41 AM)bullet Wrote:  An interesting number is how these schools revenues (expenditures) have changed over the last year:

23-24 24-25 change
USF 95,425,212 122,093,386 26,668,174
Oregon St. 120,225,018 104,767,703 (15,457,315)
Uconn 91,800,871 97,050,998 5,250,127
SDSU 83,949,123 89,827,012 5,877,889
Boise St. 59,885,466 89,699,430 29,813,964
Wash. St. 89,041,553 82,229,485 (6,812,068)
UNLV 65,376,772 77,272,658 11,895,886
Temple 70,320,170 71,198,560 878,390
E. Carolina 65,211,957 68,011,262 2,799,305
Tulane 39,305,494 66,211,945 26,906,451
Memphis 62,737,618 65,857,423 3,119,805
Fresno St. 55,761,420 63,439,685 7,678,265
Colorado St. 50,262,504 55,794,198 5,531,694

Memphis is still relatively low among this group (Rice, JMU and Liberty are the only other G schools over $60 million, so they are pretty high among all G schools). USF, Boise and Tulane have ramped up their spending.

Overall ECU, Fresno St. and Colorado St. look like schools that will need to be content trying to be among the top G schools. UNLV needs to hope casino money is enough to overcome their other metrics looking pretty weak. I don't know that the Big 12 and ACC will take any of these schools if they get raided, but I suspect these 4 don't get a serious look.

I'm not saying that you're wrong but what does this have to do with realignment? Some of us are spending within our means, sustainably, based on what we know to be the case now.

Others are not. Memphis has already stated that their current investment will not be sustained if they do not wind up in a A4 conference. USF has not stated as such but I'm sure the same thing applies to them, at least when it comes to their revenue share (and they will not need a new football stadium anytime soon).

I'm not knocking either Memphis or USF, btw. I just think that sustainable spending matters greatly. Winning and the correpsonding increase in attendence/viewership matters more, or so I would think.

Because the P4 are going to be looking at schools that are willing to spend. No matter how much Buffalo "looks" like a P4, they aren't going to consider a school spending $40 million a year. I don't know if any G schools can really sustain what they are spending. They are all spending a lot more than they were 10 years ago. If winning and viewership were the primary factors, Boise would have long ago been in the P4. But the presidents do care about academics. They want somewhat similar schools. And they want programs that will add some value even if athletics tank. Idaho is just too small a state for Boise to add value if their football stinks.

SMU got in because they proved they would spend and they were in the 4th largest metro. San Diego St. was on the verge of getting into the PAC because they were willing to spend and they were in Southern California and the 18th largest metro. Other schools were drawing more fans, more viewers and winning more.
06-06-2026 01:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,475
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #139
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 01:09 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 12:00 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 10:41 AM)bullet Wrote:  An interesting number is how these schools revenues (expenditures) have changed over the last year:

23-24 24-25 change
USF 95,425,212 122,093,386 26,668,174
Oregon St. 120,225,018 104,767,703 (15,457,315)
Uconn 91,800,871 97,050,998 5,250,127
SDSU 83,949,123 89,827,012 5,877,889
Boise St. 59,885,466 89,699,430 29,813,964
Wash. St. 89,041,553 82,229,485 (6,812,068)
UNLV 65,376,772 77,272,658 11,895,886
Temple 70,320,170 71,198,560 878,390
E. Carolina 65,211,957 68,011,262 2,799,305
Tulane 39,305,494 66,211,945 26,906,451
Memphis 62,737,618 65,857,423 3,119,805
Fresno St. 55,761,420 63,439,685 7,678,265
Colorado St. 50,262,504 55,794,198 5,531,694

Memphis is still relatively low among this group (Rice, JMU and Liberty are the only other G schools over $60 million, so they are pretty high among all G schools). USF, Boise and Tulane have ramped up their spending.

Overall ECU, Fresno St. and Colorado St. look like schools that will need to be content trying to be among the top G schools. UNLV needs to hope casino money is enough to overcome their other metrics looking pretty weak. I don't know that the Big 12 and ACC will take any of these schools if they get raided, but I suspect these 4 don't get a serious look.

I'm not saying that you're wrong but what does this have to do with realignment? Some of us are spending within our means, sustainably, based on what we know to be the case now.

Others are not. Memphis has already stated that their current investment will not be sustained if they do not wind up in a A4 conference. USF has not stated as such but I'm sure the same thing applies to them, at least when it comes to their revenue share (and they will not need a new football stadium anytime soon).

I'm not knocking either Memphis or USF, btw. I just think that sustainable spending matters greatly. Winning and the correpsonding increase in attendence/viewership matters more, or so I would think.

Because the P4 are going to be looking at schools that are willing to spend. No matter how much Buffalo "looks" like a P4, they aren't going to consider a school spending $40 million a year. I don't know if any G schools can really sustain what they are spending. They are all spending a lot more than they were 10 years ago. If winning and viewership were the primary factors, Boise would have long ago been in the P4. But the presidents do care about academics. They want somewhat similar schools. And they want programs that will add some value even if athletics tank. Idaho is just too small a state for Boise to add value if their football stinks.

SMU got in because they proved they would spend and they were in the 4th largest metro. San Diego St. was on the verge of getting into the PAC because they were willing to spend and they were in Southern California and the 18th largest metro. Other schools were drawing more fans, more viewers and winning more.

Fair enough.
06-06-2026 02:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
UofMemphis Away
Official MT.org Ambassador of Smack
*

Posts: 49,757
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 1239
I Root For: Univ of Memphis
Location: Memphis (Berclair)

Donators
Post: #140
RE: Gary Parish on Memphis and the Big12
(06-06-2026 12:29 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 12:16 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-06-2026 12:10 PM)random asian guy Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 07:55 PM)UofMemphis Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 06:28 PM)msu35 Wrote:  I appreciate the candor. Moving from fictional corporate finance structures to admitting this is an institutional white elephant is at least honest. But the fatal flaw of the "gamble worth making" defense is that it treats a P4 invite like a charitable intervention. This is textbook risk mispricing where one is assigning upside probabilities that don't exist while ignoring quantifiable downside.

Media executives and conference leaders don't look at a structurally insolvent G6 athletic department bleeding donors, struggling for corporate sponsorship, fighting an uphill battle against an entrenched professional sports monarchy, and think, "Yes, this program represents a stable addition. Let's invite them in to bail out their mortgage." A conference invite isn't a bailout. It's a vetting process, and financial stability is a cornerstone metric. Schools will be evaluated on stability, revenue reliability, market performance, and institutional governance; all areas where compounding debt volatility is an unambiguous negative.

Don't get me wrong. I understand that your public world-view is that you don't want anyone in the AAC to do well aside from the Bulls, but I genuinely want every program in the AAC to be successful. A stronger conference benefits all of us. In a perfect world, both Memphis and USF get the call up. I simply can't support an administration so willing to make catastrophic, and arguably unethical, financial decisions for a low-percentage, high-risk gamble; leveraging institutional health and student experience as collateral. This is de-facto "vibes-based" governance, substituting optimism for stability and solvency.

You guys were great when you were kicking the conference's ass last season in basketball. I was hoping for epic battles this season. Same for football. Unfortunately, the personnel management has been as misguided, if not moreso, than the financing. I don't understand. The athletic director gambled everything on an extreme long shot "vibes" coaching hire who immediately hired one of the least defensible coordinator gambles in the country, and immediately promoted his brother from a low-level, off-field analyst to the on-field quarterbacks coach. Instead of locking in your championship winning coach, you let Providence poach him without even a whimper.

Hopefully everything works out for you, but thus far, everything has been going wrong for the Bulls, regardless of how aggressively the social-media hype machine tries to paper over the cracks.

I would like to see enough ACC teams get poached to allow Memphis, USF, Tulane and UConn to move as a group to a reformed ACC.

I know. That's why many top G6 schools want to see the ACC explode.

I personally think Memphis has a better chance with the B12. If the B12 loses some schools, Memphis would be considered.

I hate that chaos has become our only hope. I only want to see the ACC damaged and in need. Louisville, Tulane, VATech, USF, UConn, SMU, etc...there would be enough programs we have history with for true fan (and TV) interest again IMHO.

That would not be in your best interest. Even if the ACC loses schools, the academics would still matter for that conference.

I would think if Louisville can get in Memphis could get in...

since being turned down by the Big XII Memphis has become a Carnegie research classification R1 University...

https://www.memphis.edu/mediaroom/releas...search.php

and set a new research record of 86 million dollars.

https://classic.memphis.edu/research/imp...fforts.php
06-06-2026 02:12 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.