Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Thread Closed 
Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Author Message
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #81
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  your arguments are become so desperate it is laughable

1. the screen capture I showed from The Florida Universities BOR states clearly they believe that a portion (and a large portion) of the project could be bonded out with tax free bonds......your OPINION on that carries no weight relative to their opinion on that especially to anyone with a brain

I'm glad you're finding this amusing. Again, you have a complete and fundamental inability to comprehend English. It clearly states: "We are not in a position to make this assessment since we have not been involved in the planning or structuring of the financing but encourage the University to consider the additional cost of using taxable debt and do everything possible to reduce the cost of the debt by using tax-exempt financing."

You're completely misunderstanding the meaning of the sentence. It means if at all possible, do everything to leverage a tax-exempt bond. The fact that USF resorted to a commercial loan is the answer -- they were not legally qualified for tax-exempt bonding. Again, Federal tax law. I repeat this every time, and nothing has changed. Reality is reality.

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  Examples of Bond-Funded Stadiums

<TRUNCATED>

so I provided proof that people that fel with these types of things on a frequent basis believe it is possible and I provided proof that it has been done for pro sports

you used "dunning kruger" two times while being shown proof that others of way higher intellect and knowledge disagree with you

"Way higher intellect and knowledge," huh? A shame that you're too ill-informed to grasp the concept that tax laws can and do change. You're citing pre-2017 loopholes that no longer exist. Do you think cars still use leaded fuel? Again, reality doesn't bend to your delusions. Dunning-Kruger indeed.

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  2. once again your desperation and ignorance is showing....I made clear about the restricted-nonextendible money and the other money

Desperation and ignorance? Interesting projection. Pro tip: insults have more of a sting if they're grounded in fact and logic.

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  I am the one that has repeatedly stated that a university cannot spend the corpus of the endowment while you are the one that repeatedly states "the endowment is under threat" which is you attempting to imply that the university will in fact spend into the corpus

You're creating a straw man and confusing corpus with unrestricted endowment funds. They're not the same thing and the memorandum explicitly refers to the latter: "The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment." Clearly the State of Florida calls it the USF endowment. I recommend arguing with the State if you disagree because I genuinely have no more patience for your inability to comprehend English.

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  the fact that you do not understand that universities and other non-profits can and do raise and lower the distributions from their endowments just shows you are daft

<TRUNCATED>

and once again....USF has grown their academic profile dramatically over the last 10 to 15 years and they have grown their research productivity over the last 10 to 15 years dramatically.....I am sure they are more confident in what they are doing than someone from Memphis

Your commentary reflects a catastrophic and fundamental misunderstanding of how endowment payouts work under UPMIFA. Arbitrarily increasing distributions doesn't generate "free money" for football. Increasing the distribution directly reduces long-term endowment growth, reduces academic funding, and still does not solve the structural athletic deficits. They're borrowing internally to service the external stadium loan, locking up university capital, and not even applying a single cent towards paying down principal.

It's indefensible. If you still can't comprehend, there is genuinely nothing more to say. I've already explained this to you repeatedly. You've been objectively wrong on every single point that you're making, and this is devolving into the absurd. If you insist on weaponizing your ignorance, I'm done entertaining it.

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  3. I did not backtrack on any point....I did not state that USF could farm out their stajium for up front money just like Texas did"

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  4. I am not sure why you are saying "what".....UT Austin could have easily built their new facility on their own......but the university is generally not in the concert and events business they are not in the business of dealing with Taylor Swift, Metallica, circus acts or whatever else might want to use their venue.....it is easier, more profitable, and just a smarter business decision to let a company that manages multiple venues,that signs contracts with tour operators for several venues at a time, that deals with other aspects of event management on a much larger basis handle that while UT concentrates on sports......where they have been doing very well recently

Venue managers don't assume debt, don't bail out insolvent projects, and don't hand out upfront cash to debtors. That's not how the industry works. Furthermore, are you trying to compare UT Austin with USF? If I have to explain to you why that's so stupid, the explanation would assuredly fly over your head.

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  5. and what is embarrassing is someone that does not understand that endowment payouts can be adjusted, they do not understand that many athletics venues have been built with tax free bonds even for pro sports and that The State of Florida BOR for public universities believes it is possible to do so.......and that does not understand venue management especially of college sports venues (and even more so shiny new ones) is becoming a very big business and very competitive and there is nothing preventing USF from making a deal after the venues are built for management of it....be it for up front cash or for a % of the revenues and doing so will most likely give them a lot of financial relief

Again, so financially illiterate as to be embarrassing.

(06-05-2026 12:57 AM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  you are the one that started this thread so there is no embarrassment on my part to point out "pssst.....hey mr concerned about the impending DOOOM for USF and their endowment and academics.....have you looked over at what is going on in far west Tennessee?".....have you compared that to what is going on over in slightly off on direction/location Florida

I stand by everything I wrote, and West Tennessee has exactly nothing to do with USF's predicament. The facts are that the athletic department is insolvent and unable to cover their debt service. USF is burning unrestricted funds from their endowment to prevent massive cuts to the athletics budget. They're leveraging internal lending to cover the Truist debt service, and effectively paying nothing towards the principal. This is a highly leveraged and toxic financial shell game whether you accept it or not.

I genuinely don't care if you disagree, that's your prerogative. Spreading your misinformed, delusional takes is next level, and frankly shocking. Let it be clear, I will not continue to repeat myself to you. If you're an adult -- I have my doubts -- act like one and do the research.

You're bending yourself into pretzels trying to warp your primitive understanding of finance to conform to your predetermined outcome. It's only serving to prove your financial illiteracy, and you should be embarrassed. At this point, there is zero potential this is a misunderstanding on your part -- it's willful ignorance in the best-case scenario, and the facts are here. Take it or leave it.
06-05-2026 04:10 AM
Find all posts by this user
USF_Bullsharks Offline
Special Teams
*

Posts: 936
Joined: May 2025
Reputation: 287
I Root For: USF
Location:
Post: #82
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
Is anyone going to call out the "raiding of the capital improvement trust fund"? That one really made me laugh.
06-05-2026 08:23 AM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #83
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 08:23 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  Is anyone going to call out the "raiding of the capital improvement trust fund"? That one really made me laugh.

03-lmfao Since living in Georgia, I will just repeat a favorite phrase up here. “Bless his heart”
06-05-2026 08:37 AM
Find all posts by this user
shere khan Offline
Southerner
*

Posts: 76,740
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10825
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
Post: #84
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 08:37 AM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 08:23 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  Is anyone going to call out the "raiding of the capital improvement trust fund"? That one really made me laugh.

03-lmfao Since living in Georgia, I will just repeat a favorite phrase up here. “Bless his heart”

Todge is on it.
03-lmfao
06-05-2026 08:50 AM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #85
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 08:23 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  Is anyone going to call out the "raiding of the capital improvement trust fund"? That one really made me laugh.

Keep demonstrating your abject ignorance and complete state of denial with every post. Vibes over competence indeed:

Quote:The university plans to use $31 million from the Capital Improvement Trust Fund (CITF) – a tuition fee collected at all Florida public universities.

Here’s how USF says it is funding its stadium
06-05-2026 10:19 AM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #86
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 08:50 AM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 08:37 AM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 08:23 AM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  Is anyone going to call out the "raiding of the capital improvement trust fund"? That one really made me laugh.

03-lmfao Since living in Georgia, I will just repeat a favorite phrase up here. “Bless his heart”

Todge is on it.
03-lmfao

03-lmfao Yes he is 03-lmfao
06-05-2026 11:16 AM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #87
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
1. the Florida higher education board was not a part of the decision as to why USF made the decision they made......but they are still of the opinion that bonds can be used.....they made an assessment that projects like that can use tax exempt and taxed bonds and they regularly do.....what they did not make an assessment on is why USF made the decision they did.......but you having no inside information yourself have made the assessment that they were not able to at all for any of it.......but again you have no knowledge of the project or the decisions being made you just have your opinion with nothing to support it and with many instances that show similar projects have used tax free money for all or a portion of the project

again here is another very recent example

https://news3lv.com/news/local/clark-cou...nstruction

Clark County bonds to be repaid with a TIF on the surrounding area......there is nothing that prevents Hillsborough County from doing the same

in fact there is a very new legal opinion that says it is 100% possible

https://baynews9.com/fl/tampa/news/2026/...ugh-county

A major legal question surrounding a proposed multi-billion-dollar stadium deal for the Tampa Bay Rays now has an answer — and it could shape the future of the project.

A newly issued legal opinion issued by Bryant Miller Olive says Hillsborough County can use Community Investment Tax (CIT) dollars to help fund a new stadium — even if it’s leased to a professional baseball team.

so right there in the same exact county as USF......but I suppose your next argument is that a TIF is a tax and not a bond......while you will ignore that the TIF revenue generation will be used to pay off MUNICIPAL BONDS that will need to be sold in order to fund the stajium.......or are you going to try and say that they will place a TIF on raw land, collect up the money for (hundreds at that rate) of years and then pay cash for the stajium

no of course they will not they will sell municipal bonds, build the project, and then use the TIF to pay those bonds

so again no matter what you argue about "in the past and times dey be uh changin" the fact is RIGHT NOW today there are projects for sports arenas in the USA including one large one in the very same state and in the very same county as USF that are going to use municipal bonds to fund some of the project

Under the proposal:

The Rays would cover roughly half the cost
Taxpayers would fund the remaining portion through public sources, including CIT dollars

Why the legal opinion matters

The question of whether CIT funds could legally be used for a stadium has been a major point of debate.

Hillsborough County Commissioner Gwen Myers requested the legal review after hearing conflicting concerns from the public.

“What we're hearing now is that we're receiving so many emails that the funds cannot be used. And we're hearing that the funds can be used. So the legal opinion would answer the question for all of us.”

The opinion concludes:

A publicly owned stadium qualifies as a “recreational public facility” under Florida law
CIT funds can be used for such facilities
There is no legal restriction in place, since a proposed ban on using the funds for a stadium was never formally approved

so what does all of that say....lets see it says you are wrong, you are wrong on that as well....and oh yea yep you are wrong there too.....and damn it you are wrong again and again and again

because no matter how you try and twist it Clark County, Nevada is issuing municipal bonds for a pro sports stajium......and no matter how you will try and deflect or concentrate on the TIF aspect of what is happening right in the same county as USF anyone with even a modicum of intelligence will know that the TIF money will go towards paying for MUNICIPAL BONDS to fund a pro sports stajium that has been legally termed as....wait for it ---->>>>"A publicly owned stadium qualifies as a “recreational public facility” under Florida law"

it is VERY VERY VERY clear....it makes no distinction that it be publicly owned by a city or county and not a PUBLIC state university.....or that it be used for pro sports only and not for college sports at a PUBLIC university

so again lets go over this very slowly for those that are slow

1. public bonds and their use......you are wrong
2. that was in the past, but times dey uh changin.....you are wrong
3. the project cannot have parts of it funded in different ways because some part of it might not be "public use"......you are wrong
4. stajiums that generate revenue through commerce or "money making" cannot be public use......you are wrong

how much more wrong can you be

and in fact not only can bonds be used, but it is clear that a TIF can be placed on the area to pay those bonds

but since you like to be wrong often we can all prepare ourselves for you to try and say that Clark County, Nevada and their clear use of bonds is somehow different because well....in Nevada, for pro sports, it is a county not a public university.....or some other nonsense

or you are going to try and argue that Hillsborough is not going to use bonds for their project they are going to use the money fairy, the lending tree, money from thin air, or they just have extra cash in the treasure bath out back to pay for it and they will use the TIF money to fill the treasure bath back up over time.....but hey you will still be wrong



2. once again.....endowment managers can increase the payout from the endowment....I never said this creates "free money", but it does allow for a larger distribution that can be used for a number of things.....and I stated this comes at a cost of reinvesting some of that return that is paid out

but there is nothing that prevents it and it happens on a regular basis

there are dozens if not hundreds of articles discussing that universities have upped distributions for a period of time t create extra available funds or in some cases they have shortened the number of years used to calculate the average value of the endowment to a window that has a higher return and thus that higher return period means that distributions increase for a period of time

3. nowhere did I say a venue manager would assume debt....I clearly never said that.....this is another attempt for you to make an argument against something that was never said

nor did say they would "bail anyone out"......and the stupid person is the one that says I am comparing UT Austin to USF.......when what I am actually doing is discussing what one university did to get a single athletics facility built vs. what another university is doing to get a larger overall area with several things developed.......this is not a comparison of athletics programs it is a comparison of methods to build venues

and because you say "things do not work like that" in reference to a venue management company giving some up front money as part of an agreement to take over the management of a venue or venues for a long period of time that does not mean it is true or not possible.....as I stated Oak View did pay up front......they paid a hell of a lot of money up front to actually build a facility they will never own in exchange for the rights to manage it for a period of time and some profit sharing with UT

they PAID 100% up front

the difference is USF is doing all the work up front......and there is NOTHING at all that would prevent a company from giving cash up front to take on a long term management deal

The Moody center was $375 million to build all paid UP FRONT before a single event happened in that space and all paid for by others not names UT Austin

you can pretend that is not "paying up front", but there is nothing that would have prevented a similar deal from being structured where the university covered the cost up front and then 10% $37.5 million (or 5%, 20%, 12.5% or whatever amount) was paid to the university UP FRONT for the rights to manage the venue and in that case I would expect the university would want a large share of profits because they still have the UP FRONT cost.....as USF will have

your argument is "things do not work like that" or made up ideas about "assuming debt" (never stated by me) or "bailing out a debtor" again this was never stated by me and is based on your assumption that USF will absolutely need a "bail out"

and really the only comparable project to USF in recent times is SDSU

https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Jo...acilities/

their agreement for management is $2 million per year annually no matter what, OVG gets the next $1 million, and then after that all revenue is split 50/50 and OVG covers all expenses except for SDSU game days

that is a very generous split of revenues IMO......and on day one of the deal SDSU got their $2 million UP FRONT

there is nothing that says a deal could not be $5 million up front with a lower split of revenues after that......but somehow you pretend you are the arbiter of how these deals operate and are structured.....even though the entire business of coming in and managing venues like this especially on college campuses is relatively new and projects this size on a college campus are rare

and the SDSU deal (like the UT deal) really only includes a venue it does not include any surrounding land.....USF has surrounding land just as SDSU does, but SDSU is choosing to use a lot more of their land for university functions though there will be retail and housing and in the case of USF there is nothing that stops up front money from being paid for the rights to develop some of that with a revenue sharing agreement in place.....other than your inability to understand that concept in your head

4. lastly you are claiming that the project is already insolvent or that it is guaranteed to be insolvent when it is not even finished yet......just a ridiculous take and if you look at what was said about the SDSU project vs. what has actually happened with it your take becomes even more of a stretch

and even more laughable is you claiming that USF is in some type of "predicament" when there are few if any other universities in the country that have raised their academic and research profile to the level that USF has and in the time frame they did it.....they did not just talk a lot about it and make some moves that looked OK

they actually did it....and while that does not mean "great lets just blow money on athletics" I am willing to give a lot of the benefit of the doubt to an administration that elevated their academic and research profile as rapidly and in the time frame they did for other university decisions vs. someone that hopes their university in Memphis does not follow that same path

I have done the research.....what USF has done academically is very impressive.....and I have also clearly showed that in the very recent past professional sports venues had municipal bond funding used for part of their construction

including an decision right in the same state and in the same county as USF for a very similar project.....other than it being for pro sports and not (currently) for university sports

and I have shown examples of venues being managed with up front money (SDSU actual cash $2 million per year) and a very generous split of all other revenues and UT Austin where UP FRONT money was paid out to construct a facility the company will never own.....because they did not hand that directly to UT does not mean it was not an up front cost.....and because USF is financing their project up front themselves (AS SDSU DID) that does not mean they cannot get UP FRONT cash paid to them for a management agreement......because as I showed SDSU is getting just that....$2 million up front every year and then a very large split of revenues past a very small threshold of $1 million more going to the management company

plus there are still naming rights to sell and raw land to work with developers on

but in your mind somehow people that do extremely well running a university are wrong, all proven examples of deals are wrong, and USF is going to be insolvent before the venue even opens based on......well your desire to not follow the path of a university with elevated academics and research that now wants more attention from athletics as well......while you just want overall under-performance all around
(This post was last modified: 06-05-2026 12:43 PM by TodgeRodge.)
06-05-2026 12:36 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #88
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 12:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. the Florida higher education board was not a part of the decision as to why USF made the decision they made......but they are still of the opinion that bonds can be used.....they made an assessment that projects like that can use tax exempt and taxed bonds and they regularly do.....what they did not make an assessment on is why USF made the decision they did.......but you having no inside information yourself have made the assessment that they were not able to at all for any of it.......but again you have no knowledge of the project or the decisions being made you just have your opinion with nothing to support it and with many instances that show similar projects have used tax free money for all or a portion of the project

<TRUNCATED THE LUNATIC DIATRIBE>

but in your mind somehow people that do extremely well running a university are wrong, all proven examples of deals are wrong, and USF is going to be insolvent before the venue even opens based on......well your desire to not follow the path of a university with elevated academics and research that now wants more attention from athletics as well......while you just want overall under-performance all around

Look, I'm done. You're too ignorant to carry a cohesive discussion based on the facts, and incapable of any degree of rational thought.

Your math and legal analysis remain an absolute embarrassment. You just spent paragraphs conflating a local voter-approved sales tax (CIT) with Tax Increment Financing (TIF), completely oblivious to the fact that local county tax opinions do not magically rewrite 26 U.S. Code Sec. 141 federal private-use restrictions for a state university project.

Furthermore, your SDSU example completely defeats your own point -- a hilarious self-own. An annual operational revenue guarantee is not "upfront capital to pay down a mortgage principal," and it completely ignores the actual reality of the newly signed TSA agreement; where TSA takes up to a 20% cut of gross non-football revenue while USF covers 100% of the operational overhead. You can't legally siphon restricted academic endowment yields to cover an athletic deficit, no matter how many times you misspell basic words and prove your lack of basic education.

If you continue to be confused about the "stajium" financing, go back and read my previous posts. Nothing has changed. Enjoy your echo chamber, mired in intellectual debt.
(This post was last modified: 06-05-2026 12:47 PM by msu35.)
06-05-2026 12:44 PM
Find all posts by this user
TodgeRodge Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,149
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 276
I Root For: Todge
Location: Westlake
Post: #89
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 12:44 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 12:36 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  1. the Florida higher education board was not a part of the decision as to why USF made the decision they made......but they are still of the opinion that bonds can be used.....they made an assessment that projects like that can use tax exempt and taxed bonds and they regularly do.....what they did not make an assessment on is why USF made the decision they did.......but you having no inside information yourself have made the assessment that they were not able to at all for any of it.......but again you have no knowledge of the project or the decisions being made you just have your opinion with nothing to support it and with many instances that show similar projects have used tax free money for all or a portion of the project

<TRUNCATED THE LUNATIC DIATRIBE>

but in your mind somehow people that do extremely well running a university are wrong, all proven examples of deals are wrong, and USF is going to be insolvent before the venue even opens based on......well your desire to not follow the path of a university with elevated academics and research that now wants more attention from athletics as well......while you just want overall under-performance all around

Look, I'm done. You're too ignorant to carry a cohesive discussion based on the facts, and incapable of any degree of rational thought.

Your math and legal analysis remain an absolute embarrassment. You just spent paragraphs conflating a local voter-approved sales tax (CIT) with Tax Increment Financing (TIF), completely oblivious to the fact that local county tax opinions do not magically rewrite 26 U.S. Code Sec. 141 federal private-use restrictions for a state university project.

Furthermore, your SDSU example completely defeats your own point -- a hilarious self-own. An annual operational revenue guarantee is not "upfront capital to pay down a mortgage principal," and it completely ignores the actual reality of the newly signed TSA agreement; where TSA takes up to a 20% cut of gross non-football revenue while USF covers 100% of the operational overhead. You can't legally siphon restricted academic endowment yields to cover an athletic deficit, no matter how many times you misspell basic words and prove your lack of basic education.

If you continue to be confused about the "stajium" financing, go back and read my previous posts. Nothing has changed. Enjoy your echo chamber, mired in intellectual debt.

you are "done" because you have been exposed as being ignorant of reality and ignorant in general and no one is believing your desire to place USF in "financial peril"

1. as predicted you looked at the "TIF" aspect of what I stated while pretending that the same county in the same state as USF is going to use municipal bonds to build a pro stajium

and of course you completely ignore Clark County, Nevada using municipal bonds to build a pro baseball stajium (because there was nothing in that article you could try and use to deflect)

2. the SDSU article is not a "self pwned" because it clearly states every year no matter what SDSU gets $2 million.......which would mean when they signed the deal.....guess what they got $2 million

and nowhere did I say it was "up front capital to pay down mortgage principle"......but of course the laughable aspect of what you are attempting to claim is that there is nothing that prevents SDSU from using that $2 million they get every year up front including when they signed the deal from servicing the debt they incurred to build the venue

so lets be clear.....SDSU signs a deal.....the deal states that SDSU gets $2 million every year no matter what and then a half of all revenues after the next million......I am not sure what you call it in Memphis, but getting $2 million every year up front for a deal means that you in fact got UP FRONT MONEY

there is nothing in the article I posted that said "after the first year of revenues SDSU gets $2 million" up front every year......it stated the deal is SDSU gets $2 million up front at the start of every year.....and that would include the year the deal is signed

plus you have still failed to show why it would not be possible for SDSU, USF or anyone else with a similar development to work a deal that gives them $10 million upon signing the deal and then they get $1 million up front for the remaining deals and 50% of all revenues after the next million

nor have you shown why in the case of UT if UT had desired to do a different deal that UT could not have built the facility themselves then ask for some amount of money UP FRONT and then some share of revenues after that including guaranteed money each year

again when it comes to the cost of the deal and the expected return on the deal for any investor if the numbers are the same they can structure a deal how they wish and in the case of an entity like UT, USF, or SDSU they can also look to structure a deal how they wish

in the case of UT there was a very large UP FRONT cost to the investors to build the facility they will never own......if the profits on investment were the same or better there would be no difference if they let UT build it and then paid UT $50 million UP FRONT (which is a great deal less then they paid to build the venue) and then they work a % revenue split

because that is what SDSU did.....they paid the cost up front and then they get $2 million UP FRONT every year and a much larger 5 of revenues than UT gets in their deal......and the article states EACH YEAR they get $2 million......it makes no claim that they did not get that for the year the deal was signed......and again no matter what wording you try and change or use there is nothing that prevents a deal from being $10 million UP FRONT when the deal is signed and then a different revenue split or a lower up front payment each year......because your head is so thick, you are so desperate to be right, and you lack the ability to understand that deals can be structured hundreds of ways that you somehow think that it is impossible that money could be paid at the signing of a deal to manage a venue......or because you somehow think that because USF paid a large amount of money to build a venue somehow they can't even find a deal that will pay them money UP front for the rights to manage that venue.......even though in terms of cost to the management company there is a lot less money up front out of their pockets to pay a university $10 million, $25 million, or $50 million when they sign a deal to manage a venue vs. paying what was paid up front to build the Moody Center at UT

and again if you do not understand the difference between the distribution of an endowment and the endowment itself that is on you.......but there is the ability for those that hold endowments to adjust payouts and it would be rare that any university has all of their DISTRIBUTION dollars spoken for especially if they are choosing to increase the distribution % for a brief period of time

the only echo chamber is you.....you and your desire to try and convince all of us that a university that has been extremely well manged and guided academically and research wise is somehow absolutely in a financial crisis before their venue even opens and that it is impossible for them to get any money up front, front loaded in the early years, or anything else to cover some of the cost of that venue.....because somehow you think that companies and venue owners cannot adjust money paid up front, money guaranteed per year, and % payment of yearly revenues to meet both of their financial goals

even though it has been shown in one case a management company paid a massive amount of money out of pocket and the university took a % of revenues while another university paid a very large amount of money up front and their management partner is paying them money guaranteed each year as well as a very large % of revenues after a very low financial threshold to meet

and just because that was not CASH to UT does not make it an expense for the management company any more than the management company paying CASH to UT after UT builds a facility

and just because SDSU paid it all up front does not mean they could not have found a management partner that would have paid HALF of the construction cost up front (even if not paid directly to SDSU, but instead paid to contractors and then they pay less per year, have a higher threshold of money they keep before giving a lower % of revenues after that

but of course in your desperation to declare USF in financial crisis you cannot possibly allow for the very real fact that companies pay large amounts of money to manage venues.....some pay for the cost of the venue themselves up front (that they will never own) and others pay guarantees starting in year one of the deal (up front money) and come can work any model in between those

but if you remotely accept that clear FACT then that means that USF has the ability to get some money (including up front) be it $2 million right when the deal starts and a generous revenue share after a low threshold or be it a larger amount up front......or maybe it is ZERO in year one, but then $3 million per year and 55% of all revenues after the next $750,000 and USF will face "financial doom and impending collapse" for a single year before they start getting money on a yearly basis guaranteed that will cover a lot of the cost of the debt

one would have to be simply thick to not see the potential available deals possible for USF or how they could be structured to meet the needs of USF and the investors

but somehow we are all suppose to support your theory that this project will fail financially pretty much no matter what and that a very sound university administration with a very strong academic and research performance will let that happen and there will be no avenues of partnerships available to them to offer any relief at all much less potentially meaningful revenue like SDSU is starting to get

no lets all listen to someone that has been shown time and again with example after example that they are wrong because they want to declare failure for something that is not even up and operating yet.....while being a strong advocate for a place that has a hell of a lot of real issues of their own and a whole lot less proven performance than USF
06-05-2026 02:51 PM
Find all posts by this user
shere khan Offline
Southerner
*

Posts: 76,740
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10825
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
Post: #90
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao
06-05-2026 02:52 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #91
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 02:51 PM)TodgeRodge Wrote:  you are "done" because you have been exposed as being ignorant of reality and ignorant in general and no one is believing your desire to place USF in "financial peril"

1. as predicted you looked at the "TIF" aspect of what I stated while pretending that the same county in the same state as USF is going to use municipal bonds to build a pro stajium

and of course you completely ignore Clark County, Nevada using municipal bonds to build a pro baseball stajium (because there was nothing in that article you could try and use to deflect)

2. the SDSU article is not a "self pwned" because it clearly states every year no matter what SDSU gets $2 million.......which would mean when they signed the deal.....guess what they got $2 million

and nowhere did I say it was "up front capital to pay down mortgage principle"......but of course the laughable aspect of what you are attempting to claim is that there is nothing that prevents SDSU from using that $2 million they get every year up front including when they signed the deal from servicing the debt they incurred to build the venue

so lets be clear.....SDSU signs a deal.....the deal states that SDSU gets $2 million every year no matter what and then a half of all revenues after the next million......I am not sure what you call it in Memphis, but getting $2 million every year up front for a deal means that you in fact got UP FRONT MONEY

there is nothing in the article I posted that said "after the first year of revenues SDSU gets $2 million" up front every year......it stated the deal is SDSU gets $2 million up front at the start of every year.....and that would include the year the deal is signed

plus you have still failed to show why it would not be possible for SDSU, USF or anyone else with a similar development to work a deal that gives them $10 million upon signing the deal and then they get $1 million up front for the remaining deals and 50% of all revenues after the next million

nor have you shown why in the case of UT if UT had desired to do a different deal that UT could not have built the facility themselves then ask for some amount of money UP FRONT and then some share of revenues after that including guaranteed money each year

again when it comes to the cost of the deal and the expected return on the deal for any investor if the numbers are the same they can structure a deal how they wish and in the case of an entity like UT, USF, or SDSU they can also look to structure a deal how they wish

in the case of UT there was a very large UP FRONT cost to the investors to build the facility they will never own......if the profits on investment were the same or better there would be no difference if they let UT build it and then paid UT $50 million UP FRONT (which is a great deal less then they paid to build the venue) and then they work a % revenue split

because that is what SDSU did.....they paid the cost up front and then they get $2 million UP FRONT every year and a much larger 5 of revenues than UT gets in their deal......and the article states EACH YEAR they get $2 million......it makes no claim that they did not get that for the year the deal was signed......and again no matter what wording you try and change or use there is nothing that prevents a deal from being $10 million UP FRONT when the deal is signed and then a different revenue split or a lower up front payment each year......because your head is so thick, you are so desperate to be right, and you lack the ability to understand that deals can be structured hundreds of ways that you somehow think that it is impossible that money could be paid at the signing of a deal to manage a venue......or because you somehow think that because USF paid a large amount of money to build a venue somehow they can't even find a deal that will pay them money UP front for the rights to manage that venue.......even though in terms of cost to the management company there is a lot less money up front out of their pockets to pay a university $10 million, $25 million, or $50 million when they sign a deal to manage a venue vs. paying what was paid up front to build the Moody Center at UT

and again if you do not understand the difference between the distribution of an endowment and the endowment itself that is on you.......but there is the ability for those that hold endowments to adjust payouts and it would be rare that any university has all of their DISTRIBUTION dollars spoken for especially if they are choosing to increase the distribution % for a brief period of time

the only echo chamber is you.....you and your desire to try and convince all of us that a university that has been extremely well manged and guided academically and research wise is somehow absolutely in a financial crisis before their venue even opens and that it is impossible for them to get any money up front, front loaded in the early years, or anything else to cover some of the cost of that venue.....because somehow you think that companies and venue owners cannot adjust money paid up front, money guaranteed per year, and % payment of yearly revenues to meet both of their financial goals

even though it has been shown in one case a management company paid a massive amount of money out of pocket and the university took a % of revenues while another university paid a very large amount of money up front and their management partner is paying them money guaranteed each year as well as a very large % of revenues after a very low financial threshold to meet

and just because that was not CASH to UT does not make it an expense for the management company any more than the management company paying CASH to UT after UT builds a facility

and just because SDSU paid it all up front does not mean they could not have found a management partner that would have paid HALF of the construction cost up front (even if not paid directly to SDSU, but instead paid to contractors and then they pay less per year, have a higher threshold of money they keep before giving a lower % of revenues after that

but of course in your desperation to declare USF in financial crisis you cannot possibly allow for the very real fact that companies pay large amounts of money to manage venues.....some pay for the cost of the venue themselves up front (that they will never own) and others pay guarantees starting in year one of the deal (up front money) and come can work any model in between those

but if you remotely accept that clear FACT then that means that USF has the ability to get some money (including up front) be it $2 million right when the deal starts and a generous revenue share after a low threshold or be it a larger amount up front......or maybe it is ZERO in year one, but then $3 million per year and 55% of all revenues after the next $750,000 and USF will face "financial doom and impending collapse" for a single year before they start getting money on a yearly basis guaranteed that will cover a lot of the cost of the debt

one would have to be simply thick to not see the potential available deals possible for USF or how they could be structured to meet the needs of USF and the investors

but somehow we are all suppose to support your theory that this project will fail financially pretty much no matter what and that a very sound university administration with a very strong academic and research performance will let that happen and there will be no avenues of partnerships available to them to offer any relief at all much less potentially meaningful revenue like SDSU is starting to get

no lets all listen to someone that has been shown time and again with example after example that they are wrong because they want to declare failure for something that is not even up and operating yet.....while being a strong advocate for a place that has a hell of a lot of real issues of their own and a whole lot less proven performance than USF

Unhinged.
06-05-2026 02:57 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #92
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 02:52 PM)shere khan Wrote:  And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao

If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.
06-05-2026 03:05 PM
Find all posts by this user
shere khan Offline
Southerner
*

Posts: 76,740
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10825
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
Post: #93
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 02:52 PM)shere khan Wrote:  And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao

If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.

Youre an idiot to think i would ever work for college professor wages

Quit embarrassing the Univ of Memphis.

Todge eviserated you. Take the L
06-05-2026 03:47 PM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #94
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 03:47 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 02:52 PM)shere khan Wrote:  And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao

If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.

Youre an idiot to think i would ever work for college professor wages

Quit embarrassing the Univ of Memphis.

Todge eviserated you. Take the L

He can’t handle it. He needs to have the last word. This why even after he said he was done, he still posting. He is one of those that thinks if he is the last one to talk or post then he didn’t lose. 03-lmfao
06-05-2026 03:53 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #95
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 03:47 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 02:52 PM)shere khan Wrote:  And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao

If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.

Youre an idiot to think i would ever work for college professor wages

Quit embarrassing the Univ of Memphis.

Todge eviserated you. Take the L

More fan-fiction from the resident anti-Memphis cheerleader. Dance harder, maybe someone will clap.

The instant, histrionic pivot to financial cope smoking says everything.

Keep those vibes flowing... it's cute.

04-cheers
06-05-2026 03:58 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #96
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 03:53 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:47 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 02:52 PM)shere khan Wrote:  And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao

If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.

Youre an idiot to think i would ever work for college professor wages

Quit embarrassing the Univ of Memphis.

Todge eviserated you. Take the L

He can’t handle it. He needs to have the last word. This why even after he said he was done, he still posting. He is one of those that thinks if he is the last one to talk or post then he didn’t lose. 03-lmfao

Yeah... Keep telling yourself that.

(06-05-2026 02:16 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 01:58 PM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 01:41 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 01:24 PM)USF_Bullsharks Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 01:09 PM)msu35 Wrote:  Ah, smart guy. Tell me again how the school isn't raiding the trust. USF Oracle certainly disagrees with you. You must have graduated before the AAU membership. At the very least, laughing is better than crying.

Bottom line, the STUDENTS rejected paying for the vanity project you can't afford. So what does the school do? They take it anyway. Nice.

Nobody said we weren't utilizing CITF funds for the stadium. It's laughable that you don't realize CITF funds are for exactly this - capital projects including building and renovating academic and athletic projects. It's controlled by the state and utilized by all universities in the state university system. This fund literally exists to help finance large projects like an OCS and over the past few years has spent $50MM/yr across the SUS for dozens of projects statewide. If you think an OCS isn't in the benefit of the students on campus, I can't help you. But, I will continue to laugh.

Keep laughing, because your complete lack of institutional literacy is doing all the work for me.

You trying to frame the CITF as a generic "state pot" is a transparently dishonest attempt to cover up the backdoor tax. Do you know how the Capital Improvement Trust Fund actually works under Florida Statute 1009.24 and BOG regulations?

CITF funds are not generic state dollars. They're built directly from a mandatory fee levied on students per credit hour. Furthermore, by state law, CITF allocations require a joint student-faculty committee where students hold formal voting power to recommend the project list. The fund's explicit, primary purpose is to finance projects that support the daily, general student experience: student unions, campus rec centers, student health clinics, and study spaces.

When your administration used $31M of CITF money for the stadium, they didn't magically "get money from the state." They actively pressured the student allocation process to divert a massive, disproportionate chunk of USF's limited campus-improvement capital away from everyday student infrastructure and dumped it into an athletic project. The university quite literally took $31M in restricted public fees -- statutorily collected per credit hour from everyday students specifically to fund non-revenue campus improvements -- and used it as an equity cushion to lower the borrowing costs on a commercial, auxiliary football stadium whose future revenues are legally pledged to Truist Bank. They used restricted student infrastructure capital to underwrite a private bank note.

The students explicitly voted NO on a direct stadium fee in 2017. So the school waited, bypassed that democratic rejection, and siphoned $31M out of the exact trust fund meant to improve Student Unions and campus life just to bail out an athletic department running a multi-million dollar deficit. USF took money meant for the entire student body's daily campus experience to subsidize a vanity mortgage because your athletic department lacks the donor base and liquidity to pay its own bills.

That isn't "utilizing state funds." That is a literal backdoor raid on student-generated tuition capital to fund a project they already told you they didn't want to pay for. But please, tell me more about how elite your "competence" is while you starve your own campus infrastructure to pay Truist Bank.

Again, keep laughing...

Nobody said they were state funds. Nobody said the students were obligated to vote for an additional fee - in fact any form of students voting to raise their own tuition at any campus usually fails, no matter what it's for. Correct, the CITF is a student-paid fee tacked into tuition that goes into a trust, whereby distribution is controlled by the state, and yes $31MM of it was voted and approved to be distributed to USF in 5 payments of $6MM and change. You can bold stuff and inject your own hyperbole while cherry picking random quotes from different sources all you want - I will continue to be entertained by your attack of USF and the irony in each of your posts. Struggling with checkers is a simple life.

The frantic backpedaling here is spectacular. More vibes?

You literally wrote in your previous post: "It's controlled by the state and utilized by all universities... has spent $50MM/yr across the SUS for dozens of projects statewide." You were explicitly trying to paint this as a generic state-controlled pot of money. After I had to educate you with regards to the actual statutes, proving it is a mandatory student-paid fee meant for campus life, you're scrambling backward with "Nobody said they were state funds."

Let's deal with your defense of those five annual installments of $6 million and change. It doesn't matter if the state "controls" the distribution of the trust. There is no ambiguity here, the state can't alter the statutory definition of what those funds are legally restricted to build under Florida Law.

By taking five consecutive years of USF's student capital -- $31M total -- and diverting it to an auxiliary football stadium, the administration quite literally starved the general student body's campus life infrastructure. Every dollar of that $31M going into stadium concrete is a dollar that can't go toward fixing leaky HVAC systems, updating student health clinics, expanding traditional student unions, or building study spaces for the 50K commuting, working-class students on campus.

You can try to hide behind your "I'm just entertained" routine all you want, but you completely lost the argument. You're actively sunshine pumping an administration that used a regulatory loophole to raid its own students' tuition capital to serve as an equity cushion for a commercial Truist Bank mortgage. Want to know what's really going to be entertaining? The "30 for 30" hit piece that will document everything for the general public in about 5-10 years, if the bottom falls out, which seems more plausible than the golden ticket materializing when you're carrying an insolvent athletic department without any corporate or donor interest -- nobody even wants to secure naming rights.

If you think using restricted student-life infrastructure funds to underwrite corporate athletic debt in a hyper-saturated pro sports market is "smart administration," it's pretty clear who's actually struggling with checkers. Keep laughing, but the receipts don't lie; and Memphis will enjoy their $0.22B in renovations while remaining debt free.
06-05-2026 04:00 PM
Find all posts by this user
shere khan Offline
Southerner
*

Posts: 76,740
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10825
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
Post: #97
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 03:53 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:47 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 02:52 PM)shere khan Wrote:  And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao

If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.

Youre an idiot to think i would ever work for college professor wages

Quit embarrassing the Univ of Memphis.

Todge eviserated you. Take the L

He can’t handle it. He needs to have the last word. This why even after he said he was done, he still posting. He is one of those that thinks if he is the last one to talk or post then he didn’t lose. 03-lmfao

01-wingedeagle

Everybody laughs at that weirdo

03-lmfao
06-05-2026 05:43 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #98
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
This was from another thread, but it greatly enhances context, so I'm posting it here too:

(06-06-2026 08:12 AM)TIGERCITY Wrote:  South Florida is betting with a credit card at the casino recognizing that the next few years are all that matter. You win , you're a big winner , you lose , it doesn't matter anyway.

Frankly, not the same thing at all. Not even close. To be blunt, you probably get better odds at the casino.

One can't treat a $350M+ state-backed capital project like a casual trip to a Vegas blackjack table. A state university can't declare bankruptcy and walk away from a commercial bank note. Director J. Ben Watkins III immediately noticed the extreme structural danger and wrote an explicit warning memo to the Board of Governors outlining the systemic risks.

This is exactly what the State of Florida put on the record, and what it really means for USF, irrespective of their misdirection and spin:
  • The 386% Revenue Lie: "Projected stadium revenues were increased by $15.2 million, from $5.3 million to $20.5 million, favorably impacting projected financial performance of the Project."

    This reads exactly how it looks. When the interest rate spiked to 7%, the surging cost of the debt service meant USF could no longer legally justify the loan under their original metrics. Instead of acting with prudence by scaling back or postponing, they hired a consultant to suddenly "discover" an extra $15.2 million in annual revenue -- objectively a nearly 400% increase over their original baseline. They fabricated an extreme best-case scenario out of thin air just to make the debt-to-income ratio look legal on paper.
    .
  • The Ghost Capital: "The revisions to the projections for the Project highlight the uncertainty of future financial performance and dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources."

    The state is politely calling out a fantasy. That extra $15.2 million in "untapped revenue" has no historical basis in reality for a G6 program that couldn't even generate enough discretionary donor capital to prevent Providence from poaching their conference-champion basketball coach.
    .
  • Zero Margin for Error: "Whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultants estimates."

    By wiping out any conservative budgeting buffer to justify the Truist loan, USF has left themselves with literally zero margin for error. For this financing structure not to become an immediate disaster, every single highly volatile variable -- from premium seating donations to naming rights -- must hit 100% execution, perfectly, every single year for two decades.
    .
  • Compounding Financial Risk: "The material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts..."

    Director Watkins is reminding the Board of Governors that USF's original, more conservative model already posed a structural threat to the university's broader endowment and fundraising health. By overlaying a hyper-aggressive, fabricated revenue projection on top of a significantly higher interest rate, they have escalated that pressure from a standard operational risk to a catastrophic one.
    .
  • The Permanent Lien on USF Athletics: "The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

    This is the ultimate indictment of the "casino" logic. Truist Bank isn't gambling; they have a permanent, legally binding lien on the gross revenues of the athletic department. Before USF pays a single coach, funds a single roster spot, or distributes a dime of NIL, Truist Bank takes their $20M debt service right off the top. If the stadium underperforms by even a fraction, the university faces a brutal choice: trigger immediate, crippling budget cuts across all sports, or systematically raid the university's unrestricted endowment to bail out a football stadium.
    .
  • The TSA Agreement and Asymmetric Risk: The facility operating framework under the Tampa Sports Authority (TSA) term sheet shifts 100% of the downside financial volatility onto the university while protecting the operator's primary asset.

    The TSA's chief institutional priority is -- and always will be -- managing and funding the massive $1B+ upcoming renovations at Raymond James Stadium to keep their primary tenant, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers (the premier sports product in Tampa), locked down long-term. Under the new on-campus operating agreement, the TSA has explicitly insulated itself from any upfront cash exposure. The deal ensures the TSA captures a protected 15% to 20% gross revenue skim from non-USF stadium bookings to offset its own broader operational ecosystem, while requiring the USF Intercollegiate Athletic Association to cover all day-to-day operating overhead. If the consultant's hyper-aggressive ticket sales or event bookings fail to materialize, the TSA's bottom line is legally protected; leaving USF entirely exposed to absorb every single dime of the downside operating deficits. This greatly reduces the feasibility of hitting the unrealistic revenue projections that must materialize to avoid financial disaster.

Stating that if you lose, "it doesn't matter anyway" might make sense if this only impacted football. Where this idea fails is the fact that this places great exposure on both athletics and the health of the entire university. This isn't theoretical, and the only way to avoid disaster is for everything to align perfectly -- for 20 years -- based on an egregious financial fiction. It wouldn't be an exaggeration to state that this places even their oft bragged about AAU membership at risk. AAU isn't a static state, and it's not unprecedented for a school to be stripped of their membership due to financial mismanagement and lapses in governance.

Consider that even an "M2 promotion" won't solve this. No G6 program is receiving an invite at full shares. Even Stanford and Cal were offered 30% revenue shares when they were invited to the ACC. That's not nearly enough for USF when year over year for the next two decades, they start out of the gate in a $20M hole they have to dig out of. Furthermore, playing in the bigger pond means they have to find a way to not only cover their liabilities, they will be required to dramatically scale up their operations to even compete on the court and the field. A "power" conference invite isn't a silver bullet and won't fix this easily. It's far worse than anyone has been admitting.

It's no surprise that the USF Board of Trustees Chairman Will Weatherford -- former Florida Speaker of the House -- has recently stepped down now that the financial realities are coming to fruition. It's better to let this be the "next guy's" problem while retaining all of the political capital tied to plastering your name over the "sunshine and rainbows" marketing spiel and groundbreaking photo ops that lead up to construction. Vibes over competence indeed.

Hopefully this clarifies.
06-06-2026 02:40 PM
Find all posts by this user
Cubanbull1 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,571
Joined: Jul 2005
Reputation: 668
I Root For: USF
Location: North Georgia
Post: #99
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-05-2026 05:43 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:53 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:47 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 02:52 PM)shere khan Wrote:  And......

The always succinct Todge broke him

03-lmfao

If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.

Youre an idiot to think i would ever work for college professor wages

Quit embarrassing the Univ of Memphis.

Todge eviserated you. Take the L

He can’t handle it. He needs to have the last word. This why even after he said he was done, he still posting. He is one of those that thinks if he is the last one to talk or post then he didn’t lose. 03-lmfao

01-wingedeagle

Everybody laughs at that weirdo

03-lmfao

Yeah I can see why, is funny how he brings up stuff and tries to tie into his whole BS act.
He would be great at spreading conspiracy theories. 03-lmfao
06-06-2026 03:39 PM
Find all posts by this user
msu35 Offline
Observing Reality
*

Posts: 21,519
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2232
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
Post: #100
RE: Vibes vs Competence: How Memphis Plays Chess While USF Struggles With Checkers
(06-06-2026 03:39 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 05:43 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:53 PM)Cubanbull1 Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:47 PM)shere khan Wrote:  
(06-05-2026 03:05 PM)msu35 Wrote:  If that’s your takeaway, no wonder you never made tenure. Carry on.

Youre an idiot to think i would ever work for college professor wages

Quit embarrassing the Univ of Memphis.

Todge eviserated you. Take the L

He can’t handle it. He needs to have the last word. This why even after he said he was done, he still posting. He is one of those that thinks if he is the last one to talk or post then he didn’t lose. 03-lmfao

01-wingedeagle

Everybody laughs at that weirdo

03-lmfao

Yeah I can see why, is funny how he brings up stuff and tries to tie into his whole BS act.
He would be great at spreading conspiracy theories. 03-lmfao

It's always a "conspiracy theory" when you don't possess the baseline financial literacy to read a public state record. That's what's "funny" to anyone with a shred of objectivity and a high school education.

You can spam the laugh emojis all you want, but a "conspiracy" doesn't explain why your own Board of Trustees just had to authorize an emergency $22.5M internal loan for the athletic department. A "conspiracy" doesn't invent the fact that athletic contributions cratered by 18.11% in your state compliance audit.

And it certainly isn't a conspiracy that your insolvent administration just contractually committed an unprecedented $9.7M annually to Brian Hartline and his assistant staff pool, while simultaneously passing a $16M emergency budget hike just to cover the impending player revenue-sharing mandates.

You are a G6 athletic department generating G6 revenue, yet you are burning P4 cash on credit and praying a power conference bails you out of a 7% high-interest commercial bank note. Cosplaying a P4 program isn't the same thing as executing like a P4 program. In case you continue to be confused, I didn't write the bond memo -- J. Ben Watkins III did. Go argue with the State of Florida.

Instead of posting nonsensical drivel, if you're so informed, address the points I made with facts and data. All of your attacks and denials only prove that you have literally zero factual basis to attack anything that I wrote. I would bet my investment portfolio that you can't discredit any of the following, because I did the research and I know the truth, whether you have the capability to comprehend or not:

One can't treat a $350M+ state-backed capital project like a casual trip to a Vegas blackjack table. A state university can't declare bankruptcy and walk away from a commercial bank note. Director J. Ben Watkins III immediately noticed the extreme structural danger and wrote an explicit warning memo to the Board of Governors outlining the systemic risks.

This is exactly what the State of Florida put on the record, and what it really means for USF, irrespective of their misdirection and spin:
  • The 386% Revenue Lie: "Projected stadium revenues were increased by $15.2 million, from $5.3 million to $20.5 million, favorably impacting projected financial performance of the Project."

    This reads exactly how it looks. When the interest rate spiked to 7%, the surging cost of the debt service meant USF could no longer legally justify the loan under their original metrics. Instead of acting with prudence by scaling back or postponing, they hired a consultant to suddenly "discover" an extra $15.2 million in annual revenue -- objectively a nearly 400% increase over their original baseline. They fabricated an extreme best-case scenario out of thin air just to make the debt-to-income ratio look legal on paper.
    .
  • The Ghost Capital: "The revisions to the projections for the Project highlight the uncertainty of future financial performance and dependence on generating substantial untapped revenue sources."

    The state is politely calling out a fantasy. That extra $15.2 million in "untapped revenue" has no historical basis in reality for a G6 program that couldn't even generate enough discretionary donor capital to prevent Providence from poaching their conference-champion basketball coach.
    .
  • Zero Margin for Error: "Whatever conservatism was baked into the original assumptions has been eliminated and revenue projections/financial performance are fully dependent on realizing the consultants estimates."

    By wiping out any conservative budgeting buffer to justify the Truist loan, USF has left themselves with literally zero margin for error. For this financing structure not to become an immediate disaster, every single highly volatile variable -- from premium seating donations to naming rights -- must hit 100% execution, perfectly, every single year for two decades.
    .
  • Compounding Financial Risk: "The material operating risk exacerbates the potential financial pressure on USF's endowment and fundraising efforts..."

    Director Watkins is reminding the Board of Governors that USF's original, more conservative model already posed a structural threat to the university's broader endowment and fundraising health. By overlaying a hyper-aggressive, fabricated revenue projection on top of a significantly higher interest rate, they have escalated that pressure from a standard operational risk to a catastrophic one.
    .
  • The Permanent Lien on USF Athletics: "The debt being incurred is secured by gross revenues from athletics so that any negative operating performance or failure to meet fundraising goals will likely necessitate budget cuts for athletics or require additional subsidies from unrestricted funds from the USF endowment."

    This is the ultimate indictment of the "casino" logic. Truist Bank isn't gambling; they have a permanent, legally binding lien on the gross revenues of the athletic department. Before USF pays a single coach, funds a single roster spot, or distributes a dime of NIL, Truist Bank takes their $20M debt service right off the top. If the stadium underperforms by even a fraction, the university faces a brutal choice: trigger immediate, crippling budget cuts across all sports, or systematically raid the university's unrestricted endowment to bail out a football stadium.
    .
  • The TSA Agreement and Asymmetric Risk: The facility operating framework under the Tampa Sports Authority (TSA) term sheet shifts 100% of the downside financial volatility onto the university while protecting the operator's primary asset.

    The TSA's chief institutional priority is -- and always will be -- managing and funding the massive $1B+ upcoming renovations at Raymond James Stadium to keep their primary tenant, the Tampa Bay Buccaneers (the premier sports product in Tampa), locked down long-term. Under the new on-campus operating agreement, the TSA has explicitly insulated itself from any upfront cash exposure. The deal ensures the TSA captures a protected 15% to 20% gross revenue skim from non-USF stadium bookings to offset its own broader operational ecosystem, while requiring the USF Intercollegiate Athletic Association to cover all day-to-day operating overhead. If the consultant's hyper-aggressive ticket sales or event bookings fail to materialize, the TSA's bottom line is legally protected; leaving USF entirely exposed to absorb every single dime of the downside operating deficits. This greatly reduces the feasibility of hitting the unrealistic revenue projections that must materialize to avoid financial disaster.

Stating that if you lose, "it doesn't matter anyway" might make sense if this only impacted football. Where this idea fails is the fact that this places great exposure on both athletics and the health of the entire university. This isn't theoretical, and the only way to avoid disaster is for everything to align perfectly -- for 20 years -- based on an egregious financial fiction. It wouldn't be an exaggeration to state that this places even their oft bragged about AAU membership at risk. AAU isn't a static state, and it's not unprecedented for a school to be stripped of their membership due to financial mismanagement and lapses in governance.

Consider that even an "M2 promotion" won't solve this. No G6 program is receiving an invite at full shares. Even Stanford and Cal were offered 30% revenue shares when they were invited to the ACC. That's not nearly enough for USF when year over year for the next two decades, they start out of the gate in a $20M hole they have to dig out of. Furthermore, playing in the bigger pond means they have to find a way to not only cover their liabilities, they will be required to dramatically scale up their operations to even compete on the court and the field. A "power" conference invite isn't a silver bullet and won't fix this easily. It's far worse than anyone has been admitting.

It's no surprise that the USF Board of Trustees Chairman Will Weatherford -- former Florida Speaker of the House -- has recently stepped down now that the financial realities are coming to fruition. It's better to let this be the "next guy's" problem while retaining all of the political capital tied to plastering your name over the "sunshine and rainbows" marketing spiel and groundbreaking photo ops that lead up to construction. Vibes over competence indeed.

Hopefully this clarifies.
(This post was last modified: 06-12-2026 12:13 AM by msu35.)
06-06-2026 04:02 PM
Find all posts by this user
Thread Closed 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.