1. the Florida higher education board was not a part of the decision as to why USF made the decision they made......but they are still of the opinion that bonds can be used.....they made an assessment that projects like that can use tax exempt and taxed bonds and they regularly do.....what they did not make an assessment on is why USF made the decision they did.......but you having no inside information yourself have made the assessment that they were not able to at all for any of it.......but again you have no knowledge of the project or the decisions being made you just have your opinion with nothing to support it and with many instances that show similar projects have used tax free money for all or a portion of the project
again here is another very recent example
https://news3lv.com/news/local/clark-cou...nstruction
Clark County bonds to be repaid with a TIF on the surrounding area......there is nothing that prevents Hillsborough County from doing the same
in fact there is a very new legal opinion that says it is 100% possible
https://baynews9.com/fl/tampa/news/2026/...ugh-county
A major legal question surrounding a proposed multi-billion-dollar stadium deal for the Tampa Bay Rays now has an answer — and it could shape the future of the project.
A newly issued legal opinion issued by Bryant Miller Olive says Hillsborough County can use Community Investment Tax (CIT) dollars to help fund a new stadium — even if it’s leased to a professional baseball team.
so right there in the same exact county as USF......but I suppose your next argument is that a TIF is a tax and not a bond......while you will ignore that the TIF revenue generation will be used to pay off MUNICIPAL BONDS that will need to be sold in order to fund the stajium.......or are you going to try and say that they will place a TIF on raw land, collect up the money for (hundreds at that rate) of years and then pay cash for the stajium
no of course they will not they will sell municipal bonds, build the project, and then use the TIF to pay those bonds
so again no matter what you argue about "in the past and times dey be uh changin" the fact is RIGHT NOW today there are projects for sports arenas in the USA including one large one in the very same state and in the very same county as USF that are going to use municipal bonds to fund some of the project
Under the proposal:
The Rays would cover roughly half the cost
Taxpayers would fund the remaining portion through public sources, including CIT dollars
Why the legal opinion matters
The question of whether CIT funds could legally be used for a stadium has been a major point of debate.
Hillsborough County Commissioner Gwen Myers requested the legal review after hearing conflicting concerns from the public.
“What we're hearing now is that we're receiving so many emails that the funds cannot be used. And we're hearing that the funds can be used. So the legal opinion would answer the question for all of us.”
The opinion concludes:
A publicly owned stadium qualifies as a “recreational public facility” under Florida law
CIT funds can be used for such facilities
There is no legal restriction in place, since a proposed ban on using the funds for a stadium was never formally approved
so what does all of that say....lets see it says you are wrong, you are wrong on that as well....and oh yea yep you are wrong there too.....and damn it you are wrong again and again and again
because no matter how you try and twist it Clark County, Nevada is issuing municipal bonds for a pro sports stajium......and no matter how you will try and deflect or concentrate on the TIF aspect of what is happening right in the same county as USF anyone with even a modicum of intelligence will know that the TIF money will go towards paying for MUNICIPAL BONDS to fund a pro sports stajium that has been legally termed as....wait for it ---->>>>
"A publicly owned stadium qualifies as a “recreational public facility” under Florida law"
it is VERY VERY VERY clear....it makes no distinction that it be publicly owned by a city or county and not a PUBLIC state university.....or that it be used for pro sports only and not for college sports at a PUBLIC university
so again lets go over this very slowly for those that are slow
1. public bonds and their use......you are wrong
2. that was in the past, but times dey uh changin.....you are wrong
3. the project cannot have parts of it funded in different ways because some part of it might not be "public use"......you are wrong
4. stajiums that generate revenue through commerce or "money making" cannot be public use......you are wrong
how much more wrong can you be
and in fact not only can bonds be used, but it is clear that a TIF can be placed on the area to pay those bonds
but since you like to be wrong often we can all prepare ourselves for you to try and say that Clark County, Nevada and their clear use of bonds is somehow different because well....in Nevada, for pro sports, it is a county not a public university.....or some other nonsense
or you are going to try and argue that Hillsborough is not going to use bonds for their project they are going to use the money fairy, the lending tree, money from thin air, or they just have extra cash in the treasure bath out back to pay for it and they will use the TIF money to fill the treasure bath back up over time.....but hey you will still be wrong
2. once again.....endowment managers can increase the payout from the endowment....I never said this creates "free money", but it does allow for a larger distribution that can be used for a number of things.....and I stated this comes at a cost of reinvesting some of that return that is paid out
but there is nothing that prevents it and it happens on a regular basis
there are dozens if not hundreds of articles discussing that universities have upped distributions for a period of time t create extra available funds or in some cases they have shortened the number of years used to calculate the average value of the endowment to a window that has a higher return and thus that higher return period means that distributions increase for a period of time
3. nowhere did I say a venue manager would assume debt....I clearly never said that.....this is another attempt for you to make an argument against something that was never said
nor did say they would "bail anyone out"......and the stupid person is the one that says I am comparing UT Austin to USF.......when what I am actually doing is discussing what one university did to get a single athletics facility built vs. what another university is doing to get a larger overall area with several things developed.......this is not a comparison of athletics programs it is a comparison of methods to build venues
and because you say "things do not work like that" in reference to a venue management company giving some up front money as part of an agreement to take over the management of a venue or venues for a long period of time that does not mean it is true or not possible.....as I stated Oak View did pay up front......they paid a hell of a lot of money up front to actually build a facility they will never own in exchange for the rights to manage it for a period of time and some profit sharing with UT
they PAID 100% up front
the difference is USF is doing all the work up front......and there is NOTHING at all that would prevent a company from giving cash up front to take on a long term management deal
The Moody center was $375 million to build all paid UP FRONT before a single event happened in that space and all paid for by others not names UT Austin
you can pretend that is not "paying up front", but there is nothing that would have prevented a similar deal from being structured where the university covered the cost up front and then 10% $37.5 million (or 5%, 20%, 12.5% or whatever amount) was paid to the university UP FRONT for the rights to manage the venue and in that case I would expect the university would want a large share of profits because they still have the UP FRONT cost.....as USF will have
your argument is "things do not work like that" or made up ideas about "assuming debt" (never stated by me) or "bailing out a debtor" again this was never stated by me and is based on your assumption that USF will absolutely need a "bail out"
and really the only comparable project to USF in recent times is SDSU
https://www.sportsbusinessjournal.com/Jo...acilities/
their agreement for management is $2 million per year annually no matter what, OVG gets the next $1 million, and then after that all revenue is split 50/50 and OVG covers all expenses except for SDSU game days
that is a very generous split of revenues IMO......and on day one of the deal SDSU got their $2 million UP FRONT
there is nothing that says a deal could not be $5 million up front with a lower split of revenues after that......but somehow you pretend you are the arbiter of how these deals operate and are structured.....even though the entire business of coming in and managing venues like this especially on college campuses is relatively new and projects this size on a college campus are rare
and the SDSU deal (like the UT deal) really only includes a venue it does not include any surrounding land.....USF has surrounding land just as SDSU does, but SDSU is choosing to use a lot more of their land for university functions though there will be retail and housing and in the case of USF there is nothing that stops up front money from being paid for the rights to develop some of that with a revenue sharing agreement in place.....other than your inability to understand that concept in your head
4. lastly you are claiming that the project is already insolvent or that it is guaranteed to be insolvent when it is not even finished yet......just a ridiculous take and if you look at what was said about the SDSU project vs. what has actually happened with it your take becomes even more of a stretch
and even more laughable is you claiming that USF is in some type of "predicament" when there are few if any other universities in the country that have raised their academic and research profile to the level that USF has and in the time frame they did it.....they did not just talk a lot about it and make some moves that looked OK
they actually did it....and while that does not mean "great lets just blow money on athletics" I am willing to give a lot of the benefit of the doubt to an administration that elevated their academic and research profile as rapidly and in the time frame they did for other university decisions vs. someone that hopes their university in Memphis does not follow that same path
I have done the research.....what USF has done academically is very impressive.....and I have also clearly showed that in the very recent past professional sports venues had municipal bond funding used for part of their construction
including an decision right in the same state and in the same county as USF for a very similar project.....other than it being for pro sports and not (currently) for university sports
and I have shown examples of venues being managed with up front money (SDSU actual cash $2 million per year) and a very generous split of all other revenues and UT Austin where UP FRONT money was paid out to construct a facility the company will never own.....because they did not hand that directly to UT does not mean it was not an up front cost.....and because USF is financing their project up front themselves (AS SDSU DID) that does not mean they cannot get UP FRONT cash paid to them for a management agreement......because as I showed SDSU is getting just that....$2 million up front every year and then a very large split of revenues past a very small threshold of $1 million more going to the management company
plus there are still naming rights to sell and raw land to work with developers on
but in your mind somehow people that do extremely well running a university are wrong, all proven examples of deals are wrong, and USF is going to be insolvent before the venue even opens based on......well your desire to not follow the path of a university with elevated academics and research that now wants more attention from athletics as well......while you just want overall under-performance all around