(09-27-2026 04:55 PM)3DogNight Wrote: (09-27-2026 01:05 PM)whupemall Wrote: The idea that poaching an FBS school is ALWAYS better than calling up an FCS team is flawed on its face.
Most of the time, sure, it's better, for any number of reasons. And when everything falls into place and you can pull it off, great!
But honestly... if we had two slots available and had to fill them in a hurry, would you rather have Tarleton and SDSU or ULM and Kent State?
If it's up to me, in this case, I'm welcoming our newest members, the Texans and Jackrabbits. Potential trumps a track record of consistent failure.
You’re picking 2 of the worst FBS schools out there. I could just as easily say would you rather have SC State and Lamar or would you rather have Troy and Miami Ohio? As far as FCS goes, Tarleton looks to be a decent option. Other than them, I don’t see any other FCS school that would be that beneficial. As far as being a boon by adding a football only school all the way in Brookings South Dakota, I just don’t see that much of a benefit for CUSA. If the goal is being a conference that’s just a call up destination for FCS schools, then limiting the pool to only FCS schools is the way to go I guess.
Are you so consistently missing the point on purpose, just for engagement?
OF COURSE I PICKED THE TWO WORST TEAMS.
You don't seem to understand that the point of the "FCS Prospects Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc.." thread is to vet any possible FCS Prospects with Real Data, Opinions, Analytics, Budgets, Revenue, Etc.
So I said the idea that FBS is ALWAYS BETTER is flawed on its face, by pointing out that there are FBS teams which are simply not desirable.
Then you proceed to say, "As far as FCS goes, Tarleton looks to be a decent option."
While this is true, it also reflects what the currently 146 pages of discussion in the FCS Prospects thread has concluded. There aren't any other decent options in FCS who are ready to move NOW.
Which is why we're waiting on expansion and specifically NOT just inviting other schools to invite other schools.
SFA? 3-5 years away at a minimum. EKU? Probably 5-10 years away, but trending in the wrong direction. UTC? Not interested and 5-10 years away at best. I could keep going, but then I'm undermining TOPSTRAIGHT's hard work, which is on full display in the prospect thread.
Miami-OH was allegedly willing to pay tens of millions to the American. That does NOT mean they'd be willing to pay CUSA the same. CUSA is in a healthier position, when you look at enrollment numbers, state populations, etc., but right now, we're a tier below the AAC, and much closer to the MAC in our media deal. The same can be said for the Sun Belt.
If Miami is that anxious to escape the MAC, then by all means, we should be courting them. I don't think too many folks would argue with that. But for the RedHawks, CUSA would be a mostly lateral move. Their motivation to make such a move would likely be tempered by the fact they'd have to pay far more in travel without the benefit of the AAC's extra revenue.
Absolutely no one -- NO ONE -- has (as you've alleged in another thread) is saying, "Forget about attempting to get a solid FBS team to jump conferences. We should go after Austin Peay instead!"
But by the same token, no one realistically thinks we can successfully go after a high-end SBC or MAC team.
We're not thinking too small. We're being realistic.
I don't care about who it would be NICE to have. I care about who could legitimately join us here in CUSA to make us a stronger conference.
And right now, short of crazy shenanigans in the P4, PAC, and AAC, that's a very, very short list.
EDIT: Corrected Bobcats to RedHawks. LOL. Sorry to both of you, Miami and Ohio. I was tired.