(08-19-2026 01:54 PM)3DogNight Wrote: CUSA needs to pursue 1-3 of the MAC schools along with Tarleton to either put us at 12 or 14 and be done with it. If we do that we’re not waiting and wondering when another FCS school is ready to move up to go along with Tarleton. We could get 1-3 established FBS schools that are well within our footprint as well as getting a qualified FCS school that fits our footprint as well. If we’re waiting for another FCS school to be ready as an addition to go along with Tarleton, we’ll end up losing Tarleton IMO. All of these additions would end up being all sports additions which I like. I personally don’t care for adding football only schools.
I don't think this is realistic. Unless the MAC experiences a mass exodus, none of the current MAC schools have any financial incentive to join CUSA. Plus, the exiting 10 CUSA schools have zero financial incentive to invite the middle/bottom of the MAC too.
The 1-3 MAC schools we would want don't want CUSA. Those schools would only be willing to leave the MAC for the American, MWC (FB Only), PAC (FB Only) or Sun Belt.
We don't need the bottom of the MAC.
There are long shot FCS schools that are worth waiting for before increasing from 10 by picking up MAC schools. South Dakota St, the Montanas, Tarleton St & maybe even UTRGV (within the next few years) would all be more sexier picks than the middle/bottom of the MAC.
PER Google's AI
The elite FCS programs—Montana State, Montana, South Dakota State, and Tarleton State—rank significantly higher than the vast majority of the 2026 Mid-American Conference (MAC) teams in terms of roster quality and overall power rankings, while UTRGV ranks near the bottom of the MAC tier. [1, 2, 3, 4]
The national Stats Perform FCS Preseason Top 25 Poll and the ESPN College Football SP+ Projections outline how these programs stack up. [1, 4]
The Tier 1 Powerhouses (Ranked Ahead of All MAC Schools)
The absolute best teams in the FCS routinely rank higher than lower-tier FBS teams. Advanced metrics place this group on par with a typical 7-to-9 win Mountain West or Sun Belt team, putting them ahead of the entire MAC.
Montana State Bobcats: Ranked No. 1 in the FCS. With an elite A+ grade across power, offense, and defense, they would be favored by double digits against any team in the MAC.Montana Grizzlies: Ranked No. 2 in the FCS. Boasting a robust defense and an explosive offense, they project higher than top MAC tier teams like Miami (OH) and Western Michigan.South Dakota State Jackrabbits: Ranked No. 3 in the FCS. They possess the No. 1 defensive power rating in the subdivision and would cleanly sweep the MAC schedule. The Upper-Mid Tier (Ranked Ahead of Most MAC Schools)
• Tarleton State Texans: Ranked No. 5 in the FCS . Tarleton State features a high-powered transfer portal class and a top-5 offensive unit . They would comfortably project to finish near the very top of the MAC alongside Western Michigan , and easily clear mid-to-bottom tier MAC schools like Akron , Kent State , or Ball State . [1, 4, 5, 6, 7]
The Developmental Tier (Ranked Below the MAC)
• UTRGV Vaqueros: Unranked in the FCS . Entering just their second competitive season in the Southland Conference, the Vaqueros are still building up their roster limits . They rank significantly lower than all 2026 MAC programs, including Sacramento State and UMass . [1, 4, 8, 9]
Direct Overview: 2026 Respective Standings
To visually contextualize their competitive strength against the landscape of the 13-team 2026 MAC, the programs compare as follows: [4]
| Program / Conference Tier | 2026 Status / National Standing | Projected MAC Equivalent Spot |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Montana State | No. 1 National FCS Preseason Ranking | Clear No. 1 (Favored over full conference) |
| Montana | No. 2 National FCS Preseason Ranking | Clear No. 2 (Ahead of championship contenders) |
| South Dakota State | No. 3 National FCS Preseason Ranking | Clear No. 3 (Ahead of championship contenders) |
| Western Michigan | No. 1 in MAC Coaches Poll | Top Tier FBS |
| Miami (OH) | No. 2 in MAC Coaches Poll | Top Tier FBS |
| Tarleton State | No. 5 National FCS Preseason Ranking | Top 3-4 MAC Finisher (Championship contender) |
| Mid-Tier MAC; (Toledo , Ohio, CMU) | Mid-pack MAC programs | Mid-Tier FBS |
| Bottom-Tier MAC; (Ball St , Sac State , UMass) | Rebuilding or transitioning programs | Lower-Tier FBS |
| UTRGV | Second-year FCS program / Unranked | Bottom of the Pack; (Below UMass / Sacramento State) |
If you want, I can break down the exact returning production or quarterback situations for Montana State, Montana, or South Dakota State to show why they are heavily favored over the MAC. Which team are you most interested in?
AI responses may include mistakes.
[1]
https://fbschedules.com/montana-state-to...p-25-poll/
[2]
https://www.facebook.com/WeAreAFCA/posts...957856269/
[3]
https://www.espn.com/college-football/fpi/_/group/15
[4]
https://www.espn.com/college-football/st...redictions
[5]
https://www.versussportssimulator.com/FCS/rankings
[6]
https://www.ncaa.com/news/football/artic...-27-season
[7]
https://athlonsports.com/college-footbal...redictions
[8]
https://goutrgv.com/news/2026/1/6/footba...edule.aspx
[9]
https://www.krgv.com/news/utrgv-vaqueros...-schedule/