TIGERCITY
Hall of Famer

Posts: 21,650
Joined: Feb 2009
Reputation: 581
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
Both AIs agree that the 'too lame' hire is questionable.
|
|
| 12-08-2025 10:00 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-08-2025 06:21 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:03 PM)shere khan Wrote: (12-08-2025 04:52 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Time will tell.
Nah. Been told here. #1 coach in nation, this thread. Experts have spoken
Championship next year!

lol. I’m kind of over it, Huffs the guy and I’ll support him until he gives me reason not to. Just disappointed we didn’t aim higher. Oh well, time to move forward. He can make us feel better with some great signings soon…
You keep saying things like "aim higher". Help define that for the class, please - with examples.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 11:24 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-08-2025 06:31 PM)roachman48 Wrote: My 3 guesses at who wrote this evaluation-
1 Coach Huff
2 Our AD
3 Some Silverfield hater
I don't think MSU35 or AI are any of those.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 11:28 AM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,074
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 11:24 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:21 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:03 PM)shere khan Wrote: (12-08-2025 04:52 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Time will tell.
Nah. Been told here. #1 coach in nation, this thread. Experts have spoken
Championship next year!

lol. I’m kind of over it, Huffs the guy and I’ll support him until he gives me reason not to. Just disappointed we didn’t aim higher. Oh well, time to move forward. He can make us feel better with some great signings soon…
You keep saying things like "aim higher". Help define that for the class, please - with examples.
Jeez man. This is no splash hire whatsoever. Plenty of names have been fielded here. It’s not a terrible hire, I’d expect Silverfield type performance. 8-4, upper middle tier AAC. I wasn’t a fan of firing Silverfield, but I wasn’t upset to see him leave either.
Not the splash hire that the university teased. I think Huff will maintain status quo, which isn’t terrible by any means.
He’s the guy, so I’ll support him. No doubt that many fans are disappointed with this hire. I’d grade it as a B- to C+. We did better than Tulane for sure, but I like the other top G5 hires better, particularly USFs.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 11:51 AM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 11:51 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 11:24 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:21 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:03 PM)shere khan Wrote: (12-08-2025 04:52 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Time will tell.
Nah. Been told here. #1 coach in nation, this thread. Experts have spoken
Championship next year!

lol. I’m kind of over it, Huffs the guy and I’ll support him until he gives me reason not to. Just disappointed we didn’t aim higher. Oh well, time to move forward. He can make us feel better with some great signings soon…
You keep saying things like "aim higher". Help define that for the class, please - with examples.
Jeez man. This is no splash hire whatsoever. Plenty of names have been fielded here. It’s not a terrible hire, I’d expect Silverfield type performance. 8-4, upper middle tier AAC. I wasn’t a fan of firing Silverfield, but I wasn’t upset to see him leave either.
Not the splash hire that the university teased. I think Huff will maintain status quo, which isn’t terrible by any means.
He’s the guy, so I’ll support him. No doubt that many fans are disappointed with this hire. I’d grade it as a B- to C+. We did better than Tulane for sure, but I like the other top G5 hires better, particularly USFs.
Agree it's not a splash hire. Ed should have never said that. But it's also the most qualified coach we've hired in a loooonnnnggg time.
So when you say "aim higher", you mean hire an unproven coordinator from a P4.
You think...
unproven, 39 years old, 3 years as an OC, never been HC, been with 1 program his entire career...
is greater than...
42 years old, 5 years as HC, with multiple successful mentor coaches.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 02:09 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,743
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2237
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
People are certainly getting bent out of shape over nothing. I asked an AI system to give me a blunt and objective critique of recent hires across the following criteria: organizational leadership and resilience, program foundation and cultural discipline, and in-game and scheme adaptability; with a final assessment with regards to program fit. This is what it came up with on its own.
I don't necessarily agree or disagree with anything that it stated, and it seems to have placed the greatest weight on risk profile on its own. I do think it's an interesting evaluation of the pros and cons, and it's nice that it had such a high opinion of our new coach. I feel it graded a bit too harshly for lacking experience (e.g. risk) among other factors, but in my opinion it's not too far off the mark.
Aside from that, I asked it to use UBB code for formatting, font face, and color. It did and excellent job with that. AI is simply a tool and certainly doesn't have all of the answers, but discounting it wholesale is as silly as relying on it as the final word.
Resorting to an immediate indictment because "AI did it!" is silly. It's hard to argue that the facts it presented are objectively false. Discussing the evaluation itself and what one agrees or disagrees with would promote better discussion and board content, but then again, this is the ORG.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 02:40 PM by msu35.)
|
|
| 12-09-2025 02:29 PM |
|
k2tigers
Hall of Famer

Posts: 18,343
Joined: Feb 2004
Reputation: 993
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
here is today's from Sr. CFB writer for the Athletic - in chronolical order of hire:
(this site is premium so I didn't link article - six of the Top 20 received grades A- and above)
Grading college football's coaching carousel:
- by Chris Vannini
Tulane - Will Hall: B-
Memphis - Charles Huff: A-
"Huff checks off a lot of boxes for Memphis. He's won a conference championship at Marshall in 2024. He's very good at accumulating talent on a roster, as one of the best recruiters in the country at Penn St. and Alabama as an assistant. Memphis has one of the largest roster budgets in the Group of 5, so it should be able to get players, and fans had become frustrated with former coach Ryan Silverfield's inability to take the Tigers to a conference championship game. Huff went from Sun Belt championship Marshall to 1-11 Southern Miss last offseason due to clashes with the Marshall administration. But he brought a lot of those good Marshall players with him and improved Southern Miss to 7-5 and played for a division title on the last week of the season. The upside here is clear, and Memphis wanted upside."
UConn - Jason Candle: B
Penn State - Matt Campbell: A-
Kansas State - Collin Klein: A-
Cal - Tosh Lupoi: B+
James Madison - Billy Napier: B
South Florida - Brian Hartline: B+
North Texas - Neal Brown: B
Kentucky - Will Stein: B+
UCLA - Bob Chesney: B+
Michigan State - Pat Fitzgerald: B-
LSU - Lane Kiffin: A
Ole Miss - Pete Golding: B
Florida - Jon Sumrall: A-
Auburn - Alex Golesh: B+
Arkansas - Ryan Silverfield: B
Colorado State - Jim Mora: B
Oklahoma /state - Eric Morris: B+
Virginia Tech - James Franklin: A-
|
|
| 12-09-2025 03:09 PM |
|
shere khan
Southerner

Posts: 76,768
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10831
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
^
Looks like grade inflation
|
|
| 12-09-2025 03:16 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 03:16 PM)shere khan Wrote: ^
Looks like grade inflation

Sure it is.
But nice to see we're in the high side of the curved grade, unlike some of the choices from cold takes on this board.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 03:30 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,074
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 02:09 PM)Tiger87 Wrote: (12-09-2025 11:51 AM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 11:24 AM)Tiger87 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:21 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-08-2025 06:03 PM)shere khan Wrote: Nah. Been told here. #1 coach in nation, this thread. Experts have spoken
Championship next year!

lol. I’m kind of over it, Huffs the guy and I’ll support him until he gives me reason not to. Just disappointed we didn’t aim higher. Oh well, time to move forward. He can make us feel better with some great signings soon…
You keep saying things like "aim higher". Help define that for the class, please - with examples.
Jeez man. This is no splash hire whatsoever. Plenty of names have been fielded here. It’s not a terrible hire, I’d expect Silverfield type performance. 8-4, upper middle tier AAC. I wasn’t a fan of firing Silverfield, but I wasn’t upset to see him leave either.
Not the splash hire that the university teased. I think Huff will maintain status quo, which isn’t terrible by any means.
He’s the guy, so I’ll support him. No doubt that many fans are disappointed with this hire. I’d grade it as a B- to C+. We did better than Tulane for sure, but I like the other top G5 hires better, particularly USFs.
Agree it's not a splash hire. Ed should have never said that. But it's also the most qualified coach we've hired in a loooonnnnggg time.
So when you say "aim higher", you mean hire an unproven coordinator from a P4.
You think...
unproven, 39 years old, 3 years as an OC, never been HC, been with 1 program his entire career...
is greater than...
42 years old, 5 years as HC, with multiple successful mentor coaches.
Oh, I’d take Hartline in a second. Some risk but could be spectacular. Not even close.
I’m not against Huff, but dig deeper and it looks like Silverfield. 39-25 (.610) overall record. He had 2 decent seasons at Marshall 2022 (9-4) and 2024 (10-3). The rest around .500. His record against winning teams is poor. Again, looks like Silverfield.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 04:06 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,743
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2237
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 04:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Oh, I’d take Hartline in a second. Some risk but could be spectacular. Not even close.
I’m not against Huff, but dig deeper and it looks like Silverfield. 39-25 (.610) overall record. He had 2 decent seasons at Marshall 2022 (9-4) and 2024 (10-3). The rest around .500. His record against winning teams is poor. Again, looks like Silverfield.
I don't recall Silverfield winning the conference championship, let alone even qualifying for the game. Did Silverfield take over a 1-win team, making them bowl eligible his first year on the job, or did he immediately regress after inheriting a championship team that won the conference and made a NY6 bowl the year prior?
Yeah, looks exactly like Silverfield.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 04:12 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,074
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 04:12 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Oh, I’d take Hartline in a second. Some risk but could be spectacular. Not even close.
I’m not against Huff, but dig deeper and it looks like Silverfield. 39-25 (.610) overall record. He had 2 decent seasons at Marshall 2022 (9-4) and 2024 (10-3). The rest around .500. His record against winning teams is poor. Again, looks like Silverfield.
I don't recall Silverfield winning the conference championship, let alone even qualifying for the game. Did Silverfield take over a 1-win team, making them bowl eligible his first year on the job, or did he immediately regress after inheriting a championship team that won the conference and made a NY6 bowl the year prior?
Yeah, looks exactly like Silverfield.
Whatever. Similar overall record. Terrible against teams over .500.
Some high points too. A conference championship, albeit the Sun Belt, is an accomplishment. Turning USM around was noteworthy too, although he did bring a bunch of his Marshall players with him.
Silverfield went 8-4 with a huge rebuild last year. It’s the way it is. Every year the coach will practically recruit a new team from the portal.
Again, I’m not against the guy at all. I just think he’s just an average hire and in no way the “splash hire” that Ed Scott mentioned. I’d call it about a push between Huff and Silverfield. Time will tell.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 04:57 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,743
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2237
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 04:57 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:12 PM)msu35 Wrote: I don't recall Silverfield winning the conference championship, let alone even qualifying for the game. Did Silverfield take over a 1-win team, making them bowl eligible his first year on the job, or did he immediately regress after inheriting a championship team that won the conference and made a NY6 bowl the year prior?
Yeah, looks exactly like Silverfield.
Whatever. Similar overall record. Terrible against teams over .500.
Some high points too. A conference championship, albeit the Sun Belt, is an accomplishment. Turning USM around was noteworthy too, although he did bring a bunch of his Marshall players with him.
Silverfield went 8-4 with a huge rebuild last year. It’s the way it is. Every year the coach will practically recruit a new team from the portal.
Again, I’m not against the guy at all. I just think he’s just an average hire and in no way the “splash hire” that Ed Scott mentioned. I’d call it about a push between Huff and Silverfield. Time will tell.
Whatever? Nice way to avoid owning that you couldn't be more wrong. At least Huff beat Notre Dame in South Bend when the Irish were ranked #8 in the country. For someone who claims to be not against the guy you sure are doing some impressive mental gymnastics to portray him in the worst light possible.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 05:02 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,074
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 05:02 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:57 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:12 PM)msu35 Wrote: I don't recall Silverfield winning the conference championship, let alone even qualifying for the game. Did Silverfield take over a 1-win team, making them bowl eligible his first year on the job, or did he immediately regress after inheriting a championship team that won the conference and made a NY6 bowl the year prior?
Yeah, looks exactly like Silverfield.
Whatever. Similar overall record. Terrible against teams over .500.
Some high points too. A conference championship, albeit the Sun Belt, is an accomplishment. Turning USM around was noteworthy too, although he did bring a bunch of his Marshall players with him.
Silverfield went 8-4 with a huge rebuild last year. It’s the way it is. Every year the coach will practically recruit a new team from the portal.
Again, I’m not against the guy at all. I just think he’s just an average hire and in no way the “splash hire” that Ed Scott mentioned. I’d call it about a push between Huff and Silverfield. Time will tell.
Whatever? Nice way to avoid owning that you couldn't be more wrong. At least Huff beat Notre Dame in South Bend when the Irish were ranked #8 in the country. For someone who claims to be not against the guy you sure are doing some impressive mental gymnastics to portray him in the worst light possible.
Simple facts. He’s done some noteworthy things: SBC champs, beat ND, and turned around USM. I’ll certainly give him credit for that.
He’s done some average things too. Very Silverfield(ish). .610 winning percentage, and an awful percentage against teams with winning records. I find him an average hire. Ed Scott promised a “splash hire”. Is Huff that? Are these not facts?
Time will be the judge here. I think he’ll do pretty good, just like Silverfield (who I didn’t want to fire). Maybe he’ll do better, I hope that’s the case.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 05:24 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,743
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2237
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 05:24 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 05:02 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:57 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:12 PM)msu35 Wrote: I don't recall Silverfield winning the conference championship, let alone even qualifying for the game. Did Silverfield take over a 1-win team, making them bowl eligible his first year on the job, or did he immediately regress after inheriting a championship team that won the conference and made a NY6 bowl the year prior?
Yeah, looks exactly like Silverfield.
Whatever. Similar overall record. Terrible against teams over .500.
Some high points too. A conference championship, albeit the Sun Belt, is an accomplishment. Turning USM around was noteworthy too, although he did bring a bunch of his Marshall players with him.
Silverfield went 8-4 with a huge rebuild last year. It’s the way it is. Every year the coach will practically recruit a new team from the portal.
Again, I’m not against the guy at all. I just think he’s just an average hire and in no way the “splash hire” that Ed Scott mentioned. I’d call it about a push between Huff and Silverfield. Time will tell.
Whatever? Nice way to avoid owning that you couldn't be more wrong. At least Huff beat Notre Dame in South Bend when the Irish were ranked #8 in the country. For someone who claims to be not against the guy you sure are doing some impressive mental gymnastics to portray him in the worst light possible.
Simple facts. He’s done some noteworthy things: SBC champs, beat ND, and turned around USM. I’ll certainly give him credit for that.
He’s done some average things too. Very Silverfield(ish). .610 winning percentage, and an awful percentage against teams with winning records. I find him an average hire. Ed Scott promised a “splash hire”. Is Huff that? Are these not facts?
Time will be the judge here. I think he’ll do pretty good, just like Silverfield (who I didn’t want to fire). Maybe he’ll do better, I hope that’s the case.
Do you realize how stupid that criteria is? Do you realize that 30 of Sumrall's 43 wins were against teams that were .500 or less? How about those facts?
|
|
| 12-09-2025 05:33 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,074
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 05:33 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 05:24 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 05:02 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:57 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:12 PM)msu35 Wrote: I don't recall Silverfield winning the conference championship, let alone even qualifying for the game. Did Silverfield take over a 1-win team, making them bowl eligible his first year on the job, or did he immediately regress after inheriting a championship team that won the conference and made a NY6 bowl the year prior?
Yeah, looks exactly like Silverfield.
Whatever. Similar overall record. Terrible against teams over .500.
Some high points too. A conference championship, albeit the Sun Belt, is an accomplishment. Turning USM around was noteworthy too, although he did bring a bunch of his Marshall players with him.
Silverfield went 8-4 with a huge rebuild last year. It’s the way it is. Every year the coach will practically recruit a new team from the portal.
Again, I’m not against the guy at all. I just think he’s just an average hire and in no way the “splash hire” that Ed Scott mentioned. I’d call it about a push between Huff and Silverfield. Time will tell.
Whatever? Nice way to avoid owning that you couldn't be more wrong. At least Huff beat Notre Dame in South Bend when the Irish were ranked #8 in the country. For someone who claims to be not against the guy you sure are doing some impressive mental gymnastics to portray him in the worst light possible.
Simple facts. He’s done some noteworthy things: SBC champs, beat ND, and turned around USM. I’ll certainly give him credit for that.
He’s done some average things too. Very Silverfield(ish). .610 winning percentage, and an awful percentage against teams with winning records. I find him an average hire. Ed Scott promised a “splash hire”. Is Huff that? Are these not facts?
Time will be the judge here. I think he’ll do pretty good, just like Silverfield (who I didn’t want to fire). Maybe he’ll do better, I hope that’s the case.
Do you realize how stupid that criteria is? Do you realize that 30 of Sumrall's 43 wins were against teams that were .500 or less? How about those facts?
I don’t mention Sumrall in this.
So, we don’t care that he has a poor w/l percentage against teams with winning records? Wasn’t this a knock on Silverfield that he couldn’t beat good teams? Stupid criteria? Lol
|
|
| 12-09-2025 06:03 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,743
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2237
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 06:03 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: I don’t mention Sumrall in this.
So, we don’t care that he has a poor w/l percentage against teams with winning records? Wasn’t this a knock on Silverfield that he couldn’t beat good teams? Stupid criteria? Lol
Since you seem to be struggling with the totality of the exchange, allow me to clarify. I brought up Sumrall (both a SBC and AAC coach) to prove that the criteria you used to judge Huff is faulty. You called him "Silverfield-ish" because of his poor record against winning teams. If you haven't figured it out yet, I basically showed you that a 3x champion (Sumrall) built 70% of his wins against teams without winning records.
You want facts? The fact is that Huff won a conference championship and beat #8 Notre Dame on the road. Unlike Silverfield, Huff took his programs and made them better. Silverfield has never accomplished anything approaching this. Backpedal all you want. Instead of manning up and owning your error, you're going to double down which is your standard tactic. The bottom line is that Huff has demonstrated a higher proven ceiling and the debate is over.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 06:38 PM by msu35.)
|
|
| 12-09-2025 06:31 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,074
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 06:31 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 06:03 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: I don’t mention Sumrall in this.
So, we don’t care that he has a poor w/l percentage against teams with winning records? Wasn’t this a knock on Silverfield that he couldn’t beat good teams? Stupid criteria? Lol
Since you seem to be struggling with the totality of the exchange, allow me to clarify. I brought up Sumrall (both a SBC and AAC coach) to prove that the criteria you used to judge Huff is faulty. You called him "Silverfield-ish" because of his poor record against winning teams. If you haven't figured it out yet, I basically showed you that a 3x champion (Sumrall) built 70% of his wins against teams without winning records.
You want facts? The fact is that Huff won a conference championship and beat #8 Notre Dame on the road. Unlike Silverfield, Huff took his programs and made them better. Silverfield has never accomplished anything approaching this. Backpedal all you want. Instead of manning up and owning your error, you're going to double down which is your standard tactic. The bottom line is that Huff has demonstrated a higher proven ceiling and the debate is over.
I’m not backpedaling at all. He has a poor record playing against winning teams, much like our last coach. Facts. Is it true or not?
I’ve acknowledged some of his accomplishments too.
Overall, an uninspired hire. Our AD mentioned a “splash hire”. This isn’t one.
Again, decent hire, but not great by any means. I expect Silverfield type success. We’ll see if he does better.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 06:54 PM |
|
msu35
Observing Reality

Posts: 21,743
Joined: Dec 2021
Reputation: 2237
I Root For: Truffles
Location: Tennessee
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 06:54 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: I’m not backpedaling at all. He has a poor record playing against winning teams, much like our last coach. Facts. Is it true or not?
I’ve acknowledged some of his accomplishments too.
Overall, an uninspired hire. Our AD mentioned a “splash hire”. This isn’t one.
Again, decent hire, but not great by any means. I expect Silverfield type success. We’ll see if he does better.
None of them have winning records against teams with winning records. This includes Silverfield, Huff, Golesh, and Sumrall. Might as well knock them down a peg because they all breathe oxygen too. Sheesh.
(This post was last modified: 12-09-2025 07:20 PM by msu35.)
|
|
| 12-09-2025 07:15 PM |
|
Tiger87
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,723
Joined: Jan 2012
Reputation: 1743
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW
(12-09-2025 04:12 PM)msu35 Wrote: (12-09-2025 04:06 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Oh, I’d take Hartline in a second. Some risk but could be spectacular. Not even close.
I’m not against Huff, but dig deeper and it looks like Silverfield. 39-25 (.610) overall record. He had 2 decent seasons at Marshall 2022 (9-4) and 2024 (10-3). The rest around .500. His record against winning teams is poor. Again, looks like Silverfield.
I don't recall Silverfield winning the conference championship, let alone even qualifying for the game. Did Silverfield take over a 1-win team, making them bowl eligible his first year on the job, or did he immediately regress after inheriting a championship team that won the conference and made a NY6 bowl the year prior?
Yeah, looks exactly like Silverfield.
It's a weak argument to try to support an agenda.
No consideration for the state of the programs taken over. No admittance of the conference championship. Says "the rest" when talking about 2 seasons while dismissing the other 3.
Just wants to talk wins and losses without context - the same way Ryan apologists wanted to do when touting his winning records.
|
|
| 12-09-2025 10:19 PM |
|