![]() |
|
2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html) +---- Forum: Members (/forum-401.html) +----- Forum: MemphisTigers.org (/forum-446.html) +------ Forum: Dockery-Finch Memorial Tiger Sports Forum (/forum-499.html) +------ Thread: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW (/thread-1021669.html) |
2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - msu35 - 12-08-2025 04:05 PM . ** THE 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW ** This review provides a comprehensive evaluation of the 2025 Head Coaching Hires, focusing on **CEO Stability** (organizational leadership and resilience), **Structural Integrity** (program foundation and cultural discipline), and **Tactical Completeness** (in-game and scheme adaptability). The grades reflect the risk profile and long-term viability of each hire. --- ### #1. Charles Huff (Memphis) | Grade: *A*
--- ### #2. Jon Sumrall (Florida, SEC) | Grade: *B+*
--- ### #3. Jason Candle (UConn) | Grade: *B*
--- ### #4. Jerry Mack (Kennesaw State) | Grade: *B-*
--- ### #5. Ryan Silverfield (Arkansas, SEC) | Grade: *C*
--- ### #6. Eric Morris (Oklahoma State, P4) | Grade: *C-*
--- ### #7. Alex Mortensen (UAB) | Grade: *D+*
--- ### #8. Neal Brown (North Texas) | Grade: *D*
--- ### #9. Billy Napier (JMU) | Grade: *D*
--- ### #10. Alex Golesh (Auburn, SEC) | Grade: *D-*
--- ### #11. Brian Hartline (South Florida) | Grade: *D-*
--- ### #12. Will Hall (Tulane) | Grade: *F* [Worst Hire]
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - Claw - 12-08-2025 04:13 PM Source??? RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - shere khan - 12-08-2025 04:19 PM ![]() We will be undefeated next year! We got the bestest coach in the nation!
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - memtiger1987 - 12-08-2025 04:52 PM Time will tell. RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - TigerinFL - 12-08-2025 05:11 PM this needs to be posted as a sticky note at the top of the page. let's see how well it ages. 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - tnzazz - 12-08-2025 05:38 PM Where is this from? Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - bbqtiger - 12-08-2025 05:42 PM I am curious as to the source as well. MSU35, did you do this rating? If not, where did you get it? Thanks. RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - former guest - 12-08-2025 05:54 PM Why would Jerry Mack be in this list? He was already the coach at KSU, wasn't he? I googled the title of the thread and the 1st hit was this thread. No other hit had close to the same ratings of the hirings as this. I think it is an opinion piece - not that there is anything wrong with that..... RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - shere khan - 12-08-2025 06:03 PM (12-08-2025 04:52 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Time will tell. Nah. Been told here. #1 coach in nation, this thread. Experts have spoken Championship next year!
RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - k2tigers - 12-08-2025 06:19 PM (12-08-2025 05:42 PM)bbqtiger Wrote: I am curious as to the source as well. MSU35, did you do this rating? If not, where did you get it? Seriously? RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - memtiger1987 - 12-08-2025 06:21 PM (12-08-2025 06:03 PM)shere khan Wrote:(12-08-2025 04:52 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Time will tell. lol. I’m kind of over it, Huffs the guy and I’ll support him until he gives me reason not to. Just disappointed we didn’t aim higher. Oh well, time to move forward. He can make us feel better with some great signings soon… RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - UOFMGLENN - 12-08-2025 06:25 PM (12-08-2025 05:54 PM)former guest Wrote: Why would Jerry Mack be in this list? He was already the coach at KSU, wasn't he? First thing I noticed. I thought wow hey , then I saw this and it made me doubt the brain of the writer and legitimacy of the article. RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - roachman48 - 12-08-2025 06:31 PM My 3 guesses at who wrote this evaluation- 1 Coach Huff 2 Our AD 3 Some Silverfield hater RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - shere khan - 12-08-2025 07:35 PM (12-08-2025 06:31 PM)roachman48 Wrote: My 3 guesses at who wrote this evaluation- 4. GIGO AI RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - Herff Tiger - 12-08-2025 07:38 PM (12-08-2025 06:21 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: I’ll support him until he gives me reason not to. I suspect the several posters saying that will not require much of a reason. (12-08-2025 06:21 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: Just disappointed we didn’t aim higher. How do you know that? Your disappointment is based on some fantasy of yours. There's probably some "-osis" for that. And it's probably already the beginning for your "reason" to not support him. 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - aardWolf - 12-08-2025 08:34 PM It is certainly an AI, but not sure which one. My guess is ChatGPT or Grok. RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - memtiger1987 - 12-08-2025 08:57 PM (12-08-2025 07:38 PM)Herff Tiger Wrote:(12-08-2025 06:21 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: I’ll support him until he gives me reason not to. You’re a weird dude. It’s just an uninspiring hire. Typical Memphis. RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - murphster - 12-08-2025 08:59 PM (12-08-2025 08:34 PM)aardWolf Wrote: It is certainly an AI, but not sure which one. My guess is ChatGPT or Grok. Agreed... none the less good to see positive feedback. RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - TIGERCITY - 12-08-2025 09:42 PM (12-08-2025 08:34 PM)aardWolf Wrote: It is certainly an AI, but not sure which one. My guess is ChatGPT or Grok. Probably Grok. A lot of the AIs have guardrails that prevent over harsh judgements (like F grades). RE: 2025 COACHING HIRES: ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW - TIGERCITY - 12-08-2025 09:54 PM From gemini 3 pro The 2025-26 coaching carousel has been one of the most volatile in recent memory, with massive movement across the Power 4 and the American Conference. Below are the grades for the major head coaching hires made for the requested conferences as of December 8, 2025. SEC The SEC saw historic turnover with heavyweights LSU, Florida, and Auburn all making moves. LSU: Lane Kiffin (A+) The Move: Hired away from Ole Miss. The Verdict: The absolute winner of the cycle. Kiffin is the premier offensive mind in the sport and fits the "win-at-all-costs" culture of Baton Rouge perfectly. LSU wanted a splash to replace Brian Kelly, and they got the biggest one possible. Florida: Jon Sumrall (A) The Move: Hired from Tulane. The Verdict: A smart, tactical hire. Sumrall has been a rising star who understands the SEC footprint intimately (former Kentucky/Ole Miss assistant) and dominated the G5 level. He brings a discipline and defensive edge that Florida has desperately lacked. Auburn: Alex Golesh (B+) The Move: Hired from South Florida. The Verdict: Auburn craves offensive identity, and Golesh (the architect of the uber-fast Tennessee offense of 2022) brings exactly that. It’s a high-upside play, though he lacks the long-term head coaching resume of Kiffin or Sumrall. Ole Miss: Pete Golding (B-) The Move: Promoted from Defensive Coordinator. The Verdict: Promoting the coordinator is often a "safe" move that maintains continuity but rarely elevates the program (see: Oregon promoting Mario Cristobal vs. Mark Helfrich). Golding is an elite recruiter, but learning to be a CEO in the SEC West is a brutal trial by fire. Kentucky: Will Stein (B) The Move: Hired from Oregon (OC). The Verdict: A necessary pivot. After years of the Mark Stoops defensive grinder mindset, Kentucky is swinging for offensive modernization. Stein is a bright young mind, but the SEC is a tough place for a first-time head coach. Arkansas: Ryan Silverfield (C+) The Move: Hired from Memphis. The Verdict: Silverfield was consistent at Memphis, but Arkansas is a pressure cooker. This feels like a "safe" hire rather than a transformative one. Big Ten A stunning cycle for the Big Ten, highlighted by Penn State poaching a Big 12 stalwart. Penn State: Matt Campbell (A) The Move: Hired from Iowa State. The Verdict: Campbell has been the "next big thing" for five years; he finally jumped. His blue-collar, development-heavy style is a perfect cultural match for State College. He consistently did more with less at Iowa State, suggesting he could be a giant-killer with Penn State's resources. UCLA: Bob Chesney (B) The Move: Hired from James Madison. The Verdict: Chesney is a winner who has succeeded at every level (Assumption, Holy Cross, JMU). He is an excellent culture builder, which UCLA desperately needs, though he lacks West Coast ties. Big 12 The league continues to lean into offensive innovation with its new hires. Oklahoma State: Eric Morris (B+) The Move: Hired from North Texas. The Verdict: Morris is a Mike Leach disciple who understands the "Air Raid" DNA of the Big 12. Replacing a legend like Mike Gundy is impossible, so hiring a schemer who can put up points immediately is the right strategy. Kansas State: Collin Klein (A-) The Move: Promoted from Offensive Coordinator. The Verdict: The prodigal son returns to the throne. Klein is a K-State legend who understands the program's unique "development u" identity better than anyone. Continuity here is key after Klieman's retirement. Iowa State: Jimmy Rogers (B-) The Move: Hired from South Dakota State. The Verdict: Rogers built a dynasty at the FCS level with SDSU. It fits the Iowa State model (hiring successful lower-division coaches), but the jump from FCS to the Big 12 is steeper than ever. ACC The ACC pulled off the most shocking coup of the offseason Virginia Tech: James Franklin (A+) The Move: Hired from Penn State. The Verdict: A massive flex for the Hokies. Franklin is an elite recruiter with strong ties to the DMV (DC/MD/VA) region. Leaving a Big Ten power for Virginia Tech is rare, but Franklin’s ceiling at VT (where the path to the playoff is easier) is arguably higher. Stanford: Tavita Pritchard © The Move: Hired from within/NFL (Commanders QB coach). The Verdict: Pritchard loves Stanford, but the program is in a deep hole. Hiring a "Stanford Man" feels good nostalgically but might not bring the ruthless modernization the program needs to survive in the ACC. Cal: Tosh Lupoi (C+) The Move: Hired from Oregon (DC). The Verdict: Lupoi is arguably the best recruiter in the country, but his track record as a game manager and tactician is mixed. This is a "boom or bust" hire—he will get talent to Berkeley, but can he coach it? American Athletic Conference (AAC) The AAC continues to be a feeder league, raiding other staffs for high-upside coordinators. South Florida: Brian Hartline (B) The Move: Hired from Ohio State (OC). The Verdict: Hartline is an elite recruiter and developer of talent (WRs specifically). He has zero head coaching experience, making this a risky but exciting swing for a USF program with high potential. Memphis: Charles Huff (B) The Move: Hired from Marshall. The Verdict: Huff is a solid, proven G5 coach who recruits well. He keeps the floor high for Memphis, ensuring they stay in the mix for the conference title. Tulane: Will Hall (D) The Move: Hired (formerly of Southern Miss). The Verdict: A head-scratcher. Hall struggled mightily at Southern Miss. Tulane has been a premier G5 job recently (Fritz, Sumrall); hiring a coach who was recently fired by a peer program is a significant step backward. North Texas: Neal Brown (C+) The Move: Hired (formerly of West Virginia). The Verdict: A classic "retread" hire. Brown is a competent coach who knows the state of Texas, but his tenure at WVU was uninspiring. He raises the floor but lowers the ceiling. Charlotte: Tim Albin © The Move: Hired from Ohio. The Verdict: Albin is a solid coach, but his success at Ohio was largely maintaining Frank Solich's system. It’s unclear if his style translates to the Charlotte market. |