MemTigers1998
Hall of Famer

Posts: 20,663
Joined: May 2017
Reputation: 2757
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
Eventually, it’s gonna be 10 SEC and B10 teams and 2 from ND, ACC and B12. That will be your 12 every year. Then they set their sights on March madness so they can have all teams from the 4 power conferences and the Big East (that’s about 78-80 or so teams)
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:30 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:32 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:14 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: (12-07-2025 03:01 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 02:54 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote: (12-07-2025 02:45 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote: There's going to be a point in a few years where a conference is going to pull a team like Alabama out of the conference championship game in favor of Vanderbilt or Texas. I agree with Herbstreit yesterday on College Gameday. They do need to get rid of the weekly Tuesday night show. All it is used for is for entertainment.
ACC needs to decide on Notre Dame. Are they part of the ACC or not. Notre Dame needs to join the ACC. If they are not, then I will dump Notre Dame out of the ACC for Olympic sports and then potentially replace them for a team that can add value (not really sure who that is). But Notre Dame has done well in Women's basketball, but just really average in all of their other sports. Notre Dame needs to be in the ACC in all sports.
ACC also needs to get their tiebreaker stuff figured out. Miami needs to be in the ACC Championship, and if they win, we won't be discussing Notre Dame along with Alabama. It was a great crowd in Arlington, Texas, Atlanta, and Indianapolis for their respected conference championship games, but it was a disappointment for the ACC crowd in Charlotte. I know it's an evening game outdoors, but still a big disappointment.
We're going to 16 teams some point down the road. It's a matter of if, not when. But I'm okay with Notre Dame being left out. With that being said, the ACC has a major problem.
The whole conference tiebreaker issue is because NONE of the conferences play a round robin schedule…
Most of this drama could have been avoided if the ACC had a different tiebreaker. If they just went with the highest ranked team as a tiebreaker, you’d have Miami-UVA play for the spot. The committee should have left them out for spite.
Not too sympathetic for ND either. Join a conference and play for the title. Plus, they played a weak schedule anyway.
Notre Dame played 4 ranked teams this season. Lost the first 2, beat the 2nd two.
Their strength of schedule is comparable to Miami's.
Bama losing their 3rd game shoulda knocked them out of the playoffs. Notre Dame has a legit gripe.
I don’t know what to tell you. They just weren’t willing to punish Alabama for playing in the Championship game while others couldn’t get in one. That left Miami and ND who had almost identical metrics. The week 1 head to head win was the tiebreaker.
I’ll say that ND looked to be better than Miami for most of the season. They just couldn’t pick ND over Miami when they lost the head to head. But neither team has near the metrics as Alabama.
ND chooses to be independent. They would have won the ACC this year and they could have played UVA for the title. Oh well! They’ll eventually join the B1G….
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:37 PM |
|
GoDownSwinging
Special Teams

Posts: 998
Joined: Mar 2019
Reputation: 65
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:14 PM)EarthBoundMisfit Wrote: (12-07-2025 03:01 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 02:54 PM)DDrum1961 Wrote: (12-07-2025 02:45 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote: There's going to be a point in a few years where a conference is going to pull a team like Alabama out of the conference championship game in favor of Vanderbilt or Texas. I agree with Herbstreit yesterday on College Gameday. They do need to get rid of the weekly Tuesday night show. All it is used for is for entertainment.
ACC needs to decide on Notre Dame. Are they part of the ACC or not. Notre Dame needs to join the ACC. If they are not, then I will dump Notre Dame out of the ACC for Olympic sports and then potentially replace them for a team that can add value (not really sure who that is). But Notre Dame has done well in Women's basketball, but just really average in all of their other sports. Notre Dame needs to be in the ACC in all sports.
ACC also needs to get their tiebreaker stuff figured out. Miami needs to be in the ACC Championship, and if they win, we won't be discussing Notre Dame along with Alabama. It was a great crowd in Arlington, Texas, Atlanta, and Indianapolis for their respected conference championship games, but it was a disappointment for the ACC crowd in Charlotte. I know it's an evening game outdoors, but still a big disappointment.
We're going to 16 teams some point down the road. It's a matter of if, not when. But I'm okay with Notre Dame being left out. With that being said, the ACC has a major problem.
The whole conference tiebreaker issue is because NONE of the conferences play a round robin schedule…
Most of this drama could have been avoided if the ACC had a different tiebreaker. If they just went with the highest ranked team as a tiebreaker, you’d have Miami-UVA play for the spot. The committee should have left them out for spite.
Not too sympathetic for ND either. Join a conference and play for the title. Plus, they played a weak schedule anyway.
Notre Dame played 4 ranked teams this season. Lost the first 2, beat the 2nd two.
Their strength of schedule is comparable to Miami's.
Bama losing their 3rd game shoulda knocked them out of the playoffs. Notre Dame has a legit gripe.
I disagree. I understand Alabama hasn't looked good in a while and they played bad yesterday to Georgia, but if you penalized Alabama for losing a conference championship game while other teams aren't playing, then go ahead and get rid of the conference championships.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:38 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:41 PM |
|
GermantownTiger
Don't Tread On Me!

Posts: 13,822
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 483
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location: G'town
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 04:07 PM)TigerBlue4Ever Wrote: (12-07-2025 01:07 PM)shere khan Wrote: Thanks for the nothin Ruin
Huff you are on the clock

The fool had it in his hands; our path was clear-cut and should have been fairly easy.
One our starting QB was badly hobbled along with RS interviewing for his next gig, the playoff dreams were pretty much cut off at the knees.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:44 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,189
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:46 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
Exactly it’s collusion. It's not about who earns it—it's about who gets denied a chance to earn it. Refusing schedules, controlling polls, it's all gatekeeping. If you limit their games, how do they ever get the resume to compete? Plus Congress would actually get involved. If a senator or House member from a G5-heavy state like West Virginia or Louisiana starts pushing bills to mandate inclusivity—or block any NCAA antitrust carve-outs—suddenly the power brokers lose their biggest safety net.
(This post was last modified: 12-07-2025 05:57 PM by BigTigerMike.)
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:56 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
C’mon. They can (and will) change the rules. You can’t sue for changing the format to include the highest rated teams. That lawsuit will get flushed fast. Cory B Trotz won’t even take that case.
These kind of things will just expedite the inevitable break between P4 and G5(6).
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:58 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:56 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
Exactly it’s collusion. It's not about who earns it—it's about who gets denied a chance to earn it. Refusing schedules, controlling polls, it's all gatekeeping. If you limit their games, how do they ever get the resume to compete? Plus Congress would actually get involved. If a senator or House member from a G5-heavy state like West Virginia or Louisiana starts pushing bills to mandate inclusivity—or block any NCAA antitrust carve-outs—suddenly the power brokers lose their biggest safety net.
Oh boy.. lol
|
|
| 12-07-2025 05:59 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:58 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
C’mon. They can (and will) change the rules. You can’t sue for changing the format to include the highest rated teams. That lawsuit will get flushed fast. Cory B Trotz won’t even take that case.
These kind of things will just expedite the inevitable break between P4 and G5(6).
Yeah anti-trust lawsuits could speed up a split to a Power 4 super league, it may be the G5's nightmare but not some easy win for the big boys — Because if the Power 4 tries to split and make their own league, they’re still subject to antitrust scrutiny. They can’t just say, We have better teams, so we get all the money. If they lock out G5 teams, those schools can still sue, and the government could step in. Plus, if ESPN and other broadcasters help enforce the split, they could face claims too.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:10 PM |
|
tnzazz
Hall of Famer

Posts: 11,002
Joined: Apr 2009
Reputation: 437
I Root For: Memphis Tigers!
Location: Franklin, TN
|
2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
Fuq’em…the ACC did this to themselves. They have divisions and it backfired spectacularly.
What’s funny is that the ACC and B12 think they matter. They don’t. Anyone outside of the SEC and B10 are at the kids table. Some are just closer to Grandma.
I hope JM and Tulane don’t blow this opportunity like Liberty.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:11 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 06:10 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:58 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
C’mon. They can (and will) change the rules. You can’t sue for changing the format to include the highest rated teams. That lawsuit will get flushed fast. Cory B Trotz won’t even take that case.
These kind of things will just expedite the inevitable break between P4 and G5(6).
Yeah anti-trust lawsuits could speed up a split to a Power 4 super league, it may be the G5's nightmare but not some easy win for the big boys — Because if the Power 4 tries to split and make their own league, they’re still subject to antitrust scrutiny. They can’t just say, We have better teams, so we get all the money. If they lock out G5 teams, those schools can still sue, and the government could step in. Plus, if ESPN and other broadcasters help enforce the split, they could face claims too.
There’s no case there. They don’t have to offer participation trophies to conference champions that have lower rankings than other teams. They’ll go to highest ranked, and why shouldn’t they? The best G5 has already lost by 5 TDs against the team they’ll play in the CFP. Again the best deal for us is going to 16 teams.
Congress could care less about this stuff. They can’t even agree to a budget.
(This post was last modified: 12-07-2025 06:16 PM by memtiger1987.)
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:15 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 06:15 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 06:10 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:58 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
C’mon. They can (and will) change the rules. You can’t sue for changing the format to include the highest rated teams. That lawsuit will get flushed fast. Cory B Trotz won’t even take that case.
These kind of things will just expedite the inevitable break between P4 and G5(6).
Yeah anti-trust lawsuits could speed up a split to a Power 4 super league, it may be the G5's nightmare but not some easy win for the big boys — Because if the Power 4 tries to split and make their own league, they’re still subject to antitrust scrutiny. They can’t just say, We have better teams, so we get all the money. If they lock out G5 teams, those schools can still sue, and the government could step in. Plus, if ESPN and other broadcasters help enforce the split, they could face claims too.
There’s no case there. They don’t have to offer participation trophies to conference champions that have lower rankings than other teams. They’ll go to highest ranked, and why shouldn’t they? The best G5 has already lost by 5 TDs against the team they’ll play in the CFP. Again the best deal for us is going to 16 teams.
Congress could care less about this stuff. They can’t even agree to a budget.
It's not about a merit system argument; it's a potential closed system argument. And yeah, Tulane lost by a lot once, but that doesn't justify excluding them forever.
Congress might fight over budgets, but when billions in TV money are at stake, and local economies too, they'll step in. The NCAA's already been sued into oblivion once. The big boys think they're safe, but history says they're not. It’s exclusion dressed up as excellence.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:39 PM |
|
roachman48
Heisman

Posts: 7,664
Joined: Jul 2004
Reputation: 189
I Root For:
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
If the CFP is anti- G5, why did they invite 2 G5 teams?
They were only required to invite 1.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:47 PM |
|
UofMstateU
Legend

Posts: 46,189
Joined: Dec 2009
Reputation: 4536
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 05:58 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:41 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
There’s no anti-trust. They’ll just go off of rankings and it will essentially be mostly B1G and SEC teams. Hate to say it, but they just have the best teams. The ACC and B12 are weak overall (with some exceptions). Texas Tech looks legit and Miami could scare some folks.
Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
C’mon. They can (and will) change the rules. You can’t sue for changing the format to include the highest rated teams. That lawsuit will get flushed fast. Cory B Trotz won’t even take that case.
These kind of things will just expedite the inevitable break between P4 and G5(6).
Sure you can, because the ranking is subjective. If you collude to make it harder to be impressive in the polls, that will fall under anti-trust.
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:53 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 06:39 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-07-2025 06:15 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 06:10 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:58 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:46 PM)UofMstateU Wrote: Actually it would be. The P2/P4 has already said they arent going to schedule G5. If they do that AND rely on only the polls, its still anti-trust because you are refusing to allow teams to participate in games in which are needed to get ranked high enough to make the playoffs.
C’mon. They can (and will) change the rules. You can’t sue for changing the format to include the highest rated teams. That lawsuit will get flushed fast. Cory B Trotz won’t even take that case.
These kind of things will just expedite the inevitable break between P4 and G5(6).
Yeah anti-trust lawsuits could speed up a split to a Power 4 super league, it may be the G5's nightmare but not some easy win for the big boys — Because if the Power 4 tries to split and make their own league, they’re still subject to antitrust scrutiny. They can’t just say, We have better teams, so we get all the money. If they lock out G5 teams, those schools can still sue, and the government could step in. Plus, if ESPN and other broadcasters help enforce the split, they could face claims too.
There’s no case there. They don’t have to offer participation trophies to conference champions that have lower rankings than other teams. They’ll go to highest ranked, and why shouldn’t they? The best G5 has already lost by 5 TDs against the team they’ll play in the CFP. Again the best deal for us is going to 16 teams.
Congress could care less about this stuff. They can’t even agree to a budget.
It's not about a merit system argument; it's a potential closed system argument. And yeah, Tulane lost by a lot once, but that doesn't justify excluding them forever.
Congress might fight over budgets, but when billions in TV money are at stake, and local economies too, they'll step in. The NCAA's already been sued into oblivion once. The big boys think they're safe, but history says they're not. It’s exclusion dressed up as excellence.
They.don’t.care
It’s laughable. So you’re saying that basing CFP slots on merit alone is discriminatory?
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:53 PM |
|
BigTigerMike
Hall of Famer

Posts: 24,858
Joined: Nov 2007
Reputation: 1200
I Root For: Memphis Tigers
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 06:47 PM)roachman48 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
If the CFP is anti- G5, why did they invite 2 G5 teams?
They were only required to invite 1.
The ACC’s total dumpster fire this year meant their champ limped in with five losses, barely scraping by on tiebreakers and weak wins, so the committee had no choice but to slot in two G5 champs based on the rules like JMU and Tulane as the top-ranked ones - it’s a total fluke.
They’re tossing in those extra G5 invites to keep the appearance of inclusivity for now while they huddle up and strategize on how to pull the rug out in the future. The fools at ESPN are openly talking about it instead of shutting up for legal reasons (they’ll claim they were just giving their opinions). But the moment the ‘Big Boys’ try to make it permanent, those temporary concessions become damning evidence in court. It’s like putting lipstick on a pig and calling it progress.
(This post was last modified: 12-07-2025 06:58 PM by BigTigerMike.)
|
|
| 12-07-2025 06:56 PM |
|
memtiger1987
Heisman

Posts: 7,077
Joined: May 2010
Reputation: 370
I Root For: Memphis
Location:
|
RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 06:56 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: (12-07-2025 06:47 PM)roachman48 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
If the CFP is anti- G5, why did they invite 2 G5 teams?
They were only required to invite 1.
The ACC’s total dumpster fire this year meant their champ limped in with five losses, barely scraping by on tiebreakers and weak wins, so the committee had no choice but to slot in two G5 champs based on the rules like JMU and Tulane as the top-ranked ones - it’s a total fluke.
They’re tossing in those extra G5 invites to keep the appearance of inclusivity for now while they huddle up and strategize on how to pull the rug out in the future. The fools at ESPN are openly talking about it instead of shutting up for legal reasons (they’ll claim they were just giving their opinions). But the moment the ‘Big Boys’ try to make it permanent, those temporary concessions become damning evidence in court. It’s like putting lipstick on a pig and calling it progress.
You’re delusional if you think there’s a case here. If they simply choose by merit (ranking), you don’t get any fairer than that. And it’s a fact that no G5 would (or should) get in based on merit. The top G5 (Tulane) played Ole Miss (ranked 5th) and was absolutely drilled. No G5 has a a decent win.
If I were a team that lost out due to the current rules, I’d complain too.
But there is no court that will make them add a G5 that isn’t good enough to make it on their own accomplishments. They’re not saying you can’t get it, but you have to be good enough to be ranked in the top 12.
There will be rule changes after this season. Guaranteed. Maybe they’ll still allow 1 G5 a chance. Maybe they’ll go to 16 teams.
It’s not great for TV ratings to have such expected lopsided games. Tulane +17.5, JMU +21.5. How much more interest (viewing) would you have if ND and Texas were in instead of Tulane and JMU?
|
|
| 12-07-2025 07:55 PM |
|
tnzazz
Hall of Famer

Posts: 11,002
Joined: Apr 2009
Reputation: 437
I Root For: Memphis Tigers!
Location: Franklin, TN
|
2 Group of Five teams in CFP!
(12-07-2025 06:47 PM)roachman48 Wrote: (12-07-2025 05:32 PM)BigTigerMike Wrote: The point is NOT ONLY to try to remove G5 out of existence— No they won’t stop there — they eventually will try to remove ACC and Big12 after they take a few teams and have the Power 2. There’s going to be massive anti-trust lawsuits when G5 and the rest are told to boot it. You can't just say earn it if they never get a real shot to earn it. That's textbook antitrust.
If the CFP is anti- G5, why did they invite 2 G5 teams?
They were only required to invite 1.
Because if they didn’t invite the other than it would have looked beyond bad. 5 conference champions get access and the ACC screwed themselves. They didn’t want to do, but they had to do it.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
|
|
| 12-07-2025 08:03 PM |
|