CSNbbs
2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: Members (/forum-401.html)
+----- Forum: MemphisTigers.org (/forum-446.html)
+------ Forum: Dockery-Finch Memorial Tiger Sports Forum (/forum-499.html)
+------ Thread: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! (/thread-1021570.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6


2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - roachman48 - 12-07-2025 12:42 PM

Tulane and J Madison
Unbelievable!


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - MemTigers1998 - 12-07-2025 12:44 PM

Even better is they told ND to pound sand


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - MemTiger90 - 12-07-2025 12:52 PM

I don’t see this as a good thing. Both teams, especially JMU, are going to get their doors blown off. The CFP will make it priority #1 to eliminate the auto qualifier for the G5. Duke screwed the future of the G5, I’m afraid.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - memphistiger89 - 12-07-2025 01:01 PM

(12-07-2025 12:52 PM)MemTiger90 Wrote:  I don’t see this as a good thing. Both teams, especially JMU, are going to get their doors blown off. The CFP will make it priority #1 to eliminate the auto qualifier for the G5. Duke screwed the future of the G5, I’m afraid.

This. I’m sure the blowback from the networks and P4 fans will bring about an end to the auto qualifier sooner than later.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - BigTigerMike - 12-07-2025 01:05 PM

The blame on the G5 is an excuse. The problem lies with the ACC and its SHODDY conference, a supposedly “power 4.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - shere khan - 12-07-2025 01:07 PM

Thanks for the nothin Ruin

Huff you are on the clock

03-banghead


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - MemTigers1998 - 12-07-2025 01:16 PM

(12-07-2025 12:52 PM)MemTiger90 Wrote:  I don’t see this as a good thing. Both teams, especially JMU, are going to get their doors blown off. The CFP will make it priority #1 to eliminate the auto qualifier for the G5. Duke screwed the future of the G5, I’m afraid.

The espn studio crew is already lobbying for that


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - memtiger1987 - 12-07-2025 01:20 PM

(12-07-2025 01:16 PM)MemTigers1998 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 12:52 PM)MemTiger90 Wrote:  I don’t see this as a good thing. Both teams, especially JMU, are going to get their doors blown off. The CFP will make it priority #1 to eliminate the auto qualifier for the G5. Duke screwed the future of the G5, I’m afraid.

The espn studio crew is already lobbying for that

It’s gonna happen. While the ACC tiebreaker was a big issue too, the end result is they’ll tweak this again and the G5 will get cut out.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - Unionman76 - 12-07-2025 01:25 PM

why do they make alabama play games

just pencil them in

their record doesnt matter


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - memtiger1987 - 12-07-2025 01:29 PM

(12-07-2025 01:25 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  why do they make alabama play games

just pencil them in

their record doesnt matter

They don’t want to punish teams that play in their conference championships. Why even play if it’s gonna cost you a chance of getting dropped from the CFP? These games are big $$$ makers. Media, teams, communities where they play the games, etc.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - BigTigerMike - 12-07-2025 01:37 PM

They’re eventually are going to conference play-in games in #3 vs #6 —#4vs#5


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - Herff Tiger - 12-07-2025 01:37 PM

(12-07-2025 12:52 PM)MemTiger90 Wrote:  I don’t see this as a good thing. Both teams, especially JMU, are going to get their doors blown off. The CFP will make it priority #1 to eliminate the auto qualifier for the G5. Duke screwed the future of the G5, I’m afraid.

Yep.

And Tulane is going back to Oxford where they lost 45-10 early in the season. Maybe Misspissi won't kill 'em this time since they have the new HC.

We've got to hope they both can look like they belong. Tulane does, they've already beaten Northwestern & Duke, so the anti-G5 blabbers can shut up about them. If JMU can hold it to a decent deficit into the 3rd qtr, then if Oregon blows it out to a 4 score win, it won't seem so bad. I hope it's not 28-0 a few minutes into the 2nd qtr.

If Tulane wins, the blab will be "They should have had to play Miami or Notre Dame. If you can omit 13-0 FL St a few years ago because they lost the starting QB, you should omit 11-1 Misspissi because they lost their HC."


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - Unionman76 - 12-07-2025 01:39 PM

(12-07-2025 01:29 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:25 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  why do they make alabama play games

just pencil them in

their record doesnt matter

They don’t want to punish teams that play in their conference championships. Why even play if it’s gonna cost you a chance of getting dropped from the CFP? These games are big $$$ makers. Media, teams, communities where they play the games, etc.

they have in the past, multiple times


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - Unionman76 - 12-07-2025 01:40 PM

i like the fcs model, also used by all the other classifications

conference champions, and a few at large


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - memtiger1987 - 12-07-2025 01:48 PM

(12-07-2025 01:39 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:29 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:25 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  why do they make alabama play games

just pencil them in

their record doesnt matter

They don’t want to punish teams that play in their conference championships. Why even play if it’s gonna cost you a chance of getting dropped from the CFP? These games are big $$$ makers. Media, teams, communities where they play the games, etc.

they have in the past, multiple times

Examples?


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - Unionman76 - 12-07-2025 02:01 PM

(12-07-2025 01:48 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:39 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:29 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:25 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  why do they make alabama play games

just pencil them in

their record doesnt matter

They don’t want to punish teams that play in their conference championships. Why even play if it’s gonna cost you a chance of getting dropped from the CFP? These games are big $$$ makers. Media, teams, communities where they play the games, etc.

they have in the past, multiple times

Examples?

2017 Auburn: Dropped five spots after losing the SEC Championship rematch to Georgia, while 10-2 Alabama moved up into the playoff.
SMU (2024): Dropped two spots in the final rankings after losing the ACC Championship to Clemson, falling to the last at-large spot.
TCU (2014): Dropped from No. 3 to No. 6 in the first CFP year after losing their final game (Big 12 non-championship), allowing Florida State and Ohio State in.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - memtiger1987 - 12-07-2025 02:15 PM

(12-07-2025 02:01 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:48 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:39 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:29 PM)memtiger1987 Wrote:  
(12-07-2025 01:25 PM)Unionman76 Wrote:  why do they make alabama play games

just pencil them in

their record doesnt matter

They don’t want to punish teams that play in their conference championships. Why even play if it’s gonna cost you a chance of getting dropped from the CFP? These games are big $$$ makers. Media, teams, communities where they play the games, etc.

they have in the past, multiple times

Examples?

2017 Auburn: Dropped five spots after losing the SEC Championship rematch to Georgia, while 10-2 Alabama moved up into the playoff.
SMU (2024): Dropped two spots in the final rankings after losing the ACC Championship to Clemson, falling to the last at-large spot.
TCU (2014): Dropped from No. 3 to No. 6 in the first CFP year after losing their final game (Big 12 non-championship), allowing Florida State and Ohio State in.

These aren’t in the current format. SMU lost last year, but remained in. They just weren’t going to punish Alabama when multiple teams didn’t even make the championship game. Everyone has a gripe, and many are legitimate. But for the 3 that were on play, Miami, ND, and Alabama had solid arguments. In the end, they didn’t want to set the precedent to punish a team for playing in their conference championship game. That left them 2 teams, and Miami won the head to head. This is how I thought it would play out.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - GoDownSwinging - 12-07-2025 02:45 PM

There's going to be a point in a few years where a conference is going to pull a team like Alabama out of the conference championship game in favor of Vanderbilt or Texas. I agree with Herbstreit yesterday on College Gameday. They do need to get rid of the weekly Tuesday night show. All it is used for is for entertainment.

ACC needs to decide on Notre Dame. Are they part of the ACC or not. Notre Dame needs to join the ACC. If they are not, then I will dump Notre Dame out of the ACC for Olympic sports and then potentially replace them for a team that can add value (not really sure who that is). But Notre Dame has done well in Women's basketball, but just really average in all of their other sports. Notre Dame needs to be in the ACC in all sports.
ACC also needs to get their tiebreaker stuff figured out. Miami needs to be in the ACC Championship, and if they win, we won't be discussing Notre Dame along with Alabama. It was a great crowd in Arlington, Texas, Atlanta, and Indianapolis for their respected conference championship games, but it was a disappointment for the ACC crowd in Charlotte. I know it's an evening game outdoors, but still a big disappointment.
We're going to 16 teams some point down the road. It's a matter of if, not when. But I'm okay with Notre Dame being left out. With that being said, the ACC has a major problem.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - UofMstateU - 12-07-2025 02:51 PM

Notre Dame is about to go thermonuclear on the ACC. Grab your popcorn.


RE: 2 Group of Five teams in CFP! - DDrum1961 - 12-07-2025 02:54 PM

(12-07-2025 02:45 PM)GoDownSwinging Wrote:  There's going to be a point in a few years where a conference is going to pull a team like Alabama out of the conference championship game in favor of Vanderbilt or Texas. I agree with Herbstreit yesterday on College Gameday. They do need to get rid of the weekly Tuesday night show. All it is used for is for entertainment.

ACC needs to decide on Notre Dame. Are they part of the ACC or not. Notre Dame needs to join the ACC. If they are not, then I will dump Notre Dame out of the ACC for Olympic sports and then potentially replace them for a team that can add value (not really sure who that is). But Notre Dame has done well in Women's basketball, but just really average in all of their other sports. Notre Dame needs to be in the ACC in all sports.
ACC also needs to get their tiebreaker stuff figured out. Miami needs to be in the ACC Championship, and if they win, we won't be discussing Notre Dame along with Alabama. It was a great crowd in Arlington, Texas, Atlanta, and Indianapolis for their respected conference championship games, but it was a disappointment for the ACC crowd in Charlotte. I know it's an evening game outdoors, but still a big disappointment.
We're going to 16 teams some point down the road. It's a matter of if, not when. But I'm okay with Notre Dame being left out. With that being said, the ACC has a major problem.

The whole conference tiebreaker issue is because NONE of the conferences play a round robin schedule…