https://www.sportingnews.com/us/ncaa-foo...f570fe7347
Why to expand-the author's opinion:
"...A year ago, the public concern over the presentation of at-large bids primarily involved whether a team with Indiana’s meager football history and relative absence of consequential victories could, at 11-1, be more deserving than a 9-3 Alabama that defeated No. 4 Georgia but managed to lose twice to unranked opponents. This seems almost quaint just 12 months later.
Now, with only two more weekends of football before the 2025 College Football Playoff field is arranged, we have eight remaining power conference teams with one or no losses, but 10 that have lost twice – and no concrete means of distinguishing which among them might be most deserving of positions in the field. So the members of the CFP selection committee have resorted to employing the laziest means of sorting the prospective entrants.
They’re guessing.
Which is why it’s already time – possibly past time, honestly -- to expand the CFP field to 16 teams, which would consist of five automatic qualification positions awarded to the five highest-ranked conference champions plus 11 at-large bids.
At that point, you’re not debating whether worthy teams would be excluded from the field. Like with NCAA March Madness, the discussion would be which of the less deserving teams would fill the final spot in the field....
It is not entirely the fault of the CFP committee they’ve come to rely so heavily this season on guesswork in the weekly presentation of its top 25. There has been precious little intersection among the members of different major conferences for years, an issue that likely will abate as the SEC and ACC join the Big 12 in requiring members to play at least one Power 4 opponent in a non-conference game.
There also is the matter of greater balance in the sport, catalyzed by the more even distribution of talent that resulted when athletes learned they could make more money playing in a less established program than sitting on the bench at a major power.
It is the fault of the committee members that they’re guessing so haphazardly. The most obvious example of this is the placement of Notre Dame and its two-loss record as the No. 9 team in the rankings, safely in the field were it to be determined today, well ahead of such two-loss teams as Vanderbilt, Michigan and, most notably, No. 13 Miami...."