schmolik
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
|
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(11-02-2025 08:06 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (11-02-2025 07:38 PM)Lurker Above Wrote: (11-01-2025 12:28 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (11-01-2025 09:42 AM)JRsec Wrote: (11-01-2025 09:22 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: The ratings for the Big Ten are actually up this year. This is the context that I think a lot of people are either missing or ignoring. It’s just that the SEC is waaaaay up even further. And the SEC *should* be way up: they have been able to offer a better game with respect to playoff implications in nearly every time slot. The fact that the ratings for the Big Ten are still up this year despite having inferior games compared to the last couple of seasons belies that argument that you have that there is any structural problem. This season is actually evidence that the Big Ten floor is quite high. They’re just getting compared to an SEC season where they’re reaching their ceiling in terms of the sheer number of top 15 vs. top 15 matchups (all of which are big playoff implication games).
The structural part is not the Big Ten or its ability to draw viewers Frank. The structural part is in the 3-party contract and the diverse interests of the parties you contracted with. ABC has obvious advantages in working with ESPN even though ABC is not officially still under the same Disney umbrella. I believe when the SEC contract is finally out in the open that we will find that ABC is the T1 rights holder, that ESPN has kept T2 and T3 rights and likely for the same revenue plus what Texas and Oklahoma add for the SECN, and that where the SEC makes its money will be with ABC. We'll see but that seems to account for the stances of what may have led to what I discounted initially as poor reporting.
Anyway my point is that it is the "structure of rights distribution" between your three parties that prevents FOX from holding an audience all day on Saturday, where ABC has no such problem with ESPN. And yes part of that advantage is a greater number of higher content games for the SEC, but part of it is also that FOX can't air what would be the #1 and #2 Big Ten games and hold their audience for the #4 or #5 game while one of the networks is showing the #3. ABC is doing that and that feature of their contract with the SEC is holding the audience for that third game which is still a decent matchup, but which shouldn't be outdrawing one of the Big Ten's top 3. The structural issue is not the Big Ten schools. It is in the division of the contracted rights.
I fundamentally and completely disagree about having at least 3 guaranteed OTA games per week on 3 major networks being a structural issue. The NFL has the *exact* same structure on Sundays and what we call an elite viewership game in college football (e.g. Michigan-Ohio State, SEC Championship Games, almost all CFP games) are what just a random non-marquee Sunday afternoon game on CBS or FOX gets. Every single other sports property with any value at all in the United States - the NBA, MLB, etc. - simply splits its best games among multiple media partners. The SEC deal with one single media partner is actually a total throwback and is more akin to the much weaker US sports properties in the US like MLS and F1 with soccer. Now, I’ll grant that ABC/ESPN are far superior platforms for casual sports fans than Apple TV, but without a doubt in my mind, if the SEC were able to go to the open market today, its TV deal would look way closer to the current Big Ten deal with multiple networks and (frankly more importantly) streamers than today’s SEC deal with a single media partner. This is a total red herring based on the college football bubble: if you are a valuable sports property in the US that wants to get anywhere near its market value, you *have* to involve multiple media partners. The schedule for where the national NFL and NBA games are each week looks like a Sudoku puzzle. If the games are high quality, the audience will find them. Heck - this isn’t like it’s even a new situation for the Big Ten because they had been splitting their games between FOX and ABC/ESPN for many years before the current Big Ten contract.
If anything, you’re letting the Big Ten performance off the hook. I’m a Big Ten fan that can acknowledge a weakness of our league this season: our games are straight up worse than the SEC offerings. The only time during the conference season where the Big Ten had a better game in a key time slot was the Oregon-Penn State game that went up against the Alabama-Georgia game. In that case, you can argue that some of the carryover in viewers on ABC from the Ole Miss-LSU game helped the Bama-UGA game beat Oregon-PSU, that’s fair, but we’re talking about marginal differences there. I can’t think of any other Big Ten matchup this season where the competing SEC game didn’t have a combo of better brands that were also highly ranked involved. Even Oregon-Indiana had to go up against the Red River Rivalry. The SEC has many more teams in the CFP mix compared to this year and a lot of those are also big brands, so the SEC ratings advantage this season is much more meritocratic than structural.
Now, I’ll play your game because, as much as many here think otherwise, I’m not just blindly in the tank that everything the Big Ten does is great. To the extent that there is a structural issue with the Big Ten TV contract, it’s that they give *too* much preference to FOX. In the prior FOX/ESPN Big Ten contract, FOX got the first pick of the year (which was always Michigan-Ohio State week), but then it was an equal rotation between the two media partners. In the current contract, giving the top 3 picks (nearly 25% of the season) to FOX when there are also two other OTA networks to satisfy is too much. The network lineups look so much different if Michigan-Ohio State goes to FOX but then Texas-Ohio State goes to NBC and then Penn State-Ohio State (even if it now looks like a much weaker matchup) goes to CBS and so on and so forth as opposed to all 3 of those games going to FOX. *THAT* is something that the NFL makes sure to do where it gives enough to each media partner that they don’t feel screwed. The person in charge of NFL scheduling even has stated directly that the idea is that each media partner gets something that they want, but not *everything* that they want. I believe that needs to change to a much more equal rotation in the next Big Ten media deal.
The other potential structural issue goes to the heart of everything we discuss here: conferences can expand with even big brands (like USC and Oregon), but collecting brands doesn’t do any good if they don’t actually play each other. The Big Ten has 3 teams in the top 10 this season but there will be only one game matching up 2 of those teams before the Big Ten Championship Game and it has already occurred (Oregon-Indiana). Now, Penn State falling off a cliff certainly didn’t help (as their game with Oregon when they were both in the top 10 was huge and they’ve got Ohio State today and Indiana later), but I think it’s safe to say that there’s a dilution of the schedule in moving to 18 teams that isn’t as pronounced as moving to 16 teams where you can still keep a much more regular rotation of matchups. You talk about culture a lot, but I think it’s less about regionalism and more “are we playing you enough to hate you” that the SEC admittedly has it better as of now. That is an inherent structural issue with expansion: the Big Ten didn’t even expand with any “fat” - USC and Oregon are big brands, Washington has a sneaky large fan base in a large market with a lot of history, and UCLA locks down the LA market that networks literally pay a premium for compared to other markets. Yet, if that means Ohio State-Penn State is no longer an annual game or USC and Oregon don’t play each other any more than they did when they were in the Pac-12 or all of the legacy Big Ten teams don’t have as many moments to build their brands against Michigan/Ohio State, then that can be a drag even if you actually have more brand names in total. And to be clear, the Big Ten ratings are still UP there year, so there actually isn’t a drag when you look at the data, but one of the biggest reasons why the SEC is doing so particularly well this season is simply that they have more playoff-contending teams and a smaller league means there are far more matchups between those contending teams.
Of course, as sports fans, we have a terrible habit of thinking that whatever is happening right now is how it’s going to be forever. Yet, we all should know watching sports all of our lives is that it rarely works out that way. That’s why we watch sports in the first place: there are days that are predictable but then many other days where predictions all go out the window and all conventional wisdom is wrong. Who would have taken a bet in January 2024 that not only would Indiana make it to the new CFP before the National Championship Game teams of Michigan and Washington, but that IU would do it immediately and is set to do it two times in a row? I only point that out because IU was always a popular example on this forum forum for many years of a team that would “never” be good in football, but sports eventually make fools out of all us consistently. Heck, the entire sports gambling industry exists because the conventional wisdom of fans actually turns out being wrong more often than being correct.
Still, I’m someone that has long believed that there is a point of diminishing returns when it comes to expansion (and you will find few people that love talking about expansion and conference realignment more than me). The real value comes from big brands and highly ranked teams actually playing each other as opposed to simply collecting big brands. We may be hitting that point of diminishing returns if we go beyond an 18-team league. That’s something that we all need to remember.
The B1G needs more schools that have a history of playing really good football with really great fan support way more than it needs markets or even brands. The mouths to feed argue for expansion is challenged when your average game viewership pales to the SEC. Furthermore, Indiana shows a winning program brings better ratings way more than markets or brands. Of course the B1G could use more of its schools getting a great coach like Cig, but individual coaches do not coach forever. Football fanbases continuously pressuring their schools to figure it out and win is a constant over time, and when a school tries hard enough and long enough they eventually win. The B1G needs more of that.
While I realize the B1G is waiting to see if it can score any ACC jewels before inviting any other options, if the B1G gets locked out, or mostly locked out, of the ACC's biggest brands and markets, the B1G must get football first historical winners. It's staus as one of the P2 might depend on it.
Utah is not getting looks because of market size, but they win and have a good football fanbase. They should be considered. Colorado is trying, and whether or not Deion can take them to the promise land himself, the schools is trying to compete. Other options are excluded because of academics, but maybe that needs to be reevaluated.
Outside of ND and the most valuable ACC schools the biggest get would be West Virginia. Now we all know the B1G will NOT invite the Mountaineers because of academics, but that is a shame. Before the Big East fell apart and left WV a refugee in the middle of nowhere and all of the challenges that entails, the Mountaineers were one of college football's more successful programs based on winning percentage. WV would thrive in the B1G. WV vs OSU or Penn St would be instant rivalry games, as well as others. Their fans care, and with B1G money they could field competitive teams. Again, I know the B1G will NOT invite WV, but they should. One bad academic performer would not ruin your precious academic conference standing, just like the mole on Cindy Crawford's face did not make her any less beautiful.
Ugh. I’ve heard the arguments for West Virginia countless times ever since I started writing about realignment years ago. They are a solid football program, but they aren’t the national needle mover that you intimate and certainly not so much that the Big Ten can just overlook their academics or lack of any market of value. Florida State is the level of brand and total value that we’re talking about when it comes to the Big Ten “overlooking” academics. If we’re going to get crazy and have the Big Ten ignore its normal institutional profile, at least suggest someone like, say, TCU where they’re in a great location, have had national success, and at least has undergrad academic standards that are in the Big Ten range.
It’s a moot point because the schools that can add value to the Big Ten today - Miami, FSU, UNC, etc. - would meet the Big Ten academic standards, anyway. There isn’t some magical hidden value to be unlocked from the Big Ten “slumming it” academically for expansion.
Florida State isn't AAU but they're currently #51 in US News & World Report, ahead of, among others, Penn State (#59), Indiana (#73), and Oregon (#110), all AAU schools.
By contrast West Virginia ranks #222, below even Mississippi State (#208).
You can overlook AAU if the school is good academically. You can't if they're pathetic.
|
|