quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(11-01-2025 08:57 AM)JRsec Wrote: (11-01-2025 07:33 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (10-31-2025 02:42 PM)JRsec Wrote: (10-31-2025 02:06 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (10-31-2025 10:27 AM)johnbragg Wrote: You're mostly right, but "that one detail" is one of the few things that is actually the responsibility of the conference office. We tend to overstate the impact of the commissioner and the league office (remember when the C7 got their ducks in a row, got a league and a media deal without having a commissioner at all, and then rented league office space from a law firm for like $1 a month for a while?).
IF you're wang-measuring the SEC vs the Big Ten (and that definitely one of the major topics on this board) then everything you listed (summarized here as: the program power of the individual SEC schools) is absolutely true, and if you stack up the 16 SEC schools school-for-school against the 18 Big Ten schools, you get the results you get.
The SEC media revenue, from everything we can tell, lags the Big Ten media revenue. Now maybe the leaks are wrong, and when we get the 2024-25 tax forms, maybe the SEC numbers are higher than we're led to believe and the Big Ten lower. But that would run counter to all of the reporting.
There is something to be said for being inside the ESPN ecosystem. Having your games talked about on College Gameday is better than having them talked about on Big Noon Kickoff, etc etc. Quo is unimpressed by that argument, consistently. He's equally unimpressed when American Conference fans bring it up. (no idea if you're following those discussions, JRsec, because why would you, you have no dogs in that fight and you're not just here for the media contract drama.) He values that at roughly $0, and I disagree with him on that -- it's worth something, maybe 10%, maybe 15%.
JRsec, I respect what you say about the culture of the SEC, and about how handshake deals are binding there. But I'm skeptical, because those unwritten handshake deals are only binding on the hand that shakes, not on the institution. And the counterparty, ESPN, doesn't have that kind of culture at all. I don't think anyone in Bristol cares one little bit what Jimmy Pitaro did or didn't promise Mike Slive fifteen years ago.
Quo has an argument that, if the SEC office had followed his line of thinking, they would not have signed any TV deal at all for the SEC GOTW in 2020. They would have put the deal up for auction much closer to the end of the deal, and caught the height of the "let's spend billions of dollars on building a streaming service and be the next Netflix" mania that burned up all of PAramount's and WBD's cash.
The other side of that is, you can't predict when that kind of bubble will peak and when it will pop. the SEC chose a very lucrative deal with long term security, even if it meant leaving up to a billion possible but not at all guaranteed money on the table. (Sure, the SEC GOTW could have hit the market and gotten the same sort of overvalued deal that the Big Ten got from CBS or NBC. But it's also possible that the SEC would have hit at exactly the wrong six-month window and gotten an undervalued deal. It's not as guaranteed as Quo thinks)
I don't think disagreeing, even at length and repetitively, is trolling. (Obviously, given my post history)
Yeah, I do not think the ESPN ecosystem is a.big deal. Heck twice thia year Gameday has chosen big B1G games over big SEC games. More broadly, the "exposure" concept juat doesn't IMO apply to an entity like the SEC, it has exposure out the wazzoo. Its not like 2012 AAC trying to get noticed.
Also, the SEC signed the 2020 deal at the height of covid era uncertainty. I am nott sure why anyone would think 2-3 years later would be worse. And rights fees have escalated almost uniformly, so imo waiting is the ipso fatso better bet.
IMO the SEC panicked a bit, was spooked by the big leap in money the B1G got from its 2017 deal, and wanted to mollify its members by signing early so they would know a $20m boost was in the pipeline. Of course that kind of pressure wouldn't have existed had better deals been signed earlier.
jmo.
First to JohnBragg. I never said a handshake agreement was binding. Don't know where you got that. Some other SEC guys have said it, not me. What I said is that UNC approached the SEC in 2011 about having a slot and one for Duke. They approached again in 2021. I have no reason to doubt that either side has changed their position.
ESPN is not considered in the myriad of delusional conversations about school movement. They have the ACC's rights until 2036. They have now given them a payment schedule for leaving. Nobody has announced an intent to do so yet. If or when they do ESPN will have a great deal of leverage over a destination. If the Big 10 wanted to foot someone's exit fee that's one thing. If ESPN wants to spread it out with the withholding of an annual amount from the SEC's contracted amount should they decide to move there they can and can make that payment to the ACC because they hold 100% of the rights to both. Now outside of that the SEC has natural advantages in that regard due to their strength in all ancillary areas of revenue and because of travel and fan and donor preferences at the more Southern ACC schools, save perhaps Miami. That's what I have said.
Second, I don't know where you cooked up the garbage about what Bristol promise Slive. Slive promised UNC that Duke would have a slot in 2011. I don't know what Sankey has said. The only other promise Slive made was to Machen the then president of Florida and to Pastides the then president at South Carolina when each requested that their in state rival (and their donation game for the season ticket books) be admitted to the SEC. Slive asked that they support Missouri and Texas to activate a renegotiation clause in the SEC contract with ESPN and promised them in the future there would be no such restrictions placed on fellow in state schools other than profitability. That was the Gentlemen's agreement Slive asked for and not wholesale lie about blackballs sold by Clay Travis.
I think you've conflated a whole bunch of stuff in the rest of your comment, but these are the only issues where I have stated details about that particular realignment.
As to Quo's claims on 2020 the new deal being worked with ESPN with a deadline of the end of January was a screw up, that is when CBS needed to know where they stood on that contract extension. There was no goof by the SEC they simply had to get it done and did. It was just with ESPN as CBS's offer of 307 million was rejected and CBS notified prior to the deadline. ESPNs was higher though the SBJ rounded the total down that CBS offered and called it simply a 300-million-dollar contract. That was never a solid number.
Mixed into all of that was the breaking news in 2021 of Texas and Oklahoma to the SEC. When the contract was signed to complete CBS's deadline nobody was free to talk about the additions of Texas and Oklahoma which had been in the works for some time. Pro rata for their inclusion was placed into the contract, but the full reworking wasn't going to get done until they were on board and everyone at that time expected them on board sooner rather than later. Now we are all still waiting for those details and contracted amounts to be disclosed.
The troll was that the SEC screwed up. Will the Big Ten screw up because it signs a new deal in 2031 when their old deal expires? Will the SEC screw up again by signing a new deal in 2034 or the ACC in 2036? You sign a new deal when the old one has expired! It's not a screw up, just a matter of business. In 2020 ESPN was trying to buy out the remainder of CBS's contract with the SEC. CBS didn't want to sell. It's pretty clear now they knew what was going to happen when they lost the product.
Because of that and a time lapse difference ESPN picked up the Oklahoma and Texas contract for a year independently of the SEC.
There's a lot of things none of us will know until taxes are filed next year. Meanwhile the ad Exec Thompson who handles Disney/ESPN and Coke stated that the final deal would be worth closer to 375 for T1 rights than 350 and the whole package is estimated to around a billion give or take a skosh. Either way that's on par or slightly better than the Big 10's deal. Ours is for 16 schools and theirs for 18.
Until all of the information is known this whole line of argumentation is needless. But it has been Quo's shave and a haircut knock to start this needless line of argumentation for the whole time I've been on this forum and that's over 13 years now. The first 11 there was no argument about the CBS contract being inferior. Now there is no evidence that ESPN's contract is. Hence the classic definition of a troll, and not just a difference of opinion. The misuse of information to stir controversy and arguments on a forum is a troll.
Now for the touchy-feely crowd who think I'm being mean, has Quo been banned? Nope, I've simply let him know that this has gotten way to old. May of next year isn't that far away and the truth will out then. End of story.
JR, about the bolded ... why did the SEC have to make a decision on a deal that wouldn't kick in until Fall of 2024 by the end of 2020?
IIRC, the CBS deal didn't end until after the Fall of 2023, so why did the SEC have to notify them of anything by 12/2020? And why was ESPN have to have been told "yes" and a deal accepted at that time as well?
These are real, not rhetorical questions btw, as I've never heard of that. Was that in the 2008 CBS contract, that a renewal for 2024 had to be agreed to by the end of 2020?
Or IOWs, what would the consequences (legal, etc) have been to the SEC had it just said "we're not deciding on the 2024 deal until 2023"?
FWIW, I do not think the 2020 ESPN deal is nearly as bad as the 2008 CBS deal. It obviously isn't. But when the B1G (apparently, we'll see) seems to be getting as much from CBS for Minnesota vs Iowa type games as ESPN is paying for the SEC GOTW, that IMO is a bad deal.
1. Because CBS's option came 2 years prior to the expiration of the contract. Negotiations were starting with an SEC which had no intentions of renewing with them.
2. Because Oklahoma and Texas's deals were done except for the ceremonial vote and their giving of what was expected to be a 2-year notice to the Big 12. When the Chronicle's story broke you will note that Texas and Oklahoma officially submitted their applications and a vote was held within two days approving their memberships. The process of joining a conference with legal work takes almost 2 years. They were already through with the process. It caught CBS flatfooted and that's one reason they were adamantly resistant to ESPN's efforts to buy out those last two years.
3. Given the three games on ABC now, the domination of the ratings, and the secrecy of the contract you need to ask different questions. How much did ABC pay for that contract? ESPN still doesn't own the SEC's T1 rights, at least not like the public thinks about it. Did ESPN rework it's T2 and T3 contract or are they paying the same 789 million for it? There's your billion-dollar question. If ESPN simply reworked a T2 and T3 contract to include the Horns and Sooners, they may not have increased their part of the equation since obviously Texas and Oklahoma were worth pro rata, and it increased their and the SEC's payouts in the SECN which are determined by NET profits and not by a set amount in a contract. Then if ABC paid what CBS offered for the T1 or more the SEC's total contract is worth over a billion. And who knows maybe it's more if UNC and FSU or UVa, or Duke, or anyone else were already in the works too. You wouldn't have to change the negotiated deal, just have a pro rata clause.
4. If it is such a lousy deal, why is it blowing away the competition?
5. North Carolina and partner(s) approached the SEC in 2021. Is their deal done too save for a public announcement and a ceremonial vote, and was that deal in the works when ESPN consented to the annual reducing exit fees?
Then you might have something to talk about that's actually fresh and relevant. 
And here's a 6th question for you. If the Big 10 starts renegotiating their contract in 2030 for 2031 and the SEC's new contract is now the standard, and they lag the SEC dramatically in viewership due to the structural deficiencies of working with 3 networks with none of them having material they need to promote the product like ABC, how successful will that new offer be? FOX apparently wasn't willing to foot all of the bill for this contract, and CBS and NBC aren't as cooperative with FOX as ABC has been with ESPN. There are some solid reasons nobody yet knows what is in the details of the SEC contract.
Thanks for the reply JR.
To respond to some points:
1) I was intrigued by your use of the term "option" in reference to CBS above. That prompted me to do some googling. To my shock and amazement, apparently the 2008 deal had a clause giving CBS a right of first refusal (see first link below) on the renewal of the contract in 2024. No wonder CBS wasn't so keen to give the SEC any kind of bump in 2012, when TAMU and Missouri joined! The probably figured even if the SEC was pissed off, they could always just match whatever deal the SEC negotiated with someone else. That makes a bad 2008 deal even worse, IMO.
The SEC disputed the idea that the contract had a right of first refusal, but the language quoted seems to say it did (IANAL).
2) Also, CBS having an option or right of refusal doesn't IMO mean deals needed to be done in 2020. The articles linked below seem to indicate that CBS, circa 2019, wanted to begin negotiations, and for whatever reason the SEC joined them in that. But in 2019-2020, CBS essentially bowed out. I assume because the SEC was asking for a price point that it wasn't willing to pay. If so, bad move by CBS, as $300m spent on the ESPN GOTW in 2024 would have been worth a lot more than what they are paying the B1G for worse games. Or maybe they didn't want the legal hassle of dealing with an SEC that was getting contentious over the contract terms and all that. But either way, I don't see any reason as to why the SEC had to sign the Disney deal in 2020.
3) No question, as admitted before, I do not know the terms of the 2020 deal, what provisions have been made for TX and OU and all that. I concede that I have been going on what has been reported, that ESPN is paying about $340m for the package (originally $300m, but with $40m added in pro-rata once TX and OU joined), which is IMO what has been reported by the media, so I haven't been making this up out of thin air.
If in fact there are secret terms that haven't been reported, and the deal is actually considerably more munificent to the SEC than I and the press seem to believe, then of course I will have been proven wrong, you right, and I will merit a big heaping pile of crow to eat. For that we await IRS filings.
4) No question, the ABC deal is crushing the competition in the ratings. My belief of course is this because of the quality of the SEC product, and would be happening no matter what major network we are on, it's not due to anything special about having everything on the ESPN family. Hard to prove one way or the other.
5) If the B1G goes up in 2030 for its new deal, and ends up taking a haircut or something due to poorer then expected ratings, that will obviously be bad for the B1G and the SEC will look better by comparison. Again, we have to wait and see on that. My belief though is that the B1G will get a nice raise in 2030. Heck, the nB12 got a slight raise in 2023, despite losing its 800 and 700 pound ratings gorillas to the SEC and backfilling with four G5 teams. Rights fees just seem to go up.
https://www.al.com/alabamafootball/2019/...otiations.
https://www.sportspro.com/broadcast-ott/...roadcast,'
|
|