(10-30-2025 09:18 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote: (10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: This is all spin, though.
The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.
I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.
And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.
Odd that you speak of spin.
You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.
Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.
You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.
On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.
I admit quite often when I’m wrong. I also critique the Big Ten quite often. I’m an alum of a Big Ten school, but I actually acknowledge when they have a disadvantage against the SEC. And no, I don’t believe that if people actually read and understood my analysis on the GOR (that schools can’t just unilaterally break them and time reduces the damages and the ultimate settlement was still based on time) that I was wrong about it, but if you want to position it that way, then that’s fine. If you want to throw out a laundry list of where I’ve made a wrong prediction, then that’s fine, too. I have plenty of them and many are even on my own website that I can’t hide from.
You admit you're wrong after the fact when it would be nothing short of foolhardy to do otherwise. That's not really relevant to my criticism. We're all wrong sometimes, but I can't remember a hint of humility ever appearing in your analyses until a certain scenario unfolds in a manner you didn't predict. Then you're willing to admit it, sure, and not learn the lesson on why you were wrong in the first place. The next prediction is just as demonstrative as the one before it.
We all make predictions, but predictions aren't fact...they are speculation by definition. You pretend your analysis is thorough, unquestionably factual and then pump your credibility as if that matters. It's not my intention to be rude, but as I said, if you're going to ask us to place a special weight on your predictions then don't be taken aback when your words are held to a higher standard.
BTW, I did read much of your analysis on the GORs and understood it just fine. You didn't just offer hypothetical musings on the nature and purpose of GORs...you made specific predictions about how certain scenarios would unfold without ever having read any of the relevant contracts. I wasn't the only one that noticed and I'm not just talking about JR.
I'm not positioning anything, you're spinning your past conclusions to make it appear as though they were more measured than they actually were.
(10-30-2025 09:18 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: However, on this issue, there is an actual scoreboard via years of tax filings: the Big Ten distributes more conference money than the SEC. Seeing that there is very little variance between the Big Ten and SEC on other types of conference revenue (and if anything, the SEC historically has more bowl revenue than the Big Ten), that difference is explained by the Big Ten having higher media rights revenue. Seeing that the most recent tax filings don’t fully take into account the Big Ten’s newest media deals that are even larger, that difference is almost certainly going to expand (although I will admit that is an educated prediction as opposed to historical data unlike prior tax filings).
I have no idea why you keep referencing tax filings. I'm not debating that the Big Ten has brought down more media money in recent years. We(or at least I was) were discussing the dynamics on why that was the case in the first place.
My postulation(which could be incorrect) is that the SEC has traditionally settled for less than what it could get in order to have aid in other areas. I'm not talking about secret revenue streams that would be visible on legally filed tax returns, I'm talking about trade in other areas beyond the monetary.
Additionally, in one of your previous posts, you stated I was implying the Big Ten was just greedy and after nothing more than money. I don't recall stating anything to that effect. I simply outlined a cultural approach I'm personally familiar with, one that would inform SEC leaders' thinking on certain matters. If you want to speak of facts then stick to them. Criticize me for what I've said, not straw men.
(10-30-2025 09:18 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: Many SEC partisans (sorry that I didn’t make myself clear that this wasn’t Greg Sankey himself stating this) with few exceptions (such as quo) for whatever reason try to spin this a million different ways that have nothing to do with finances when the reality is simply that the SEC signed an undermarket long-term deal. There is little question in my own mind that the SEC would be getting more money in media rights than the Big Ten if they were able to go to the open market today. (Is that enough spin for you coming from a Big Ten fan?) I can readily admit that the Big Ten media rights advantage has to do with management and timing and calculated risks as opposed to only the on-the-field product… which is exactly what the *conference* is supposed to be doing beyond just letting the on-the-field results be the sole determinant of value. I don’t say that from the vantage point of the Big Ten being a superior collection of football teams, but rather the SEC actually *is* the superior collection of football teams yet has managed to not get paid what it’s worth due to multiple long-term mistakes. The fact that it can’t be rectified until 2034 *should* be a point that makes every SEC school angry as much as the ACC schools are angry at their own media rights deal, but as I’ve repeatedly stated, I do think Greg Sankey knows how to control his flock in the way that Jim Delany did for the Big Ten before and that makes a massive difference.
I've complimented the Big Ten on their efforts to maximize their media deal. Maybe I don't say it often, but they've made very solid moves that have helped them.
I have only contended, however, that perhaps the Big Ten was more motivated to do so because they were behind in other areas. Long term, we'll see how moves like West Coast expansion work, but either way the league has done a lot of things right.
Not this one specifically, but in some of your other posts you point out that the conferences that have failed did so because of poor media deals and thus understanding the importance of that dynamic, one can then contemplate why some have pointed at the SEC deals and criticized them. If I may, the premise is only half true. There have been leagues that suffered due to poor media deals, but the media deals were downstream of other matters, not causal in and of themselves.
The PAC's media value was weak due to the specific collection of schools and their markets/economics. Combining that with poor leadership, the contracts available to them were sub-standard and thus created an opportunity for some schools to leave for greener pastures. But they weren't just leaving for more media money...the media money was downstream other factors that contributed to the health of the whole. So no, the whole reason some of these leagues have faltered does not rest of media value.
This is not to imply media value isn't important, this is to put it in context. Media value is one stream, not the only stream. Keep in mind, however, that for some institutions media value may represent a greater percentage of their potential budget and thus those dollars seem more important to some than others. The further down the FBS/FCS you go, this principle rings generally true. Media value is not the most important revenue stream for the very reason I stated, it's downstream and not a make or break proposition. For example, no one is staying in the Ivy League because of the media contract. In that same vein of thought, Oklahoma and Texas didn't choose the SEC just based on media value...there are numerous other revenue streams that are affected by conference membership.
Point being, while negotiating media deals is an important function of conference leadership, it is not in itself the driving force behind unity and overall prosperity. It's a variable, an important one, but it's not the same thing as an earnings report for a publicly traded company.
To conclude that the SEC hasn't positioned themselves to maximize media revenue is not to intimate failure. That's not necessarily to say they've gotten everything they wanted either. Two things can be true at the same time, but stability and non-liquid assets are worth something...they're worth a lot. Anyone dealing in building institutions and not just earnings reports can appreciate that. I'm sure you do as well, I just think you're being cantankerous.