Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
CBS TV ratings 2025
Author Message
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #121
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 09:30 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 07:00 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Man, between your two posts above, and the quoting style, it is hard for me to respond. But I will say that yes, I think I erred when I said the SECN deal was linked to the Mizzo/TAMU pro rats. Thought I don't think it changes the points I made.

As for the ESPN hype machine, I'm not so sure. ESPN doesn't even always hype its own games. Twice this year so far, it has chosen to put Gameday at the location of major B1G games while passing over major SEC games played the same day. ESPN hypes everyone sort of, though obviously they advertise the leagues it has deals with more.

I guess my overall point is that IMO, in 2008 the SEC signed really bad deals with both Disney and CBS. And while CBS played somewhat harder hardball - refusing to do a Missouri/TAMU pro rata while ESPN did - ESPN has really never "given back" much if any of the advantage they gained in that deal. Heck the recent 2024 deal that was signed in 2020 is undervalued as well, IMO. And yet the SEC clings strongly to Disny.

We have a contract with Disney, but that doesn't mean that we "cling strongly" to them, any more than the B1G "clings strongly" to Fox by giving them favorable treatment in their current media rights agreement. We will see what 2034 brings. I am optimistic that we will spread out our rights a bit, possibly more than just a bit.

My belief is based on a vague feeling derived from statements by SEC officials and talking heads in the media, but it is a belief that there is a strong sentiment in the SEC that Disney is the SEC's "partner", whereas I think the B1G takes a more "strictly business" view of their media partners, even with FOX.

And IMO it has served them well.

Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.

It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade Strong A** Offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.

Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'll tag a corollary to your remarks. The SEC has no interest in raiding a healthy ACC. It's only interest in taking ACC schools is defensive. Why wouldn't ESPN rather strengthen the ACC? A healthy ACC would enable ESPN to add Kansas and perhaps another to the West, or allow them to add Kansas and retain the rights to FSU through the SEC.

If Florida State is hellbent on leaving the ACC, the best pairing to end realignment for the SEC would be F.S.U. and Kansas. The ACC only loses that which refuses to be retained, and ESPN gets full control of Kansas, a product that they have given sweetheart T3 deals to in the past so that they could own more of them in the Winter. The ACC picks up South Florida, ESPN agrees to full shares for Cal, Stanford and SMU and we move on with more scheduling between us.

The SEC gets the dominant position in Florida for now and adds Missouri's rival and more basketball branding to go with Kentucky. The ACC picks up an AAU school which within a decade will be rivaling Florida and F.S.U. in strength and which pairs nicely with Miami.

A healthier ACC permits the SEC to function normally without having to protect its region or brand, which it otherwise would be committed to doing. And the two conferences grew out of the old Southern Conference and have ties and complimentary individual approaches to athletics and pair well anyway.
10-29-2025 12:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #122
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 09:30 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 07:00 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Man, between your two posts above, and the quoting style, it is hard for me to respond. But I will say that yes, I think I erred when I said the SECN deal was linked to the Mizzo/TAMU pro rats. Thought I don't think it changes the points I made.

As for the ESPN hype machine, I'm not so sure. ESPN doesn't even always hype its own games. Twice this year so far, it has chosen to put Gameday at the location of major B1G games while passing over major SEC games played the same day. ESPN hypes everyone sort of, though obviously they advertise the leagues it has deals with more.

I guess my overall point is that IMO, in 2008 the SEC signed really bad deals with both Disney and CBS. And while CBS played somewhat harder hardball - refusing to do a Missouri/TAMU pro rata while ESPN did - ESPN has really never "given back" much if any of the advantage they gained in that deal. Heck the recent 2024 deal that was signed in 2020 is undervalued as well, IMO. And yet the SEC clings strongly to Disny.

We have a contract with Disney, but that doesn't mean that we "cling strongly" to them, any more than the B1G "clings strongly" to Fox by giving them favorable treatment in their current media rights agreement. We will see what 2034 brings. I am optimistic that we will spread out our rights a bit, possibly more than just a bit.

My belief is based on a vague feeling derived from statements by SEC officials and talking heads in the media, but it is a belief that there is a strong sentiment in the SEC that Disney is the SEC's "partner", whereas I think the B1G takes a more "strictly business" view of their media partners, even with FOX.

And IMO it has served them well.

Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.

It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade Strong A** Offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.

Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.
10-29-2025 04:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AztecEmpire Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,079
Joined: May 2020
Reputation: 105
I Root For: SDSU
Location:
Post: #123
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 12:51 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 04:29 PM)AztecEmpire Wrote:  JMO, but partisanship is relatively new to CFB, but it appears to be hitting full swing this season, and B12 and BIG fans appear to be BIG MAD with ESPN. I expect softening of the SEC's numbers as CFB watching begins to balkanize. They will remain on top for sure, but the way things are going, it could slow overall growth in CFB values for a while. Maybe it won't persist, but politics has seemingly gotten into every aspect of our lives...and I think CFB having so much passion around it, it might be heading in that direction.

Actually, a BiG fan doesn't need to subscribe to ESPN any more to follow the conference. So if there is any partisanship, I bet it's driven by economics not politics. And to watch the CFP, these fans will sign up for ESPN - "anger" and all.

Im referring to CFB's internal politics, not national stuff. Anyone online right now would have to be deaf, blind, and dumb to not notice the rising tide of animosity. Also, whether you have ESPN or not, ratings are impacted by viewership, not subscriptions.
(This post was last modified: 10-29-2025 05:06 PM by AztecEmpire.)
10-29-2025 05:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,023
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #124
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 09:30 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  We have a contract with Disney, but that doesn't mean that we "cling strongly" to them, any more than the B1G "clings strongly" to Fox by giving them favorable treatment in their current media rights agreement. We will see what 2034 brings. I am optimistic that we will spread out our rights a bit, possibly more than just a bit.

My belief is based on a vague feeling derived from statements by SEC officials and talking heads in the media, but it is a belief that there is a strong sentiment in the SEC that Disney is the SEC's "partner", whereas I think the B1G takes a more "strictly business" view of their media partners, even with FOX.

And IMO it has served them well.

Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.

It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade Strong A** Offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.

Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.
10-29-2025 07:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #125
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 05:05 PM)AztecEmpire Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:51 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 04:29 PM)AztecEmpire Wrote:  JMO, but partisanship is relatively new to CFB, but it appears to be hitting full swing this season, and B12 and BIG fans appear to be BIG MAD with ESPN. I expect softening of the SEC's numbers as CFB watching begins to balkanize. They will remain on top for sure, but the way things are going, it could slow overall growth in CFB values for a while. Maybe it won't persist, but politics has seemingly gotten into every aspect of our lives...and I think CFB having so much passion around it, it might be heading in that direction.

Actually, a BiG fan doesn't need to subscribe to ESPN any more to follow the conference. So if there is any partisanship, I bet it's driven by economics not politics. And to watch the CFP, these fans will sign up for ESPN - "anger" and all.

Im referring to CFB's internal politics, not national stuff. Anyone online right now would have to be deaf, blind, and dumb to not notice the rising tide of animosity. Also, whether you have ESPN or not, ratings are impacted by viewership, not subscriptions.

I've gotten PMs on this board from people in the past when I linked an ESPN article b/c they didn't like ESPN and they wanted me to stop linking articles from that company. It's bizarre to me. I mean, I have a thread going on its 2nd year that discusses CBS's poor ratings, but that doesn't mean that I wouldn't watch a game I was interested in just b/c it was on CBS.
10-29-2025 07:15 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #126
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:04 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  My belief is based on a vague feeling derived from statements by SEC officials and talking heads in the media, but it is a belief that there is a strong sentiment in the SEC that Disney is the SEC's "partner", whereas I think the B1G takes a more "strictly business" view of their media partners, even with FOX.

And IMO it has served them well.

Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.

It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade Strong A** Offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.

Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.
10-29-2025 07:20 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,947
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3763
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #127
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.

It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade Strong A** Offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.

Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.
10-29-2025 07:46 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #128
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

Another contrived argument over matters nobody here has access to, and it's the same tired troll from the poster. Do you have access to what the Texas and Oklahoma attorneys signed onto? Do you know what aspects of the new contract kick in when? Does anyone know the full amount of the contract? The SBJ set a value at the rounded number of the rejected CBS offer. Now why might that be? Maybe it's because the SEC didn't want the full details and value (especially if it escalated past 2031 dramatically) known to the Big Ten. Is anyone in the SEC hurting for cash? Does the current projection of being within the Big Ten plus or minus 2 to 3 million damage the SEC's chances in realignment? Nope! The SEC will report earnings for this year next Spring. What you will see then is a baseline compensation which will be a solid indication of where it will be headed and the only obscuring detail could be any remaining COVID loan repayments.

This whole issue is a nothing burger, and one I've gotten damned tired of addressing over the nearly 13 years I've been here and always presented by the same poster. You know if you keep inhaling dinosaur crap it's bad for your lungs!
10-29-2025 08:10 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
schmolik Online
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader
*

Posts: 12,628
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1100
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
Post: #129
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:19 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  Oh, I think that's a good take based upon the available evidence. However, it's also smart business for the SEC to be a good partner b/c we're still locked in with ESPN for 9 more years, and we might be looking for another raise with, I dunno, a 10th game, a couple more schools added, something, right? Also, everybody is FBS is a major partner with ESPN through the CFP until at least 2032. The ~ $23m that each SEC school gets from the CFP is a huge chunk of our total Conference revenues this year. Even if, say, Netflix or Amazon jumps in with an offer we can't refuse in 2034, we'll still have the SECN and probably the CFP with ESPN, and many of our OOC games would still be on ESPN networks, too. Additionally, ESPN has done more to grow all College Sports, including CFP, than any other entity over the past several decades.

It's far stranger that the B1G turned their backs on ESPN than that the SEC has welcomed them with open arms. Ofc, that's worked out for everybody thus far. It's not unreasonable to expect ESPN to bring in a Will Wade Strong A** Offer for some B1G content in 2030, and it's also not unreasonable to think that ESPN could end up essentially trading a bunch of the SEC for a portion of the B1G once all the dust settles in 2034.

Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

Is this for real? quo vadis being accused of trolling against the SEC now? quo vadis is one of the most if not the most pro SEC posters there is here. If you want to say my comments are anti SEC or pro Big Ten that's fair. I highly doubt quo vadis is anti SEC in his comments. If he is upset with the SEC signing a poor deal it's because he wants the SEC and its schools to have more money as compared to the Big Ten.

If quo vadis can't even criticize the SEC without being called a troll, who can?
10-29-2025 08:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gitanole Offline
Barista
*

Posts: 13,916
Joined: May 2016
Reputation: 2818
I Root For: Florida State
Location: Speared Turf
Post: #130
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 11:34 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 11:07 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 10:47 AM)Gitanole Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 10:11 AM)Garrettabc Wrote:  The ACC rarely gets a game on ABC compared to the SEC, so I don’t think the ACC contract has a stipulation that the ACC has to get X amount of games on ABC or the main ESPN channel. The ACC has to get creative to break through all the SEC games by agreeing to even more Thurs./Fri games and being a regular fixture on Sunday and Labor Day in week 1.

The ACC contract is with a single media partner: ESPN. I am pretty sure the SEC contract works the same way. Anything that goes elsewhere from there is sublicensed by that entity from ESPN.

ESPN is basically the ACC’s media QB. Every play goes through its hands. It can keep, it can hand off—but it gets the ball first.

(This arrangement was actually a factor in the recent ACC litigation. The ACC’s grant of rights document was copied from the B12’s—but the ACC’s media deal is with one partner, not multiple partners as the B12’s is. The crude search-and-replace approach taken by the ACC in adapting the text led to clumsy language that might in court have resulted in huge loopholes.)

Mostly right. But the sublicense from ESPN to Raycom to CW is written into the ESPN - ACC contracts going back to 2010 or so. (The CW bought the sublicense from Raycom that used to go to the RSNs. The other half of the old Raycom package, ESPN had to buy back from Raycom to make the ACC Network have enough games to be viable).

What they were talking about were contract details that specify that ESPN/ABC has to carry a certain number (I'm going to say 5) games on ABC. And the ACC is required to provide a certain number of Friday night games (let's say 5 again). And let's say that the ACC is guaranteed 15 games a year on ESPN, another 20 on ESPN2, and has to provide 5 a year to ESPN-U.

I made up all of those numbers, the point is there are specifications in the contract.

FWIW, I think GarrettABC is wrong about the ACC not having a guarantee for X games a year on ABC. I just think the number is pretty low, I'm guessing 5. (Which was a reasonable number in 2010 when the base contract was written).

Yes it would be a big surprise to me if neither the big 12 or ACC contracts didn't have language specifying a minimum number of appearances on specific channels like ABC, ESPN, Fox et cetera.

I mean I recall that even when the AAC signed its peanuts deal back in 2012 there was language in the contract specifying a certain number of appearances on certain channels So it would shock me if major conferences like the ACC and big 12 don't have that same kind of language.

I'm not saying those M2 contracts do have that kind of language I don't know I'm just saying it would be a big surprise to me if they didn't.

Of course. In the ACC’s case, however the arrangements technically once the final contracts are drawn up, other media parties go through ESPN to get there. That’s the main structure.

When it was time to re-up the contract from 2027 to 2036, ESPN decided. Other arrangements follow downstream from that decision.
(This post was last modified: 10-29-2025 10:38 PM by Gitanole.)
10-29-2025 10:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AllTideUp Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,744
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 903
I Root For: Alabama & Cincinnati
Location:
Post: #131
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 12:41 PM)Redwood86 Wrote:  Why would ESPN bid up for BiG content or trade SEC content for BiG content when the SEC/ACC apples-to-apples ratings comparisons w/ the BiG ratings are favorable?

It would make more sense for ESPN to help the SEC/ACC combo strengthen its position relative to the BiG and/or Big-12.

I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."
10-30-2025 01:13 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
johnbragg Offline
Five Minute Google Expert
*

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
Post: #132
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-29-2025 12:21 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-28-2025 11:29 AM)JRsec Wrote:  ....
Nope! And that's why you never have grasped the SEC mindset. CBS sealed its fate when it refused a pro rata share to Texas A&M and Missouri. ...
....
CBS knew two years before the contract was up how badly they screwed things up. ....

Here's my outlook in general response to the above sentiments.

The SEC is similar to Notre Dame in that they value things other than money.


I mean, if loyalty was the driver, then the SEC should have re-signed with CBS, a company that it had been with since 1994, the dawn of the conference-specific TV deals.

Loyalty isn't just about longevity, though. It's about a positive relationship, and after 2011 the SEC - CBS marriage was an unhappy one. JRsec, I know you very much dislike Clay Travis, but he is very good at "skating to where the puck is going". He was calling for CBS to sell the package to ESPN back in 2014. That's how ruptured the relationship was.

https://www.outkick.com/analysis/cbss-re...-its-games

CBS had a point in 2011-- they weren't getting any new content. The SEC GOTW package probably didn't get 17% better by adding Mizzou and Texas A&M. But there's such a thing as negotiating, and CBS could have reasonably asked to up the number of games they were showing.

I don't expect business people to have total clairvoyance 20 years down the road, so I don't blame the 2008 SEC leadership for locking in with ESPN. Especially adding the SEC Network a few years later, having all-but-one game on the ESPN family of networks has been very very good to the SEC.

A long contract also provided insurance against downside risks. If Alabama had hired Mack Brown and Texas had hired Nick Saban, maybe things work out differently.

If Larry Ellison decides between now and 2030 that his son is actually a fool, the media landscape looks a lot darker and colder and the Big Ten might envy the SEC's guaranteed money.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 06:39 AM by johnbragg.)
10-30-2025 06:36 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #133
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 04:32 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  I'm not saying that ESPN would "want to" do that, just that it could end up happening that way. ESPN went hard for the B1G last time and missed out. They're probably happy that they missed out on that last deal, but there are legitimate reasons for both ESPN and the B1G to want to do some business together in the future if the numbers make sense. And on the SEC front, there are legitimate business reasons that we might want to have multiple partners, more like an NFL model instead of our current setup. One problem that I can see with sticking with a single partner is that ESPN is the only company (at least in the last cycle) willing to pony up enough money to get the entire SEC. Do we really want to essentially just award the next contract to the only company willing and able to pay an amount that's moderately close to the actual value of it, or do we want a bidding frenzy like we saw with the B1G last time that had NBC, CBS, ESPN and Amazon all fighting for 2 spots that were eventually significantly overpriced? The NFL has much the same problem, only x10 b/c their contract is more like $12b instead of $1.2b, so they pieced it out, then they carved out additional spots here and there (like the Netflix Xmas day deal for example). When every single game is tied to one company until 2034, you can't even think about things like that.

I believe that Sankey got the best deal that he could at the time in 2020, and it just happened to all be with ESPN. However, he's also put the most positive spin on it possible. Things like "we like the flexibility of having all games under one roof", more certainty (and early certainty) on game dates/start times/etc, ESPN will hype all of our games now to the Moon, things like that, those sound great, and there's an amount of value there. How much value? I dunno...5% of the total contract price? 10%? It's probably in that range. But the value of the SEC rights today is probably more like 50-100% higher than what we're getting paid right now, not 5-10% more. We can talk until we're blue in the face about the value of a contract, and friendship, and the Southern Way of doing business, but, ultimately, our valued business partners need to be competitive in what they're paying us or WE won't be competitive in the long term if we stick with them.

Right now, today, it's impossible to level criticism at what the SEC has done. The league dominates everybody else financially, and part of that is b/c of the media rights deals that they've negotiated over the decades. Criticizing the SEC for not getting "enough" on that last media rights agreement is like criticizing the B1G for bringing in Rutgers and Maryland. Last time I checked, the B1G was making ridiculous amounts of money from their media rights deal and killed off the Pac 12, in part b/c they added...Rutgers and Maryland. Same with the SEC, we're all making ridiculous amounts of money and we gutted the Big 12 (for the 2nd time) in part b/c of our media rights agreement. It doesn't matter that it didn't get every last cent b/c what it provides us was enough to get us into the next round. My contention is that, now that we're starting to actually consider that next round, it's extremely important that we remain cognizant that the B1G is a looming threat. Perhaps we sign a true alliance with them, perhaps we set up some sort of North/South, AFL-NFL style "partnership", but the threat of them stealing some of our schools or us stealing some of their schools will always be looming. And, given the choice, I'd rather have my Aggies spend the next 100 years in the SEC instead of the B1G of some breakaway super conference that's half composed of B1G schools.

IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.
10-30-2025 07:33 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AllTideUp Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,744
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 903
I Root For: Alabama & Cincinnati
Location:
Post: #134
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.
10-30-2025 08:43 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AllTideUp Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,744
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 903
I Root For: Alabama & Cincinnati
Location:
Post: #135
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:10 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  IMO, the problem with the 2020 deal is twofold. First, the SEC signed it too soon. For a deal that wasn't going to kick in until the Fall of 2024, it was IMO pretty nutso to sign it almost four years in advance. Merely waiting two or three years and you probably boost that from $300m a year to $350m a year just via natural escalation of media rights fees.

The other problem is that it didn't allow the SEC to capture the value of adding two genuine top-10 all time brand blue bloods in Texas and Oklahoma. It is IMO basically nutso that the SEC, to my understanding, got merely pro-rata on the base deal and the GOTW deal, when adding Texas and OU creates clearly more of the big brand vs big brand matchups that drive the highest ratings. They have created extra synergy into what was already the conference with the most big brands.

Instead, CBS is paying the B1G just about as much for their absurd Minnesota vs Iowa games as Disney is paying for the best SEC game of the week.

That IMO is the issue here and so the SEC has to view Disney in a strictly-business way, not as some kind of sympatico partner. It ain't sympatico, ABC has taken the SEC to the cleaners. JMO.

Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah.

One other thought I forgot to include. I don't know who you're referencing when you say "they." I don't speak for the SEC...never have and never could.

I share my thoughts and observations. To my knowledge, the SEC has never made any statement addressing this notion.

Who is "they?"
10-30-2025 08:47 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,874
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #136
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I've got to agree with Frank on this. The SEC got FMV on their game of the week since it was up for bid, but the rest of the package is significantly undervalued because of the long term contract. They got some more with the SECN. They got more when they extended to 2034. But not as much as if it was all out for bid. Just like the CFP--they would get more the next 6 years if they let it expire, but they wanted money for the first 2 years and they were under contract to ESPN. So they took less in the next 6 to get more now.

Now it all worked very well for them until the market skyrocketed and the Big Ten moved ahead with their 2017 renewal. Before that, the SEC was making more. We need to remember what the economy was like in 2008 when the SEC signed that deal. It was widely viewed as a great deal.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 08:55 AM by bullet.)
10-30-2025 08:53 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AllTideUp Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,744
Joined: Jul 2015
Reputation: 903
I Root For: Alabama & Cincinnati
Location:
Post: #137
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 08:53 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I've got to agree with Frank on this. The SEC got FMV on their game of the week since it was up for bid, but the rest of the package is significantly undervalued because of the long term contract. They got some more with the SECN. They got more when they extended to 2034. But not as much as if it was all out for bid. Just like the CFP--they would get more the next 6 years if they let it expire, but they wanted money for the first 2 years and they were under contract to ESPN. So they took less in the next 6 to get more now.

Now it all worked very well for them until the market skyrocketed and the Big Ten moved ahead with their 2017 renewal. Before that, the SEC was making more. We need to remember what the economy was like in 2008 when the SEC signed that deal. It was widely viewed as a great deal.

I get what you're saying, but 2008 was a long time ago. That's less relevant than what has been proposed thus far.

I'm not saying the SEC isn't interested in money, I'm simply saying it's possible that's not the only thing they're interested in. If it was their desire to take everything to market and get as much as possible then they would. My contention is I don't really see that as the pattern.

So we can either conclude SEC leadership is hamstrung, not as competent as needed, or is intentionally handling their affairs differently than what might be expected in an environment where everyone is focused on the prime figure of the media deal. Each of those are possible outcomes.

My contention with Frank is that he's not actually in a position to know which one it is. I'm not either, by the way. These are my opinions and not ironclad fact. Nonetheless, I think there's good circumstantial evidence for my perspective. it's not spin when I'm perfectly capable of admitting my outlook could be incorrect.
10-30-2025 09:09 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #138
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:20 PM)JRsec Wrote:  Quo when the details come out on this one don't be surprised if I visit you with long overdue retribution for your trolling. The deal was signed when it was signed because things were solemnized with Texas and Oklahoma in every way but publicly and were set to be announced a bit later than when the news broke. There were details in the deal that were time sensitive. It was a complete rework, and the SEC is not concerned with how it has progressed. If you haven't noticed, we are doing extremely well. Sorry sport but your one trick pony is about worn out.

It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I admit quite often when I’m wrong. I also critique the Big Ten quite often. I’m an alum of a Big Ten school, but I actually acknowledge when they have a disadvantage against the SEC. And no, I don’t believe that if people actually read and understood my analysis on the GOR (that schools can’t just unilaterally break them and time reduces the damages and the ultimate settlement was still based on time) that I was wrong about it, but if you want to position it that way, then that’s fine. If you want to throw out a laundry list of where I’ve made a wrong prediction, then that’s fine, too. I have plenty of them and many are even on my own website that I can’t hide from.

However, on this issue, there is an actual scoreboard via years of tax filings: the Big Ten distributes more conference money than the SEC. Seeing that there is very little variance between the Big Ten and SEC on other types of conference revenue (and if anything, the SEC historically has more bowl revenue than the Big Ten), that difference is explained by the Big Ten having higher media rights revenue. Seeing that the most recent tax filings don’t fully take into account the Big Ten’s newest media deals that are even larger, that difference is almost certainly going to expand (although I will admit that is an educated prediction as opposed to historical data unlike prior tax filings).

Many SEC partisans (sorry that I didn’t make myself clear that this wasn’t Greg Sankey himself stating this) with few exceptions (such as quo) for whatever reason try to spin this a million different ways that have nothing to do with finances when the reality is simply that the SEC signed an undermarket long-term deal. There is little question in my own mind that the SEC would be getting more money in media rights than the Big Ten if they were able to go to the open market today. (Is that enough spin for you coming from a Big Ten fan?) I can readily admit that the Big Ten media rights advantage has to do with management and timing and calculated risks as opposed to only the on-the-field product… which is exactly what the *conference* is supposed to be doing beyond just letting the on-the-field results be the sole determinant of value. I don’t say that from the vantage point of the Big Ten being a superior collection of football teams, but rather the SEC actually *is* the superior collection of football teams yet has managed to not get paid what it’s worth due to multiple long-term mistakes. The fact that it can’t be rectified until 2034 *should* be a point that makes every SEC school angry as much as the ACC schools are angry at their own media rights deal, but as I’ve repeatedly stated, I do think Greg Sankey knows how to control his flock in the way that Jim Delany did for the Big Ten before and that makes a massive difference.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 09:20 AM by Frank the Tank.)
10-30-2025 09:18 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13521
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #139
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 08:53 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-29-2025 07:46 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  It's awfully hard to look at the SEC and B1G deals, even if the SEC is $10m ahead through 2030 once all the dust settles, and not think that we left lot of money on the table. We are absolutely crushing them in the ratings. I understand and fully support what the Conference has done up until now b/c the results speak for themselves, but a clear-eyed assessment of ways we can improve in the next round of discussions is also valuable and important.

But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I've got to agree with Frank on this. The SEC got FMV on their game of the week since it was up for bid, but the rest of the package is significantly undervalued because of the long term contract. They got some more with the SECN. They got more when they extended to 2034. But not as much as if it was all out for bid. Just like the CFP--they would get more the next 6 years if they let it expire, but they wanted money for the first 2 years and they were under contract to ESPN. So they took less in the next 6 to get more now.

Now it all worked very well for them until the market skyrocketed and the Big Ten moved ahead with their 2017 renewal. Before that, the SEC was making more. We need to remember what the economy was like in 2008 when the SEC signed that deal. It was widely viewed as a great deal.
Bullet you and Frank and both wrong. The SEC is playing the long game much better than the Big Ten which reminds me of chain store spread. The more locations you build in chain stores the more tax write off they have, so they keep spreading until one day there is no good reason to spread further and then what looked like the superior short term strategy of using your perks to your advantage collapses them.

The SEC is getting stronger regionally, it sacrifices more now for better exposure realizing that their brand is growing without having to overreach markets to make it appear stronger and realizing that less overhead means more profit. That's why all ledger lines favor the SEC so much more than just media money which you and Frank can't see but for different reasons. For Frank it's the only number he can spin for his conference and his natural audience for the blog.

You can't see it because you are focused on that one line in the ledger fully, until you look at the next. 2008 was aberrant. I was fortunate to work in non-profit at the time and see countless people with meager means acquiring home loans. The bell went off in my head that there was funny money being created in the system somewhere so I got the hell out of equities and into commodities. The vast majority of my buddies lost their butts in equities setting more than a few of them back in the retirement timeline.

My point? Neither the SEC nor ACC, nor the networks saw that coming. That little fiasco wasn't part of anyone's plan. You allude to that but don't make the connection to the fact it didn't alter the SEC's superior financial situation an iota. Why? Because it didn't alter its markets, its profitability across all lines of revenue, and it didn't cause it to make a knee jerk reaction by trying to outgrow its problem. The SEC's financial model was organic enough to ride out that mini global financial meltdown.

There's another coming and likely a world war along with it. That will touch us all. That's my free for today offering. Looking at what actually is and what was, is not the same thing as looking to the horizon to plan for tomorrow. The reason the SEC is where it is, is because it remained true to its branding as a regional conference by expanding only within that region and then by expanding from the other region most organically like it, the Southwest. We kept our culture.

The Big Ten's appeal was that it had just as strong of a culture, and while the Pacific West organically grew out of the Big Ten and Plains states' diaspora during the depression, Dust Bowl days, and to supply workers for West Coast industrialization, it grew its own culture which was alien to that of the more conservative (talking social mores not politics) of the Northern Midwest. Now their desire to expand into the Southeast will meet with more in the mouth vomit responses than it did when they went west. It simply isn't their identity. The SEC's identity has remained largely intact through expansion. The Big Ten is becoming unrecognizable to their own people. And the masses always vote with their feet and pocketbook, and apparently with their channel remote.

You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 09:38 AM by JRsec.)
10-30-2025 09:28 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,551
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #140
RE: CBS TV ratings 2025
(10-30-2025 09:28 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:53 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 08:43 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 07:33 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-30-2025 01:13 AM)AllTideUp Wrote:  But again, just because the dollar amount doesn't appear to be market rate doesn't mean the SEC didn't get other things it values.

Thinking of the media contract as a revenue stream only is one-dimensional. Large organizations and businesses don't always construct their deals with this line of thinking.

Fans are focused on it because the contract figures get the headlines and everyone wants their favorite league or school to have the highest dollar amount, but as JR pointed out, we don't even know what the SEC pulled down. Did they refuse to publicize the figure because they're ashamed of it? Well, that's unlikely.

Even everyday workers don't usually sign contracts purely for straight cash. Think in terms of what other benefits do employees expect in order for them to be properly compensated? Then extrapolate that out.

It's like what Carmine Falcone says to the Scarecrow in Batman Begins. "Maybe money isn't as interesting to me as favors."

This is all spin, though.

The SEC straight up doesn’t have the ability to actually go out to market and get the most media rights money, so of course they will try to position it that they just care about all of the non-monetary benefits and a long-term relationship blah blah blah. Come on now! You don’t add Texas and Oklahoma without the intent of accruing an enormous amount of financial value from it. The reason why the SEC hasn’t been able to cash in on its full market value is because they have ZERO choice. This supposed altruism has nothing to do with “values” or “regionalism” or “we just do things differently than that money grubbing Big Ten”, but rather they are purely locked into under market value contractual terms that they cannot get out of until 2034. To suggest that the SEC is willingly passing up money is absurd: the SEC has *zero* choice because of the ESPN contract that they signed.

I don’t know why so many SEC partisans can’t just admit this. It’s not a debate: the dollar figures are public and it has been shown on the conference and school tax returns for many years. The SEC took long-term deals for security with ESPN and previously with CBS and they all have turned out to be wildly under market value in 2025. It wasn’t because of values or relationships or anything other than they made a bet that a long-term deal for security would be better financially than taking the risk of shorter-term deals. They lost that bet. It happens all of the time in business and that’s fine. I have faith in Greg Sankey that he won’t make the same type of mistake. But let’s not sugarcoat in flowery language that this is anything other than about revenue maximization. As JRsec loves to point out, the SEC schools individually make more school-specific revenue than the Big Ten schools on average, which I will continuously say isn’t a flex, but rather even more evidence that the SEC is wildly underpaid for its media rights.

And yes, media rights revenue isn’t the only source of revenue for schools, but it is the one thing that the *conference* controls. That is why virtually every single conference realignment discussion that we have centers on media rights. The Big 12 lost its most valuable members because of media rights money differences. The Pac-12 directly broke apart because of a terrible media rights proposal. The most valuable ACC schools want to leave because of their poor media rights deal. Yet, for some reason, when it comes to the SEC vs. Big Ten, the media rights revenue is just a “small piece” and “not the whole picture” and “individual school revenue matters more”. Come on now! Just admit that the SEC straight up lost on that metric! It’s not a permanent situation (as once again even as a Big Ten guy, I completely believe that Greg Sankey is a great leader), but it’s a situation that is going to continue to be in place for almost another decade.

Odd that you speak of spin.

You're not in a position to know what you're saying is fact and that's the only thing not debatable. Just like you didn't know what the ACC Grant of Rights said because you were never in a position to read it. You said without any reservation whatsoever there would be no settlement and it would at a minimum cost hundreds of millions for anyone to exit the ACC legally. You behaved as though your perspective was unassailable and that's not uncommon.

Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas to the SEC wasn't a "non-starter" despite your supreme confidence. Just like you weren't in a position to know Texas A&M was going to the SEC even though you concluded there was no good reason for that. Just like you weren't in a position to know the Big Ten would raid the PAC 12 and alter their relationship along with the Rose Bowl arrangement despite positioning such actions as outside the realm of possibility.

You're quite good at spin, yourself. Either that or you speak off the cuff and believe the message board equivalent of pounding the table will lead others to give you credit that isn't due. Most message board posters are just regular people stating opinions, but you consistently represent yourself as one of the smartest people in the room, one of the most accomplished, and one with enough experience to know what you're talking about. If we are supposed to accept everything you say because you're an attorney that handles high dollar contracts in your sleep then I don't mind holding your words to a higher standard than I would the vast majority of people on this board. You've essentially told us we should, after all.

On the whole, the more demonstrative you are in your declarations, the more confident I become you're dead wrong in your conclusion. There's plenty of of evidence at this point to show that as a bellwether.

I've got to agree with Frank on this. The SEC got FMV on their game of the week since it was up for bid, but the rest of the package is significantly undervalued because of the long term contract. They got some more with the SECN. They got more when they extended to 2034. But not as much as if it was all out for bid. Just like the CFP--they would get more the next 6 years if they let it expire, but they wanted money for the first 2 years and they were under contract to ESPN. So they took less in the next 6 to get more now.

Now it all worked very well for them until the market skyrocketed and the Big Ten moved ahead with their 2017 renewal. Before that, the SEC was making more. We need to remember what the economy was like in 2008 when the SEC signed that deal. It was widely viewed as a great deal.
Bullet you and Frank and both wrong. The SEC is playing the long game much better than the Big Ten which reminds me of chain store spread. The more locations you build in chain stores the more tax write off they have, so they keep spreading until one day there is no good reason to spread further and then what looked like the superior short term strategy of using your perks to your advantage collapses them.

The SEC is getting stronger regionally, it sacrifices more now for better exposure realizing that their brand is growing without having to overreach markets to make it appear stronger and realizing that less overhead means more profit. That's why all ledger lines favor the SEC so much more than just media money which you and Frank can't see but for different reasons. For Frank it's the only number he can spin for his conference and his natural audience for the blog.

You can't see it because you are focused on that one line in the ledger fully, until you look at the next. 2008 was aberrant. I was fortunate to work in non-profit at the time and see countless people with meager means acquiring home loans. The bell went off in my head that there was funny money being created in the system somewhere so I got the hell out of equities and into commodities. The vast majority of my buddies lost their butts in equities setting more than a few of them back in the retirement timeline.

My point? Neither the SEC nor ACC, nor the networks saw that coming. That little fiasco wasn't part of anyone's plan. You allude to that but don't make the connection to the fact it didn't alter the SEC's superior financial situation an iota. Why? Because it didn't alter its markets, its profitability across all lines of revenue, and it didn't cause it to make a knee jerk reaction by trying to outgrow its problem. The SEC's financial model was organic enough to ride out that mini global financial meltdown.

There's another coming and likely a world war along with it. That will touch us all. That's my free for today offering. Looking at what actually is and what was, is not the same thing as looking to the horizon to plan for tomorrow. The reason the SEC is where it is, is because it remained true to its branding as a regional conference by expanding only within that region and then by expanding from the other region most organically like it, the Southwest. We kept our culture.

The Big Ten's appeal was that it had just as strong of a culture, and while the Pacific West organically grew out of the Big Ten and Plains states' diaspora during the depression, Dust Bowl days, and to supply workers for West Coast industrialization, it grew its own culture which was alien to that of the more conservative (talking social mores not politics) of the Northern Midwest. Now their desire to expand into the Southeast will meet with more in the mouth vomit responses than it did when they went west. It simply isn't their identity. The SEC's identity has remained largely intact through expansion. The Big Ten is becoming unrecognizable to their own people. And the masses always vote with their feet and pocketbook, and apparently with their channel remote.

You and Frank continue to look at media revenue and you continue to miss a larger picture because of it. Frank does it to spin a position as ATU points out. You do it because examining each line and focusing upon it is your profession. Pull back from you line by line examination and look at the Big Picture. The SEC is kicking ass and taking names. And I'm not talking championship sports play. I'm talking business.

Look - I don’t think the SEC is going anywhere. The product is strong and the TV ratings reflect it. However, the media rights aren’t some tangential issue - it’s the very core of the financial value that the *conference* (not talking about individual school ticket sales and donations) brings to the table. The only reason why we’re talking about FSU, Clemson and UNC leaving the ACC is because they’re locked into an even longer and worse media rights deal with ESPN. The whole reason why the Pac-12 collapsed was literally the lack of a sufficient media rights deal.

As I’ve stated, I think Greg Sankey is a great leader for the SEC *now*. I would have full faith in his ability to negotiate the largest media rights deal in college sports history if/when he’s given the opportunity. That doesn’t detract that he’s handcuffed by the decisions of his predecessors to sign the 2014 long-term deal with ESPN, which means he has to squeeze out money from ESPN in other ways such as going to a 9-game conference schedule. I actually commend Sankey for being able to do that, but anyone giving him truth serum surely would rationally believe that he wishes he could go to the open market for the SEC rights far earlier than 2034. The NFL is going to opt out of its current TV deals that were signed right at the same time as the 2020 SEC-ESPN deal so that it’s back on the open market in 2029. Anyone that has premium sports rights to sell wants to be on the open market ASAP, which is why the Big Ten and anyone else that can be on the open market in the next few years is happy with the timing. This isn’t just a college football issue, but rather about the entire media ecosystem that wants premium sports rights wherever possible. The SEC simply can’t take advantage of it despite having the best viewership of any US sport property other than the NFL.
(This post was last modified: 10-30-2025 10:03 AM by Frank the Tank.)
10-30-2025 10:01 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.