8/10/26 update in Post #63
Original post:
I still stand by
the "Perfect" Playoff being the most competitive and fair way of structuring an expanded field. But where it fails is in politics. Having 3 play-in games when there are 4 "Power" conferences does not jive. Given the push this offseason for conference-owned Wild Card Games, I thought I'd re-present the proposal in an "Almost Perfect" form.
At its base this is a 14-team playoff. 5 AQ champions get spots as do the winners of 4 Wild Card Games, 1 (and only 1) owned by each A4 conference. The
M2 balked at giving the P2 multiple Wild Card Games while they got only 1; this proposal evens the playing field.
SEPTEMBER 2025 REVISION:
The final 5 at large spots will be allocated BEFORE Championship weekend and will be given to conferences rather than directly to teams. The conference can then decide how to structure competition for those spots (1 CCG + 1 WCG? 2 WCGs? will the CCG loser get a spot? does a team bypass a 13th game?).
This will give conferences the power to reward strong regular season play without feeling the need to ‘game’ the post-CCG rankings. The committee, similarly, can evaluate all teams on 12 games and not have to worry about whether a CCG loss should eliminate a team.
The 5 spots are allocated by the following method: The #1 and #3 highest ranked teams from from each A4 conference (along with the top two G6 teams) are ignored and the Top 5 teams remaining earn at large bids for their conference. Notre Dame earns a bid for themselves; the G6 pool any bids. The #2 teams from the SEC and B1G are exceedingly likely to earn 2 of these 5 spots; formalizing this could be negotiated amongst the A4.
Provisional Spots in 2024:
B1G: #1 Oregon, #3 Penn State, #6 Ohio State
SEC: #2 Texas, #5 Georgia, #7 Tennessee
M2: #8 SMU, #15 Arizona St, #17 Clemson, #18 BYU
AtL: #4 Notre Dame, #9 Indiana, #11 Alabama
As stated, the conferences have a fair degree of latitude in staging competition for their allocated bids. The above teams are not necessarily guaranteed to be given a shot by their conference and the conference could even invite teams from outside their conference to compete for their bids.
But most likely conferences will prefer to reward their own teams and establish a minimum standard of giving the top 4 teams in their standings playoff access. The CFP may establish playoff minimums (Top 25 ranking and/or 3-loss maximum) to prohibit mediocre teams from taking up playoff spots, but this does not seem likely.
2024 Example (WCG teams given non-Top 8 seeds)
*#1 Oregon (ROSE) and #2 Georgia (SUGAR) given byes to NYD
(#23 Colorado @ #18 BYU) @ #3 Texas to FIESTA
#16 Clemson (ACC Champion) @ #4 Penn State to PEACH
(#22 Syracuse @ #13 Miami) @ #5 Notre Dame to PEACH
#12 Arizona St (Big 12 Champion) @ #6 Tennessee to FIESTA
(#14 Ole Miss @ #11 Alabama) @ #7 Indiana to SUGAR
(#21 Illinois @ #9 Ohio State) @ #8 Boise St to ROSE