CSNbbs
The "Almost Perfect" Playoff (now promoted by SEC/ESPN) - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff (now promoted by SEC/ESPN) (/thread-1011801.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4


The "Almost Perfect" Playoff (now promoted by SEC/ESPN) - Crayton - 06-25-2025 09:39 PM

8/10/26 update in Post #63

Original post:


I still stand by the "Perfect" Playoff being the most competitive and fair way of structuring an expanded field. But where it fails is in politics. Having 3 play-in games when there are 4 "Power" conferences does not jive. Given the push this offseason for conference-owned Wild Card Games, I thought I'd re-present the proposal in an "Almost Perfect" form.

At its base this is a 14-team playoff. 5 AQ champions get spots as do the winners of 4 Wild Card Games, 1 (and only 1) owned by each A4 conference. The M2 balked at giving the P2 multiple Wild Card Games while they got only 1; this proposal evens the playing field.

SEPTEMBER 2025 REVISION:
The final 5 at large spots will be allocated BEFORE Championship weekend and will be given to conferences rather than directly to teams. The conference can then decide how to structure competition for those spots (1 CCG + 1 WCG? 2 WCGs? will the CCG loser get a spot? does a team bypass a 13th game?).

This will give conferences the power to reward strong regular season play without feeling the need to ‘game’ the post-CCG rankings. The committee, similarly, can evaluate all teams on 12 games and not have to worry about whether a CCG loss should eliminate a team.

The 5 spots are allocated by the following method: The #1 and #3 highest ranked teams from from each A4 conference (along with the top two G6 teams) are ignored and the Top 5 teams remaining earn at large bids for their conference. Notre Dame earns a bid for themselves; the G6 pool any bids. The #2 teams from the SEC and B1G are exceedingly likely to earn 2 of these 5 spots; formalizing this could be negotiated amongst the A4.

Provisional Spots in 2024:
B1G: #1 Oregon, #3 Penn State, #6 Ohio State
SEC: #2 Texas, #5 Georgia, #7 Tennessee
M2: #8 SMU, #15 Arizona St, #17 Clemson, #18 BYU
AtL: #4 Notre Dame, #9 Indiana, #11 Alabama

As stated, the conferences have a fair degree of latitude in staging competition for their allocated bids. The above teams are not necessarily guaranteed to be given a shot by their conference and the conference could even invite teams from outside their conference to compete for their bids.

But most likely conferences will prefer to reward their own teams and establish a minimum standard of giving the top 4 teams in their standings playoff access. The CFP may establish playoff minimums (Top 25 ranking and/or 3-loss maximum) to prohibit mediocre teams from taking up playoff spots, but this does not seem likely.

2024 Example (WCG teams given non-Top 8 seeds)
*#1 Oregon (ROSE) and #2 Georgia (SUGAR) given byes to NYD
(#23 Colorado @ #18 BYU) @ #3 Texas to FIESTA
#16 Clemson (ACC Champion) @ #4 Penn State to PEACH
(#22 Syracuse @ #13 Miami) @ #5 Notre Dame to PEACH
#12 Arizona St (Big 12 Champion) @ #6 Tennessee to FIESTA
(#14 Ole Miss @ #11 Alabama) @ #7 Indiana to SUGAR
(#21 Illinois @ #9 Ohio State) @ #8 Boise St to ROSE


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - The Beaver - 06-25-2025 10:45 PM

You'll never solve it with one format with a set amount of teams for every season.

Thus, here is my ualternate proposal: All teams that have lost to one or zero opposing teams (so, if a team loses to Utah once in the regular season and again in the Big XII title game, that only counts as one loss) are invited to a playoff with straight seeding. Byes are given as neccissary. Teams are allowed to forfeit out of "extra" games, like CCGs or a "Hawaii game," if they so choose but must otherwise complete a 12 game schedule. FCS teams may, with committee discression, be invited to compete, as App State could have been in that Michigan season, but in practice never will be.

If only one team finishes the season meeting those requirements, they shall be awarded the championship without having to play for it. In the event of no team finishing the season with less than two losses to seperate opponents, teams with two seperate opponent losses will be invited. In the event of no candidates being eligible for that, no champion will be declared.


Will it happen? No. Is it feasible? Not with tv contracts? Is it better than pretty much every other proposal from a fairness perspective? Yes.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - GoBuckeyes1047 - 06-26-2025 06:29 AM

So to me, with the slightly more recent news of multiple AQs vs. 5+X debate, I have my format that takes both via. a CFP Wild Card round prior to the 1st round of the CFP, which makes it a defacto 18 team playoff.

Start out with 5/5/3/3/1+1

B1G and SEC
1v2 in CCG (PSU-Ore, UGA-Tex)
3v4 in WCG A (OSU-IND, Bama-Tenn)
5v6 in WCG B (ILL-Iowa, SC-LSU)

ACC and B12
1v2 in CCG (Clem-SMU, ISU-ASU)
3v4 in WCG (Cuse-Miami, Col-BYU)

G6 play their CCGs (Of note, UNLV-BSU, Tulane-Army)

At-Large can play a WCG for the lone bid (Miss-ND), but suspect ND says no. ND in if top 14-16, maybe play-in game if ND not top 14-16 featuring top 2 at-large not in conf. WCG.

For the CFP Wild Card Round, the B1G and SEC 3v4 losers and 5v6 winners + ACC and B12 CCG losers and 3v4 winners the Wild Card, and the CFP bracket is released. Matchups are based on CFP Rankings with the 4 winners advancing into the main 14 team field.

All 5 conf. champs, P2 CCG losers, P2 3v4 winners, and at-large winner/lone at-large bid recipient (ND in this case) get at least a single bye. Top 2 champs get the bye QFs, next 2 champs guaranteed a home game (top 8 seed). I would do it this way to preserve the value of CCGs and ease of logistics with 2 matchups guaranteed that can be played mid-week with 9-10 days notice while the other 4 stick to Fri.-Sat. format.

This allows P4 to have their conf. WCGs, granted not even on number of WCGs, but still allows the main 14 team CFP to be 5+9, which the M2 say they want, with the P2 guaranteed 3-5 bids each while the M2 is guaranteed 1-3 bids each every season (excluding the at-large bid) in a 14 team field so your bids still have to be earned on the field. I think this is a good compromise for the CFP.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - indianasniff - 06-26-2025 06:44 AM

All Conference champs invited would expand viewer base to ALL of college football.

I have no interest in a playoff that does not include the conference I am a fan of, the MAC.

Include the SBC....include CUSA....AAC.....MWC....PAC whatever....and leave the 3rd and 4th place team of conferences out of it.

I did not watch last year and will not be watching this year.....unless Toledo gets an invite :-)


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - RUScarlets - 06-26-2025 07:34 AM

4/4/2/2/1/1 with 10 conference games played amongst all P4s (as OOC is irrelevant outside of who ND is playing). One out of conference G6/FCS BS game and another P4/rivalry game OOC.

Otherwise, 5/5/2/2/1/1

P2 plays a 5/6
At-Large spot goes to ND if top 16... or next best M2 team. P2 ineligible for At-Large. M2 would play a 2v3 or 3v4 to determine their 2 (or 3rd) participants.

Or...

4.5/4.5/2.5/2.5/1/1

P2 plays a 5vs5
M2 plays a 3v3

ND gets At-Large if top 16. Otherwise, highest remaining P2 #5 and M2 #3 gets the At-Large.

If a P4 clinches the At-Large (Because ND is below 16), the next best team from that conference moves into the play-in slot.

Short and simple. All play-ins are played in lieu of P4 WCGs or CCGs. G6 retain their CCGs.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - ken d - 06-26-2025 11:22 AM

(06-26-2025 06:29 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  So to me, with the slightly more recent news of multiple AQs vs. 5+X debate, I have my format that takes both via. a CFP Wild Card round prior to the 1st round of the CFP, which makes it a defacto 18 team playoff.

Start out with 5/5/3/3/1+1

B1G and SEC
1v2 in CCG (PSU-Ore, UGA-Tex)
3v4 in WCG A (OSU-IND, Bama-Tenn)
5v6 in WCG B (ILL-Iowa, SC-LSU)

ACC and B12
1v2 in CCG (Clem-SMU, ISU-ASU)
3v4 in WCG (Cuse-Miami, Col-BYU)


G6 play their CCGs (Of note, UNLV-BSU, Tulane-Army)

At-Large can play a WCG for the lone bid (Miss-ND), but suspect ND says no. ND in if top 14-16, maybe play-in game if ND not top 14-16 featuring top 2 at-large not in conf. WCG.

For the CFP Wild Card Round, the B1G and SEC 3v4 losers and 5v6 winners + ACC and B12 CCG losers and 3v4 winners the Wild Card, and the CFP bracket is released. Matchups are based on CFP Rankings with the 4 winners advancing into the main 14 team field.

All 5 conf. champs, P2 CCG losers, P2 3v4 winners, and at-large winner/lone at-large bid recipient (ND in this case) get at least a single bye. Top 2 champs get the bye QFs, next 2 champs guaranteed a home game (top 8 seed). I would do it this way to preserve the value of CCGs and ease of logistics with 2 matchups guaranteed that can be played mid-week with 9-10 days notice while the other 4 stick to Fri.-Sat. format.

This allows P4 to have their conf. WCGs, granted not even on number of WCGs, but still allows the main 14 team CFP to be 5+9, which the M2 say they want, with the P2 guaranteed 3-5 bids each while the M2 is guaranteed 1-3 bids each every season (excluding the at-large bid) in a 14 team field so your bids still have to be earned on the field. I think this is a good compromise for the CFP.

Either that guarantees the ACC and B12 three bids, or a third or fourth place team will jump ahead of the CCG loser. I don't think the P2 would agree to the first scenario, and the ACC and B12 shouldn't want the second.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - GoBuckeyes1047 - 06-26-2025 12:04 PM

(06-26-2025 11:22 AM)ken d Wrote:  
(06-26-2025 06:29 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  So to me, with the slightly more recent news of multiple AQs vs. 5+X debate, I have my format that takes both via. a CFP Wild Card round prior to the 1st round of the CFP, which makes it a defacto 18 team playoff.

Start out with 5/5/3/3/1+1

B1G and SEC
1v2 in CCG (PSU-Ore, UGA-Tex)
3v4 in WCG A (OSU-IND, Bama-Tenn)
5v6 in WCG B (ILL-Iowa, SC-LSU)

ACC and B12
1v2 in CCG (Clem-SMU, ISU-ASU)
3v4 in WCG (Cuse-Miami, Col-BYU)


G6 play their CCGs (Of note, UNLV-BSU, Tulane-Army)

At-Large can play a WCG for the lone bid (Miss-ND), but suspect ND says no. ND in if top 14-16, maybe play-in game if ND not top 14-16 featuring top 2 at-large not in conf. WCG.

For the CFP Wild Card Round, the B1G and SEC 3v4 losers and 5v6 winners + ACC and B12 CCG losers and 3v4 winners the Wild Card, and the CFP bracket is released. Matchups are based on CFP Rankings with the 4 winners advancing into the main 14 team field.

All 5 conf. champs, P2 CCG losers, P2 3v4 winners, and at-large winner/lone at-large bid recipient (ND in this case) get at least a single bye. Top 2 champs get the bye QFs, next 2 champs guaranteed a home game (top 8 seed). I would do it this way to preserve the value of CCGs and ease of logistics with 2 matchups guaranteed that can be played mid-week with 9-10 days notice while the other 4 stick to Fri.-Sat. format.

This allows P4 to have their conf. WCGs, granted not even on number of WCGs, but still allows the main 14 team CFP to be 5+9, which the M2 say they want, with the P2 guaranteed 3-5 bids each while the M2 is guaranteed 1-3 bids each every season (excluding the at-large bid) in a 14 team field so your bids still have to be earned on the field. I think this is a good compromise for the CFP.

Either that guarantees the ACC and B12 three bids, or a third or fourth place team will jump ahead of the CCG loser. I don't think the P2 would agree to the first scenario, and the ACC and B12 shouldn't want the second.

Depends on the CFP Wild Card Matchups, which would be based on CFP Rankings and include the following:

SMU (ACC CCG loser)
Iowa St. (B12 CCG loser)
Cuse-Miami winner
Col-BYU winner
OSU-Ind loser
Bama-Tenn loser
ILL-Iowa winner
SC-LSU winner

Then those 4 winners in the CFP Wild Card would enter the 14 team field, which would comprise of 3-5 B1G teams, 3-5 SEC teams, 1-3 ACC teams, 1-3 B12 teams, top G5 champ, and ND (being top 14) after starting with 5/5/3/3/1+1. Again, this is a compromise that would satisfy the B1G and SEC ADs with multiple AQs initially so they can make money off their comf. WCGs before trimming down to 5+9 with the CFP Wild Card round (Army-Navy week), which the M2 and SEC coaches want since they want to bet on their selves and earn their way into the CFP on the field.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - Crayton - 06-26-2025 06:09 PM

(06-26-2025 06:29 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  For the CFP Wild Card Round, the B1G and SEC 3v4 losers and 5v6 winners + ACC and B12 CCG losers and 3v4 winners the Wild Card, and the CFP bracket is released. Matchups are based on CFP Rankings with the 4 winners advancing into the main 14 team field.

Your proposal is competitively fair but I think it is deficient both logistically and politically.

Logistically, you are adding 10 games spread across 2 rounds leading into the mean 14-team field. The OP is able to give almost the same access with only 1 round of 4 games. The only teams who lose access are unranked LSU and unranked Iowa. The bloat of 6 extra games, 2 unranked teams, and 1 superfluous round are all excised.

The NBA play-in system works for basketball because the 3 games amount to HALF a playoff round. In football this same number of games is TWO rounds. It is just as bloated as if each game of the NBA play-in was expanded to a best-of-5 or best-of-7 series.

Politically, the M2 have already positioned themselves against giving the P2 twice as many Wild Card Games. While your proposal makes it possible for the ACC or XII to send a 3rd team to the Round-of-14; the OP expands this max to 4 (5 if ND is not Top 14). This emphasizes the regular season.

The NBA play-in model might help preserve CCGs for the M2, but is excessive otherwise. Fans, coaches, and ADs of SEC teams #3 through #6 would all rather prep for a single, win-or-go-home game than have to play 2 games to make the main playoff field. Notably both proposals cap the P2 at 5 playoff spots (6 if able to take Notre Dame’s spot).


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - Crayton - 06-26-2025 06:15 PM

(06-26-2025 06:44 AM)indianasniff Wrote:  All Conference champs invited would expand viewer base to ALL of college football.

Include the SBC....include CUSA....AAC.....MWC....PAC whatever....and leave the 3rd and 4th place team of conferences out of it.

Or… do both. Give access to the G6 AND 4-8 teams from each P4. All without adding more rounds than currently proposed: The MEGA Playoff.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - GoBuckeyes1047 - 06-26-2025 08:20 PM

(06-26-2025 06:09 PM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-26-2025 06:29 AM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  For the CFP Wild Card Round, the B1G and SEC 3v4 losers and 5v6 winners + ACC and B12 CCG losers and 3v4 winners the Wild Card, and the CFP bracket is released. Matchups are based on CFP Rankings with the 4 winners advancing into the main 14 team field.

Your proposal is competitively fair but I think it is deficient both logistically and politically.

Logistically, you are adding 10 games spread across 2 rounds leading into the mean 14-team field. The OP is able to give almost the same access with only 1 round of 4 games. The only teams who lose access are unranked LSU and unranked Iowa. The bloat of 6 extra games, 2 unranked teams, and 1 superfluous round are all excised.

The NBA play-in system works for basketball because the 3 games amount to HALF a playoff round. In football this same number of games is TWO rounds. It is just as bloated as if each game of the NBA play-in was expanded to a best-of-5 or best-of-7 series.

Politically, the M2 have already positioned themselves against giving the P2 twice as many Wild Card Games. While your proposal makes it possible for the ACC or XII to send a 3rd team to the Round-of-14; the OP expands this max to 4 (5 if ND is not Top 14). This emphasizes the regular season.

The NBA play-in model might help preserve CCGs for the M2, but is excessive otherwise. Fans, coaches, and ADs of SEC teams #3 through #6 would all rather prep for a single, win-or-go-home game than have to play 2 games to make the main playoff field. Notably both proposals cap the P2 at 5 playoff spots (6 if able to take Notre Dame’s spot).

The NBA play-in model was the direct inspiration for my model. I originally had the CFP Wild Card as a 2nd set of conf. WCGs for the P4, but though pairing them based on CFP Rankings might be more fair and enticing for the M2.

Maybe an alternative of my model could be dropping the 3v4 WCGs from the P2 conferences, if they're willing, giving the 3rd and 4th place teams in the P2 at least a wild card spot while removing some of that bloated, primarily on CCG Weekend. So essentially 5v6 in the P2 and 3v4 in the M2. The P4 still play their CCGs. This still allows the P4 conferences to make additional money from the WCG creating a 5/5/3/3/1+1, and games outside the CCGs are win and advance.

From here, probably set the bracket with the CFP Wild Card round featuring the 4 conf. WCG winners playing the bottom 4 non-champs. I know you include Ole Miss and exclude Iowa St., but I think CCG losers should be included, especially if Ole Miss just sat at home. I also think if the SEC goes to 9 conf. games, or even an agreement to play 10 P4 games, it'll help with the tiebreakers (since there was a 5-way tie for 4th) as Ole Miss finished 7th while LSU finished 5th. I could live with Ole Miss over Iowa St., but I would prefer a 13th game played by all CFP contenders (top 2 teams not in a WCG) though I doubt it happens.

ILL/Iowa
SC/LSU
Col/BYU
Cuse/Miami
Iowa St. (maybe Ole Miss)
Bama
Indiana
SMU

Because the 5 champs avoid the Wild Card round, 5/5/3/3/1+1 trims down to 5+9. I'm sure you're not a fan of 2 rounds, but I don't see the CFP schedule moving. I think the P4 want to make as much money as possible and want to utilize both weekends if possible. If we're going to see a 16 team CFP with 2 byes and 2 play-ins, I don't think adding 2 additional play-ins will hurt, which you have as well. Similar ideas, but different paths getting there.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - Scoochpooch1 - 06-27-2025 02:20 PM

(06-25-2025 09:39 PM)Crayton Wrote:  I still stand by the "Perfect" Playoff being the most competitive and fair way of structuring an expanded field. But where it fails is in politics. Having 3 play-in games when there are 4 "Power" conferences does not jive. Given the push this offseason for conference-owned Wild Card Games, I thought I'd re-present the proposal in an "Almost Perfect" form.

At its base this is a 14-team playoff. 5 AQ champions get spots as do the winners of 4 Wild Card Games, 1 (and only 1) owned by each A4 conference. The M2 balked at giving the P2 multiple Wild Card Games while they got only 1; this proposal evens the playing field. The final 5 spots are at large, though there are a couple methods of divvying up these which we'll touch on later.

To determine who plays in the Wild Card Games, 14 spots are provisionally assigned to teams BEFORE Championship Games are played. (a) 5 spots to the highest ranked teams competing for each of the 5 champion spots, (b) 4 spots to the highest ranked teams in each A4 conference NOT competing for a championship, and (c} 5 at large spots, mostly by rank. At its base this is a 2-2-2-2-1+5 format.

Provisional Spots in 2024:
(a) #1 Oregon, #2 Texas, #8 SMU, #10 Boise St, #15 Arizona St
(b) #6 Ohio State*, #7 Tennessee*, #12 Miami*, #18 BYU*
(c} #3 Penn State, #4 Notre Dame, #5 Georgia, #9 Indiana*, #11 Alabama*
*eligible to host Wild Card Game

Conferences would then create the pairings for their WCGs, consisting of 1 of the above teams against any other teams. Conferences own these games and have leeway to choose who they pair together. The Big Ten could choose whether Indiana (with a lower rank) or Ohio State (further down the conference standings) participates in the Wild Card Game. Similarly the SEC would choose whether Alabama plays Ole Miss (with the next highest rank) or LSU (next highest in conference standings). I do think it'd be worthwhile for the CFP to mandate that only ranked teams play in these Wild Card Games; perhaps opening the door for conferences to invite higher-ranked OOC opponents into their WCGs.

Likely Wild Card Opponents:
(d) #13 Ole Miss, #21 Illinois, #22 Syracuse, #23 Colorado
Other CCG Teams with direct playoff access:
(e) #16 Iowa St, #17 Clemson, #20 UNLV
Top 25 teams iced out of the playoff:
(f) #14 South Carolina, #19 Missouri, #24 Army, #25 Memphis

I suspect that the Wild Card Games will be played at the home of the higher ranked team. The P2 indicated that they wanted Army-Navy to lie fallow for their members, but as these games are technically "regular season" I could see the ACC and XII staging their Wild Card Games that weekend and rake in all the college football viewers. I also suspect that the WCG winner will all be visitors during the de jure First Round of the Playoff.

2024 Example (WCG teams given non-Top 8 seeds)
*#1 Oregon (ROSE) and #2 Georgia (SUGAR) given byes to NYD
(#23 Colorado @ #18 BYU) @ #3 Texas to FIESTA
#16 Clemson (ACC Champion) @ #4 Penn State to PEACH
(#22 Syracuse @ #13 Miami) @ #5 Notre Dame to PEACH
#12 Arizona St (Big 12 Champion) @ #6 Tennessee to FIESTA
(#14 Ole Miss @ #11 Alabama) @ #7 Indiana to SUGAR
(#21 Illinois @ #9 Ohio State) @ #8 Boise St to ROSE

At Large Spots
Any team provisionally given a playoff spot who is idle or wins their CCG/WCG will matriculate into the playoff. Teams that lose their CCG or WCG are not guaranteed spots, even if they are given provisional spots above. If there are losers, the committee will re-evaluate after the CCG/WCGs who will get these final spots. In 2024 The ACCCG would be winner-take-all as SMU would not be able to qualify with a loss to Clemson; if Miami were still ranked above Alabama and holding a provisional playoff spot, the committee would take one last look after the CCG to compare the ACCCG loser against all other teams to determine the last playoff qualifier.

For political reasons an exemption may be granted to the P2 so that their Championship losers always get 2 of the 5 at large spots. This shouldn't matter most years, but does bring this proposal into accord with what the Big Ten proposed last year according to Dellenger (and what schmolnik suggested a few weeks ago): a best compromise of 3-3-2-2-1+3.

Notre Dame gets a pre-negotiated bid if they are in the Top 14. The committee will not release a post-CCG/WCG Top 25, only the expanded bracket; they won't really have any tough decisions that week and will be able to focus mostly on building a fair bracket considering perhaps rematches.

Perfect playoff is 4-6 teams.
ND will always be in Top 14, so just hand them their spot.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - Crayton - 06-28-2025 06:51 AM

(06-26-2025 08:20 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  From here, probably set the bracket with the CFP Wild Card round featuring the 4 conf. WCG winners playing the bottom 4 non-champs. I know you include Ole Miss and exclude Iowa St., but I think CCG losers should be included, especially if Ole Miss just sat at home. I also think if the SEC goes to 9 conf. games, or even an agreement to play 10 P4 games, it'll help with the tiebreakers (since there was a 5-way tie for 4th) as Ole Miss finished 7th while LSU finished 5th. I could live with Ole Miss over Iowa St., but I would prefer a 13th game played by all CFP contenders (top 2 teams not in a WCG) though I doubt it happens.

ILL/Iowa
SC/LSU
Col/BYU
Cuse/Miami
Iowa St. (maybe Ole Miss)
Bama
Indiana
SMU

Because the 5 champs avoid the Wild Card round, 5/5/3/3/1+1 trims down to 5+9. I'm sure you're not a fan of 2 rounds, but I don't see the CFP schedule moving. I think the P4 want to make as much money as possible and want to utilize both weekends if possible. If we're going to see a 16 team CFP with 2 byes and 2 play-ins, I don't think adding 2 additional play-ins will hurt, which you have as well. Similar ideas, but different paths getting there.

When the 4-4-2-2-1+3 was announced as a possible compromise, many rightly groaned that those 3 at large spots would be contested by a bunch of WCG/CCG losers. We don't need to build a playoff that caters to losers. Though, understandably, some CCGs feature TOP teams and elimination would be a high burden.

I take your proposal as an attempt to correct the above flaw by assigning at large spots through the 4 play-in games. This allows conferences to reap the benefits of a good year by getting more teams in.

But I think you are doing it backwards have overfit it for the 2025 finish. See what happens when your model is added to these potential finishes for 2026: 5 sims for 2026. In Sim #1 I see #9 Wisconsin having to play 2 games just to make it to the same round as #12 Georgia; in Sim #2 I see #5 Clemson being given the same treatment as 2 unranked Big 12 teams; and there are likely more gaping discrepancies.

Instead, we should assign the at larges to Top 10 teams and let the conferences' Wild Card games fill out the main 14-team bracket. This way teams are competing all year for those at large spots and we don't need an extra round to sort through teams with wildly different finishes.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - GoBuckeyes1047 - 06-28-2025 11:09 AM

(06-28-2025 06:51 AM)Crayton Wrote:  
(06-26-2025 08:20 PM)GoBuckeyes1047 Wrote:  From here, probably set the bracket with the CFP Wild Card round featuring the 4 conf. WCG winners playing the bottom 4 non-champs. I know you include Ole Miss and exclude Iowa St., but I think CCG losers should be included, especially if Ole Miss just sat at home. I also think if the SEC goes to 9 conf. games, or even an agreement to play 10 P4 games, it'll help with the tiebreakers (since there was a 5-way tie for 4th) as Ole Miss finished 7th while LSU finished 5th. I could live with Ole Miss over Iowa St., but I would prefer a 13th game played by all CFP contenders (top 2 teams not in a WCG) though I doubt it happens.

ILL/Iowa
SC/LSU
Col/BYU
Cuse/Miami
Iowa St. (maybe Ole Miss)
Bama
Indiana
SMU

Because the 5 champs avoid the Wild Card round, 5/5/3/3/1+1 trims down to 5+9. I'm sure you're not a fan of 2 rounds, but I don't see the CFP schedule moving. I think the P4 want to make as much money as possible and want to utilize both weekends if possible. If we're going to see a 16 team CFP with 2 byes and 2 play-ins, I don't think adding 2 additional play-ins will hurt, which you have as well. Similar ideas, but different paths getting there.

When the 4-4-2-2-1+3 was announced as a possible compromise, many rightly groaned that those 3 at large spots would be contested by a bunch of WCG/CCG losers. We don't need to build a playoff that caters to losers. Though, understandably, some CCGs feature TOP teams and elimination would be a high burden.

I take your proposal as an attempt to correct the above flaw by assigning at large spots through the 4 play-in games. This allows conferences to reap the benefits of a good year by getting more teams in.

But I think you are doing it backwards have overfit it for the 2025 finish. See what happens when your model is added to these potential finishes for 2026: 5 sims for 2026. In Sim #1 I see #9 Wisconsin having to play 2 games just to make it to the same round as #12 Georgia; in Sim #2 I see #5 Clemson being given the same treatment as 2 unranked Big 12 teams; and there are likely more gaping discrepancies.

Instead, we should assign the at larges to Top 10 teams and let the conferences' Wild Card games fill out the main 14-team bracket. This way teams are competing all year for those at large spots and we don't need an extra round to sort through teams with wildly different finishes.

The thought that I may be putting too much weight on this past season has crossed my mind and have . Maybe the Wild Card Round could be the bottom 8 at-large teams (non-champs) from the 5/5/3/3/1+1 rather than designating certain WCG or CCG teams that still trims down to 5+9.

So CCGs, 1 WCG for each P4 conf. (P2 - 5v6, M2 - 3v4) even though the P2 would want a 2nd WCG. Top 2 champs get a bye, next 2 champs get a home game. You still have the Wisconsin situation with the 1st Sim, but with a WCG win, maybe they move up a spot to avoid that 2nd game.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" Playoff - Meepmeep2011 - 06-29-2025 08:28 AM

I like how the FCS does it.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" 2-2-2-2-1+5 Playoff - Crayton - 07-10-2025 07:54 PM

After a few weeks, I think this can be cleaned up to give more power to the conferences and less to data jockeys like me trying to over-prescribe the “perfect” format. Each conference has different priorities.

2-2-2-2-1+5

A4 conferences get 2 13th games (either CCG+WCG or 2xWCG) for their auto spots and the G6 can continue to rely on the committee to pick their top champion.

The 5 At Larges are ‘distributed’ to the conferences prior to CCGs, based on the Top 25 standings. These At Larges are essentially byes (teams that don’t have to win a 13th game) and the conferences control which teams they are given to.

How are they distributed?
Setting aside the Top 3 ranked teams from each A4 conference and the top 2 from the G6, the 5 spots are given to the conferences (or ND) of the next 5 highest ranked teams (the G6 sharing any spot). The P2 might automatically be given 2 of the 5 spots; a cap of 2 to any 1 conference might also be implemented so the Big Ten doesn’t fall ‘too’ far behind the SEC.

2024 Example
After the above teams (3 from each A4 and 2 G6) are set aside, the following conference get at large spots:
#4 Notre Dame/Notre Dame
#9 Indiana/Big Ten
#11 Alabama/SEC
#13 Ole Miss/SEC
#21 Illinois/Big Ten

Now these teams do not necessarily get access to the playoff (by WCG or directly through an at large); their conferences now have full control of these spots. The only thing the committees does the final week is seed the 14 playoff teams that these conferences designate.

EDIT: I’m still for teams needing to be in the Top 25 to be eligible for the playoff should they win their 13th game. This might push the Big 12 to sometimes invite P2 teams to their WCG or for the G6 to consolidate their top 2 games.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" 2-2-2-2-1+5 Playoff - AztecNation - 07-10-2025 10:00 PM

(06-26-2025 06:44 AM)indianasniff Wrote:  All Conference champs invited would expand viewer base to ALL of college football.

I have no interest in a playoff that does not include the conference I am a fan of, the MAC.

Include the SBC....include CUSA....AAC.....MWC....PAC whatever....and leave the 3rd and 4th place team of conferences out of it.

I did not watch last year and will not be watching this year.....unless Toledo gets an invite :-)

I posted a playoff format that would include all conferences without diluting the Playoffs too much. Only issue is this didn't include the Pac at the time so it'd need to be further tweaked to accommodate them as well.

This is what I posted:
Quote:IMO a better system would be auto bids to the playoffs for the top 5 conference winners, they can even add a contingency like you must be a top 20 team to get that autobid otherwise you fall into the play-in. All other conference winners enter play-in tournament for 6th autobid.

So for example last season autobids: Oregon, Texas, Boise St., Arizona St., SMU

Play-in tournament for final autobid:

Jacksonville St.* (CUSA) @ Army* (AAC)
Ohio* (MAC) @ Marshall* (Sun Belt)

Lets say Army wins the play-in and gets final autobid. Rest of the bids are wildcard bids and seeding is based on rankings (whichever system they decide to go with). Top 8 seeds get to be the hosting school.


So the playoff would be something like:

#16 Army* (AAC) @ #1 Oregon* (B1G)
#15 Arizona St. * (B12) @ #2 Texas * (SEC)
#14 South Carolina/Iowa St? @ #3 Penn State
#13 Ole Miss @ #4 Norte Dame
#12 Miami @ #5 Georgia
#11 Alabama @ #6 Ohio State
#10 Boise St * (MWC) @ #7 Tennessee
#9 Indiana @ #8 SMU* (ACC)

Every conference gets to be involved like basketball without impacting the integrity of the playoff system with a bunch of lower quality teams. When the Pac returns then you have bottom 2 conference winners face-off for 4th play in spot, or they can find a way to tweak it to work better.



RE: The "Almost Perfect" 2-2-2-2-1+5 Playoff - bryanw1995 - 07-10-2025 10:59 PM

(06-26-2025 06:44 AM)indianasniff Wrote:  All Conference champs invited would expand viewer base to ALL of college football.

I have no interest in a playoff that does not include the conference I am a fan of, the MAC.

Include the SBC....include CUSA....AAC.....MWC....PAC whatever....and leave the 3rd and 4th place team of conferences out of it.

I did not watch last year and will not be watching this year.....unless Toledo gets an invite :-)

Top 5 conference winners get an auto bid. Last season, the MWC champ was the 3rd highest ranked champ. A few years ago, Cincy was the AAC champ and the 3rd highest ranked champ. No reason that the MAC couldn’t do the same in any given year. Heck, last year Northern Illinois probably would have been ahead of Boise and thus the #3 overall seed even with one loss, their problem was that they fell apart after beating ND.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" 2-2-2-2-1+5 Playoff - Eldonabe - 07-11-2025 09:53 AM

Any scenario that includes "auto" is BS.

Frankly, if there are 12 or 16 teams 99% of the time the ones tabbed for "auto" bids are making it in any full merit based system. And if you don't make it, you didn't deserve to - so tough schidt.

If the actual goal is to crown a National Champion - the best "X" number of teams should be the only ones with that chance.

A number of years back, the Pac12 and Big12 did not get a team into the playoff (SEC got 2 of the 4) - ever since then, the push for additional teams to make sure all the P5s were represented has been going on.


If you are gonna auto bid teams - Just make it a 32 team tournament FFS and let everyone play.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" 2-2-2-2-1+5 Playoff - Crayton - 07-11-2025 10:43 PM

(06-28-2025 06:51 AM)Crayton Wrote:  But I think you are doing it backwards have overfit it for the 2025 finish. See what happens when your model is added to these potential finishes for 2026: 5 sims for 2026.
(07-10-2025 07:54 PM)Crayton Wrote:  After a few weeks, I think this can be cleaned up to give more power to the conferences and less to data jockeys like me trying to over-prescribe the “perfect” format. Each conference has different priorities.

I'll take my own advice to avoid over-fitting for 2024. In those 5 sims, who gets the at large bids when using the 2+2+2+2+1+5?

2024: B1G (4), SEC (4), XII (2), ACC (2), G5 (1), ND (1)
Sim #1: B1G (4), SEC (4), XII (2), ACC (2), G5 (1), ND (1)
Sim #2: B1G (4), SEC (3), XII (2), ACC (2), G5 (2), ND (1)
Sim #3: B1G (3), SEC (4), XII (2), ACC (3), G5 (1), ND (1)
Sim #4: B1G (3), SEC (4), XII (3), ACC (2), G5 (1), ND (1)
Sim #5: B1G (3), SEC (4), XII (2), ACC (2), G5 (2), ND (1)

In Sim #3 and #5, the SEC would have qualified for a 5th spot, if allowed. It would have been taken from the B1G, though if the B1G was guaranteed a 3rd bid then the P2 would have taken a bid from the M2/G5. I think the only fair way a conference can get 5 bids, without stealing from the M2/G5 (and giving the P2 at least 1 at large apiece) is to say a conference cannot receive a 5th bid until after (when walking down the rankings) each P2 receives their 3rd.


RE: The "Almost Perfect" 2-2-2-2-1+5 Playoff - quo vadis - 07-12-2025 07:35 AM

IMO it makes no sense for the ACC and B12 to have the same number of guaranteed bids as the SEC and B1G**. The SEC and B1G have far better performance on the field and far better brand value. There is no "P4" anymore, there is a P2 and M2, IMO.

The only way those four are equal is in an "A" sense, all four have autonomy. But in terms of football there is a big gap.






** Unless that same number is "zero", as in nobody has autobids.