(06-16-2025 01:18 PM)bullet Wrote: (06-16-2025 12:08 PM)solohawks Wrote: The SEC has said they don't need AQs... The Big 10 feels like they do
But the SEC would like more objective criteria.
Realistically, if people were betting on a neutral site game, how many would:
Bet on Boise St. over Clemson and Arizona St.;
Bet on SMU over Alabama, Ole Miss and South Carolina, or even BYU who beat them in Dallas and had the same number of losses;
Bet on Indiana (although this would be closer) over Alabama, Ole Miss and South Carolina? IU had a G5 level strength of schedule. They had a weak ooc and it worked out that they mostly got the weaker opponents in the Big Ten.
I think this is where we can all find some common ground. As a Big Ten fan, I’m not overly concerned about the playoff format—whether it’s automatic qualifiers vs. at-larges—or the number of conference games (8 vs. 9). What matters most to me is how teams are selected for the College Football Playoff.
The selection process should be as objective and unbiased as possible. That’s the core issue for me.
I’m not a fan of using Strength of Schedule as a primary factor because it often relies on preseason expectations about which teams are good, rather than actual results. That makes it inherently subjective.
Instead, I’d rather focus on clear, performance-based metrics—things that reflect what actually happened on the field against quality competition. Some of the criteria I think should carry the most weight include:
Win-loss record vs. top-tier opponents (e.g., P2 and M2 teams)
— Perhaps weighted: 2 points for a P2 win, 1 point for an M2 win
Point differential vs. those same opponents
— With greater weight for margins against higher-tier teams
Opponent win percentage (only games vs. Power 4 opponents)
Home vs. away performance vs. Power 4 opponents
These are measurable, on-field results—not projections or assumptions—and they give a more accurate picture of a team’s true strength. Additionally, they are transparent—everyone knows what they need to do to make the playoff.
I know this isn't perfect so don't beat me up too bad on the metrics / weightings. It was for example purposes only, not what is should be.