Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
Author Message
NDSUguy Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 260
Joined: Dec 2012
Reputation: 29
I Root For: NDSU
Location:
Post: #821
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 09:45 AM)Shox Wrote:  
(12-12-2024 05:44 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  NDSU/SDSU combined make more sense than NIU.

Gotta remember that UNLV and likely Air Force will be gone in 5 years once the ransom payments are done. Better to bring on NDSU/SDSU/MT/MSU now to give them ramp up time.

Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.
12-16-2024 11:13 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,553
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #822
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 09:45 AM)Shox Wrote:  
(12-12-2024 05:44 PM)andybible1995 Wrote:  
(12-12-2024 05:41 PM)Barbershop Wrote:  FWIW, I'd prefer the MW to take NDSU over NIU. It will be interesting to see what happens.

NDSU/SDSU combined make more sense than NIU.

Gotta remember that UNLV and likely Air Force will be gone in 5 years once the ransom payments are done. Better to bring on NDSU/SDSU/MT/MSU now to give them ramp up time.

Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint. And to be honest...they don't really care what happens to the MWC over the long term.

I agree that university presidents will take actions based on their own short-term self-preservation. That being said, not every short-term financial decision is misaligned with long-term strategic decisions. As an extreme example, the SEC adding Texas and Oklahoma was both a short-term financial gain AND a long-term strategic move.

For the MWC, maybe you can call the UC Davis decision as purely a large market grab. Who knows if they have the wherewithal to move up to FBS and, from a pure basketball standpoint, there were plenty of better options (e.g. St. Mary’s). You could also call the interest from the MWC in Texas State as pure attempt at grabbing a market.

However, I think anyone criticizing the desirability of NIU is viewing it through a biased lens. This isn’t just a large TV market grab. This is an existing FBS school that, in the past 15 years, has won 5 MAC championships, 3 other MAC Championship Game appearances, an Orange Bowl appearance (which would have been a CFP playoff appearance in today’s system), and a bunch of high profile wins against power schools (including Notre Dame this season). It’s also right in an excellent football recruiting territory. The Dakota schools know that territory well: SDSU’s QB that has led them to 2 straight FCS championships and won the Walter Payton Award is from the Chicago suburb that I live in and so is their backup QB. Outside of football, the Chicago area is also the biggest net exporter of college students to out-of-state schools anywhere - they are to “regular student recruits” as Texas is to football student recruits. The fact that NIU is also in the #3 TV market of Chicago is almost gravy by comparison.

This seems pretty obvious to me if you’re looking at it from an objective university president perspective. I know *fans* have an inherent bias against realignment moves that are perceived as valuing a large TV market over a smaller market fan base and/or on-the-field performance while certainly not liking either non-all-sports moves or geographic outliers, but those are fan-based concerns as opposed to university president concerns. NIU seems pretty strategic both for the long-term and short-term: if the old Pac-12 could get broken apart because of being too geographically concentrated in the West, then it stands to reason that non-power leagues can have the same problem. NIU has all of the geographic market advantages with good-to-great on-the-field performance as an actual FBS program (which can’t be underestimated).
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2024 11:31 AM by Frank the Tank.)
12-16-2024 11:26 AM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #823
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 09:45 AM)Shox Wrote:  Gotta remember that UNLV and likely Air Force will be gone in 5 years once the ransom payments are done. Better to bring on NDSU/SDSU/MT/MSU now to give them ramp up time.

Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

Presidents care about market audience, not total market size. But a program that is attracting a 4% market share in a top five market is not likely to lose its market niche, and has substantial head room if it makes a splash.

Now, 20% market share in a market a quarter the size is still a larger audience, but it's less head room. 50% market share in a market a tenth the size is still a larger audience, but it's even less head room.

And market audience is also partly determined by the channel and programming slot. At the level Go5 weekend audience sizes, the counter-programming benefit of having a 3:30pm ETZ game of more interest to MTZ/PTZ audiences than the slate of ETZ/CTZ games on offer is a noticeable media value boost ... even more at ETZ Prime Time, which for many ETZ/CTZ audiences will be their third college football game of the day but which for many MTZ/PTZ audiences will be their second. That is part of the premium that the present day MWC obtained for its inventory over what it would have received if a similar slate of college brand equities were located in the much more crowded ETZ.

That Saturday crowding of games of ETZ/CTZ interest is why the MAC and CUSA are being paid primarily for midweek October and November games, after regular season MLB content has shut down. If CUSA is being paid what it is getting for 4 ESPN2 midweek games, 4 ESPNU midweek games and 8+ CBSSN midweek games, then it is clear that with 7 ESPN2 midweek games, 6 ESPNU midweek games and 4 CBSSN midweek games, the MAC is going to arrive at a premium above the current CUSA, with the open questions being how big the premium will be and whether another sublicensing partner takes the place of CBSSN.

And scale of comparison does matter. While the mentions in local news that a Go5 school in a crowded big city market gets for their University for a National Championship in a subsidy sport, or a trip to Omaha, or being in the running for the (formerly) Access Bowl spot or (presently) CFP top 5 FBS spot might seem to some to be approximately zero, that is when scaled relative to the mentions that the sports of the power conference school(s) in the market. Relative to the mentions that that non-power-conference University might otherwise receive in that market -- where it is very expensive to buy mentions -- that is an appreciable amount of valuable exposure.
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2024 11:57 AM by BruceMcF.)
12-16-2024 11:48 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jacksfan29! Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,444
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Jackrabbits, Army, CU
Location: Colorado
Post: #824
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 09:45 AM)Shox Wrote:  Gotta remember that UNLV and likely Air Force will be gone in 5 years once the ransom payments are done. Better to bring on NDSU/SDSU/MT/MSU now to give them ramp up time.

Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.
12-16-2024 04:21 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,553
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #825
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The denial in here is incredible. Let’s put aside the Dakota schools and focus on the multitude of people pushing for New Mexico State to the MWC. Just going line by line with New Mexico State, NIU has had (1) significantly better on-the-field performance for the past 15 years, (2) #3 TV market, and (3) a major recruiting area for both athletes and students. Basically, the only real reason why people point to NMSU as a MWC candidate is reverting back to simplistic thinking of geography.

Ultimately, outside of the Boise State/Memphis-types, pretty much no other G5 program has much standing to think that they’re big-footing NIU, much less an FCS program. I just outlined all of the non-TV market reasons a few posts ago as to why NIU would be attractive. People don’t have to personally like it, but they’re being completely obtuse if they don’t understand it (or want to understand it).
(This post was last modified: 12-16-2024 06:52 PM by Frank the Tank.)
12-16-2024 06:50 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #826
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.
12-16-2024 06:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
FargoBison Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 363
Joined: Oct 2005
Reputation: 34
I Root For: NDSU and MN
Location: Fargo
Post: #827
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 11:01 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 09:45 AM)Shox Wrote:  Gotta remember that UNLV and likely Air Force will be gone in 5 years once the ransom payments are done. Better to bring on NDSU/SDSU/MT/MSU now to give them ramp up time.

Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illniois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

In my opinion it does come down to "fit". Problem anyone in the Dakotas have is who really wants them? Who do they fit with? Other Dakota's. maybe Montana.

I believe a school like ND State, if they want to be big time, if they want to control say the Dakota's market...then they need to act like it. Your stadium, go Indy at FBS, you have to go all in to separate yourself, not just win football games.

There are programs doing just that. Liberty for example. UTSA. These schools didnt care about their conference affiliation, who their rivalries were. UCF did it before them. Back in the 70's ECU did it.

Liberty had a mountain of cash to burn, NDSU doesn't and scheduling without a conference is going to make things incredibly difficult. Maybe NDSU could pull an SMU and say we'll take no conference revenue for x amount of years. Honestly, that might be what it takes since is appears the almighty dollar is what speaks to a lot of these conferences.
12-16-2024 07:12 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #828
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

We have a couple of ornery NDSU people here who just don't want to understand why taking an existing FBS school that has shown to be pretty good at football and is very near Chicago is more desirable than an FCS callup that's thrived on weak competition for decades and is nowhere close to any large clump of people.

What's the holdup on NIU making a decision? Are you guys just going to stay in the MAC?
12-16-2024 07:23 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,961
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3765
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #829
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 07:12 PM)FargoBison Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:01 AM)HP-TBDPITL Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:24 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Too many people aren’t thinking like university presidents in this thread.

There is nothing obvious to a university president about taking a FCS call-up and it’s *especially* not obvious when that FCS call-up is in a small market. That is how the university presidents view these things - the performance at the FCS level barely registers. Go back to the list posted elsewhere by bullet of the 23 schools that moved up from FCS to FBS since 2000: Western Kentucky had the *smallest* population state with Kentucky and that’s still 4.5 million people. Everyone that has moved up from FCS this century was in a large population state and/or market. The latest ones are Missouri State (large population state) and Delaware (directly located in the #4 TV market of Philadelphia).

It sucks because no school can control its location, but this has been a time and time again issue with conference realignment. People naturally want conferences to choose the school that might be in a small market but has a more rabid fan base and better performance, but those generally aren’t the ones chosen. Think like a university president.

University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illniois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

In my opinion it does come down to "fit". Problem anyone in the Dakotas have is who really wants them? Who do they fit with? Other Dakota's. maybe Montana.

I believe a school like ND State, if they want to be big time, if they want to control say the Dakota's market...then they need to act like it. Your stadium, go Indy at FBS, you have to go all in to separate yourself, not just win football games.

There are programs doing just that. Liberty for example. UTSA. These schools didnt care about their conference affiliation, who their rivalries were. UCF did it before them. Back in the 70's ECU did it.

Liberty had a mountain of cash to burn, NDSU doesn't and scheduling without a conference is going to make things incredibly difficult. Maybe NDSU could pull an SMU and say we'll take no conference revenue for x amount of years. Honestly, that might be what it takes since is appears the almighty dollar is what speaks to a lot of these conferences.

You say this as if it's a revelation instead of a human trait that's been evident to any who were paying attention for, well, for about as long as there have been conferences at all.
12-16-2024 07:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
nodak651 Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,313
Joined: Oct 2014
Reputation: 136
I Root For: North Dakota
Location:
Post: #830
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

Or it's group think.
12-17-2024 10:20 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
johnbragg Online
Five Minute Google Expert
*

Posts: 19,638
Joined: Dec 2011
Reputation: 1371
I Root For: St Johns
Location:
Post: #831
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-17-2024 10:20 AM)nodak651 Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

Or it's group think.

Athletic success comes and goes.
Endowment, location in a major metropolitan area endure.
If North Dakota State falls off athletically, they're still in North Dakota.
12-17-2024 10:38 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jacksfan29! Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,444
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Jackrabbits, Army, CU
Location: Colorado
Post: #832
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-17-2024 10:38 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-17-2024 10:20 AM)nodak651 Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

Or it's group think.

Athletic success comes and goes.
Endowment, location in a major metropolitan area endure.
If North Dakota State falls off athletically, they're still in North Dakota.

And they will still grab more viewers than NIU. And I'm not sure why endowment was brought up, but NIU's is a 1/3rd of NDSUs. Does anyone in Illinois actually care about NIU? Seems that answer is no.
12-17-2024 03:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
FargoBison Offline
2nd String
*

Posts: 363
Joined: Oct 2005
Reputation: 34
I Root For: NDSU and MN
Location: Fargo
Post: #833
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-17-2024 03:09 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-17-2024 10:38 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-17-2024 10:20 AM)nodak651 Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

Or it's group think.

Athletic success comes and goes.
Endowment, location in a major metropolitan area endure.
If North Dakota State falls off athletically, they're still in North Dakota.

And they will still grab more viewers than NIU. And I'm not sure why endowment was brought up, but NIU's is a 1/3rd of NDSUs. Does anyone in Illinois actually care about NIU? Seems that answer is no.

Yeah, NDSU's athletic endowment is closer to NIU's total endowment.

It is strange how people think NDSU is going to fall off a cliff if it goes FBS and turn into Idaho, I just don't get it.
12-17-2024 06:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,900
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #834
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 07:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

We have a couple of ornery NDSU people here who just don't want to understand why taking an existing FBS school that has shown to be pretty good at football and is very near Chicago is more desirable than an FCS callup that's thrived on weak competition for decades and is nowhere close to any large clump of people.

What's the holdup on NIU making a decision? Are you guys just going to stay in the MAC?

Decision makers just finished the semester and now are out skiing.
12-17-2024 08:38 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #835
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-17-2024 08:38 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 07:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

We have a couple of ornery NDSU people here who just don't want to understand why taking an existing FBS school that has shown to be pretty good at football and is very near Chicago is more desirable than an FCS callup that's thrived on weak competition for decades and is nowhere close to any large clump of people.

What's the holdup on NIU making a decision? Are you guys just going to stay in the MAC?

Decision makers just finished the semester and now are out skiing.

They deserve to hold their extravagant XMas and NYE parties. Those of us in the Chronically Online Community can sit behind our computers the next 3 weeks and wait.
12-17-2024 08:56 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,767
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #836
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-17-2024 08:38 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 07:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  ... What's the holdup on NIU making a decision? Are you guys just going to stay in the MAC?

Decision makers just finished the semester and now are out skiing.

To be clear, it isn't necessarily the case that key (eg) Horizon decision makers to formalize NIU's invite are out skiing.

Not all of them like to ski. Some might be at the beach in Rio.
12-19-2024 09:24 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BeatWestern! Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,681
Joined: Feb 2018
Reputation: 575
I Root For: Central Michigan
Location:
Post: #837
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 07:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

We have a couple of ornery NDSU people here who just don't want to understand why taking an existing FBS school that has shown to be pretty good at football and is very near Chicago is more desirable than an FCS callup that's thrived on weak competition for decades and is nowhere close to any large clump of people.

What's the holdup on NIU making a decision? Are you guys just going to stay in the MAC?

This could go either way. I would say 50/50, maybe 60/40 in favor of moving.

Keep an eye on the lawsuit filed by CSU/USU and recently joined by Boise State. Fresno State and SDSU are expected to file as well.

NIU also is reportedly having difficulty finding a home for its wrestling and women's gymnastics programs. For wrestling, the only potential landing spot is the Big 12, while the gymnastics program has the Big 12 or the Midwest Independent Conference that includes Illinois State, but is not recognized as a conference by the NCAA.

The MAC is expected to distribute approximately $2.5 million per school annually in media rights beginning next year once UMass joins. I would be very surprised if the MWC can increase its current distribution of $3.5 million per school in 2026 after it loses its top brands to the Pac.

Could NIU decide to leave the MAC for the MWC/Horizon League? Yes, absolutely, although many people, not just me, thinks it would be a mistake.

If the MAC does lose NIU, it could remain at 12, or add two schools to get to 14. We'll see how this shakes out in January.
12-19-2024 11:56 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jacksfan29! Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,444
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Jackrabbits, Army, CU
Location: Colorado
Post: #838
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:40 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  University presidents aren't known for being the most strategic or forward thinking types of individuals. Given that their tenure is typically 6-7 years, they are worried about NOW instead of what happens in the future.

Everyone can see that UNLV and Air Force are a flight risk. Instead of taking schools that could be foundational in nature for the next 20-30 years, they go for whatever is the quickest cash grab. They fail to think forward enough to think about what might make the MWC the best version of itself going forward from a competitive standpoint.

I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

I highly doubt TV executives are telling the MWC to grab a school with an athletic budget which falls in below the top 20 in FCS. My guess, they say get into the central time zone. NIU is likely the only G5 in the central who will consider moving to the MWC. The MWC has been turned down by the Texas schools and don't want CUSA schools, NIU is the last man standing. It has been reported by McFeely in North Dakota that the ADs wanted strong football programs, and were interested in the bigger FCS. The presidents of the MWC want a G5, which is fine, but lets see how the lawsuits being filed fall out. UNLV and Air Force were promised a lot of money to stay. If UNLV especially doesn't see that money, all bets are off and my guess, they file a lawsuit to nullify the agreement and run to the new PAC.
12-19-2024 01:02 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jacksfan29! Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,444
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 77
I Root For: Jackrabbits, Army, CU
Location: Colorado
Post: #839
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
(12-16-2024 07:23 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 06:54 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 04:21 PM)jacksfan29! Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 11:13 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:  
(12-16-2024 10:47 AM)johnbragg Wrote:  I dont think it's even about time horizons.

Best case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is like Northern Illinois in the MAC. Went to the CCG 9 times in the last 20 years, went in ranked 4 times, won 5 MAC titles, and to a rough approximation nobody noticed.

Worst case scenario, NDSU in the Mountain West is what Idaho used to be in FBS.

Meanwhile if you take a garbage FBS program in a large TV market, they'll always be an FBS program in a large TV market.

The large TV argument is so funny to me... I keep on hearing that NIU is in the Chicago market... Tell me what good the #3 Chicago market did for the MAC tv deal?

Also, the current MAC conference (including NIU) overall has larger markets than the new MWC including Cleveland/Akron #19, Grand Rapids/Kalamazoo #42, Buffalo #54, Toledo #80.

The new MWC which will be #10 SF/San Jose, #103 Reno, #40 Las Vegas, ABQ #49, Laramie #195, El Paso #89

Its obvious that TV executives don't only care about markets. If that was true, the MAC should be able to pick off football only schools from the MWC given their better overall markets and more access to players/recruiting.

Someone explain this to me like i'm 5 years old.

They can't and you are correct. If NIU was the Chicago market the MAC deal would be bigger than the current MWC, minus Boise of course. Why anyone would want NIU is beyond me. Low budget, failing school in massive debt bleeding students. They beat Notre Dame are current G5 and are in the central time zone. That seems to be the biggest reasons given.

The tv executives - who have significantly more data than anyone here - want the MWC to add NIU.

If NIU didn't bring more tv value relative to other options, then the tv executives would implore the MWC to add someone else.

We have a couple of ornery NDSU people here who just don't want to understand why taking an existing FBS school that has shown to be pretty good at football and is very near Chicago is more desirable than an FCS callup that's thrived on weak competition for decades and is nowhere close to any large clump of people.

What's the holdup on NIU making a decision? Are you guys just going to stay in the MAC?

Nah, I'm not an NDSU fan. By the way, that stronger FCS competition you speak of, were still around when NDSU were rolling up their first 5 titles. At least sound knowledgeable when speaking of the school. The reality, lost on those who can't see past their tiny corner of the world.
12-19-2024 01:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
HP-TBDPITL Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,529
Joined: Jun 2010
Reputation: 250
I Root For: College Sports
Location:
Post: #840
RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU
I think some folks need to understand the realities of markets. Why did the B1G add Rutgers?

Hint...it wasnt because of Rutgers. I'm not trying to demean Rutgers either.

It was because VERY valuable programs like Michigan, Ohio State and Penn State wanted exposure in the #1 TV market in the country.

That is also why Maryland is so valuable. Wash DC is the #8 tv market.

So, as you can see NIU is valuable. It was valuable for the MAC and it will be valuable for the MWC. With the MWC having a higher profile tv platform with higher profile other schools, it is more valuable to the MWC than it was to the MAC.

And just looking at that, you can see why redundancy is NOT valuable. If Ole Miss and Miss State were going into conferences today, you would not want them in the same conference.

For example Clemson is more valuable to the B1G than it is to the SEC.
12-19-2024 01:16 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.