![]() |
|
McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - Printable Version +- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com) +-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html) +--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html) +---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html) +---- Thread: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU (/thread-1000541.html) |
McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - solohawks - 11-06-2024 10:08 AM RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - Dr Dawgma III - 11-06-2024 10:18 AM This is the move. A market add at the G6 level is insignificant compared to adding a legitimate football machine like NDSU. Are they permitted to park Olympic sports in the Mid-Con, er, Summit? Next Boise State vibes anyone? RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - bullet - 11-06-2024 10:20 AM (11-06-2024 10:18 AM)esayem Wrote: This is the move. A market add at the G6 level is insignificant compared to adding a legitimate football machine like NDSU. Are they permitted to park Olympic sports in the Mid-Con, er, Summit? Georgia Southern was a football machine. Success at FCS is not a guarantee of anything. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - solohawks - 11-06-2024 10:21 AM Summit isn't a football league so there shouldn't be any issues about where NDSU plays football RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - solohawks - 11-06-2024 10:23 AM I gotta think this would be the best case scenario for NDSU Non football sports remain with the other Dakotas in about as travel friendly a conference as they can get while they move into the most regional FBS conference available to them RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - Dr Dawgma III - 11-06-2024 10:23 AM (11-06-2024 10:20 AM)bullet Wrote:(11-06-2024 10:18 AM)esayem Wrote: This is the move. A market add at the G6 level is insignificant compared to adding a legitimate football machine like NDSU. Are they permitted to park Olympic sports in the Mid-Con, er, Summit? Correct, but they also stopped running the option, which was their bread and butter. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - PeteTheChop - 11-06-2024 10:27 AM (11-06-2024 10:08 AM)solohawks Wrote: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU ![]() So many questions 1. So NIU's "interest as a FO member is waning" .... Did Toledo already pull the plug on this foolishness? Did Velarez tell the two MAC schools it's both or none? 2. Would it really just be NDSU and not SDSU? That would've been the G6 equivalent of taking Washington or Oregon as opposed to bringing each in as a much more sensible regional pair 3. Does the MWC have a 12/13 membership option on the table with NDSU, SDSU, Montana and Montana State all coming aboard? All four are absolutely G6 worthy and likely already would've moved up if not for geography challenges 4. What's up with UND and USD? RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - NDSUguy - 11-06-2024 10:28 AM (11-06-2024 10:23 AM)esayem Wrote:(11-06-2024 10:20 AM)bullet Wrote:(11-06-2024 10:18 AM)esayem Wrote: This is the move. A market add at the G6 level is insignificant compared to adding a legitimate football machine like NDSU. Are they permitted to park Olympic sports in the Mid-Con, er, Summit? Posted this elsewhere but here are the records of the last 15 schools to move from FCS to FBS. The most successful transitions were those schools who had a sustained success in FCS. The worst transitions were those who were in the FCS for less than 5 years. Western Kentucky: 104-89 (9 bowl games) Texas State: 48-97 (1 bowl game) UMass: 23-101 (0 bowl games) USTA: 80-69 (4 bowl games) South Alabama: 58-77 (2 bowl games) Georgia State: 51-83 (5 bowl games) App State: 95-35 (8 bowl games) Georgia Southern: 65-61 (6 bowl games) Old Dominion: 46-65 (4 bowl games) Charlotte:32-71 (1 bowl game) Coastal Carolina: 52-35 (4 bowl games) Liberty: 53-23 (5 bowl games) James Madison:19-5 (1 bowl game) Sam Houston: 3-9 (0 bowl games) Jacksonville State: 9-4 (1 bowl game) RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - The Beaver - 11-06-2024 10:28 AM Just foootball to the MWC makes a lot more sense than all sports to the MAC. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - bullet - 11-06-2024 10:33 AM (11-06-2024 10:28 AM)NDSUguy Wrote:(11-06-2024 10:23 AM)esayem Wrote:(11-06-2024 10:20 AM)bullet Wrote:(11-06-2024 10:18 AM)esayem Wrote: This is the move. A market add at the G6 level is insignificant compared to adding a legitimate football machine like NDSU. Are they permitted to park Olympic sports in the Mid-Con, er, Summit? UMass was doing very well before transitioning. UTSA, South Alabama, Georgia St., ODU and UNCC basically didn't have a program. App St. is 2-3 in Sun Belt this year. Sam Houston was just off an FCS title. And going further back, Idaho was better than Boise in FCS. ULM had a good bit of success in FCS before moving up. UCF basically didn't have a program. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - 1IvyDog - 11-06-2024 10:51 AM Crazy as it sounds I'm hearing NDSU wants all sports in the MW. The only difficult travel is Hawaii. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - Scoochpooch1 - 11-06-2024 11:08 AM (11-06-2024 10:18 AM)esayem Wrote: This is the move. A market add at the G6 level is insignificant compared to adding a legitimate football machine like NDSU. Are they permitted to park Olympic sports in the Mid-Con, er, Summit? Nah, end of their extreme football success, which would be great. They only started to succeed once many of the FCS powers left for FBS. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - NDSUguy - 11-06-2024 11:15 AM (11-06-2024 11:08 AM)Scoochpooch1 Wrote:(11-06-2024 10:18 AM)esayem Wrote: This is the move. A market add at the G6 level is insignificant compared to adding a legitimate football machine like NDSU. Are they permitted to park Olympic sports in the Mid-Con, er, Summit? This isn't true. If you're referencing Georgia Southern and App State, NDSU already won 3 championships before they left. After those departures, their primary challenger was James Madison and SHSU. They both left much later. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - quo vadis - 11-06-2024 11:19 AM FCS callups are silly, IMO, just dilute a conference's CFP share. But at least this makes way more geo-sense than NIU. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - bryanw1995 - 11-06-2024 11:32 AM (11-06-2024 10:45 AM)PeteTheChop Wrote: So Toledo and Northern Illinois were on the board for MWC Lite football Nos. 9 and 10. There was chatter about potential consequences for Conferences that were potentially moving up FCS schools in the wake of the Pac's moves a few months ago. I don't know exactly what they were, or even how they were worded, but the threat is there. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - RUScarlets - 11-06-2024 11:34 AM Dead man walking conference. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - HawaiiMongoose - 11-06-2024 11:37 AM (11-06-2024 10:51 AM)1IvyDog Wrote: Crazy as it sounds I'm hearing NDSU wants all sports in the MW. The only difficult travel is Hawaii. That would be dumb for all parties. NDSU as a football-only addition makes sense. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - bullet - 11-06-2024 11:42 AM (11-06-2024 11:19 AM)quo vadis Wrote: FCS callups are silly, IMO, just dilute a conference's CFP share. Yeah. They need to be patient if they don't want NMSU. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - PicksUp - 11-06-2024 11:49 AM (11-06-2024 11:37 AM)HawaiiMongoose Wrote:Agree. They already have a good home for their olympic sports in the Summit.(11-06-2024 10:51 AM)1IvyDog Wrote: Crazy as it sounds I'm hearing NDSU wants all sports in the MW. The only difficult travel is Hawaii. RE: McMurphy - MWC pivoting to NDSU - HawaiiMongoose - 11-06-2024 11:51 AM (11-06-2024 10:45 AM)PeteTheChop Wrote: But why on Earth does only NDSU get an opportunity to move up while the two-time defending I-AA champions a couple hours down I-29 get left behind? According to the U.S. DOE's Equity in Athletics database, the average 2022-23 athletic budget of schools committed the MWC beyond 2026 was $46.6 million. NDSU's athletic budget that academic year was $30.3 million. SDSU's was only $24.2 million. I think the increased ongoing financial commitment required to play at the FBS level may just be more than SDSU can handle right now. Also NDSU has won several more FCS titles than SDSU in recent years and is probably more psychologically ready to move on and try something new. |