Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
Chances that non-SEC teams earn byes, given finish. There are just so many SEC permutations that I didn't list them
93% 12-1 Miami
86% 12-1 Wake Forest
79% 11-1 Notre Dame
14% 11-2 Miami (Champ)
100% 13-0 Utah
73% 12-1 Utah (CG Loss) - reminds me of TCU a few years back who was better off losing in Arlington than in the regular season
60% 12-1 Texas Tech
55% 12-1 Utah (Champ)
28% 11-2 BYU
100% 13-0 UCLA
77% 12-1 UCLA (Champ)
71% 12-1 Indiana
39% 11-2 USC
27% 12-1 UCLA (CG Loss)
11% 10-3 Oregon
(This post was last modified: 11-12-2026 12:38 PM by Crayton.)
|
|
| 11-12-2026 12:36 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 12:25 PM)Crayton Wrote: (11-12-2026 11:55 AM)bullet Wrote: Biggest differences Massey composite vs. CFP
LSU -11
Ole Miss -8
Ohio St. -8
BYU +7
Houston +5
Oklahoma St. +4
Texas Tech +4
Kentucky +4
UCLA, Iowa, USC, South Carolina +3
And Oklahoma is #25, but is unrated by the CFP.
Wow. That is a big Big 12 bias (one way or the other). I kinda swing toward the CFP for the top few and then toward Massey after that.
There are things computers can't take into account. But humans tend to focus on a very limited data set, especially the number of losses. I don't think BYU is that far off. But Kentucky and Oklahoma St. are probably overrated. Ohio St. is a case of them evaluating Ohio St. without Sayin. I do think LSU and Ole Miss got punished too much for their losses, but I don't see them as top 11 at this point.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 12:59 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 12:59 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-12-2026 12:25 PM)Crayton Wrote: (11-12-2026 11:55 AM)bullet Wrote: Biggest differences Massey composite vs. CFP
LSU -11
Ole Miss -8
Ohio St. -8
BYU +7
Houston +5
Oklahoma St. +4
Texas Tech +4
Kentucky +4
UCLA, Iowa, USC, South Carolina +3
And Oklahoma is #25, but is unrated by the CFP.
Wow. That is a big Big 12 bias (one way or the other). I kinda swing toward the CFP for the top few and then toward Massey after that.
There are things computers can't take into account. But humans tend to focus on a very limited data set, especially the number of losses. I don't think BYU is that far off. But Kentucky and Oklahoma St. are probably overrated. Ohio St. is a case of them evaluating Ohio St. without Sayin. I do think LSU and Ole Miss got punished too much for their losses, but I don't see them as top 11 at this point.
If I were an LSU or Miss (or even Buckeye) fan I wouldn’t be too worried with the drops. Humans overweight recency; if those teams win out they’ll be re-evaluated and given benefit of the doubt over teams who close out the season with a loss.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 01:44 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,983
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 04:08 PM)ken d Wrote: (11-11-2026 12:20 PM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:46 AM)dbackjon Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:30 AM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:39 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: I'm happy to see SOS get more attention these days, but it feels like whiplash. Consider:
2024, 2025: B1G AD is CFP Commissioner, all they care about is Ws and Ls
2026: SEC AD is CFP Commissioner, all of a sudden SOS is really important again
PICK A FREAKING CRITERIA AND STICK TO IT.
the outlier was really 2024 and 2025. Thru the entire CFP time. Warde Manuel tried to change things.
Of course the SEC homer would say that
of course Big Ten Fanboy would try to defend how Warde Manuel tried to change things. The outlier thru this entire time with the CFP committee was the last 2 years. Amd that includes times with guys like Barry Alvarez from Wisconsin on the committee. You have to look at SOS and not just ignore it like the committee the last 2 years did.
Unless one of us was actually in the room with the committee when they discussed their picks, we have no way of knowing what criteria they considered and what they ignored and how much weight they gave to each criterion. They have a thankless task, because they will be criticized by somebody regardless of what they do, simply because some fans will disagree with the outcome.
As for how much weight to give to head to head, here's a conundrum for you. Let's say that thanks to some quirk of scheduling, Georgia, Utah and Alabama all played each other in the regular season. In those games, Georgia beat Alabama, Alabama beat Utah, and Utah beat Georgia, all by comparable margins. And none lost to anyone else. How should the committee rank them?
Great example of a good time to look at everything else since h2h and W/L are exactly the same.
Who had the toughest schedule?
Who performed the best during their wins?
SOR
FPI
MC
I’d even look at the human polls
Whose conference was toughest?
Who played the best OOC schedule?
Did anyone have 11 P4 opponents? Or 9?
The issue is not that we lack things to evaluate schools, it’s that we sometimes over rate the importance of looking good against bad teams or not giving enough attention to a h2h win, especially a h2h blowout like Tennessee inflicted on Alabama.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 03:45 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 03:45 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: The issue is not that we lack things to evaluate schools, it’s that we sometimes over rate the importance of looking good against bad teams or not giving enough attention to a h2h win, especially a h2h blowout like Tennessee inflicted on Alabama.
I’ll opine that the “issue” is that whatever ‘is’ used is not used consistently team-to-team or week-to-week.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 06:29 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,983
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 12:59 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-12-2026 12:25 PM)Crayton Wrote: (11-12-2026 11:55 AM)bullet Wrote: Biggest differences Massey composite vs. CFP
LSU -11
Ole Miss -8
Ohio St. -8
BYU +7
Houston +5
Oklahoma St. +4
Texas Tech +4
Kentucky +4
UCLA, Iowa, USC, South Carolina +3
And Oklahoma is #25, but is unrated by the CFP.
Wow. That is a big Big 12 bias (one way or the other). I kinda swing toward the CFP for the top few and then toward Massey after that.
There are things computers can't take into account. But humans tend to focus on a very limited data set, especially the number of losses. I don't think BYU is that far off. But Kentucky and Oklahoma St. are probably overrated. Ohio St. is a case of them evaluating Ohio St. without Sayin. I do think LSU and Ole Miss got punished too much for their losses, but I don't see them as top 11 at this point.
If BYU is 11-2 then they’re Big 12 champs, very likely with 2 top 10 or even top 5 wins. Getting them to 11-2 takes some doing ofc, but if they get there, they have a decent shot at a bye.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 06:42 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,983
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 06:29 PM)Crayton Wrote: (11-12-2026 03:45 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: The issue is not that we lack things to evaluate schools, it’s that we sometimes over rate the importance of looking good against bad teams or not giving enough attention to a h2h win, especially a h2h blowout like Tennessee inflicted on Alabama.
I’ll opine that the “issue” is that whatever ‘is’ used is not used consistently team-to-team or week-to-week.
+3
|
|
| 11-12-2026 06:46 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 06:29 PM)Crayton Wrote: (11-12-2026 03:45 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: The issue is not that we lack things to evaluate schools, it’s that we sometimes over rate the importance of looking good against bad teams or not giving enough attention to a h2h win, especially a h2h blowout like Tennessee inflicted on Alabama.
I’ll opine that the “issue” is that whatever ‘is’ used is not used consistently team-to-team or week-to-week.
Its not unusual for them to give the exact opposite reason the following week!
|
|
| 11-12-2026 09:22 PM |
|
Just Joe
1st String

Posts: 1,884
Joined: Oct 2020
Reputation: 400
I Root For: Bama
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
It’s silly for anyone to give any special credit (or blame) to a particular year’s committee based on who the chair is. They don’t have an extra vote and just get tasked with defending a muddy consensus on TV every week even if they don’t agree with it.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 10:52 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,990
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13538
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 09:22 PM)bullet Wrote: (11-12-2026 06:29 PM)Crayton Wrote: (11-12-2026 03:45 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: The issue is not that we lack things to evaluate schools, it’s that we sometimes over rate the importance of looking good against bad teams or not giving enough attention to a h2h win, especially a h2h blowout like Tennessee inflicted on Alabama.
I’ll opine that the “issue” is that whatever ‘is’ used is not used consistently team-to-team or week-to-week.
Its not unusual for them to give the exact opposite reason the following week!
Bullet, the decisions are made and then the reasons for them are made up. They've been doing this all along.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 11:14 PM |
|
tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
|
|
| 11-13-2026 07:40 AM |
|
jmu98
All American

Posts: 4,875
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 85
I Root For: JMU
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
Yes, they keep inferring that MSU was a t full strength, but conveniently leave out that Taylor was obviously hobbling in that game and Fluff Bothwell I think had one carry in the game.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 08:15 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,983
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3771
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 10:52 PM)Just Joe Wrote: It’s silly for anyone to give any special credit (or blame) to a particular year’s committee based on who the chair is. They don’t have an extra vote and just get tasked with defending a muddy consensus on TV every week even if they don’t agree with it.
I used to think that, but Manuel seemed to have an outsized influence in 24-25, and Yuracek seems to have a similarly outsized influence this year. Might just be coincidence ofc, or perhaps a reaction in 2026 to perceived poor decisions in 24-25, or perhaps as you said it's just that Manuel was falling back on his belief that W/L are all that matter and Yuracek falling back on his belief that SOS is more important to defend a process that they ultimately didn't have all that much influence on.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 08:45 AM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
well even if Mississippi St isn't a quality win now, South Carolina is a quality win now.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 10:27 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
Well the computers have Alabama higher than the committee.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 11:20 AM |
|
GoodOwl
The 1 Hoo Knocks

Posts: 29,362
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 4935
I Root For: New Horizons
Location: Planiverse
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
well, they 'earned' it over the years of bias, right?
|
|
| 11-13-2026 11:34 AM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 11:20 AM)bullet Wrote: (11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
Well the computers have Alabama higher than the committee.
pesky little details.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 01:02 PM |
|
tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 01:02 PM)stever20 Wrote: (11-13-2026 11:20 AM)bullet Wrote: (11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
Well the computers have Alabama higher than the committee.
pesky little details.
They also have two losses. They're the only team on track for a first round bye with two losses, and one of only two two-loss teams ranked higher than #9 (Texas is the other).
Further, they also have a double digit loss in a game which, if anything, probably wasn't even as close as the final score. Fwiw, the only other team on pace to reach the CFP with a double digit loss is Kentucky (which has two of them, but they would be the last team in if the season ended today).
|
|
| 11-13-2026 02:06 PM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 02:06 PM)tf8693 Wrote: (11-13-2026 01:02 PM)stever20 Wrote: (11-13-2026 11:20 AM)bullet Wrote: (11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
Well the computers have Alabama higher than the committee.
pesky little details.
They also have two losses. They're the only team on track for a first round bye with two losses, and one of only two two-loss teams ranked higher than #9 (Texas is the other).
Further, they also have a double digit loss in a game which, if anything, probably wasn't even as close as the final score. Fwiw, the only other team on pace to reach the CFP with a double digit loss is Kentucky (which has two of them, but they would be the last team in if the season ended today).
They also have a loss where the officials totally botched a call.
Meanwhile you have teams like Indiana with 1 loss who haven't played anyone all year long.
|
|
| 11-13-2026 02:19 PM |
|
tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,902
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-13-2026 11:20 AM)bullet Wrote: (11-13-2026 07:40 AM)tf8693 Wrote: There's definitely a pro-Alabama bias in the CFP Committee. This week Yurachek was STILL citing Alabama's win over Mississippi State as a *quality win,* even though Mississippi State's season has hit the skids (they're currently 4-5).
Well the computers have Alabama higher than the committee.
Not all of them.
I looked up the computers that were used during the BCS rankings. This is how they stack up as of right now:
Massey: 2
Sagarin: 2
Colley: 6
Wolfe: 6
Billingsley: 8
Anderson and Hester doesn't have any published rankings for this season, at least not that I could find. That's an average ranking of 4.8. If you throw out the highest and lowest ranking, as the BCS used to do, that's 4.67, a negligible difference.
By comparison, Notre Dame actually has a higher average computer ranking:
Massey: 3
Sagarin: 3
Billingsley: 4
Wolfe: 4
Colley: 7
That's an average of 4.2. Throw out the low and high outliers, and the average is 3.67.
(This post was last modified: 11-13-2026 02:25 PM by tf8693.)
|
|
| 11-13-2026 02:20 PM |
|