(11-11-2026 11:26 AM)dbackjon Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:21 AM)ken d Wrote: (11-10-2026 10:12 PM)The Beaver Wrote: Alabama's two ranked wins were 14 LSU and 16 Mississippi State. That definitely entitles them to be ranked over Tennessee, who beat them (6th) and Kentucky, who were also laughably ranked 6th..
Alabama beat 3 ranked teams:
@#11 Kentucky 45-17
#17 South Carolina 49-18
@#21 LSU 31-13
They lost to 2 ranked teams:
#1 Georgia 20-17
@#8 Tennessee 26-10
Should they be ranked behind Miami, whose only ranked win was Wake Forest (33-20) or Notre Dame whose only ranked win was Miami (31-24)?
And honestly, the only team Alabama beat that SHOULD be ranked is Kentucky, and they should be in the 15-20 range.
MC has LSU at 10, Kentucky at 15, and USCe at 20 - avg ranking 15
AP has LSU at 24, Kentucky 13, USCe 20 - avg ranking 19
Coaches poll has LSU 22, Kentucky 13, USCe 24 - avg ranking 19.7
CFP has LSU 21, Kentucky 11, USCe 17 - avg ranking 16.3
Overall avg ranking between those 4 is 17.5. They all agree that all 3 teams should be ranked, and there isn't even that much disagreement over where they should be ranked. Additionally, all 4 of the rankings listed above have Georgia at #1 and Tennessee also in the top 10 (pretty close to #10 for all 4).
I get that you disagree with the CFP b/c of your perception of SEC bias, but you should aim some of your ire at the coaches, AP voters, and the 40-something computer ranking systems that make up the MC. All of them agree that Alabama has played 5 ranked teams, beaten the crap out of 3 of them, and only really looked bad against Tennessee. In a year like this with so much parity, that's a very impressive resume. In past years, perhaps with OSU, Michigan, Georgia, Clemson and Florida all having solid years, perhaps not so much, but this is a really weird year. Consider the resumes of those around Alabama:
Georgia - consensus #1
Utah - #2 in all 3 human polls, #4 in MC - solid #2, pretty low SOS in mid 60s however
UCLA - #4 in all 3 human polls, #7 in MC - avg rating of 4.75 same SOS basically as Utah
ND - 3 in AP, Coaches and MC, #5 in CFP - avg rating of 3.75 1-1 against current top 10 teams and 33 SOS, nobody can complain about ND has faced on the field or accomplished this year
I think that you could make a very strong case that all 4 of those schools should be ahead of Alabama, and I would have all 4 of them ahead, but the next 5 are Texas, Miami, Tennessee, BYU and Indiana. I'd say that Alabama has clearly been better than all of those teams except ofc for the H2H vs Tennessee, so let's look at Tennessee's ranked opponents and their record against them:
lost by 3 @ current #7 Texas
lost by 3 @ current #17 USCe
beat by 16 #3 Alabama
beat by 28 #11 Kentucky
Tennessee has a 2-2 record against ranked teams, both losses were by 3 points on the road and both wins were blowouts. Alabama has huge blowouts against 3 ranked teams but the 2 highest ranked opponents beat them by 3 (understandable) and 16 (harder to understand).
Taking all of the above into account, I think that I'd probably have Tennessee 5 and Alabama 6. The only real difference between Alabama and Tennessee today is a nice win against ~ #20 ish LSU for Alabama, hardly seems like enough to put 5 spots in between Alabama and Tennessee. Ofc, Alabama gets to coast in from here with 3 of the easiest possible games for an SEC team this year, while Tennessee still has LSU and A&M (somehow considered a quality win, whatever). If both win out then I think they'll be ranked adjacent to each other, with Tennessee jumping ahead of Alabama, just like ND was jumped by Miami at the end in 2025.
#5 or #6 is a far cry from disparaging all 5 of Alabama's ranked opponents, and it's not THAT far off from the #3 that they're sitting at today.