stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 04:44 PM)ken d Wrote: (11-11-2026 04:37 PM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 04:08 PM)ken d Wrote: (11-11-2026 12:20 PM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:46 AM)dbackjon Wrote: Of course the SEC homer would say that
of course Big Ten Fanboy would try to defend how Warde Manuel tried to change things. The outlier thru this entire time with the CFP committee was the last 2 years. Amd that includes times with guys like Barry Alvarez from Wisconsin on the committee. You have to look at SOS and not just ignore it like the committee the last 2 years did.
Unless one of us was actually in the room with the committee when they discussed their picks, we have no way of knowing what criteria they considered and what they ignored and how much weight they gave to each criterion. They have a thankless task, because they will be criticized by somebody regardless of what they do, simply because some fans will disagree with the outcome.
As for how much weight to give to head to head, here's a conundrum for you. Let's say that thanks to some quirk of scheduling, Georgia, Utah and Alabama all played each other in the regular season. In those games, Georgia beat Alabama, Alabama beat Utah, and Utah beat Georgia, all by comparable margins. And none lost to anyone else. How should the committee rank them?
Manual absolutely said it out loud 2 years ago.
And how many votes did he have?
he was the leader of the committee. He basically shut things down when folks tried to use SOS.
His committee was absolutely the biggest outlier we've seen in the 13 years of the CFP now.
|
|
| 11-11-2026 04:53 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 11:30 AM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:39 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:59 AM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:49 AM)SoCalBobcat78 Wrote: (11-11-2026 08:58 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote: Few things which hurt UCLA. The early season struggle with San Diego St when Toledo had less issues.
Best win is against and average at best Oregon team. Only SC left who is decent doesnt offer a chance to show how good your playing. Also give then a great chance of going undefeated.
Does it really matter if your goal is a championship you have to beat everyone and at least being in a P2 or M2 conference you are allowed in the CFP. The ones who will get screwed are the good G6 teams who the P2 and M2 are scared to play and will not be given a chance.
Oregon is not "average at best." Oregon is ranked 16th in the nation in the CFP Rankings with victories at USC and at Ohio State. UCLA beat San Diego State 28-10. They were 13.5 points favorites in that game. They have covered the point spread in every game. They have beat expectations in every game.
UCLA is playing the schedule that the Big Ten gave them. They didn't play any FCS schools, they will play ten power conference schools, and they are ranked No. 1 in the ESPN SOR. I can't explain why San Diego State played so poorly against Toledo. It happens. Things can snowball in a game. But that has nothing to do with UCLA.
For G6 schools, you play the schedule you get, and you hope for the best. If you are a school like Liberty and you have no P4 schools on your schedule and the CUSA schedule is light, then 8-1 is not the same as 8-1 in another G6 conference. Alabama is 7-2 and ranked 3rd because of their schedule.
it's still your schedule. Oregon is the ONLY team you've played. Sorry but to most folks in the non Warde Manuel world- that has to matter. And it is. Finally the committee has gotten back to care about SOS like it had in all the years really except for the 1st 2 in the 12 team playoff.
I'm happy to see SOS get more attention these days, but it feels like whiplash. Consider:
2024, 2025: B1G AD is CFP Commissioner, all they care about is Ws and Ls
2026: SEC AD is CFP Commissioner, all of a sudden SOS is really important again
PICK A FREAKING CRITERIA AND STICK TO IT.
the outlier was really 2024 and 2025. Thru the entire CFP time. Warde Manuel tried to change things.
I don't know who did it, but it was an outlier. Didn't feel like they cared if you played a G5 schedule or P4.
|
|
| 11-11-2026 05:16 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 12:24 PM)cubucks Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:37 AM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:26 AM)cubucks Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:39 AM)b2b Wrote: Conference ___ vs. SEC ___ vs. Big Ten ___ vs. ACC ___ vs. Big 12 ___ Overall vs. P4
SEC_________________________2–1 _______5–0 _______3–1_______10–2
Big 12 ___________1–3 ________2–1 _______3–2 __________________6–7
ACC _____________0–5 ________4–1___________________2–3_______6–9
Big Ten __________1–2 ___________________1–4 ________ 1–2 ______4–9
Sweet! Now do the records in the CFP the last 3 years. Teams in September aren't the same as they are in November. Just my opinion.
This is a different year. This years Big Ten isn't the same as the past few years. I think any knowledgable Big Ten person would agree with that.
New year but same SEC bias. My knowledge comes from demonstrated results from the past 3 seasons. Your points cool though; let's place an abundant amount of teams from one conference in the playoffs so they can get their butts beat and not even compete in the title game.
Talk about bias, you only want to look at the best team. Remember IU and Oregon getting destroyed in 2024? Oregon was down 34-0 just before half. Yes, it was to another Big Ten team, the best team that year. The only school that threatened them was Texas from the SEC, who was in the red zone down 7 in the closing minutes before a fumble and defensive score.
Remember the year before when Alabama and Michigan went to OT?
And in 2025, Ohio St. lost its first game to Miami by 10. Ole Miss and Texas A&M gave Miami very close games. IU was the best team and rolled everyone until Miami in the final, including Oregon by 34.
|
|
| 11-11-2026 05:23 PM |
|
IWokeUpLikeThis
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
Fire the committee. Reinstall Warde Manuel.
|
|
| 11-11-2026 05:25 PM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 04:08 PM)ken d Wrote: (11-11-2026 12:20 PM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:46 AM)dbackjon Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:30 AM)stever20 Wrote: (11-11-2026 10:39 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote: I'm happy to see SOS get more attention these days, but it feels like whiplash. Consider:
2024, 2025: B1G AD is CFP Commissioner, all they care about is Ws and Ls
2026: SEC AD is CFP Commissioner, all of a sudden SOS is really important again
PICK A FREAKING CRITERIA AND STICK TO IT.
the outlier was really 2024 and 2025. Thru the entire CFP time. Warde Manuel tried to change things.
Of course the SEC homer would say that
of course Big Ten Fanboy would try to defend how Warde Manuel tried to change things. The outlier thru this entire time with the CFP committee was the last 2 years. Amd that includes times with guys like Barry Alvarez from Wisconsin on the committee. You have to look at SOS and not just ignore it like the committee the last 2 years did.
Unless one of us was actually in the room with the committee when they discussed their picks, we have no way of knowing what criteria they considered and what they ignored and how much weight they gave to each criterion. They have a thankless task, because they will be criticized by somebody regardless of what they do, simply because some fans will disagree with the outcome.
As for how much weight to give to head to head, here's a conundrum for you. Let's say that thanks to some quirk of scheduling, Georgia, Utah and Alabama all played each other in the regular season. In those games, Georgia beat Alabama, Alabama beat Utah, and Utah beat Georgia, all by comparable margins. And none lost to anyone else. How should the committee rank them?
You don't need to be in the room. You look at the results. SMU really had no business being in during 2024 and Clemson was underrated. Indiana was probably overrated as they played a G level SOS. James Madison had no business being in during 2025.
|
|
| 11-11-2026 05:27 PM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 11:26 AM)cubucks Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:39 AM)b2b Wrote: Conference ___ vs. SEC ___ vs. Big Ten ___ vs. ACC ___ vs. Big 12 ___ Overall vs. P4
SEC_________________________2–1 _______5–0 _______3–1_______10–2
Big 12 ___________1–3 ________2–1 _______3–2 __________________6–7
ACC _____________0–5 ________4–1___________________2–3_______6–9
Big Ten __________1–2 ___________________1–4 ________ 1–2 ______4–9
Sweet! Now do the records in the CFP the last 3 years. Teams in September aren't the same as they are in November. Just my opinion.
I agree. The thing is though, IMO teams in November that played tough schedules are a lot more worn out and banged up than teams that played soft schedules. Indiana has been fresh for the playoffs, and Georgia has been out of gas, because of those schedules.
|
|
| 11-11-2026 06:08 PM |
|
IWokeUpLikeThis
Hall of Famer

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 06:08 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:26 AM)cubucks Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:39 AM)b2b Wrote: Conference ___ vs. SEC ___ vs. Big Ten ___ vs. ACC ___ vs. Big 12 ___ Overall vs. P4
SEC_________________________2–1 _______5–0 _______3–1_______10–2
Big 12 ___________1–3 ________2–1 _______3–2 __________________6–7
ACC _____________0–5 ________4–1___________________2–3_______6–9
Big Ten __________1–2 ___________________1–4 ________ 1–2 ______4–9
Sweet! Now do the records in the CFP the last 3 years. Teams in September aren't the same as they are in November. Just my opinion.
I agree. The thing is though, IMO teams in November that played tough schedules are a lot more worn out and banged up than teams that played soft schedules. Indiana has been fresh for the playoffs, and Georgia has been out of gas, because of those schedules.
They need to play the CFP in September to neutralize the disadvantage the SEC has. Regular season can follow in October thru January.
|
|
| 11-11-2026 06:10 PM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-11-2026 06:10 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote: (11-11-2026 06:08 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (11-11-2026 11:26 AM)cubucks Wrote: (11-11-2026 09:39 AM)b2b Wrote: Conference ___ vs. SEC ___ vs. Big Ten ___ vs. ACC ___ vs. Big 12 ___ Overall vs. P4
SEC_________________________2–1 _______5–0 _______3–1_______10–2
Big 12 ___________1–3 ________2–1 _______3–2 __________________6–7
ACC _____________0–5 ________4–1___________________2–3_______6–9
Big Ten __________1–2 ___________________1–4 ________ 1–2 ______4–9
Sweet! Now do the records in the CFP the last 3 years. Teams in September aren't the same as they are in November. Just my opinion.
I agree. The thing is though, IMO teams in November that played tough schedules are a lot more worn out and banged up than teams that played soft schedules. Indiana has been fresh for the playoffs, and Georgia has been out of gas, because of those schedules.
They need to play the CFP in September to neutralize the disadvantage the SEC has. Regular season can follow in October thru January.
I really think it's a factor. In the NFL, NBA or anything else with playoffs, teams play the same schedules, but in CFB there can be dramatic differences. And you do get more banged up and worn out playing other highly-talented teams than you do playing easy teams.
I think it helped Clemson 10 years ago, when Dabo had his super-teams. They could rest and prepare for the playoffs starting in late October, because the ACC schedule was so easy. SEC contenders didn't have the luxury.
(This post was last modified: 11-11-2026 06:21 PM by quo vadis.)
|
|
| 11-11-2026 06:18 PM |
|
schmolik
CSNBB's Big 10 Cheerleader

Posts: 12,649
Joined: Sep 2019
Reputation: 1106
I Root For: UIUC, PSU, Nova
Location: Philadelphia Suburbs
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
Missouri vs. Illinois the last 3 years...
https://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/1x...he_last_3/
Overall record |24-11 |25-10
vs. teams ranked at kickoff |2-11 |5-5
vs. teams that finished ranked |0-10 |3-5
vs Other P4 Teams |4-1 |4-1
Weeks in CFP Top 25 |10 |5
Illinois has the better overall record and record against ranked teams (and is also 2-0 vs the SEC).
Missouri hasn’t beaten a single team that finished the season ranked in three years.
Despite that, Missouri has had twice as many weeks in the committee’s top 25... AND IS STILL IN THE CURRENT TOP 25.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 05:32 AM |
|
thrill_house
1st String

Posts: 1,126
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
They've still got 3 weeks until rankings actually matter.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 06:04 AM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 05:32 AM)schmolik Wrote: Missouri vs. Illinois the last 3 years...
https://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/1x...he_last_3/
Overall record |24-11 |25-10
vs. teams ranked at kickoff |2-11 |5-5
vs. teams that finished ranked |0-10 |3-5
vs Other P4 Teams |4-1 |4-1
Weeks in CFP Top 25 |10 |5
Illinois has the better overall record and record against ranked teams (and is also 2-0 vs the SEC).
Missouri hasn’t beaten a single team that finished the season ranked in three years.
Despite that, Missouri has had twice as many weeks in the committee’s top 25... AND IS STILL IN THE CURRENT TOP 25.
I just checked the Massey Composite and Illinois is #36 while Missouri is #24. That's a pretty big gap. In FPI Missouri is #25 while Illinois is #43. So both say Missouri is a 20-something CFP team while Illinois is far away from that.
I suspect Missouri is typically ranked ahead of Illinois on these kinds of power rankings.
(This post was last modified: 11-12-2026 09:01 AM by quo vadis.)
|
|
| 11-12-2026 08:58 AM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 05:32 AM)schmolik Wrote: Missouri vs. Illinois the last 3 years...
https://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/1x...he_last_3/
Overall record |24-11 |25-10
vs. teams ranked at kickoff |2-11 |5-5
vs. teams that finished ranked |0-10 |3-5
vs Other P4 Teams |4-1 |4-1
Weeks in CFP Top 25 |10 |5
Illinois has the better overall record and record against ranked teams (and is also 2-0 vs the SEC).
Missouri hasn’t beaten a single team that finished the season ranked in three years.
Despite that, Missouri has had twice as many weeks in the committee’s top 25... AND IS STILL IN THE CURRENT TOP 25.
1 team with not a single loss against an unranked team, vs a team with 5 unranked losses.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 09:49 AM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
I think weighting SOS is important, but I'm not sure Alabama over UCLA isn't a bridge too far. It seems the Committee is devaluing the Tide's losses, perhaps for reasons of injury. Here are two Top 10s I like that are primarily by SOR:
Crayton SOR / Power
1) 1969 / 1714 - Utah (9-0) W1
2) 1930 / 1686 - UCLA (9-0) W1
3) 1927 / 1790 - Georgia (8-1) W2
4) 1908 / 1792 - Alabama (7-2) W3
5) 1907 / 1753 - Notre Dame (8-1) W7
6) 1906 / 1744 - Miami (8-1) L-5
7) 1898 / 1744 - Texas (7-2) W-1
8) 1848 / 1724 - Tennessee (7-2) W9
9) 1849 / 1671 - Indiana (8-1) X-5
10) 1845 / 1646 - Kentucky (7-2) L-1
ESPN SOR:
1 UCLA
2 Georgia
3 Miami
4 Utah
5 Alabama
6 Kentucky
7 Notre Dame
8 Indiana
9 Texas
10 Wake Forest
I like mine better, with Bama a spot higher and Tennessee (not Wake Forest) in the mix. Note that both have UCLA above Alabama.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 11:00 AM |
|
stever20
Legend

Posts: 50,367
Joined: Nov 2011
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Hoyas
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 11:00 AM)Crayton Wrote: I think weighting SOS is important, but I'm not sure Alabama over UCLA isn't a bridge too far. It seems the Committee is devaluing the Tide's losses, perhaps for reasons of injury. Here are two Top 10s I like that are primarily by SOR:
Crayton SOR / Power
1) 1969 / 1714 - Utah (9-0) W1
2) 1930 / 1686 - UCLA (9-0) W1
3) 1927 / 1790 - Georgia (8-1) W2
4) 1908 / 1792 - Alabama (7-2) W3
5) 1907 / 1753 - Notre Dame (8-1) W7
6) 1906 / 1744 - Miami (8-1) L-5
7) 1898 / 1744 - Texas (7-2) W-1
8) 1848 / 1724 - Tennessee (7-2) W9
9) 1849 / 1671 - Indiana (8-1) X-5
10) 1845 / 1646 - Kentucky (7-2) L-1
ESPN SOR:
1 UCLA
2 Georgia
3 Miami
4 Utah
5 Alabama
6 Kentucky
7 Notre Dame
8 Indiana
9 Texas
10 Wake Forest
I like mine better, with Bama a spot higher and Tennessee (not Wake Forest) in the mix. Note that both have UCLA above Alabama.
Might have had something to do with the Georgia loss with that bogus no call PI at the end of the game- if that's called correctly, Alabama has the ball inside the 10 yard line with a real chance to win that game.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 11:10 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
Massey (CFP)
1. Georgia (1)
2. Alabama (3)
3. Notre Dame (5)
4. Utah (2)
5. Miami (7)
6. Texas (6)
7. UCLA (4)
8. Indiana (9)
9. Tennessee (8)
10.LSU (21)
11.Ole Miss (19)
12.Ohio St. (20)
13.Wake Forest (13)
14.Oregon (16)
15.Kentucky (11)
16.Texas Tech (12)
17. BYU (10)
18.Iowa (15)
19. Houston (14)
20.South Carolina (17)
21. USC (18)
22.Boise (24)
23.Arizona(23)
24.Missouri(22)
25.Oklahoma (U)
26.Wisconsin (U)
27.Louisville (U)
28.Florida (U)
29.Oklahoma St. (25)
30.Duke (U)
|
|
| 11-12-2026 11:17 AM |
|
PicksUp
All American

Posts: 3,616
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 09:49 AM)stever20 Wrote: (11-12-2026 05:32 AM)schmolik Wrote: Missouri vs. Illinois the last 3 years...
https://www.reddit.com/r/CFB/comments/1x...he_last_3/
Overall record |24-11 |25-10
vs. teams ranked at kickoff |2-11 |5-5
vs. teams that finished ranked |0-10 |3-5
vs Other P4 Teams |4-1 |4-1
Weeks in CFP Top 25 |10 |5
Illinois has the better overall record and record against ranked teams (and is also 2-0 vs the SEC).
Missouri hasn’t beaten a single team that finished the season ranked in three years.
Despite that, Missouri has had twice as many weeks in the committee’s top 25... AND IS STILL IN THE CURRENT TOP 25.
1 team with not a single loss against an unranked team, vs a team with 5 unranked losses.
Losses to 3-6 Purdue and 4-8 Wisconsin (2025). Missouri’s worst losses are to 8-5 A&M in 2025 and 4-5 Miss St this year.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 11:21 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
So the computers will say the Big 12 is significantly overrated and the SEC is underrated.
The 6 Big 12 schools are 22 spots higher in the CFP than the computers.
The 2 ACC are 2 spots lower than in the computers.
The 6 Big Ten school are 2 spots lower, mainly because Ohio St. is 8 spots lower, the rest are +6.
The 9 SEC schools are 10 spots lower.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 11:51 AM |
|
bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
Biggest differences Massey composite vs. CFP
LSU -11
Ole Miss -8
Ohio St. -8
BYU +7
Houston +5
Oklahoma St. +4
Texas Tech +4
Kentucky +4
UCLA, Iowa, USC, South Carolina +3
And Oklahoma is #25, but is unrated by the CFP.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 11:55 AM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
If a team finished 10-2, what are the chances they get a bye? I'd think Georgia would be higher, but maybe a loss to South Carolina or Missouri really is that damaging. Could Bama be the Dawgs only ranked win?
37% Alabama
14% Texas
14% Tennessee
7% Kentucky
6% USC
1% Georgia
|
|
| 11-12-2026 12:20 PM |
|
Crayton
Heisman

Posts: 5,317
Joined: Feb 2019
Reputation: 379
I Root For: Florida
Location:
|
RE: LOL at Alabama at 3 over UCLA , Miami and Tennesseee
(11-12-2026 11:55 AM)bullet Wrote: Biggest differences Massey composite vs. CFP
LSU -11
Ole Miss -8
Ohio St. -8
BYU +7
Houston +5
Oklahoma St. +4
Texas Tech +4
Kentucky +4
UCLA, Iowa, USC, South Carolina +3
And Oklahoma is #25, but is unrated by the CFP.
Wow. That is a big Big 12 bias (one way or the other). I kinda swing toward the CFP for the top few and then toward Massey after that.
|
|
| 11-12-2026 12:25 PM |
|