Poseidon
Special Teams

Posts: 992
Joined: Dec 2015
Reputation: 162
I Root For: Tulane
Location:
|
RE: Realignment idea wandering around
(11-06-2026 01:57 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: (11-06-2026 01:42 PM)Poseidon Wrote: (11-05-2026 05:30 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: Instead of trying to merge the two conferences, just get rid of each conference championship game and make the leader of Pac12 & American conference play a game. The winner would more than likely get the G6 autobid or be ranked in the Top 24.
Not quite fair since we have nearly double the amount of schools. Its just as likely the two teams with the best records come from a single 14 conference as opposed to an 8 team conference.
I understand we have more teams, but at the end of the regular season it is going to boil down to probably the top 1 or 2 teams at the top of the standings that have a realistic chance on making the 24 team playoffs. But the bid will be to the highest ranked G6.
So say this year Boise is their #1. They might not want to play the #1 seed in the American because if they lose, they'd be out of the playoff.
But when looking at it over a longer span of years in the future, there will be a time that say the American is behind the PAC12 or vice versa, and has no clear way of passing them and getting ranked ahead of them if both teams win out.
At least if the two conferences agreed to play, the lower ranked team (or conference) has a chance to prove it on the field.
Anyway, it probably will never happen. Just throwing out the idea.
I get the logic. However with a 24 team playoff there would be years when two G schools finish in the top 24. It has happened multiple times before or come close. In that case one team would be playing itself out of a spot.
|
|
| 11-06-2026 02:11 PM |
|
Ourland
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,317
Joined: Apr 2017
Reputation: 990
I Root For: The Rice Owls
Location: Galveston
|
RE: Realignment idea wandering around
(11-06-2026 02:11 PM)Poseidon Wrote: (11-06-2026 01:57 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: (11-06-2026 01:42 PM)Poseidon Wrote: (11-05-2026 05:30 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: Instead of trying to merge the two conferences, just get rid of each conference championship game and make the leader of Pac12 & American conference play a game. The winner would more than likely get the G6 autobid or be ranked in the Top 24.
Not quite fair since we have nearly double the amount of schools. Its just as likely the two teams with the best records come from a single 14 conference as opposed to an 8 team conference.
I understand we have more teams, but at the end of the regular season it is going to boil down to probably the top 1 or 2 teams at the top of the standings that have a realistic chance on making the 24 team playoffs. But the bid will be to the highest ranked G6.
So say this year Boise is their #1. They might not want to play the #1 seed in the American because if they lose, they'd be out of the playoff.
But when looking at it over a longer span of years in the future, there will be a time that say the American is behind the PAC12 or vice versa, and has no clear way of passing them and getting ranked ahead of them if both teams win out.
At least if the two conferences agreed to play, the lower ranked team (or conference) has a chance to prove it on the field.
Anyway, it probably will never happen. Just throwing out the idea.
I get the logic. However with a 24 team playoff there would be years when two G schools finish in the top 24. It has happened multiple times before or come close. In that case one team would be playing itself out of a spot.
This. If a merger ever happened, it would be counterproductive to play a championship game between the two "divisions." Championship games will disappear soon. If they were part of the playoff, they would have merit, but they aren't.
The American needs to drop the championship. There will be years that we'll have several ranked teams, and we can take two or three spots.
|
|
| 11-06-2026 02:52 PM |
|
shere khan
Southerner

Posts: 76,750
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10828
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
|
RE: Realignment idea wandering around
(11-06-2026 02:52 PM)Ourland Wrote: (11-06-2026 02:11 PM)Poseidon Wrote: (11-06-2026 01:57 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: (11-06-2026 01:42 PM)Poseidon Wrote: (11-05-2026 05:30 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: Instead of trying to merge the two conferences, just get rid of each conference championship game and make the leader of Pac12 & American conference play a game. The winner would more than likely get the G6 autobid or be ranked in the Top 24.
Not quite fair since we have nearly double the amount of schools. Its just as likely the two teams with the best records come from a single 14 conference as opposed to an 8 team conference.
I understand we have more teams, but at the end of the regular season it is going to boil down to probably the top 1 or 2 teams at the top of the standings that have a realistic chance on making the 24 team playoffs. But the bid will be to the highest ranked G6.
So say this year Boise is their #1. They might not want to play the #1 seed in the American because if they lose, they'd be out of the playoff.
But when looking at it over a longer span of years in the future, there will be a time that say the American is behind the PAC12 or vice versa, and has no clear way of passing them and getting ranked ahead of them if both teams win out.
At least if the two conferences agreed to play, the lower ranked team (or conference) has a chance to prove it on the field.
Anyway, it probably will never happen. Just throwing out the idea.
I get the logic. However with a 24 team playoff there would be years when two G schools finish in the top 24. It has happened multiple times before or come close. In that case one team would be playing itself out of a spot.
This. If a merger ever happened, it would be counterproductive to play a championship game between the two "divisions." Championship games will disappear soon. If they were part of the playoff, they would have merit, but they aren't.
The American needs to drop the championship. There will be years that we'll have several ranked teams, and we can take two or three spots.
Two G teams might make it but I don't ever see them letting two from the same G conf. I don't see them ranking two from the same G conf going forward
(This post was last modified: 11-06-2026 04:13 PM by shere khan.)
|
|
| 11-06-2026 04:13 PM |
|
shere khan
Southerner

Posts: 76,750
Joined: Mar 2004
Reputation: 10828
I Root For: Memphis
Location: Russia
|
RE: Realignment idea wandering around
(11-06-2026 06:56 PM)Ourland Wrote: (11-06-2026 04:13 PM)shere khan Wrote: (11-06-2026 02:52 PM)Ourland Wrote: (11-06-2026 02:11 PM)Poseidon Wrote: (11-06-2026 01:57 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: I understand we have more teams, but at the end of the regular season it is going to boil down to probably the top 1 or 2 teams at the top of the standings that have a realistic chance on making the 24 team playoffs. But the bid will be to the highest ranked G6.
So say this year Boise is their #1. They might not want to play the #1 seed in the American because if they lose, they'd be out of the playoff.
But when looking at it over a longer span of years in the future, there will be a time that say the American is behind the PAC12 or vice versa, and has no clear way of passing them and getting ranked ahead of them if both teams win out.
At least if the two conferences agreed to play, the lower ranked team (or conference) has a chance to prove it on the field.
Anyway, it probably will never happen. Just throwing out the idea.
I get the logic. However with a 24 team playoff there would be years when two G schools finish in the top 24. It has happened multiple times before or come close. In that case one team would be playing itself out of a spot.
This. If a merger ever happened, it would be counterproductive to play a championship game between the two "divisions." Championship games will disappear soon. If they were part of the playoff, they would have merit, but they aren't.
The American needs to drop the championship. There will be years that we'll have several ranked teams, and we can take two or three spots.
Two G teams might make it but I don't ever see them letting two from the same G conf. I don't see them ranking two from the same G conf going forward
How could they keep us out? Any schools ranked in the top 24 should be included, and most years there are 2, sometimes three.
You believe the rankings are objective. To a certain degree they are self fulfilling. If the ranked p4 teams never play g teams....well you get the point. Two G teams from the same conference. Don't think it's happening. 7-1 Boise has 3 p4 teams with 3 losses ranked higher. No other g teams and certainly not one from the pac.
They will let 1 g team or d-1aa team in a year as a token
|
|
| 11-06-2026 07:05 PM |
|
JasonUTSA99
2nd String

Posts: 356
Joined: Feb 2024
Reputation: 29
I Root For: UTSA
Location:
|
RE: Realignment idea wandering around
(11-06-2026 07:05 PM)shere khan Wrote: You believe the rankings are objective. To a certain degree they are self fulfilling. If the ranked p4 teams never play g teams....well you get the point. Two G teams from the same conference. Don't think it's happening. 7-1 Boise has 3 p4 teams with 3 losses ranked higher. No other g teams and certainly not one from the pac.
They will let 1 g team or d-1aa team in a year as a token
I agree 100%.
If the SEC and Big10 had their way, there would be 12 teams from the BiG10 and 12 from the SEC. They'll settle and let Norte Dame in, the Big 12 champ, and the ACC champ, and 1 G6 team. That puts 20 from the SEC and Big 10.
(This post was last modified: 11-06-2026 07:16 PM by JasonUTSA99.)
|
|
| 11-06-2026 07:13 PM |
|
Ourland
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,317
Joined: Apr 2017
Reputation: 990
I Root For: The Rice Owls
Location: Galveston
|
RE: Realignment idea wandering around
(11-06-2026 07:13 PM)JasonUTSA99 Wrote: (11-06-2026 07:05 PM)shere khan Wrote: You believe the rankings are objective. To a certain degree they are self fulfilling. If the ranked p4 teams never play g teams....well you get the point. Two G teams from the same conference. Don't think it's happening. 7-1 Boise has 3 p4 teams with 3 losses ranked higher. No other g teams and certainly not one from the pac.
They will let 1 g team or d-1aa team in a year as a token
I agree 100%.
If the SEC and Big10 had their way, there would be 12 teams from the BiG10 and 12 from the SEC. They'll settle and let Norte Dame in, the Big 12 champ, and the ACC champ, and 1 G6 team. That puts 20 from the SEC and Big 10.
Has the criteria been set for how teams are selected?
|
|
| 11-06-2026 08:12 PM |
|
Ourland
Hall of Famer

Posts: 10,317
Joined: Apr 2017
Reputation: 990
I Root For: The Rice Owls
Location: Galveston
|
RE: Realignment idea wandering around
(11-06-2026 07:05 PM)shere khan Wrote: (11-06-2026 06:56 PM)Ourland Wrote: (11-06-2026 04:13 PM)shere khan Wrote: (11-06-2026 02:52 PM)Ourland Wrote: (11-06-2026 02:11 PM)Poseidon Wrote: I get the logic. However with a 24 team playoff there would be years when two G schools finish in the top 24. It has happened multiple times before or come close. In that case one team would be playing itself out of a spot.
This. If a merger ever happened, it would be counterproductive to play a championship game between the two "divisions." Championship games will disappear soon. If they were part of the playoff, they would have merit, but they aren't.
The American needs to drop the championship. There will be years that we'll have several ranked teams, and we can take two or three spots.
Two G teams might make it but I don't ever see them letting two from the same G conf. I don't see them ranking two from the same G conf going forward
How could they keep us out? Any schools ranked in the top 24 should be included, and most years there are 2, sometimes three.
You believe the rankings are objective. To a certain degree they are self fulfilling. If the ranked p4 teams never play g teams....well you get the point. Two G teams from the same conference. Don't think it's happening. 7-1 Boise has 3 p4 teams with 3 losses ranked higher. No other g teams and certainly not one from the pac.
They will let 1 g team or d-1aa team in a year as a token
It makes me sick. I hope you're so damn wrong. I realize the corruption, particularly since the BCS, but damn. I'll be so pissed if two ranked teams aren't taken. That would be complete bull.
|
|
| 11-06-2026 08:17 PM |
|