CSNbbs
Realignment idea wandering around - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Americanbbs (/forum-460.html)
+---- Forum: American Conference Talk (/forum-409.html)
+---- Thread: Realignment idea wandering around (/thread-1035260.html)

Pages: 1 2 3


Realignment idea wandering around - blazr - 11-05-2026 11:56 AM

This has been bouncing around social media:

PAC Division:
Boise State (PAC 12 currently)
Washington State (PAC 12)
Oregon State (PAC 12)
San Diego State (PAC 12)
Texas State (PAC 12)
Fresno State (PAC 12)
Utah State (PAC 12)
Colorado State (PAC 12)
Tulsa (American)
UTSA (American)
North Texas (American)

American Division:
Memphis (American)
Army (American)
Navy (American)
South Florida (American)
UAB (American)
FAU (American)
ECU (American)
Tulane (American)
Charlotte (American)
Temple (American)
Rice (American)

Wichita State - basketball only

That would easily be the best G6 and might push the ACC if you take away the "tradition" of the schools (NC State, Boston College, & Syracuse as examples)


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - Ourland - 11-05-2026 12:07 PM

It sounds like a bit much to me. Don't get me wrong, I'd like Rice playing a wider variety of schools, but the valuable markets and timezones are ours. We'd be carrying their weight to some degree.

Perhaps all of the content drives the payout up to a place where it's worth it, but the numbers still don't add up.

I might be for this if there were a "promotion/demotion" system in place that groups together the best teams, annually, based on how they performed the previous season.

Any links?


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - msu35 - 11-05-2026 12:15 PM

A promotion and relegation model would be great for the NCAA and would fix most everything wrong with the current system to ensure balance and fair competition, but it would never work on any level or even be applicable to conferences.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - blazr - 11-05-2026 12:22 PM

(11-05-2026 12:15 PM)msu35 Wrote:  A promotion and relegation model would be great for the NCAA and would fix most everything wrong with the current system to ensure balance and fair competition, but it would never work on any level or even be applicable to conferences.

Just like MLS, realignment will never happen in any American sport. No business man/booster is going to toss millions of $$ into a program just to see it playing only for the one G6 bid and a, relatively, chump schedule in front of half the fans they draw now. That means NIL dries up, new facilities are quashed, and it's a perpetual, self-fulfilling downward dive.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - We Are the Dukes of JMU - 11-05-2026 12:24 PM

(11-05-2026 11:56 AM)blazr Wrote:  This has been bouncing around social media:

PAC Division:
Boise State (PAC 12 currently)
Washington State (PAC 12)
Oregon State (PAC 12)
San Diego State (PAC 12)
Texas State (PAC 12)
Fresno State (PAC 12)
Utah State (PAC 12)
Colorado State (PAC 12)
Tulsa (American)
UTSA (American)
North Texas (American)

American Division:
Memphis (American)
Army (American)
Navy (American)
South Florida (American)
UAB (American)
FAU (American)
ECU (American)
Tulane (American)
Charlotte (American)
Temple (American)
Rice (American)

Wichita State - basketball only

That would easily be the best G6 and might push the ACC if you take away the "tradition" of the schools (NC State, Boston College, & Syracuse as examples)

So JMU is left as the sole member of the legacy American conference. I don't love the G6 super conference idea, but if you're going to leave one team behind, there may be better options.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - blazr - 11-05-2026 12:27 PM

(11-05-2026 12:24 PM)We Are the Dukes of JMU Wrote:  
(11-05-2026 11:56 AM)blazr Wrote:  This has been bouncing around social media:

PAC Division:
Boise State (PAC 12 currently)
Washington State (PAC 12)
Oregon State (PAC 12)
San Diego State (PAC 12)
Texas State (PAC 12)
Fresno State (PAC 12)
Utah State (PAC 12)
Colorado State (PAC 12)
Tulsa (American)
UTSA (American)
North Texas (American)

American Division:
Memphis (American)
Army (American)
Navy (American)
South Florida (American)
UAB (American)
FAU (American)
ECU (American)
Tulane (American)
Charlotte (American)
Temple (American)
Rice (American)

Wichita State - basketball only

That would easily be the best G6 and might push the ACC if you take away the "tradition" of the schools (NC State, Boston College, & Syracuse as examples)

So JMU is left as the sole member of the legacy American conference. I don't love the G6 super conference idea, but if you're going to leave one team behind, there may be better options.

Oops...my bad


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - We Are the Dukes of JMU - 11-05-2026 12:28 PM

(11-05-2026 12:22 PM)blazr Wrote:  
(11-05-2026 12:15 PM)msu35 Wrote:  A promotion and relegation model would be great for the NCAA and would fix most everything wrong with the current system to ensure balance and fair competition, but it would never work on any level or even be applicable to conferences.

Just like MLS, realignment will never happen in any American sport. No business man/booster is going to toss millions of $$ into a program just to see it playing only for the one G6 bid and a, relatively, chump schedule in front of half the fans they draw now. That means NIL dries up, new facilities are quashed, and it's a perpetual, self-fulfilling downward dive.

The only thing that could trigger it is a massive antitrust legal battle where promotion and relegation is essentially forced as settlement. The P4 left one G6 auto bid in the proposed 24 team playoff in hopes of avoiding that scenario. If the P4 ever attempts to create a new D1 subdivision, I see that triggering massive upheaval that could ultimately result in promotion and relegation. That's why I think the P4 will avoid it.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - Ourland - 11-05-2026 12:29 PM

I don't see why a very large conglomerate of schools couldn't do it. It might be worth asking the NCAA. But again, what would the benefit be, specifically for the American?

I'm all in for anything that improves the lot of mid-major conferences. It could actually benefit us to work together, instead of against, but none of these waters have been tested yet.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - Tiger1983 - 11-05-2026 12:32 PM

A “Best of the Rest” conference has long been my aspiration absent Memphis’ P4 invitation. The main issue is money, I believe. American nor PAC members will be willing to take less media money, although I think that is short sighted unless other revenue streams (eg, CFP, NCAA BB tournament, attendance, etc.) are considered.

Also, if it could be done from a practical perspective, the merger would be an opportunity to prune schools unable or unwilling to pay players up to a minimum standard.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - blazr - 11-05-2026 12:39 PM

(11-05-2026 12:32 PM)Tiger1983 Wrote:  The “Best of the Rest” conference has always been my aspiration absent Memphis’ P4 invitation. The main issue is money, I believe. American nor PAC members will be willing to take less media money, although I think that is short sighted unless other revenue streams (eg, CFP, NCAA BB tournament, attendance, etc.) are considered.

Also, if it could be done from a practical perspective, the merger would be an opportunity to prune schools unable or unwilling to pay players up to a minimum standard.

Honestly, how are we going to avoid P2/G8? Big XII schools are already losing donations and if the GOR didn't exist half the ACC would be gone.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - msu35 - 11-05-2026 12:52 PM

(11-05-2026 12:22 PM)blazr Wrote:  
(11-05-2026 12:15 PM)msu35 Wrote:  A promotion and relegation model would be great for the NCAA and would fix most everything wrong with the current system to ensure balance and fair competition, but it would never work on any level or even be applicable to conferences.

Just like MLS, realignment will never happen in any American sport. No business man/booster is going to toss millions of $$ into a program just to see it playing only for the one G6 bid and a, relatively, chump schedule in front of half the fans they draw now. That means NIL dries up, new facilities are quashed, and it's a perpetual, self-fulfilling downward dive.

I have to disagree. A relegation and promotion model would actually bring significant equity to the NCAA and would ensure that everyone is investing to the best of their ability if they want to stay in the top tier -- no more charity case bottom feeders or programs skating off of their "birth" rights. Most teams within a competitive tier remain in that tier in this model, and only the best or worst teams would ever move up or down. A meritocracy.

It certainly doesn't mean that NIL or revenue sharing dries up, and would represent the exact opposite of a downward dive. In fact, this system hasn't reduced the quality of European soccer at the highest levels nor does it create instability in practice. Only the perennial bottom feeders, who probably don't deserve to be in their tier, face significant risk of being relegated down.

Ultimately it would ensure media distributions are equitable like the pro sports models we have in place today and would level the playing field, promoting honest competition. Teams who invest and consistently win have an opportunity to elevate and rise up into a higher tier while the worst teams face the risk of being filtered down. This is the best-case scenario for everyone not in the P2.

I do concede that it's not a realistic outcome, but it's not any more unrealistic than this proposed G6 "super" league of unwieldy proportions.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - blazr - 11-05-2026 01:06 PM

But if I'm ESPN am I okie dokie with losing Boston/Cambrige for Oxford, OH? And UK/Europe is a FAR ways to compare to American sports management.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - msu35 - 11-05-2026 01:10 PM

(11-05-2026 01:06 PM)blazr Wrote:  But if I'm ESPN am I okie dokie with losing Boston/Cambrige for Oxford, OH? And UK/Europe is a FAR ways to compare to American sports management.

That's the beauty of it. Promotion and relegation enforces collective bargaining of media rights and it also conveniently kills the media company stranglehold on college sports. They pull the strings and this completely nullifies that effect. Win/win for everyone not in the SEC or B1G.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - shere khan - 11-05-2026 02:38 PM

Boise State (PAC 12 currently)
Washington State (PAC 12)
Oregon State (PAC 12)
San Diego State (PAC 12)
Fresno State (PAC 12)
Utah State (PAC 12)
Colorado State (PAC 12)
Memphis (American)
Army (American)
Navy (American)
South Florida (American)
ECU (American)
Tulane (American)
Airforce


Fify

Dead weight jettisoned


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - b2b - 11-05-2026 02:56 PM

(11-05-2026 02:38 PM)shere khan Wrote:  Boise State (PAC 12 currently)
Washington State (PAC 12)
Oregon State (PAC 12)
San Diego State (PAC 12)
Fresno State (PAC 12)
Utah State (PAC 12)
Colorado State (PAC 12)
Memphis (American)
Army (American)
Navy (American)
South Florida (American)
ECU (American)
Tulane (American)
Airforce


Fify

Dead weight jettisoned

Pretty close. I'd include UTSA and JMU but there's definitely no need to have 22 teams.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - VA49er - 11-05-2026 03:06 PM

Better be A LOT more money involved given the travel.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - Bull - 11-05-2026 03:49 PM

Two conferences (12-16 each). One in the west, one in the east.

Or one mega conference, with a western division and an eastern division.

For practical purposes, what is the difference? Other than negotiating TV together, and potentially sharing an autobid. Or more often than not, winning the bid.

Basically always thought all these mega conferences are just that... essentially 2 conferences stuck together. You just can't play everyone regularly in a conference that big...


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - Ned Low - 11-05-2026 04:05 PM

I like the idea of merging the PAC into the American. Add one other team (Air Force for football-only and maybe VCU for Olympics) and call it a day if so desired.

You would want to go with a 9-or even an 11-game football conference schedule to make this work and split into at least three divisions (west, central and eastern). That, or you would want to have intraconference promotion and relegation, with the scheduling reflecting as much.

The two best would meet for the conference crown each year.

I'm not sure that the NCAA would have to say about things but you would want to keep most (ideally, all) Olympic-sport travel at a bare minimum.

It's an interesting thought.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - Ned Low - 11-05-2026 04:06 PM

There's also a lot of chatter online regarding the idea of having smaller, more regionalized conferences. Frankly, I like that idea better.


RE: Realignment idea wandering around - JasonUTSA99 - 11-05-2026 05:30 PM

Instead of trying to merge the two conferences, just get rid of each conference championship game and make the leader of Pac12 & American conference play a game. The winner would more than likely get the G6 autobid or be ranked in the Top 24.