Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
Author Message
Attackcoog Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 49,255
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
Post: #81
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(10-31-2026 08:22 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 02:54 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 02:27 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  We are likely to see the A4 sign a deal with at least half a dozen bowls, maybe as many as ten, to guarantee matchups.

I think the A4 need to be careful on how many they place in their consortium, as with an expanded playoff there are going to be a number of opt outs, just like we see amongst disappointed basketball teams who pass on the NIT and Crown, several changing coaches, making it harder to fill. The plan floated in Spring for a 10-bowl consortium is likely more than they can safely fill. I checked last year and only 19 schools that didn't make the playoffs were 7-5 or better, one of them (Notre Dame) opted out of a bowl game. I think we can reasonably assume at least 3 or 4 schools will opt out, making 7 the largest number of bowls a consortium can expect to fill. (Note, something like 6 of the A4 teams in bowls played in minor bowls against G6 opponents.) If the A4 decide on more than 6 or 7 bowls to sponsor, they may need language in the contract to say, "or other high value opponent acceptable to all parties," so they can take a good traveling fan base 6-6 A4 school that just surged and are excited to play or a strong 10-win G6 school with a higher profile and reasonable following (think Boise State, South Florida, Memphis, Tulane type schools).

Personally, I'd play it safe and sponsor just 6 games (I'd still have the exception language to let some top 25 JMU or NDSU team passed over for the CFP play, as that might be higher profile than a 7-5 Purdue, Boston College or Cincinnati option). This would make these exhibitions a bit more valuable to participants. That should be sufficient number of games to fill the TV slots in the gap between the second round played just before Christmas and the NYD quarterfinals. Any remaining 7+ win A4 schools who want to play in a bowl can sign on to whatever mid-tier ones are left.

The G6 is going to have to think hard about how to come up with something worthwhile for their 9 to 11 win schools other than the leftover pre-Christmas Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday night bowls in third tier locations for ESPN2 and ESPNU channel broadcasts. If nothing else, I'd consider a 3 or 4 bowl consortium of their own ("Champions Series), with mid-tier bowls after Christmas, to match up the conference champions against each other or a strong 2nd place team. That would at least give winning the conference a good higher profile game to play in, where people can see they won a conference, maybe be seen as an advertisement for consideration in next year's CFP access slot selection. (Taking into account Frank the Tank and others observation that a G6 tournament would have a very low media value, similar to the NIT in basketball.)

Ive said for a long time some sort of Champions Bowl Series was the way to go. I'd fund it via some of the new CFP "G6" share revenue coming for the CFP expansion. You can do it one of two ways. The original way I presented it in the then "G5" era was as a traditional package of bowls designed for the 4 G5 conference champs not getting the G5 CFP slot. I'd modify it slightly since we now have a 6th "G" conference. It would be a 4 bowl series with high enough payouts to attract 3 P5 opponents. Obviously, any G6 making the CFP would not be available. I'll assume just one G6 gets in the actual CFP. The remaining 3 highest ranked G6 champs would go to Champions Series Bowls playing against selected P4 schools. The bottom 2 G6 champs would play each other in the 4th Bowl. Payouts would be the same for all 4 bowls. If necessary to make the bowls work---the payout for the 3 P4 participants might be higher than the G6 participants (that will be decided by the market).

The other option would be an actual NIT style tournament where the remaining 5 G6 champs engage in a single elimination playoff bracket using 4 of the ESPN bowls. The top 3 get a bye to semi-finals and the bottom 2 play their way into the 4-team semi-final bracket. You might need some NCAA changes to allow it----but I doubt that would be a big issue given we are already making a 24 team playoff part of FBS.

No amount of money is going to make P4 schools want to play the G6 champs—it’s a no win scenario. Lose and you’re a laughing stock; win and no one sees it as an accomplishment. There’s a reason why even now we see very few G vs P bowls.

Thats the assumption, but in an era of pay for play---every dollar of extra revenue matters. At the league level---it extra revenue. Besides, everyone knows the better players are opting out of bowls these days---so the game outcome doesnt really matter all that much anymore in the court of public opinion. Not to mention, by the time you take out the CFP participants and the surviving power bowls get their selections----you are probably looking at a 7th or 8th place P5 finisher playing the G5 champs. The result is hardly going to be a big statement game.
(This post was last modified: 11-01-2026 12:37 PM by Attackcoog.)
11-01-2026 12:33 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,554
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #82
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(10-31-2026 01:53 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 03:34 PM)ken d Wrote:  Last year, there were 15 FBS teams that finished the regular season 5-7. Of those, 8 were A4 schools: Florida State, Baylor, Kansas, UCF, Rutgers, Auburn, Kentucky, and Mississippi State. If there were a 24 team CFP, would any of those have accepted a bowl bid if offered?

Of course, they weren't playing under a mandate to schedule 10 A4 opponents, and four of them only played 8 conference games. So it's likely some, maybe even most, of them might not have had that 5th win. Would a bowl paying out A4 money want 4-8 A-4 teams if that were allowed, or G6 teams if it weren't? My guess is they wouldn't.

What P program fans want to "celebrate" a 5-7 season with a trip to Albuquerque? Honestly, there will be a cull of the lowest tiers, there's just no way around it. Or Disney will have to pay players to play.

I don’t know if “celebrate” is the right word. As much as we talk about opt-outs and the high profile Notre Dame rejection of a Pop Tarts Bowl bid last year, there is still a whole swath of coaches and players that want additional weeks of practice time at the least along with playing time. Plus, it just extends the “mindshare” that a football program has for the month of December.

Like I’ve said elsewhere, my own personal mentality for the non-CFP bowls is that they are now the equivalent of college football spring training (where the players on the field at any given time could range from starters to prospects fighting for a roster spot) that is more preparation for the future as opposed to a culmination of the past season. I think more people are eventually going to switch to that mentality if they haven’t already. Once you get to that mentality (where the result of the bowl game means less than the preparation for the future for the participating teams), all of these complaints about the bowl games largely go away. Much like MLB sorting training, it’s a chance to watch the future players for your favorite team play in a hopefully nice weather and/or vacation destination and, if you can’t go in person, pay attention to your football team for an extra month and watch the game on TV.

I think a lot of people here underestimate the continued overall demand for that type of product - they’re too hung up on the 1990s/2000s viewpoint that making a bowl “meant something” competitively (and similar to how such nostalgia is why the favorite conference alignments of people always seems to happen to be the alignment that they grew up with as teenagers or when they went to college). The bowls are a different product now… and that’s OK. If there’s no longer demand for that product, then it will die a natural death as with anything in the free market (such as what I believe we’re currently seeing with the NIT and other consolation basketball tournaments). As of now, though, when mediocre P4 vs. P4 bowl games still get 3 million-plus viewers, the networks aren’t going to be in a rush to unilaterally kill those.
11-01-2026 12:53 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Frank the Tank Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 23,554
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
Post: #83
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 12:33 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(10-31-2026 08:22 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 02:54 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 02:27 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  We are likely to see the A4 sign a deal with at least half a dozen bowls, maybe as many as ten, to guarantee matchups.

I think the A4 need to be careful on how many they place in their consortium, as with an expanded playoff there are going to be a number of opt outs, just like we see amongst disappointed basketball teams who pass on the NIT and Crown, several changing coaches, making it harder to fill. The plan floated in Spring for a 10-bowl consortium is likely more than they can safely fill. I checked last year and only 19 schools that didn't make the playoffs were 7-5 or better, one of them (Notre Dame) opted out of a bowl game. I think we can reasonably assume at least 3 or 4 schools will opt out, making 7 the largest number of bowls a consortium can expect to fill. (Note, something like 6 of the A4 teams in bowls played in minor bowls against G6 opponents.) If the A4 decide on more than 6 or 7 bowls to sponsor, they may need language in the contract to say, "or other high value opponent acceptable to all parties," so they can take a good traveling fan base 6-6 A4 school that just surged and are excited to play or a strong 10-win G6 school with a higher profile and reasonable following (think Boise State, South Florida, Memphis, Tulane type schools).

Personally, I'd play it safe and sponsor just 6 games (I'd still have the exception language to let some top 25 JMU or NDSU team passed over for the CFP play, as that might be higher profile than a 7-5 Purdue, Boston College or Cincinnati option). This would make these exhibitions a bit more valuable to participants. That should be sufficient number of games to fill the TV slots in the gap between the second round played just before Christmas and the NYD quarterfinals. Any remaining 7+ win A4 schools who want to play in a bowl can sign on to whatever mid-tier ones are left.

The G6 is going to have to think hard about how to come up with something worthwhile for their 9 to 11 win schools other than the leftover pre-Christmas Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday night bowls in third tier locations for ESPN2 and ESPNU channel broadcasts. If nothing else, I'd consider a 3 or 4 bowl consortium of their own ("Champions Series), with mid-tier bowls after Christmas, to match up the conference champions against each other or a strong 2nd place team. That would at least give winning the conference a good higher profile game to play in, where people can see they won a conference, maybe be seen as an advertisement for consideration in next year's CFP access slot selection. (Taking into account Frank the Tank and others observation that a G6 tournament would have a very low media value, similar to the NIT in basketball.)

Ive said for a long time some sort of Champions Bowl Series was the way to go. I'd fund it via some of the new CFP "G6" share revenue coming for the CFP expansion. You can do it one of two ways. The original way I presented it in the then "G5" era was as a traditional package of bowls designed for the 4 G5 conference champs not getting the G5 CFP slot. I'd modify it slightly since we now have a 6th "G" conference. It would be a 4 bowl series with high enough payouts to attract 3 P5 opponents. Obviously, any G6 making the CFP would not be available. I'll assume just one G6 gets in the actual CFP. The remaining 3 highest ranked G6 champs would go to Champions Series Bowls playing against selected P4 schools. The bottom 2 G6 champs would play each other in the 4th Bowl. Payouts would be the same for all 4 bowls. If necessary to make the bowls work---the payout for the 3 P4 participants might be higher than the G6 participants (that will be decided by the market).

The other option would be an actual NIT style tournament where the remaining 5 G6 champs engage in a single elimination playoff bracket using 4 of the ESPN bowls. The top 3 get a bye to semi-finals and the bottom 2 play their way into the 4-team semi-final bracket. You might need some NCAA changes to allow it----but I doubt that would be a big issue given we are already making a 24 team playoff part of FBS.

No amount of money is going to make P4 schools want to play the G6 champs—it’s a no win scenario. Lose and you’re a laughing stock; win and no one sees it as an accomplishment. There’s a reason why even now we see very few G vs P bowls.

Thats the assumption, but in an era of pay for play---every dollar of extra revenue matters. At the league level---it extra revenue. Besides, everyone knows the better players are opting out of bowls these days---so the game outcome doesnt really matter all that much anymore in the court of public opinion. Not to mention, by the time you take out the CFP participants and the surviving power bowls get their selections----you are probably looking at a 7th or 8th place P5 finisher playing the G5 champs. The result is hardly going to be a big statement game.

The problem is that the higher revenue still comes from P4 vs. P4 games (even the most mediocre and subpar ones) as opposed to even playing the best G6 teams. So, there isn’t this world where playing a G6 champ actually makes more for the P4 than the 10th place Big Ten team playing the 10th place SEC team or the equivalent.

That’s the market reality. Sure - everyone wants to make more revenue, but the proposal to match up G6 teams with P4 teams doesn’t actually make more revenue for the P4. I know it frustrates a lot of G6 fans that their champ is worth less in the bowl marketplace than a 6-6 ACC team, but that’s what the market is stating.
11-01-2026 12:58 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Fresno Fanatic Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,082
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 90
I Root For: Fresno State
Location:
Post: #84
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
Could G6 save 5 bowls with their own “FBS All-Champs Series”?

Conditions…
1. Top G6 still to CFP
2. A 16-team playoff where…

2A…R of 16 & Qfinals: 4 bowls host 4 pods over 2 weeks of…
1vs16 + 8vs9
2vs15 + 7vs10
3vs14 + 6vs11
4vs13 + 5vs12

2B…played approx 2 weeks after Army-Navy Game.
*which if CFP-24 were this year would have A/N Game on Dec 5th
**so 2A would happen Dec19th(Rof16) then Dec26th(Quarterfinals) for the 4, 2-winners of the round of 16

3. Semis and Championship Game played at 5th Bowl on Jan9th(semis), Jan16th(FBS All-Champs Championship Game)

4. Would take about $40million to financially make worthwhile. From tv revenue and bowl location revenue.

5. Where would remainder come from if tv revenue + bowl location (2 weeks worth!) come from if the sum doesn’t equate to at least $40MM???
(This post was last modified: 11-01-2026 03:14 PM by Fresno Fanatic.)
11-01-2026 03:11 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gemofthehills Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
Post: #85
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
Come down to the P2 and M2 dont want the public to understand the separation is small between and average team (especially M2) and an average G6 team.
11-01-2026 04:26 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AssKickingChicken Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,563
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
Post: #86
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(10-31-2026 02:06 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 12:42 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 10:56 AM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  Would anyone in Las Vegas miss the bowl if it died?

Lived in Vegas for 8 years. I looked forward to it every year.

Every West Coast school would miss this. It's arguably their best destination.

FTFY

Is there a better destination for a bunch of CFB players/fans/boosters/admins/etc? Is the bowl played on the strip? You could fly in for 5 days, 2 days to pregame, one day to game, 2 days to postgame, never leaving the Promised Land. And I don’t even gamble except to be social, for normal people it’s 100 times better.

I have zero interest in going to Vegas. If I can’t drive to the game site in a day or so, I’ll watch on TV.
11-01-2026 05:25 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,374
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 960
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #87
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 04:26 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote:  Come down to the P2 and M2 dont want the public to understand the separation is small between and average team (especially M2) and an average G6 team.

Then why can we count on one hand the number of G over P victories this year? The P programs play two Gs each, on average (some play one, some play 3.)
11-01-2026 09:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
thrill_house Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,126
Joined: Apr 2021
Reputation: 177
I Root For: Anti-CFP
Location:
Post: #88
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(10-31-2026 08:22 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  No amount of money is going to make P4 schools want to play the G6 champs—it’s a no win scenario. Lose and you’re a laughing stock; win and no one sees it as an accomplishment. There’s a reason why even now we see very few G vs P bowls.

In other news, the inaugural San Juan Bowl will feature an ACC vs. Sun Belt matchup.

https://sunbeltsports.org/news/2026/10/2...-bowl.aspx
11-01-2026 10:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
AssKickingChicken Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,563
Joined: Jan 2022
Reputation: 585
I Root For: Jax State
Location:
Post: #89
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 10:17 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  
(10-31-2026 08:22 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  No amount of money is going to make P4 schools want to play the G6 champs—it’s a no win scenario. Lose and you’re a laughing stock; win and no one sees it as an accomplishment. There’s a reason why even now we see very few G vs P bowls.

In other news, the inaugural San Juan Bowl will feature an ACC vs. Sun Belt matchup.

https://sunbeltsports.org/news/2026/10/2...-bowl.aspx

Believe it or not, there are two bowl games in Puerto Rico. The San Juan Bowl will be at a baseball stadium in San Juan on December 16. It seats 20,000 for baseball.

The Puerto Rico Bowl will be in a soccer stadium that seats 12,500 in Bayamon on December 26.

So a place that doesn’t have deep connections to football is going to host two games in ten days? A place with a poverty rate twice that of Mississippi? Do they expect many people to book flights at the last minute during Christmas season to a place where the primary language isn’t English?

A bowl game being announced in October?

I don’t see this going well.
11-01-2026 10:37 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
IWokeUpLikeThis Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 17,111
Joined: Jul 2014
Reputation: 2478
I Root For: NIU, Chicago St
Location:
Post: #90
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 09:32 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 04:26 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote:  Come down to the P2 and M2 dont want the public to understand the separation is small between and average team (especially M2) and an average G6 team.

Then why can we count on one hand the number of G over P victories this year? The P programs play two Gs each, on average (some play one, some play 3.)

Yeah, I don’t think the gap has ever been this big. At least not in my lifetime.
11-01-2026 10:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,100
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #91
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 10:44 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 09:32 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 04:26 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote:  Come down to the P2 and M2 dont want the public to understand the separation is small between and average team (especially M2) and an average G6 team.

Then why can we count on one hand the number of G over P victories this year? The P programs play two Gs each, on average (some play one, some play 3.)

Yeah, I don’t think the gap has ever been this big. At least not in my lifetime.

Hot take theory: too many G6’s watering down the talent pool.

With that, a ton of parity at the P4 level
11-02-2026 06:39 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Gemofthehills Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,184
Joined: Jan 2005
Reputation: 343
I Root For: JSU
Location:
Post: #92
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 09:32 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 04:26 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote:  Come down to the P2 and M2 dont want the public to understand the separation is small between and average team (especially M2) and an average G6 team.

Then why can we count on one hand the number of G over P victories this year? The P programs play two Gs each, on average (some play one, some play 3.)

Bottom 5 teams in the
ACC 1-3 Average loss 9 points win was 8 points
B12 did better G6 was 0-5 most by big margins
B1G was 1-4 double digit margin, did not average but in between ACC and B12
SEC 0-5 with one being close at 9 points

Top 3 of G6
SBC 0-2 average 13.5 both against mid level teams
P12 0-4 3 fairly close one blow out and Oregon St was 2 of the losses all but one was against a top level opponent
MWC 1-1 win was against a bottom level team, loss by 8 to lower middle team
MAC 0-3 if you count the Michigan game a win. One game against a low level and two against lower middle
CUSA 0-2 both Delaware one close 9 points to a bottom SEC team and one blowout to a lower middle ACC team
AC 0-2 both to high level teams

2 games were against high level G6 teams and lower level P2 or M2 schools with the results being 1-1. Win by 8 and loss by 9. Small sample but the gap doesnt look to wide when comparing top to bottom. Plus all of the G6 teams were playing on the road most likely, I didnt look it up.
11-02-2026 07:35 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
djsuperfly Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,616
Joined: Sep 2021
Reputation: 291
I Root For: UCF
Location:
Post: #93
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(10-31-2026 01:53 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 03:34 PM)ken d Wrote:  Last year, there were 15 FBS teams that finished the regular season 5-7. Of those, 8 were A4 schools: Florida State, Baylor, Kansas, UCF, Rutgers, Auburn, Kentucky, and Mississippi State. If there were a 24 team CFP, would any of those have accepted a bowl bid if offered?

Of course, they weren't playing under a mandate to schedule 10 A4 opponents, and four of them only played 8 conference games. So it's likely some, maybe even most, of them might not have had that 5th win. Would a bowl paying out A4 money want 4-8 A-4 teams if that were allowed, or G6 teams if it weren't? My guess is they wouldn't.

What P program fans want to "celebrate" a 5-7 season with a trip to Albuquerque? Honestly, there will be a cull of the lowest tiers, there's just no way around it. Or Disney will have to pay players to play.

Most of those lower-tier bowls are owned by ESPN, so those won't be the ones getting culled. It's actually the mid-tier bowls that aren't part of the playoff system that will struggle to survive in this new world. (ESPN could buy some of them if they see value in the name.)
11-02-2026 08:47 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Stugray2 Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,350
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 978
I Root For: tOSU SJSU Stan'
Location: South Bay Area CA
Post: #94
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
Reading the comments, I am more convinced the CFP 24 format, with 23 from the A4 schools, will result in the bowls looking like:

A consortium of about six (6) higher end non-CFP bowls controlled by the A4, who guarantee matchups of their members. Likely candidates include the Citrus (Camping World) and Holiday (Snapdragon), where the stadium operators need games to justify their investments. I suspect some of the NFL stadium bowls will simply cease if it means no top 20 teams. But enough will stick to fill the consortium.

The G6 will do something for their non-CFP champions to reorganize rather than just condemn them to random ESPN2/ESPNU midweek evening games before Christmas of whatever agreements individual conferences can muster with the individual promoters. Their choices really boil down to a small playoff with 4 to 8 teams or a small consortium of three mid-tier bowls to match up the champions.

The CCGs are probably dead. The American for one has a problem with Army-Navy getting the first Saturday in December, when they'd be played. And they are pretty meaningless in the others because the CFP will choose a G6 team at the end of November, so they'd be for nothing. Also finding three high enough quality bowls willing to host G6 vs G6, even conference champions, in that Christmas to New Years slots they need probably don't exist. As a result, I think they will have an "NIT" tournament, as Chris Vannini outlines has been discussed:


The G6 probably sees their tournament as a way to substitute for their CFPs. It doesn't take much to imagine an 8-team playoff where 4 of the 5 regular season conference winners who were not selected for the CFP host a first-round playoff game (allows 3 2nd place teams to be selected). Second round semifinal games using ESPN midweek slots just before Christmas to have exclusivity. That only requires one bowl game on NYD timeframe be secured. Logistically, that is the easiest format. The upside is you have conference winners hosting games, eliminating much of the bowl game expenses, and all but guarantee a full house for the games. It means the non-CFP champions are playing for something in a tournament, while playing the same number of games or less than now with CCGs.

Note, the possibility is there, with an 8-team NIT playoff format, for the G6 to contract a couple of bowls for the next three 2nd place teams and one other team who didn't get that CCG game to get a consolation bowl, much like the NY6 used to do. That would help conferences avoid the awkward sending of a 10-2 or 9-3 runner up to some random December 15th game against some random opponent and at least get a similar runner up opponent in a G6 controlled bowl (think Hawaii, Poinsettia, Military or similar type bowls). The remaining G6 would, like today, be at the mercy of however many ESPN bowls continue to have a post season game.

That's not really much more money than now, but it's a setup that could work for G6 when the 24 CFP format arrives and perhaps fifteen or more bowls vanish along with the CCGs. I'd frame it as making lemonade.
(This post was last modified: 11-03-2026 05:54 PM by Stugray2.)
11-03-2026 05:54 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Attackcoog Offline
Moderator
*

Posts: 49,255
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3527
I Root For: Houston
Location:
Post: #95
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 12:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 12:33 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(10-31-2026 08:22 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  
(10-29-2026 02:54 PM)Attackcoog Wrote:  
(10-28-2026 02:27 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  We are likely to see the A4 sign a deal with at least half a dozen bowls, maybe as many as ten, to guarantee matchups.

I think the A4 need to be careful on how many they place in their consortium, as with an expanded playoff there are going to be a number of opt outs, just like we see amongst disappointed basketball teams who pass on the NIT and Crown, several changing coaches, making it harder to fill. The plan floated in Spring for a 10-bowl consortium is likely more than they can safely fill. I checked last year and only 19 schools that didn't make the playoffs were 7-5 or better, one of them (Notre Dame) opted out of a bowl game. I think we can reasonably assume at least 3 or 4 schools will opt out, making 7 the largest number of bowls a consortium can expect to fill. (Note, something like 6 of the A4 teams in bowls played in minor bowls against G6 opponents.) If the A4 decide on more than 6 or 7 bowls to sponsor, they may need language in the contract to say, "or other high value opponent acceptable to all parties," so they can take a good traveling fan base 6-6 A4 school that just surged and are excited to play or a strong 10-win G6 school with a higher profile and reasonable following (think Boise State, South Florida, Memphis, Tulane type schools).

Personally, I'd play it safe and sponsor just 6 games (I'd still have the exception language to let some top 25 JMU or NDSU team passed over for the CFP play, as that might be higher profile than a 7-5 Purdue, Boston College or Cincinnati option). This would make these exhibitions a bit more valuable to participants. That should be sufficient number of games to fill the TV slots in the gap between the second round played just before Christmas and the NYD quarterfinals. Any remaining 7+ win A4 schools who want to play in a bowl can sign on to whatever mid-tier ones are left.

The G6 is going to have to think hard about how to come up with something worthwhile for their 9 to 11 win schools other than the leftover pre-Christmas Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday night bowls in third tier locations for ESPN2 and ESPNU channel broadcasts. If nothing else, I'd consider a 3 or 4 bowl consortium of their own ("Champions Series), with mid-tier bowls after Christmas, to match up the conference champions against each other or a strong 2nd place team. That would at least give winning the conference a good higher profile game to play in, where people can see they won a conference, maybe be seen as an advertisement for consideration in next year's CFP access slot selection. (Taking into account Frank the Tank and others observation that a G6 tournament would have a very low media value, similar to the NIT in basketball.)

Ive said for a long time some sort of Champions Bowl Series was the way to go. I'd fund it via some of the new CFP "G6" share revenue coming for the CFP expansion. You can do it one of two ways. The original way I presented it in the then "G5" era was as a traditional package of bowls designed for the 4 G5 conference champs not getting the G5 CFP slot. I'd modify it slightly since we now have a 6th "G" conference. It would be a 4 bowl series with high enough payouts to attract 3 P5 opponents. Obviously, any G6 making the CFP would not be available. I'll assume just one G6 gets in the actual CFP. The remaining 3 highest ranked G6 champs would go to Champions Series Bowls playing against selected P4 schools. The bottom 2 G6 champs would play each other in the 4th Bowl. Payouts would be the same for all 4 bowls. If necessary to make the bowls work---the payout for the 3 P4 participants might be higher than the G6 participants (that will be decided by the market).

The other option would be an actual NIT style tournament where the remaining 5 G6 champs engage in a single elimination playoff bracket using 4 of the ESPN bowls. The top 3 get a bye to semi-finals and the bottom 2 play their way into the 4-team semi-final bracket. You might need some NCAA changes to allow it----but I doubt that would be a big issue given we are already making a 24 team playoff part of FBS.

No amount of money is going to make P4 schools want to play the G6 champs—it’s a no win scenario. Lose and you’re a laughing stock; win and no one sees it as an accomplishment. There’s a reason why even now we see very few G vs P bowls.

Thats the assumption, but in an era of pay for play---every dollar of extra revenue matters. At the league level---it extra revenue. Besides, everyone knows the better players are opting out of bowls these days---so the game outcome doesnt really matter all that much anymore in the court of public opinion. Not to mention, by the time you take out the CFP participants and the surviving power bowls get their selections----you are probably looking at a 7th or 8th place P5 finisher playing the G5 champs. The result is hardly going to be a big statement game.

The problem is that the higher revenue still comes from P4 vs. P4 games (even the most mediocre and subpar ones) as opposed to even playing the best G6 teams. So, there isn’t this world where playing a G6 champ actually makes more for the P4 than the 10th place Big Ten team playing the 10th place SEC team or the equivalent.

That’s the market reality. Sure - everyone wants to make more revenue, but the proposal to match up G6 teams with P4 teams doesn’t actually make more revenue for the P4. I know it frustrates a lot of G6 fans that their champ is worth less in the bowl marketplace than a 6-6 ACC team, but that’s what the market is stating.

I never said otherwise. I believe I stated that the G6 Bowl would likely have to pay the P4 participants more than its G6 participants in order to pay a price high enough to attract P4 schools to the bowl--and that price would be determined by the marketplace. So yes---of course, any G6 Champions Series Bowls will have to pay more than the lowest paying P4 bowl or it wont work. If this was simply unattainable---the the NIT idea posted above is probably the next best option.
(This post was last modified: 11-05-2026 03:55 PM by Attackcoog.)
11-05-2026 03:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
BruceMcF Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 15,768
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation: 1019
I Root For: Reds/Buckeyes/.
Location:
Post: #96
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-01-2026 10:37 PM)AssKickingChicken Wrote:  ... So a place that doesn’t have deep connections to football is going to host two games in ten days? A place with a poverty rate twice that of Mississippi? Do they expect many people to book flights at the last minute during Christmas season to a place where the primary language isn’t English? ...

It's a warm weather destination advertisement bowl location like the Bahamas bowl. This tier of bowls are "extra football games in front of a live studio audience", where the ticket sales are not generating the participation fee, but rather the participation fee is coming from the funds that are advertising the warm weather destination.

As far as the main challenge that the Bahamas Bowl faced, between "their primary language is English" and "don't need a passport, can fly on a Real ID driver's license", the second is probably the bigger challenge.
11-05-2026 07:32 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
PicksUp Offline
All American
*

Posts: 3,615
Joined: Mar 2018
Reputation: 287
I Root For: UTEP, Texas
Location:
Post: #97
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-02-2026 07:35 AM)Gemofthehills Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 09:32 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(11-01-2026 04:26 PM)Gemofthehills Wrote:  Come down to the P2 and M2 dont want the public to understand the separation is small between and average team (especially M2) and an average G6 team.

Then why can we count on one hand the number of G over P victories this year? The P programs play two Gs each, on average (some play one, some play 3.)

2 games were against high level G6 teams and lower level P2 or M2 schools with the results being 1-1. Win by 8 and loss by 9. Small sample but the gap doesnt look to wide when comparing top to bottom. Plus all of the G6 teams were playing on the road most likely, I didnt look it up.

Power conference teams rarely travel to a G5/G6. Same as it ever was and will be. In an average season, G teams have had 18-20 home games vs P4 teams. This year there have been 9 so far (UConn hosts UNC this weekend).

Teams in the American and MW/PAC are much more likely to host P4 teams, now and over the past dozen years. Still, if we only look at home games the records are not good for most of the G6.

CFP Era 2014 to 2026 - Home vs P5
MAC, Sun Belt, CUSA and Independents are 19-86 .181
American, new PAC and MW are 56-80 .421

You can probably point to a bunch of close losses and competitive games but the win/loss record is not good. Historically there have been close games AND more wins for the G6 programs.
(This post was last modified: 11-06-2026 08:24 AM by PicksUp.)
11-06-2026 08:23 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
whittx Offline
All American
*

Posts: 2,908
Joined: Apr 2016
Reputation: 129
I Root For: FSU, Bport,Corn
Location:
Post: #98
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(10-27-2026 03:58 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:57 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:48 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:18 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.

Decades of tradition as power conference game. I don’t think that bowl game qualifies.

It is probably the Sun Bowl.07-coffee3

Gator Bowl is my guess. 7 SEC teams making CFP, getting outbid for 7-5/6-6 SEC teams by Citrus/Outback/Vegas/etc.

I think Sun Bowl continues just because it’s so important locally to El Paso. It’s El Paso’s Super Bowl.

The Gator Bowl has always been well-funded, though, and they’ll have a renovated stadium after next year in Jacksonville.

I would put the Sun Bowl as more at-risk. The Holiday Bowl has already had issues and that would qualify as a long-time power conference bowl.

As a general rule, NFL stadiums are going to have more funding and have an incentive to fill dates between NFL games. The exceptions are the Citrus Bowl and Pop Tart Bowl at Camping World Stadium, but they have the benefit of a massive Central Florida tourism bureau behind them. If your bowl is not in an NFL stadium or Orlando, you’re at risk.

The Alamo Bowl should be safe. Combination of strong tourism, lots of Texas teams, and an open Alamodome schedule helps
11-06-2026 03:04 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Stugray2 Online
Heisman
*

Posts: 9,350
Joined: Jan 2017
Reputation: 978
I Root For: tOSU SJSU Stan'
Location: South Bay Area CA
Post: #99
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
Attackcoog,

I think there won't be any A4 teams available for the G6 to match up with. You will have the top 23 in the CFP and if they A4 builds a 6 to 8-game consortium the next 12 to 16 playing in those games. If the 7-5 requirement comes in play and add a few opt outs, there simply won't be any A4 schools to invite.

That is the problem the G6 is facing. Things like the Fenway, Poinsettia and Military bowls which are G6 vs A4 are going to be gone, as will the G6 CCGs. In that reality your solution simply evaporates.

You have to ask what will the G6 do in that environment for the champions who do not play in the CFP and no longer even have a CCG? What about the runner ups? No A4 to play in a bowl.

This is why a playoff where G6 schools host in their own stadiums is likely the best of a bunch of bad options. At least this one doesn't lose money. And you only need one Bowl for the championship game.
11-06-2026 03:59 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Kittonhead Offline
Hall of Famer
*

Posts: 10,286
Joined: Jun 2013
Reputation: 133
I Root For: Rock n' Roll
Location:
Post: #100
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(11-06-2026 03:59 PM)Stugray2 Wrote:  Attackcoog,

I think there won't be any A4 teams available for the G6 to match up with. You will have the top 23 in the CFP and if they A4 builds a 6 to 8-game consortium the next 12 to 16 playing in those games. If the 7-5 requirement comes in play and add a few opt outs, there simply won't be any A4 schools to invite.

If anything the AC/PAC dream about having status by playing the A4 in bowls is a dead one, IMO.
11-06-2026 04:09 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.