CSNbbs
McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup (/thread-1034828.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - IWokeUpLikeThis - 10-27-2026 01:59 PM



Decades-long bowl with power conference matchups.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - thrill_house - 10-27-2026 02:18 PM

Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - PicksUp - 10-27-2026 02:48 PM

(10-27-2026 02:18 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.

Decades of tradition as power conference game. I don’t think that bowl game qualifies.

It is probably the Sun Bowl.07-coffee3


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Psicosis - 10-27-2026 02:50 PM

"Then die."


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - IWokeUpLikeThis - 10-27-2026 02:57 PM

(10-27-2026 02:48 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:18 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.

Decades of tradition as power conference game. I don’t think that bowl game qualifies.

It is probably the Sun Bowl.07-coffee3

Gator Bowl is my guess. 7 SEC teams making CFP, getting outbid for 7-5/6-6 SEC teams by Citrus/Outback/Vegas/etc.

I think Sun Bowl continues just because it’s so important locally to El Paso. It’s El Paso’s Super Bowl.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - TerryD - 10-27-2026 03:06 PM

I have been to both the Independence Bowl and the Sun Bowl.

I think that the Sun Bowl is about 500 times better and much more fun.

If it is between the two, I hope that the Sun Bowl survives


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - AssKickingChicken - 10-27-2026 03:32 PM

There will be 12 bowl slots open up because of the expansion and 12 P4s that won’t be in a traditional bowl. So that’s six games that won’t have a matchup like they do now.

Obviously, the top Tier Two bowls where the 12 who aren’t in the playoffs this year but will next year will just dip into the P4s ranked just below 24th place. But some will be left out and their ego won’t let them have a game without a P4. Or, more likely, their sponsors don’t want to pay the same money for a MAC-Sun Belt game that they are paying for SEC-ACC.

It will hurt the Tier Three bowls as well. Right now they barely have enough 6-6 teams to fill all the slots and then you have teams declining because half the team is in the portal. We could be seeing 4-8 teams in bowls.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Fighting Muskie - 10-27-2026 03:51 PM

I think the whole economics of the bowl system is about to be completely dismantled.

I don’t think your top non-playoff bowls are going to be able to attract the same size audience, sponsors, and quality of participants with the top 24 all being off the table.

I think there’s going to be greater reluctance to participate in them. Athletes looking to the portal will sit and ADs will be less inclined to green light what’s likely to be a money losing venture due to travel costs.

What were once the top crust bowls outside the NY6 are going to have to settle for teams that are 8-4 or worse. I only think the bowls in highly desirable locations have a prayer at survival because to entice fans to travel, they are going to need to incorporate a family vacation into the trip.

Additionally, I think Disney needs to rethink the lowest tier G6 Bowls. If they actually want to to see some gate receipts, they need to move away from Birmingham, Montgomery, Frisco, Albuquerque, Boise, Detroit, and Annapolis and concentrate those games in Orlando (Citrus Bowl/UCF/MLS stadium) and SoCal (the MLS stadiums). Offer packages that include bowl & theme park tickets and try to get bowl visitors into Disney properties rather than someone else’s hotel.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Frank the Tank - 10-27-2026 03:58 PM

(10-27-2026 02:57 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:48 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:18 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.

Decades of tradition as power conference game. I don’t think that bowl game qualifies.

It is probably the Sun Bowl.07-coffee3

Gator Bowl is my guess. 7 SEC teams making CFP, getting outbid for 7-5/6-6 SEC teams by Citrus/Outback/Vegas/etc.

I think Sun Bowl continues just because it’s so important locally to El Paso. It’s El Paso’s Super Bowl.

The Gator Bowl has always been well-funded, though, and they’ll have a renovated stadium after next year in Jacksonville.

I would put the Sun Bowl as more at-risk. The Holiday Bowl has already had issues and that would qualify as a long-time power conference bowl.

As a general rule, NFL stadiums are going to have more funding and have an incentive to fill dates between NFL games. The exceptions are the Citrus Bowl and Pop Tart Bowl at Camping World Stadium, but they have the benefit of a massive Central Florida tourism bureau behind them. If your bowl is not in an NFL stadium or Orlando, you’re at risk.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - bryanw1995 - 10-27-2026 04:01 PM

(10-27-2026 03:06 PM)TerryD Wrote:  I have been to both the Independence Bowl and the Sun Bowl.

I think that the Sun Bowl is about 500 times better and much more fun.

If it is between the two, I hope that the Sun Bowl survives

I remember we played an Independence Bowl against Miss St in white out conditions a couple decades ago. The Sun Bowl is certainly a "better" bowl, but Shreveport is a whole lot closer to civilization than El Paso is.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - thrill_house - 10-27-2026 04:53 PM

(10-27-2026 02:48 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  Decades of tradition as power conference game. I don’t think that bowl game qualifies.

It is probably the Sun Bowl.07-coffee3

From 1995-2009, the Independence Bowl was the SEC's fifth choice. The Big 12 and ACC have also sent over a dozen teams to Shreveport in the last 35 years.

The Texas Bowl killed the Independence Bowl in 2014 and rightfully so. Houston is a more affordable destination with a better stadium.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - thrill_house - 10-27-2026 05:10 PM

(10-27-2026 03:51 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think the whole economics of the bowl system is about to be completely dismantled.

I don’t think your top non-playoff bowls are going to be able to attract the same size audience, sponsors, and quality of participants with the top 24 all being off the table.

I think there’s going to be greater reluctance to participate in them. Athletes looking to the portal will sit and ADs will be less inclined to green light what’s likely to be a money losing venture due to travel costs.

What were once the top crust bowls outside the NY6 are going to have to settle for teams that are 8-4 or worse. I only think the bowls in highly desirable locations have a prayer at survival because to entice fans to travel, they are going to need to incorporate a family vacation into the trip.

Additionally, I think Disney needs to rethink the lowest tier G6 Bowls. If they actually want to to see some gate receipts, they need to move away from Birmingham, Montgomery, Frisco, Albuquerque, Boise, Detroit, and Annapolis and concentrate those games in Orlando (Citrus Bowl/UCF/MLS stadium) and SoCal (the MLS stadiums). Offer packages that include bowl & theme park tickets and try to get bowl visitors into Disney properties rather than someone else’s hotel.

[Image: gettyimages-1196071757-2048x2048.jpg]

The Cure Bowl was great when Exploria Stadium hosted it. Fans were right on top of the action, and the smaller venue provided a more lively atmosphere.

For the latest 3 editions, the game was moved to UCF/Citrus Bowl. There is no atmosphere because the stadium is 5x too big for the teams playing in it.

I wonder if rent went up to a point where MLS said: "We don't want these teams trashing our field". It makes way too much sense to play these G6 games at MLS venues, especially considering their season is over in mid-December.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Scoochpooch1 - 10-27-2026 05:15 PM

(10-27-2026 02:50 PM)Psicosis Wrote:  "Then die."

Kind of flies in the face of G6 are amazing teams theory you probably promote.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Fighting Muskie - 10-27-2026 05:22 PM

We need to answer a few questions:

Are P2/M2 teams that are 6-6 or better still going to want to go bowling?

Are bowls who were accustomed to hosting ranked P2/M2 teams going to be ok with their 7-5 conference mates?

Are bowls who used to get 6-6 and 7-5 P2/M2 teams going to be okay with G6s?

At some point in this flow chart, I think we are going to find either teams or bowls removing themselves from the equation.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Dr Dawgma III - 10-27-2026 06:21 PM

(10-27-2026 02:57 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:48 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:18 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.

Decades of tradition as power conference game. I don’t think that bowl game qualifies.

It is probably the Sun Bowl.07-coffee3

Gator Bowl is my guess. 7 SEC teams making CFP, getting outbid for 7-5/6-6 SEC teams by Citrus/Outback/Vegas/etc.

I think Sun Bowl continues just because it’s so important locally to El Paso. It’s El Paso’s Super Bowl.

The new “Gator Bowl” stadium looks incredible. They should moved past the Citrus in the pecking order with that palace. May even host a natty.

At some point I imagine some CFP bowl slots going to market.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Dr Dawgma III - 10-27-2026 06:23 PM

May I suggest some bowls transition to Kickoff Classic-esque bowls.

Some folks recall the days of the in-season Tobacco and Oyster Bowls.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Attackcoog - 10-27-2026 06:27 PM

(10-27-2026 03:51 PM)Fighting Muskie Wrote:  I think the whole economics of the bowl system is about to be completely dismantled.

I don’t think your top non-playoff bowls are going to be able to attract the same size audience, sponsors, and quality of participants with the top 24 all being off the table.

I think there’s going to be greater reluctance to participate in them. Athletes looking to the portal will sit and ADs will be less inclined to green light what’s likely to be a money losing venture due to travel costs.

What were once the top crust bowls outside the NY6 are going to have to settle for teams that are 8-4 or worse. I only think the bowls in highly desirable locations have a prayer at survival because to entice fans to travel, they are going to need to incorporate a family vacation into the trip.

Additionally, I think Disney needs to rethink the lowest tier G6 Bowls. If they actually want to to see some gate receipts, they need to move away from Birmingham, Montgomery, Frisco, Albuquerque, Boise, Detroit, and Annapolis and concentrate those games in Orlando (Citrus Bowl/UCF/MLS stadium) and SoCal (the MLS stadiums). Offer packages that include bowl & theme park tickets and try to get bowl visitors into Disney properties rather than someone else’s hotel.

I agree. The economics for the bowls going forward probably favor the survival of the small "made for television" G6 bowls more than the big crowd based major bowls. Since most of the teams filling the 24 team playoff are going to be coming from P4 ranks---there are not going to be enough P4 teams with traveling fan bases to fill out all those existing P4 bowls that count on big traveling P4 crowds. Even if there were enough P4 teams---I dont know if P4 fan bases are going to care much anymore when you have a 24 team CFP and star players are opting out of bowl games right and left.

Let some bowls die. It is what it is. Adapt or die. I suspect most of the G6 bowls should be ok---and G6 bowls might even end up with a few more P4 teams playing in them when it all shakes out. A cheap close nearby convenient G6 bowl may be attractive to some hungry fan bases of P4 schools who are 6-6 or 6-7 and excited about a turnaround year.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - Usajags - 10-27-2026 07:11 PM

For some of these aging municipal stadiums, these bowls were all they had. Now with them going away, those buildings will sit empty and decay into the ground.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - UofMemphis - 10-27-2026 07:31 PM

(10-27-2026 02:18 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.

and that stadium is quickly approaching 'dump' status without a MAJOR renovation soon.


RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup - PicksUp - 10-27-2026 07:42 PM

(10-27-2026 02:57 PM)IWokeUpLikeThis Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:48 PM)PicksUp Wrote:  
(10-27-2026 02:18 PM)thrill_house Wrote:  Shame he doesn't name the bowl game.

I'm sure it's someone like Shreveport (Independence), where no one outside of Louisiana Tech has any interest in attending now that there are better options.

There's going to be cuts at the top as well. The teams that would have made the Top-5 or so bowl games will be in the CFP going forward.

Decades of tradition as power conference game. I don’t think that bowl game qualifies.

It is probably the Sun Bowl.07-coffee3

Gator Bowl is my guess. 7 SEC teams making CFP, getting outbid for 7-5/6-6 SEC teams by Citrus/Outback/Vegas/etc.

I think Sun Bowl continues just because it’s so important locally to El Paso. It’s El Paso’s Super Bowl.

The Sun Bowl’s contract is up this year but apparently the ACC is still interested. I read that the SEC is likely not an option but the Big 12 and Big Ten have had talks.

I just remembered there was a thread about the Vegas bowl a couple months ago. That might be it.