bullet
Legend

Posts: 83,946
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5074
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
|
RE: McMurphy: One long-time bowl would rather fold than a G6 vs G6 matchup
(10-29-2026 09:32 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (10-28-2026 09:54 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: (10-28-2026 02:44 PM)NDSUguy Wrote: (10-28-2026 02:27 PM)Stugray2 Wrote: We are likely to see the A4 sign a deal with at least half a dozen bowls, maybe as many as ten, to guarantee matchups.
I think the A4 need to be careful on how many they place in their consortium, as with an expanded playoff there are going to be a number of opt outs, just like we see amongst disappointed basketball teams who pass on the NIT and Crown, several changing coaches, making it harder to fill. The plan floated in Spring for a 10-bowl consortium is likely more than they can safely fill. I checked last year and only 19 schools that didn't make the playoffs were 7-5 or better, one of them (Notre Dame) opted out of a bowl game. I think we can reasonably assume at least 3 or 4 schools will opt out, making 7 the largest number of bowls a consortium can expect to fill. (Note, something like 6 of the A4 teams in bowls played in minor bowls against G6 opponents.) If the A4 decide on more than 6 or 7 bowls to sponsor, they may need language in the contract to say, "or other high value opponent acceptable to all parties," so they can take a good traveling fan base 6-6 A4 school that just surged and are excited to play or a strong 10-win G6 school with a higher profile and reasonable following (think Boise State, South Florida, Memphis, Tulane type schools).
Personally, I'd play it safe and sponsor just 6 games (I'd still have the exception language to let some top 25 JMU or NDSU team passed over for the CFP play, as that might be higher profile than a 7-5 Purdue, Boston College or Cincinnati option). This would make these exhibitions a bit more valuable to participants. That should be sufficient number of games to fill the TV slots in the gap between the second round played just before Christmas and the NYD quarterfinals. Any remaining 7+ win A4 schools who want to play in a bowl can sign on to whatever mid-tier ones are left.
The G6 is going to have to think hard about how to come up with something worthwhile for their 9 to 11 win schools other than the leftover pre-Christmas Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday night bowls in third tier locations for ESPN2 and ESPNU channel broadcasts. If nothing else, I'd consider a 3 or 4 bowl consortium of their own ("Champions Series), with mid-tier bowls after Christmas, to match up the conference champions against each other or a strong 2nd place team. That would at least give winning the conference a good higher profile game to play in, where people can see they won a conference, maybe be seen as an advertisement for consideration in next year's CFP access slot selection. (Taking into account Frank the Tank and others observation that a G6 tournament would have a very low media value, similar to the NIT in basketball.)
He's on to something here with the champions series, however it actually should be done before the end of the regular season to help bolster the SOS of the best teams that season. The goal for the G6 should be to try to find a way to get their autobid into the CFP and get a second team in through SOS by ranking somewhere in the 18-23 range. If the cfp expanding to 24 teams with only 1 spot is inevitable, the G6 needs to find a way to combat that and do their best to sneak in 2 teams. And I fully admit this will be VERY difficult especially with the number of P4 games reducing each year.
At the end of the year they could have a championship bowl series to help with the metric driven rankings that are somewhat based on prior year performance like SP+ and FPI. The higher the G6 ranks at the beginning of the year the easier it is to be ranked as the year progresses.
Sorry, there won't be a 2nd.
It appears the selection is almost certainly going to occur after the final regular season game, before any CCGs (or your proposed matchups). And the rules are rumored to be written requiring 10 A4 opponents; meaning the non-A4 selection is almost certainly going to be a single-entry exception clause, not an open opportunity.
There is also no way the SoS can possibly increase enough to matter between two G6 schools against any of the top 30 or so A4 schools. Playing such a game would be moot. Honestly the only way I see a 2nd G6 team ever getting in is by going undefeated but consensus held to be a lower quality team than some 11-1 or 10-2 G6 school selected (e.g., say Sam Houston manages to go undefeated, but played nobody in A4 nor a G6 with a better than 8-4 record, while South Florida 11-1 had strong schedules and higher power rankings). An undefeated 2nd tier G6 conference winner like my example above, would create too much public and political pressure to be passed over without blowback. The committee and the A4 will think it better to invite them, let them get blown out in the first round, than to face press and public complaining about some 9-3 Iowa, Louisville or Mississippi State getting in over them. That scenario is unlikely to come up, as they are more likely to bump the more deserving G6 school with an 11-1 record instead, but it is a possibility.
I believe the 10 P4 opponent rule is applicable only to the P4 teams - there’s a major antitrust issue if that rule were to be applied to all teams where it’s not actually possible for the G6 teams to ever meet that metric structurally.
I did see a quote from the Sun Belt commissioner last week where he stated that 40%(!) of their ESPN rights fee was tied to their conference championship game. As a result, they may still play a CCG or need to find some other alternative.
I’m super skeptical of any multi-game consolation G6 playoff/tournament - I continue to be perplexed why this would somehow be more valuable over consolation G6 bowls. Plus, if you already have any talented G6 player that’s headed to the transfer portal or NFL Draft opting out for a single bowl game, just imagine how many more would be opting out when they are being asked to play multiple consolation games.
As I’ve stated elsewhere, the best current open opportunitiez are the time slots before and after the Army-Navy Game that will now be played in the current CCG Saturday. As of now, there’s nothing there college football-wise as the CFP seems bent on having that an open bye week.
I would suggest setting up 3 bowls/games (one game Friday night and then before and after the Army-Navy Game on Saturday) featuring the champs from each G6 league (or where any G6 champ makes the CFP, then the next best team from that league). That gives all of those games great exposure while filling an actual market need (AKA other college football games on Army-Navy weekend).
Another option is that the G6 can all still play CCGs (or play-in games) that Army-Navy weekend (excepting again any CFP qualifier as they would skip those games and Army-Navy) and that determines who gets the top bowl berth for each league, which is really what has been happening the vast majority of the time already, anyway. This allows the G6 to play these games in a way that they did before and capture that revenue (which is clearly material based on what the Sun Belt commissioner has stated) while not forcing the G6 teams that are going to the CFP to play in them. Essentially, just keep playing the G6 CCGs or their equivalent on that first December weekend just as now (sans any G6 CFP qualifier and Army-Navy) because the calendar wouldn’t actually change from what it is now and then those winners would go on to play in bowl games later in the month just as they do now. In this case, less change is more (particularly since the P4 CCGs are vacating that weekend and leaving open time slots).
They may have to move those games to Thanksgiving weekend. P4 doesn't seem interested in allocating any of the $345 million extra to the G schools.
|
|