(10-26-2026 10:37 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote: Ruminating about Miami President Joe Echevarria’s criticism of the PCSA’s provisions for stabilizing collegiate athletics, I wonder about other mechanisms that politicians could create to achieve similar ends. Economic forces are promoting consolidation and tiering into ever larger conferences…increasingly separating economic winners and losers.
IMHO, Echevarria’s most stinging criticism was the B1G and SEC’s unilateral decision on the 24 team CFP expansion basically solidified everyone else into second class status…without sufficient agency in their futures. So why not address this major concern with specific action? For example,
1) Cap the power/authority of individual conferences in CFP decision making. Any individual conference could be limited to 30% voting rights on CFP matters.
and/or
2) Cap the maximum number of participants in the CFP for individual conferences. Any individual conference could be limited to seven participants in a 24 team CFP (7/24 =0.292…does not exceed 30%). Award any open CFP bid to the best performing team from an unrepresented conference (i.e., most deserving G6).
and/or
3) Cap the financial distribution of CFP revenues to any individual conference to 30% (all conferences are currently under this existing threshold). Rather than promoting zero-sum thinking by commissioners, it fosters broader collaboration as a social good.
If PCSA doesn’t pass in this Congress, the next iteration of an antitrust exemption for collegiate athletics could include innovations on how to limit consolidation of power and money.
How does that solidify anyone into 2nd class status? You think that TCU or Miss St gets more CFP bids in the next 10 years? Virginia Tech or Illinois? My Aggies or Miami? My Texas Tech-grad cousin thinks that Tech has an easier road to the CFP out of the Big 12, and they now have the financial resources to compete with not just A&M and Texas but really anybody in the country. I certainly view Texas Tech as a stronger rather than weaker program since OUT left the Big 12. Utah looks stronger to me now, or certainly at least as strong as they've been for most of the 21st century. Miami is doing great. VT seems to have turned a corner now that they have a good coach and a group of deep-pocketed donors willing to spend what it takes to compete (VT is 6-2 while UVA is 4-4 after everyone and his dog seemed to think that UVA was the new power in the State after their 2nd ever double digit wins season in 2025). Sure, and extra $30m+ gives P2 schools a bit of a leg up, but it's easy to figure out which schools have the largest budgets...just look at stadium capacity and average attendance figures. OSU and Texas lead the pack and they both have 100k seat stadiums. The other 100k seat stadium schools are in the top 10 in revenues or very close to it. The 80-90k seat stadium club are up there, too.
Here, let's look at the 15 schools with an over-$200k budget for 24-25 per our EADA revenues thread here:
https://csnbbs.com/thread-1028397.html
Texas..........................$343,106,827 - 100k + stadium capacity and attendance
Ohio State.....................$295,265,883 - same
Notre Dame....................$289,616,198 - 77k
Tennessee....................$285,364,027 - 100k+
Penn State.....................$254,397,122 - 100k +
Alabama......................$244,551,544 - 100k +
Michigan.......................$236,376,759 - 100k +
Texas A&M...................$235,498,020 - 100k +
Oklahoma....................$234,426,470 - 83k
USC..............................$234,029,848 - 77k but weak attendance as we have documented
Georgia........................$233,526,965 - 92k
Miami (FL).....................$230,484,608 - 65k
LSU.............................$223,457,268 - 100k+
Nebraska.......................$205,807,522 - 86k, sold out every single game since Kennedy Administration
Auburn.........................$205,275,913 - 88k
South Carolina..............$204,566,524 - 79k
The group in the 190-200m budget range is filled with huge stadiums, too, other than Stanford, who spends like Texas for their Olympics and spends like, um, Texas St for their football. The total of the schools in the 190s: FSU, Wisconsin, Stanford, Florida, Arkansas. 4 football factories with ~ 70k attendance +, and ofc Stanford. The 3 privates, USC, Miami, and Stanford stand out, though they have huge financial reserves and can spend what they want on the sports they care about (fb for USC and Miami, everything but football for Stanford). But the other 16 schools? 15 huge, public, enormous fan bases, extremely wealthy, all Flagships or equivalents, and then ND, which is the opposite of Stanford in that they care only about fb and spend what it takes to win in fb but not necessarily what it takes to win in everything else.
Remember that in 24-25, revenues were still pretty close across the conferences, perhaps a $25m gap from the legacy B1G schools to the legacy ACC schools. Take $25m away from every SEC and B1G school and give same to every Big 12 and ACC school, and this list largely looks the same. Texas and OSU still dominate, the other publics with huge stadiums + ND, USC and Miami are still in the top 15, and only Miami really elevates to another level.
The P2 are not in and of themselves doing anything wrong, the issue is just that so many of the highest revenue schools have been clustering in a smaller and smaller number of Conferences over the past couple decades. First the BE lost their fb factories to greener pastures, then the Big 12 (3 different times), then the Pac 12, now the ACC looks to be on deck. Ultimately, OSU will still be OSU and Alabama will still be Alabama whether they're in a 16-18 team conference, a 10 team conference, or a 24 team conference, and the same holds true for Virginia, NW or Utah.