Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
Author Message
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #1
PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
Ruminating about Miami President Joe Echevarria’s criticism of the PCSA’s provisions for stabilizing collegiate athletics, I wonder about other mechanisms that politicians could create to achieve similar ends. Economic forces are promoting consolidation and tiering into ever larger conferences…increasingly separating economic winners and losers.

IMHO, Echevarria’s most stinging criticism was the B1G and SEC’s unilateral decision on the 24 team CFP expansion basically solidified everyone else into second class status…without sufficient agency in their futures. So why not address this major concern with specific action? For example,

1) Cap the power/authority of individual conferences in CFP decision making. Any individual conference could be limited to 30% voting rights on CFP matters.

and/or

2) Cap the maximum number of participants in the CFP for individual conferences. Any individual conference could be limited to seven participants in a 24 team CFP (7/24 =0.292…does not exceed 30%). Award any open CFP bid to the best performing team from an unrepresented conference (i.e., most deserving G6).

and/or

3) Cap the financial distribution of CFP revenues to any individual conference to 30% (all conferences are currently under this existing threshold). Rather than promoting zero-sum thinking by commissioners, it fosters broader collaboration as a social good.


If PCSA doesn’t pass in this Congress, the next iteration of an antitrust exemption for collegiate athletics could include innovations on how to limit consolidation of power and money.
10-26-2026 10:37 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #2
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 10:37 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Ruminating about Miami President Joe Echevarria’s criticism of the PCSA’s provisions for stabilizing collegiate athletics, I wonder about other mechanisms that politicians could create to achieve similar ends. Economic forces are promoting consolidation and tiering into ever larger conferences…increasingly separating economic winners and losers.

IMHO, Echevarria’s most stinging criticism was the B1G and SEC’s unilateral decision on the 24 team CFP expansion basically solidified everyone else into second class status…without sufficient agency in their futures. So why not address this major concern with specific action? For example,

1) Cap the power/authority of individual conferences in CFP decision making. Any individual conference could be limited to 30% voting rights on CFP matters.

and/or

2) Cap the maximum number of participants in the CFP for individual conferences. Any individual conference could be limited to seven participants in a 24 team CFP (7/24 =0.292…does not exceed 30%). Award any open CFP bid to the best performing team from an unrepresented conference (i.e., most deserving G6).

and/or

3) Cap the financial distribution of CFP revenues to any individual conference to 30% (all conferences are currently under this existing threshold). Rather than promoting zero-sum thinking by commissioners, it fosters broader collaboration as a social good.


If PCSA doesn’t pass in this Congress, the next iteration of an antitrust exemption for collegiate athletics could include innovations on how to limit consolidation of power and money.

The Catch 22 is that you can't declare the athletic departments of state universities a business and then tell them what to do to prevent being as profitable as they can be.

If they are indeed businesses, and I believe they are, and they are directed to pay their athletes, allow players' unions, and collectively bargain with them, which Justice Kavanaugh recommended, the whole concept of free markets should apply. And if we are going to tell the schools that they can't pool rights perhaps we should revisit exactly what all major corporate chains do as they are driving independent business people out of competition. Just food for thought.

Either the athletic departments of these schools are commercial enterprises and afforded the full spectrum of potentialities to make money as their counterparts in the marketplace already do, or we are talking about a hybrid commercial enterprise which is neither free market, nor nonprofit. If that is indeed the case, and I believe that is how the athletic departments and schools they represent see them, then we need a classification both for tax purposes and limiting the range of free market exercise permitted them. And if that is the case, and again I believe it is, then they also need a new governance structure complete with new rules to govern them. Under those circumstances it can't be the free market, but neither can it be the NCAA.

The nature of College Athletics has not been changed by the schools, but by antiquated governance that no longer is current with the reality of its sitz im leben, and because of that falling under direction of the courts as to its prescribed course of action, but with few wanting it to be truly free market, it needs to be classified and treated as what it is, a hybrid commercial product, subject to limitations and oversight of a new and unique fashion.

Perhaps we don't need the PCSA. Perhaps we need the approval to create its governance structure unique to its nature and unique to how as a product mostly owned by the states it functions within the realm of commerce on behalf of nonprofit state institutions.

The courts have directed it be treated as a for profit business. The old governance structure was predicated on amateurism. It is obviously neither. It is other.

I believe doing this will bring those schools actually NETTING revenue sufficient to compete into one collective grouping eliminating the current situation of the two strongest being the determiners of everyone's future, but absolutely setting that tier apart whether the dividing line gives us 60 or 72 schools.

That would do more for the P4 than where we are headed. Conference size then would not be an issue because the collective, much as many in the SEC and Big Ten may dislike it would pool their rights. Conferences could be kept but as voting units of presidents and not as independent negotiating and lobbying groups under the direction of commissioners. If you want to level the playing field for the upper tier the media money is a small step toward that. As anyone can see in the gross revenue totals what schools make through all other means makes the media distribution 1/4th to 1/5th of solid programs' Gross Revenue. The fairness in this is that institutions can best decide how to market themselves to their alumni and sold out venues and ticket priorities give them the means by which to optimize each schools potential. Media revenue, though it is as crack cocaine to some posters, would then be pooled and equal. Moving for more media revenue then would cease. Schools that did want to move would be moving for the associations, to curtail travel costs, and for competitive reasons for other sports.

We can't stay in an FBS with the disparity that exists in the current one. We need tiers. I'm not sure we need conference offices, commissioners, and expensive duplicated corporate office space. And if media is pooled for 60 to 72 schools in an upper tier only the voice of presidents will be needed. The rest can go. The rights provider(s) can see to the various conference networks and make sure the whole tier is represented. And the tier leadership can handle scheduling and should keep all games for revenue sports within the tier.

That should eliminate much of the current angst, eliminate the left behind scenarios, make us more revenue through elimination of duplicated overhead, and make all games relevant. What it won't permit is a "Last Rat Standing" scenario where the strong keep killing off the weaker until one Rat is left.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2026 11:31 AM by JRsec.)
10-26-2026 11:11 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Wahoowa84 Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 5,436
Joined: Oct 2017
Reputation: 1176
I Root For: UVa
Location:
Post: #3
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 11:11 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 10:37 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Ruminating about Miami President Joe Echevarria’s criticism of the PCSA’s provisions for stabilizing collegiate athletics, I wonder about other mechanisms that politicians could create to achieve similar ends. Economic forces are promoting consolidation and tiering into ever larger conferences…increasingly separating economic winners and losers.

IMHO, Echevarria’s most stinging criticism was the B1G and SEC’s unilateral decision on the 24 team CFP expansion basically solidified everyone else into second class status…without sufficient agency in their futures. So why not address this major concern with specific action? For example,

1) Cap the power/authority of individual conferences in CFP decision making. Any individual conference could be limited to 30% voting rights on CFP matters.

and/or

2) Cap the maximum number of participants in the CFP for individual conferences. Any individual conference could be limited to seven participants in a 24 team CFP (7/24 =0.292…does not exceed 30%). Award any open CFP bid to the best performing team from an unrepresented conference (i.e., most deserving G6).

and/or

3) Cap the financial distribution of CFP revenues to any individual conference to 30% (all conferences are currently under this existing threshold). Rather than promoting zero-sum thinking by commissioners, it fosters broader collaboration as a social good.


If PCSA doesn’t pass in this Congress, the next iteration of an antitrust exemption for collegiate athletics could include innovations on how to limit consolidation of power and money.

The Catch 22 is that you can't declare the athletic departments of state universities a business and then tell them what to do to prevent being as profitable as they can be.

If they are indeed businesses, and I believe they are, and they are directed to pay their athletes, allow players' unions, and collectively bargain with them, which Justice Kavanaugh recommended, the whole concept of free markets should apply. And if we are going to tell the schools that they can't pool rights perhaps we should revisit exactly what all major corporate chains do as they are driving independent business people out of competition. Just food for thought.

Either the athletic departments of these schools are commercial enterprises and afforded the full spectrum of potentialities to make money as their counterparts in the marketplace already do, or we are talking about a hybrid commercial enterprise which is neither free market, nor nonprofit. If that is indeed the case, and I believe that is how the athletic departments and schools they represent see them, then we need a classification both for tax purposes and limiting the range of free market exercise permitted them. And if that is the case, and again I believe it is, then they also need a new governance structure complete with new rules to govern them. Under those circumstances it can't be the free market, but neither can it be the NCAA.

The nature of College Athletics has not been changed by the schools, but by antiquated governance that no longer is current with the reality of its sitz im leben, and because of that falling under direction of the courts as to its prescribed course of action, but with few wanting it to be truly free market, it needs to be classified and treated as what it is, a hybrid commercial product, subject to limitations and oversight of a new and unique fashion.

Perhaps we don't need the PCSA. Perhaps we need the approval to create its governance structure unique to its nature and unique to how as a product mostly owned by the states it functions within the realm of commerce on behalf of nonprofit state institutions.

The courts have directed it be treated as a for profit business. The old governance structure was predicated on amateurism. It is obviously neither. It is other.

I believe doing this will bring those schools actually NETTING revenue sufficient to compete into one collective grouping eliminating the current situation of the two strongest being the determiners of everyone's future, but absolutely setting that tier apart whether the dividing line gives us 60 or 72 schools.

That would do more for the P4 than where we are headed. Conference size then would not be an issue because the collective, much as many in the SEC and Big Ten may dislike it would pool their rights. Conferences could be kept but as voting units of presidents and not as independent negotiating and lobbying groups under the direction of commissioners. If you want to level the playing field for the upper tier the media money is a small step toward that. As anyone can see in the gross revenue totals what schools make through all other means makes the media distribution 1/4th to 1/5th of solid programs' Gross Revenue. The fairness in this is that institutions can best decide how to market themselves to their alumni and sold out venues and ticket priorities give them the means by which to optimize each schools potential. Media revenue, though it is as crack cocaine to some posters, would then be pooled and equal. Moving for more media revenue then would cease. Schools that did want to move would be moving for the associations, to curtail travel costs, and for competitive reasons for other sports.

We can't stay in an FBS with the disparity that exists in the current one. We need tiers. I'm not sure we need conference offices, commissioners, and expensive duplicated corporate office space. And if media is pooled for 60 to 72 schools in an upper tier only the voice of presidents will be needed. The rest can go. The rights provider(s) can see to the various conference networks and make sure the whole tier is represented. And the tier leadership can handle scheduling and should keep all games for revenue sports within the tier.

That should eliminate much of the current angst, eliminate the left behind scenarios, make us more revenue through elimination of duplicated overhead, and make all games relevant. What it won't permit is a "Last Rat Standing" scenario where the strong keep killing off the weaker until one Rat is left.

My take is that all legislation is a form of compromise or mediation. The 19 member conference cap that was initially agreed to (and possibly proposed) by B1G and SEC leaders likely had more significant impact on revenues than any of these potential tweaks to the CFP. Isn’t Miami President Echevarria’s underlying concern that the biggest beneficiaries of the antitrust exemptions will be Alabama, Georgia, Michigan, Ohio State, Penn State and Texas? The pushback on PCSA is not principally along traditional ideological splits…the pushback is strongest from the few schools that are desperately close to joining the uber-elites.
10-26-2026 12:48 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,941
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3761
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #4
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 10:37 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Ruminating about Miami President Joe Echevarria’s criticism of the PCSA’s provisions for stabilizing collegiate athletics, I wonder about other mechanisms that politicians could create to achieve similar ends. Economic forces are promoting consolidation and tiering into ever larger conferences…increasingly separating economic winners and losers.

IMHO, Echevarria’s most stinging criticism was the B1G and SEC’s unilateral decision on the 24 team CFP expansion basically solidified everyone else into second class status…without sufficient agency in their futures. So why not address this major concern with specific action? For example,

1) Cap the power/authority of individual conferences in CFP decision making. Any individual conference could be limited to 30% voting rights on CFP matters.

and/or

2) Cap the maximum number of participants in the CFP for individual conferences. Any individual conference could be limited to seven participants in a 24 team CFP (7/24 =0.292…does not exceed 30%). Award any open CFP bid to the best performing team from an unrepresented conference (i.e., most deserving G6).

and/or

3) Cap the financial distribution of CFP revenues to any individual conference to 30% (all conferences are currently under this existing threshold). Rather than promoting zero-sum thinking by commissioners, it fosters broader collaboration as a social good.


If PCSA doesn’t pass in this Congress, the next iteration of an antitrust exemption for collegiate athletics could include innovations on how to limit consolidation of power and money.

How does that solidify anyone into 2nd class status? You think that TCU or Miss St gets more CFP bids in the next 10 years? Virginia Tech or Illinois? My Aggies or Miami? My Texas Tech-grad cousin thinks that Tech has an easier road to the CFP out of the Big 12, and they now have the financial resources to compete with not just A&M and Texas but really anybody in the country. I certainly view Texas Tech as a stronger rather than weaker program since OUT left the Big 12. Utah looks stronger to me now, or certainly at least as strong as they've been for most of the 21st century. Miami is doing great. VT seems to have turned a corner now that they have a good coach and a group of deep-pocketed donors willing to spend what it takes to compete (VT is 6-2 while UVA is 4-4 after everyone and his dog seemed to think that UVA was the new power in the State after their 2nd ever double digit wins season in 2025). Sure, and extra $30m+ gives P2 schools a bit of a leg up, but it's easy to figure out which schools have the largest budgets...just look at stadium capacity and average attendance figures. OSU and Texas lead the pack and they both have 100k seat stadiums. The other 100k seat stadium schools are in the top 10 in revenues or very close to it. The 80-90k seat stadium club are up there, too.

Here, let's look at the 15 schools with an over-$200k budget for 24-25 per our EADA revenues thread here: https://csnbbs.com/thread-1028397.html

Texas..........................$343,106,827 - 100k + stadium capacity and attendance
Ohio State.....................$295,265,883 - same
Notre Dame....................$289,616,198 - 77k
Tennessee....................$285,364,027 - 100k+
Penn State.....................$254,397,122 - 100k +
Alabama......................$244,551,544 - 100k +
Michigan.......................$236,376,759 - 100k +
Texas A&M...................$235,498,020 - 100k +
Oklahoma....................$234,426,470 - 83k
USC..............................$234,029,848 - 77k but weak attendance as we have documented
Georgia........................$233,526,965 - 92k
Miami (FL).....................$230,484,608 - 65k
LSU.............................$223,457,268 - 100k+
Nebraska.......................$205,807,522 - 86k, sold out every single game since Kennedy Administration
Auburn.........................$205,275,913 - 88k
South Carolina..............$204,566,524 - 79k

The group in the 190-200m budget range is filled with huge stadiums, too, other than Stanford, who spends like Texas for their Olympics and spends like, um, Texas St for their football. The total of the schools in the 190s: FSU, Wisconsin, Stanford, Florida, Arkansas. 4 football factories with ~ 70k attendance +, and ofc Stanford. The 3 privates, USC, Miami, and Stanford stand out, though they have huge financial reserves and can spend what they want on the sports they care about (fb for USC and Miami, everything but football for Stanford). But the other 16 schools? 15 huge, public, enormous fan bases, extremely wealthy, all Flagships or equivalents, and then ND, which is the opposite of Stanford in that they care only about fb and spend what it takes to win in fb but not necessarily what it takes to win in everything else.

Remember that in 24-25, revenues were still pretty close across the conferences, perhaps a $25m gap from the legacy B1G schools to the legacy ACC schools. Take $25m away from every SEC and B1G school and give same to every Big 12 and ACC school, and this list largely looks the same. Texas and OSU still dominate, the other publics with huge stadiums + ND, USC and Miami are still in the top 15, and only Miami really elevates to another level.

The P2 are not in and of themselves doing anything wrong, the issue is just that so many of the highest revenue schools have been clustering in a smaller and smaller number of Conferences over the past couple decades. First the BE lost their fb factories to greener pastures, then the Big 12 (3 different times), then the Pac 12, now the ACC looks to be on deck. Ultimately, OSU will still be OSU and Alabama will still be Alabama whether they're in a 16-18 team conference, a 10 team conference, or a 24 team conference, and the same holds true for Virginia, NW or Utah.
10-26-2026 01:28 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,069
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #5
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
If the PCSA doesn't pass soon, and the next wave of politicians thinks a lot differently... well, I don't think that benefits the B1G and SEC as much as the current iteration of the bill.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2026 01:35 PM by Dr Dawgma III.)
10-26-2026 01:34 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #6
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 12:48 PM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 11:11 AM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 10:37 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Ruminating about Miami President Joe Echevarria’s criticism of the PCSA’s provisions for stabilizing collegiate athletics, I wonder about other mechanisms that politicians could create to achieve similar ends. Economic forces are promoting consolidation and tiering into ever larger conferences…increasingly separating economic winners and losers.

IMHO, Echevarria’s most stinging criticism was the B1G and SEC’s unilateral decision on the 24 team CFP expansion basically solidified everyone else into second class status…without sufficient agency in their futures. So why not address this major concern with specific action? For example,

1) Cap the power/authority of individual conferences in CFP decision making. Any individual conference could be limited to 30% voting rights on CFP matters.

and/or

2) Cap the maximum number of participants in the CFP for individual conferences. Any individual conference could be limited to seven participants in a 24 team CFP (7/24 =0.292…does not exceed 30%). Award any open CFP bid to the best performing team from an unrepresented conference (i.e., most deserving G6).

and/or

3) Cap the financial distribution of CFP revenues to any individual conference to 30% (all conferences are currently under this existing threshold). Rather than promoting zero-sum thinking by commissioners, it fosters broader collaboration as a social good.


If PCSA doesn’t pass in this Congress, the next iteration of an antitrust exemption for collegiate athletics could include innovations on how to limit consolidation of power and money.

The Catch 22 is that you can't declare the athletic departments of state universities a business and then tell them what to do to prevent being as profitable as they can be.

If they are indeed businesses, and I believe they are, and they are directed to pay their athletes, allow players' unions, and collectively bargain with them, which Justice Kavanaugh recommended, the whole concept of free markets should apply. And if we are going to tell the schools that they can't pool rights perhaps we should revisit exactly what all major corporate chains do as they are driving independent business people out of competition. Just food for thought.

Either the athletic departments of these schools are commercial enterprises and afforded the full spectrum of potentialities to make money as their counterparts in the marketplace already do, or we are talking about a hybrid commercial enterprise which is neither free market, nor nonprofit. If that is indeed the case, and I believe that is how the athletic departments and schools they represent see them, then we need a classification both for tax purposes and limiting the range of free market exercise permitted them. And if that is the case, and again I believe it is, then they also need a new governance structure complete with new rules to govern them. Under those circumstances it can't be the free market, but neither can it be the NCAA.

The nature of College Athletics has not been changed by the schools, but by antiquated governance that no longer is current with the reality of its sitz im leben, and because of that falling under direction of the courts as to its prescribed course of action, but with few wanting it to be truly free market, it needs to be classified and treated as what it is, a hybrid commercial product, subject to limitations and oversight of a new and unique fashion.

Perhaps we don't need the PCSA. Perhaps we need the approval to create its governance structure unique to its nature and unique to how as a product mostly owned by the states it functions within the realm of commerce on behalf of nonprofit state institutions.

The courts have directed it be treated as a for profit business. The old governance structure was predicated on amateurism. It is obviously neither. It is other.

I believe doing this will bring those schools actually NETTING revenue sufficient to compete into one collective grouping eliminating the current situation of the two strongest being the determiners of everyone's future, but absolutely setting that tier apart whether the dividing line gives us 60 or 72 schools.

That would do more for the P4 than where we are headed. Conference size then would not be an issue because the collective, much as many in the SEC and Big Ten may dislike it would pool their rights. Conferences could be kept but as voting units of presidents and not as independent negotiating and lobbying groups under the direction of commissioners. If you want to level the playing field for the upper tier the media money is a small step toward that. As anyone can see in the gross revenue totals what schools make through all other means makes the media distribution 1/4th to 1/5th of solid programs' Gross Revenue. The fairness in this is that institutions can best decide how to market themselves to their alumni and sold out venues and ticket priorities give them the means by which to optimize each schools potential. Media revenue, though it is as crack cocaine to some posters, would then be pooled and equal. Moving for more media revenue then would cease. Schools that did want to move would be moving for the associations, to curtail travel costs, and for competitive reasons for other sports.

We can't stay in an FBS with the disparity that exists in the current one. We need tiers. I'm not sure we need conference offices, commissioners, and expensive duplicated corporate office space. And if media is pooled for 60 to 72 schools in an upper tier only the voice of presidents will be needed. The rest can go. The rights provider(s) can see to the various conference networks and make sure the whole tier is represented. And the tier leadership can handle scheduling and should keep all games for revenue sports within the tier.

That should eliminate much of the current angst, eliminate the left behind scenarios, make us more revenue through elimination of duplicated overhead, and make all games relevant. What it won't permit is a "Last Rat Standing" scenario where the strong keep killing off the weaker until one Rat is left.

My take is that all legislation is a form of compromise or mediation. The 19 member conference cap that was initially agreed to (and possibly proposed) by B1G and SEC leaders likely had more significant impact on revenues than any of these potential tweaks to the CFP. Isn’t Miami President Echevarria’s underlying concern that the biggest beneficiaries of the antitrust exemptions will be Alabama, Georgia, Michigan, Ohio State, Penn State and Texas? The pushback on PCSA is not principally along traditional ideological splits…the pushback is strongest from the few schools that are desperately close to joining the uber-elites.

Each with their own media contract and now a scheduling arrangement on the way to augment that revenue further, is what will separate them from the M2 in a major way leading to the push for any who are able to join them.

I think they wanted the exemption and would take the locking down of the current advantages without further growth to get it. IMO, the scheduling agreement was/is the new tool to widen the gap of advantage.

And I have heard of another prospective matter which would drive that gap to more than double in media revenue alone.

We'll never have parity in revenue generation, but attaining a baseline of it in media revenue would help reel those advantages back in by close to 50%. And everyone benefits from the elimination of duplicated overhead and being out from under the NCAA will help basketball prominent schools maximize revenue as well.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2026 01:52 PM by JRsec.)
10-26-2026 01:50 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #7
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.
10-26-2026 03:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #8
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

If it doesn't pass, there won't be a next version. It will be back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended. 07-coffee3 It's the only thing official thus far.
10-26-2026 03:57 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #9
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

The current sponsors aren't interested in going again. And what you suggest won't pass because it doesn't solve any problems. Inability to enforce rules and runaway costs are destroying the sport. I see no reason for top football and basketball players to agree to join an union and install salary caps as long as programs are not subject to real economic limits. This is not a free market. They are subsidized by students, taxpayers and donors. Otherwise, most schools would be going out of business, dramatically driving down the average salary (although the very top might still be really high).
10-26-2026 04:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,471
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #10
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 03:57 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

If it doesn't pass, there won't be a next version. It will be back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended. 07-coffee3 It's the only thing official thus far.


JR, we disagree on this point (and a few others). The Beaver is right: there would absolutely be a "next version" and as I've said a hundred times, it would likely be much less advantageous to the "P" schools than the PCSA is now.

The need for antitrust protection is so great that the schools themselves will push for legislation until something is eventually signed into law.
10-26-2026 04:42 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #11
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 04:27 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

The current sponsors aren't interested in going again. And what you suggest won't pass because it doesn't solve any problems. Inability to enforce rules and runaway costs are destroying the sport. I see no reason for top football and basketball players to agree to join an union and install salary caps as long as programs are not subject to real economic limits. This is not a free market. They are subsidized by students, taxpayers and donors. Otherwise, most schools would be going out of business, dramatically driving down the average salary (although the very top might still be really high).

I think employee status in exchange for anti-trust and a cap on "fake" NIL is a fair exchange. I don't see the point of coach caps but they are looking more likely too.
10-26-2026 04:44 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #12
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 04:44 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 04:27 PM)bullet Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

The current sponsors aren't interested in going again. And what you suggest won't pass because it doesn't solve any problems. Inability to enforce rules and runaway costs are destroying the sport. I see no reason for top football and basketball players to agree to join an union and install salary caps as long as programs are not subject to real economic limits. This is not a free market. They are subsidized by students, taxpayers and donors. Otherwise, most schools would be going out of business, dramatically driving down the average salary (although the very top might still be really high).

I think employee status in exchange for anti-trust and a cap on "fake" NIL is a fair exchange. I don't see the point of coach caps but they are looking more likely too.

1) Employee status doesn't solve the problem. Without caps, runaway costs will continue.
2) Football and basketball players DON'T WANT employee status. It has a lot of negative tax and other consequences for them. They are in the best of both worlds right now. Maybe a court eventually rules they are employees, but for now they are benefitting from not having that status. They are getting a lot of tax free compensation and are not subject to self-employment or FICA taxes.
10-26-2026 04:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Just Joe Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,880
Joined: Oct 2020
Reputation: 396
I Root For: Bama
Location:
Post: #13
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 10:37 AM)Wahoowa84 Wrote:  Ruminating about Miami President Joe Echevarria’s criticism of the PCSA’s provisions for stabilizing collegiate athletics, I wonder about other mechanisms that politicians could create to achieve similar ends. Economic forces are promoting consolidation and tiering into ever larger conferences…increasingly separating economic winners and losers.

IMHO, Echevarria’s most stinging criticism was the B1G and SEC’s unilateral decision on the 24 team CFP expansion basically solidified everyone else into second class status…without sufficient agency in their futures. So why not address this major concern with specific action? For example,

1) Cap the power/authority of individual conferences in CFP decision making. Any individual conference could be limited to 30% voting rights on CFP matters.

and/or

2) Cap the maximum number of participants in the CFP for individual conferences. Any individual conference could be limited to seven participants in a 24 team CFP (7/24 =0.292…does not exceed 30%). Award any open CFP bid to the best performing team from an unrepresented conference (i.e., most deserving G6).

and/or

3) Cap the financial distribution of CFP revenues to any individual conference to 30% (all conferences are currently under this existing threshold). Rather than promoting zero-sum thinking by commissioners, it fosters broader collaboration as a social good.


If PCSA doesn’t pass in this Congress, the next iteration of an antitrust exemption for collegiate athletics could include innovations on how to limit consolidation of power and money.

If it doesn’t pass this congress IMO it’s a moot point and nothing like it has a chance. Counting the SCORE Act that would be two of these sweeping reform bills that failed and at some point it’s not worth the time and effort.
10-26-2026 04:49 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #14
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 04:42 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:57 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

If it doesn't pass, there won't be a next version. It will be back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended. 07-coffee3 It's the only thing official thus far.


JR, we disagree on this point (and a few others). The Beaver is right: there would absolutely be a "next version" and as I've said a hundred times, it would likely be much less advantageous to the "P" schools than the PCSA is now.

The need for antitrust protection is so great that the schools themselves will push for legislation until something is eventually signed into law.

Ned, I don't care what you think. I write what I think. And if I kept a list of all the things we disagree upon I'd have to keep it on a new TP sc(roll) and to save waste I'd half to hope not to get ink on by butt when it was put to a better use. If Congress can't pass legislation, we are right back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended: allow players' unions (it doesn't matter if all participate) and utilize collective bargaining. Maybe the House and Senate compromise and pass a bill, maybe not. I don't know of anyone with a crystal ball that works on Congress. Maybe Sauron has a viewing crystal (homage to grandchildren) since his mind and that of Congress seem to work the same way, always looking for the precious. Only this time it's not a ring but the agenda that rules them all that they seek. You can bet on one thing, if the PCSA that passes is assembled by a committee and then two committee's compromising, nobody is going to like it! 07-coffee3
10-26-2026 05:17 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,069
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2768
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #15
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
Nobody wants Kavanaugh’s idea and that’s why even the B1G and SEC want the PCSA passed.
10-26-2026 06:01 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #16
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 06:01 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  Nobody wants Kavanaugh’s idea and that’s why even the B1G and SEC want the PCSA passed.
Want has nothing to do with it! The Supreme Court doesn't care what we want. He laid out how we might be in compliance. The other option was an appeal to Congress. If the latter doesn't work, we are back to accepting Kavanaugh's recommendations on how to be found in compliance. It only seems complicated because the Congressional process is complicated.
10-26-2026 06:36 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Advertisement


The Beaver Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 7,341
Joined: Apr 2024
Reputation: 955
I Root For: Penn State
Location:
Post: #17
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
The flurry of judges' decisions this past offseason make it quite clear to me, without a specific legal carve out 5 in 5 will not stand up to legal scrutiny, a ban on NFL returnees will not stand up to legal scutiny, NIL caps also might not. Its pretty clear that something needs to be passed to allow the unique eligibility restrictions that are part of collegiate athletics. But the specifics of what is in that legislation can vary wildly but it has to be legislation, non-governmental agreements like NCAA or conference bylaws are not legally good enough to block the things I just mentioned.
10-26-2026 06:41 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,869
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5067
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #18
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 06:41 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  The flurry of judges' decisions this past offseason make it quite clear to me, without a specific legal carve out 5 in 5 will not stand up to legal scrutiny, a ban on NFL returnees will not stand up to legal scutiny, NIL caps also might not. Its pretty clear that something needs to be passed to allow the unique eligibility restrictions that are part of collegiate athletics. But the specifics of what is in that legislation can vary wildly but it has to be legislation, non-governmental agreements like NCAA or conference bylaws are not legally good enough to block the things I just mentioned.

I don't know whether any of these restrictions ultimately stand up in court, but what is clear is that there will be injunctions and the issue will be moot by the time the NCAA could enforce it. So they will never win in court. The athletes will keep getting injunctions.
10-26-2026 07:06 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Ned Low Offline
Heisman
*

Posts: 6,471
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
Post: #19
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 05:17 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 04:42 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:57 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

If it doesn't pass, there won't be a next version. It will be back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended. 07-coffee3 It's the only thing official thus far.


JR, we disagree on this point (and a few others). The Beaver is right: there would absolutely be a "next version" and as I've said a hundred times, it would likely be much less advantageous to the "P" schools than the PCSA is now.

The need for antitrust protection is so great that the schools themselves will push for legislation until something is eventually signed into law.

Ned, I don't care what you think. I write what I think. And if I kept a list of all the things we disagree upon I'd have to keep it on a new TP sc(roll) and to save waste I'd half to hope not to get ink on by butt when it was put to a better use. If Congress can't pass legislation, we are right back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended: allow players' unions (it doesn't matter if all participate) and utilize collective bargaining. Maybe the House and Senate compromise and pass a bill, maybe not. I don't know of anyone with a crystal ball that works on Congress. Maybe Sauron has a viewing crystal (homage to grandchildren) since his mind and that of Congress seem to work the same way, always looking for the precious. Only this time it's not a ring but the agenda that rules them all that they seek. You can bet on one thing, if the PCSA that passes is assembled by a committee and then two committee's compromising, nobody is going to like it! 07-coffee3

You know what, JR? I could care less what you think, either.

You've got the SEC and the B10 basically begging for legislation, in conjunction with the rest of us. Luckily for the rest of us, those two have the most influence in the room at the moment.

Do you think that they will cease the activity because the Cruz/Cantwell concoction doesn't pass? They absolutely will not. Without legislative protections, the lawsuits will continue to be filed and the NCAA/schools will continue to lose.

The SEC (or any other conference) can't do anything about it. They can't "break away" and manage things any better than the NCAA because they will suffer from the same problems in addition to perhaps having an even bigger target on their backs.

Even D3 has had lawsuits filed against it's membership... and sadly, the case(s) may have some merits. That's how bad things have gotten.

The reason this bill got through the Senate with a near super majority was because many politicans recognize that something has to be done. Rest assured that recognition won't go away if the PCSA fails to pass.

Kavanaugh's majority opinion was absolutely influential. However, without legislation / employee status -that ADs, school presidents and importantly, many politicians don't want- it's ultimately worth little more than the paper it's written on.
(This post was last modified: 10-26-2026 08:58 PM by Ned Low.)
10-26-2026 07:35 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
JRsec Offline
Super Moderator
*

Posts: 44,978
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13520
I Root For: SEC
Location:
Post: #20
RE: PCSA Section 205 and FBS Stability
(10-26-2026 07:35 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 05:17 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 04:42 PM)Ned Low Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:57 PM)JRsec Wrote:  
(10-26-2026 03:49 PM)The Beaver Wrote:  If PCSA doesn't pass the next version will be big on athlete's rights and small on protecting schools' market powers. Just a hunch.

If it doesn't pass, there won't be a next version. It will be back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended. 07-coffee3 It's the only thing official thus far.


JR, we disagree on this point (and a few others). The Beaver is right: there would absolutely be a "next version" and as I've said a hundred times, it would likely be much less advantageous to the "P" schools than the PCSA is now.

The need for antitrust protection is so great that the schools themselves will push for legislation until something is eventually signed into law.

Ned, I don't care what you think. I write what I think. And if I kept a list of all the things we disagree upon I'd have to keep it on a new TP sc(roll) and to save waste I'd half to hope not to get ink on by butt when it was put to a better use. If Congress can't pass legislation, we are right back to what Justice Kavanaugh recommended: allow players' unions (it doesn't matter if all participate) and utilize collective bargaining. Maybe the House and Senate compromise and pass a bill, maybe not. I don't know of anyone with a crystal ball that works on Congress. Maybe Sauron has a viewing crystal (homage to grandchildren) since his mind and that of Congress seem to work the same way, always looking for the precious. Only this time it's not a ring but the agenda that rules them all that they seek. You can bet on one thing, if the PCSA that passes is assembled by a committee and then two committee's compromising, nobody is going to like it! 07-coffee3

You know what, JR? I could care less what you think, either.

You've got the SEC and the B10 basically begging for legislation, in conjunction with the rest of us. Luckily for the rest of us, those two have the most influence in the room at the moment.

Do you think that they will cease the activity because the Cruz/Cantwell concoction doesn't pass? They absolutely will not. Without legislative protections, the lawsuits will continue to be filed and the NCAA/schools will continue to lose.

The SEC (or any other conference) can't do anything about it. They can't "break away" and manage things any better than the NCAA because they will suffer from the same problems in addition to perhaps having an even bigger target on their backs.

Even D3 has had lawsuits filed against it's membership... and sadly, the case(s) may have some merits. That's how bad things have gotten.

The reason this bill got through the Senate with a near super majority was because many politicans recognize that something has to be done. Rest assured that recognition won't go away if the PCSA fails to pass.

Kavanaugh's majority opinion was absolutely influential. However, without legislation -that ADs, school presidents and importantly, many politicians don't want- it's ultimately worth little more than the paper it's written on.

His comments were after a ruling. If Congress doesn't act the decided cases will be acted upon or the universities will not be in compliance. The outdated NCAA is the impetus for the problems. Amateurism is dead. One size does not fit all. And, I don't have much faith in Congress. After the midterms it may be even more conflicted. With the enrollment cliff's pressure building if Congress does anything it will be to protect the largest state schools. My suspicion is they will punt this hot political football. Demographics and time will take care of the hard decisions that they will not want to make regarding future funding. If they do anything it will be some kind of restrained exemption likely for the FBS, but I'm not holding my breath. There will be a lot sweating before this gets worked out. The simplest thing to do is simply to comply with Kavanaugh. Then there will be no caps, no period of independence, and the schools can align or not as they see fit.
(This post was last modified: 10-28-2026 01:20 PM by JRsec.)
10-26-2026 08:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.