MAC takes a lot of hits from outsiders because its not a proper market based mashup of G6 teams like the other conferences. That is because it has a very different history.
1) MAC was originally founded as a mid-major BB conference that had schools like Butler and Case Western Reserve in it.
2) It became an all-sport conference in the 1950's.
3) In the 60's and 70's MAC campuses were exploding in enrollment and were producing new mid-major FB powers much like the SBC is today.
4) The first superdivision was created in the early 80's and the MAC was able to just do enough expansion in the 70s to help push it over the line.
5) The modern golden era of the MAC began in 1995 with the MAC having a team in the Top 25 for the first time in years. Not long after the MAC expanded with Marshall, added a bowl game in Detroit and then moved the BB tournament to Cleveland.
6) The success of Marshall helped push the MAC toward the Maction TV deal which gave the conference for the first time a national identity.
7) In smaller markets, slowly over time MAC schools put in faciliites to be more on par with G6 programs. This is unlike in other G6 conferences where it often happened overnight at some of those schools (going from no FB all the way to a G6 conference).
8) While rust belt demographics started affecting Ohio & Michigan in the 1970's the universities were viewed as a way out of the rust belt economy so they continued to grow for decades afterwards. The great financial crisis of 2008 was the turning point where MAC schools had peaked and were starting to feel the demographic crunch.
9) MAC's growth extended into the 2010's with improved post season access in the restrictive, pre-NIL era to make major bowl games for the first time.
10) The 2020s is representing a big change for the entire college sports industry. The G6 finds themselves at a new disadvantage as players are now being paid.
That is the history but I think if you are looking at where this is headed and in particular what is going to be the best G6 conference situation in 5 to 10 years I thinnk its looking as uncertain of a future as ever. We do not understand yet how NIL is going to translate inside the G6 and what the long term impact will be of all of these new schools moving up.
It could be that over time G6 schools and the MAC will separate more from FCS conferences because of spending.
There is also a question on whether a expanded playoff represents growth and opportunity for the G6. We may know more about that one soon.