CSNbbs
What's going to happen to the MAC? - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: Lounge (/forum-564.html)
+---- Forum: College Sports and Conference Realignment (/forum-637.html)
+---- Thread: What's going to happen to the MAC? (/thread-1033551.html)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5


What's going to happen to the MAC? - BirdHawkEagle - 09-30-2026 08:44 AM

After years of relative stability, it seems that the MAC is now under threat due to recent events.

Will it actually die off?

Or

Will it continue to survive since people say it's hard to kill a conference?


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - PicksUp - 09-30-2026 08:52 AM

What are the reasons it would implode? Bad TV deal? Are teams like Akron and Kent St really in danger of dropping to FCS? Do Miami, Ohio and Toledo actually have other conferences interested in them?


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - BirdHawkEagle - 09-30-2026 09:01 AM

(09-30-2026 08:52 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  What are the reasons it would implode? Bad TV deal? Are teams like Akron and Kent St really in danger of dropping to FCS? Do Miami, Ohio and Toledo actually have other conferences interested in them?

What you just posted is why asked the question.

People seem to be all over the place in regards to the MAC and their future.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - Frank the Tank - 09-30-2026 09:22 AM

Conferences may be maimed or mortally wounded, but we need to remove the thought of a conference actually *dying* (meaning ceasing to exist) from our lexicon.

As long as a conference has FBS status (meaning a vote and revenue share in the CFP) and Division I status (meaning an auto-bid to and revenue share from the NCAA Tournament), there will be a heavy incentive to keep any conference alive. Look at Oregon State and Washington State - you can’t get much more maimed than a league down to 2 schools and they still rebuilt themselves. Even if the MAC loses half of its members, it can find FCS schools to move up to replenish themselves (and maybe even charge their huge entry fees to do so).

This isn’t the same situation as even 5 years ago. The value of a conference with FBS and Division I status in and of itself has too much value in the marketplace to completely get extinguished as long as at least one member is still left behind to rebuild it.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - IWokeUpLikeThis - 09-30-2026 09:26 AM

Even in an unlikely doomsday scenario of departures for the MAC, there’s schools who’d take an invite in a heartbeat: Eastern Kentucky, Youngstown St. Stony Brook might be one as well.

The MAC will continue on. There’s enough of a core committed to FBS who are also unlikely to be poached.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - Smedly02 - 09-30-2026 09:27 AM

One possible (if improbable) direction the MAC could take would be to drop football as a conference sport. This move might be an option if any of Miami/Ohio/Toledo leave. Schools that want to continue at the FBS level could affiliate with Conference USA. Schools that either drop to the FCS level or eliminate football entirely would still have a conference home. This move would allow the MAC to add non-football schools as well.

I am wondering if this talk about members leaving is related to current TV negotiations. If the MAC is talking to other possible partners besides ESPN then the Mouse might persuade other conferences to look at taking some current MAC schools. The Mouse doesn’t like to cheated on.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - bullet - 09-30-2026 09:56 AM

The current enrollment trajectory of Akron and the 3 Michigan directionals is not compatible with FBS football. See the other thread that has the schools with the biggest enrollment declines since 2010. Toledo and Bowling Green are having some issues as well. I don't expect to see EMU playing FBS football in 20 years. Or Akron. Now WMU and CMU have a stronger base and history. And CMU might be merged with one of the many Division II Michigan schools to strengthen both. But we just started the enrollment cliff and they have already had big losses in number of students.

The MAC will still be around, but it will likely absorb schools from CUSA which is a mish-mash. And anyone in CUSA would jump to the American or Sun Belt in a minute. And NMSU has begged the MWC and Pac. There is a decent chance CUSA goes the way of the WAC and Big West football.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - PicksUp - 09-30-2026 10:08 AM

(09-30-2026 09:01 AM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 08:52 AM)PicksUp Wrote:  What are the reasons it would implode? Bad TV deal? Are teams like Akron and Kent St really in danger of dropping to FCS? Do Miami, Ohio and Toledo actually have other conferences interested in them?

What you just posted is why asked the question.

People seem to be all over the place in regards to the MAC and their future.

Everything I mentioned would have to happen for it to possibly implode. That would be the absolute worst case scenario. 3-4 teams would have to drop to FCS and 4-5 teams would have to leave to other conferences. If only 1 or 2 happen, it should survive.

The American is not in any hurry to expand, yet. Very much depends on what happens to the ACC. The PAC and MW need more members but there are other options out west and even in Texas that are much closer to their footprint.

Someone mentioned the top teams might want to break off and start their own conference but I don't see it, either. If you have the top 5-6 programs leave, who else would be interested? Middle Tennessee and Western Kentucky? UConn fb-only? Exit fees for the CUSA schools would not make it a cost-effective move.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - b2b - 09-30-2026 10:13 AM

(09-30-2026 09:22 AM)Frank the Tank Wrote:  Conferences may be maimed or mortally wounded, but we need to remove the thought of a conference actually *dying* (meaning ceasing to exist) from our lexicon.

As long as a conference has FBS status (meaning a vote and revenue share in the CFP) and Division I status (meaning an auto-bid to and revenue share from the NCAA Tournament), there will be a heavy incentive to keep any conference alive. Look at Oregon State and Washington State - you can’t get much more maimed than a league down to 2 schools and they still rebuilt themselves. Even if the MAC loses half of its members, it can find FCS schools to move up to replenish themselves (and maybe even charge their huge entry fees to do so).

This isn’t the same situation as even 5 years ago. The value of a conference with FBS and Division I status in and of itself has too much value in the marketplace to completely get extinguished as long as at least one member is still left behind to rebuild it.

I agree w/ all of this. It's exhausting to see this idea being brought up again and again and again.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - AssKickingChicken - 09-30-2026 10:20 AM

It is virtually impossible to kill a conference on the D1 level.

The Big XII has been poached multiple times but is still at the P4 level and seems pretty robust. But I remember seeing many people say it was on its last legs.

The WAC was left for dead many times on here but has started sponsoring football again, albeit under a new name. They tried to destroy the Southland but that raid failed and the Southland is still here.

CUSA dropped to five members but was able to rebuild.

The PAC had the easiest track to dissolving if WOSU had just joined up with the MWC. Instead, they convinced half the MWC to join them and are safe for now.

The Great West Conference did go away but it seems like it was a football only conference that tried to expand to all sports and never caught on and everyone just went away.

I think the last time we actually lost a conference was when the Big 8 joined with half of the SWC. It was also around the time the Metro and Great Midwest joined to form CUSA.

So it’s over 30 years now and that was a result of landmark shifts in conference alignment in general.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - TalonsUpPuckDown - 09-30-2026 10:37 AM

(09-30-2026 09:56 AM)bullet Wrote:  The current enrollment trajectory of Akron and the 3 Michigan directionals is not compatible with FBS football. See the other thread that has the schools with the biggest enrollment declines since 2010. Toledo and Bowling Green are having some issues as well. I don't expect to see EMU playing FBS football in 20 years. Or Akron. Now WMU and CMU have a stronger base and history. And CMU might be merged with one of the many Division II Michigan schools to strengthen both. But we just started the enrollment cliff and they have already had big losses in number of students.

The MAC will still be around, but it will likely absorb schools from CUSA which is a mish-mash. And anyone in CUSA would jump to the American or Sun Belt in a minute. And NMSU has begged the MWC and Pac. There is a decent chance CUSA goes the way of the WAC and Big West football.

This simply could not be further from the truth. Bowling Green has had two consecutive years of record freshman enrollment classes. This is on top of 5 years of freshman class growth. This is on top of a retention rate that's increased over the past 5 years. Enrollment broke 20k this year. Bowling Green State University has some Big Mo going on and has been staying ahead of the enrollment cliff. We are one of three MAC schools in the state that have exhibited growth over the past 5-7 years (Ohio and Miami being the other two) and much of this growth has been at the expense of those cretins 25 miles north of us.

It is true that Toledo is in the crapper. They appear to have bottomed out at an enrollment of 13k this year but that's down from 25k a decade ago. They also suck balls in general.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - bullet - 09-30-2026 10:51 AM

(09-30-2026 10:37 AM)TalonsUpPuckDown Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 09:56 AM)bullet Wrote:  The current enrollment trajectory of Akron and the 3 Michigan directionals is not compatible with FBS football. See the other thread that has the schools with the biggest enrollment declines since 2010. Toledo and Bowling Green are having some issues as well. I don't expect to see EMU playing FBS football in 20 years. Or Akron. Now WMU and CMU have a stronger base and history. And CMU might be merged with one of the many Division II Michigan schools to strengthen both. But we just started the enrollment cliff and they have already had big losses in number of students.

The MAC will still be around, but it will likely absorb schools from CUSA which is a mish-mash. And anyone in CUSA would jump to the American or Sun Belt in a minute. And NMSU has begged the MWC and Pac. There is a decent chance CUSA goes the way of the WAC and Big West football.

This simply could not be further from the truth. Bowling Green has had two consecutive years of record freshman enrollment classes. This is on top of 5 years of freshman class growth. This is on top of a retention rate that's increased over the past 5 years. Enrollment broke 20k this year. Bowling Green State University has some Big Mo going on and has been staying ahead of the enrollment cliff. We are one of three MAC schools in the state that have exhibited growth over the past 5-7 years (Ohio and Miami being the other two) and much of this growth has been at the expense of those cretins 25 miles north of us.

It is true that Toledo is in the crapper. They appear to have bottomed out at an enrollment of 13k this year but that's down from 25k a decade ago. They also suck balls in general.

Maybe BG has turned it around, but they dipped from around 19k down to about 15k a few years back. Akron and the 3 Michigan schools are close to 40% up to 50% declines.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - UIWElite2 - 09-30-2026 11:26 AM

MAC will be fine, as CUSA has proven

Even the WAC (UAC) managed to stay afloat


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - Morning MAC - 09-30-2026 11:27 AM

The spin I've been thinking about: What can MAC do to be successful?

I think they need to try to expand out east, with the expectation that they will lose a couple of current members.
(example Akron or EMU downgrading, or Miami, Toledo, or Ohio leaving)
Recruit Delaware.
If UCONN doesn't find a spot in the P4, find a way to get UCONN football into the MAC.
Help a school in the northeast upgrade to FBS.
That way you'd have a core out east: (Buffalo, UMass, Delaware, UCONN fb, and one other)
(maybe this eastern pod will help retain schools like Miami and Ohio)

Media Rights:
= play one game weekly in the Friday 4pET window (as has been mentioned in other threads)
= play two game weekly on Saturdays 10:40aET
= keep late season tues wed MACtion, but:
== group teams in 4 team groups
== each team in the group has a home and away game in a 2 week period, then goes back to a normal weekend schedule
(schools will have "half a bye" on the front and back of their mid week MACtion commitment)
== that way each team will only have 1 mid week home game
== ESPN won't have the choice of games on tues/wed, as there will only be 1 each night. (does the matchup really matter for tues/wed football??)

The 5-6 MAC home games will be:
= 1 Friday 4ET game
= 1 Tues/Wed MACtion game
= 2 early Sat games, 10:40aET
= 1-2 standard Sat games

Play when other teams aren't playing.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - goofus - 09-30-2026 11:31 AM

Since conferences never die, probably a better thread question would be "Whats going to happen to the current schools in the MAC? Because its pretty obvious each school has different goals and ambitions and realities. Are they in or they out in this new NIL era?

Some are looking to move up or move sideways to a new conference. Miami-Oh? Ohio? Toledo? UMass?

Some are looking to stay at the same level. WMU? CMU? Bufalo?

Some may be preparing for the reality that they may need to move down to FCS. EMU? Akron? Kent St?

If the ones that want to move on do actually leave, does that mean the ones that are left behind will one day decide to demote the entire conference to FCS? I would say the odds are pretty good that's what's going to happen.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - TalonsUpPuckDown - 09-30-2026 12:08 PM

(09-30-2026 10:51 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 10:37 AM)TalonsUpPuckDown Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 09:56 AM)bullet Wrote:  The current enrollment trajectory of Akron and the 3 Michigan directionals is not compatible with FBS football. See the other thread that has the schools with the biggest enrollment declines since 2010. Toledo and Bowling Green are having some issues as well. I don't expect to see EMU playing FBS football in 20 years. Or Akron. Now WMU and CMU have a stronger base and history. And CMU might be merged with one of the many Division II Michigan schools to strengthen both. But we just started the enrollment cliff and they have already had big losses in number of students.

The MAC will still be around, but it will likely absorb schools from CUSA which is a mish-mash. And anyone in CUSA would jump to the American or Sun Belt in a minute. And NMSU has begged the MWC and Pac. There is a decent chance CUSA goes the way of the WAC and Big West football.

This simply could not be further from the truth. Bowling Green has had two consecutive years of record freshman enrollment classes. This is on top of 5 years of freshman class growth. This is on top of a retention rate that's increased over the past 5 years. Enrollment broke 20k this year. Bowling Green State University has some Big Mo going on and has been staying ahead of the enrollment cliff. We are one of three MAC schools in the state that have exhibited growth over the past 5-7 years (Ohio and Miami being the other two) and much of this growth has been at the expense of those cretins 25 miles north of us.

It is true that Toledo is in the crapper. They appear to have bottomed out at an enrollment of 13k this year but that's down from 25k a decade ago. They also suck balls in general.

Maybe BG has turned it around, but they dipped from around 19k down to about 15k a few years back. Akron and the 3 Michigan schools are close to 40% up to 50% declines.

If by “a few years back” you mean a decade back, then fine. However, for the purposes of the topic being discussed in this thread, your comment about BG wasn’t accurate. It was accurate about Toledo.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - AssKickingChicken - 09-30-2026 12:13 PM

Right now they have 12 full members with a football affiliate. If the numbers dropped to a dangerously low number I think they would start reaching down into the FCS to restock.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - bullet - 09-30-2026 12:16 PM

(09-30-2026 12:08 PM)TalonsUpPuckDown Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 10:51 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 10:37 AM)TalonsUpPuckDown Wrote:  
(09-30-2026 09:56 AM)bullet Wrote:  The current enrollment trajectory of Akron and the 3 Michigan directionals is not compatible with FBS football. See the other thread that has the schools with the biggest enrollment declines since 2010. Toledo and Bowling Green are having some issues as well. I don't expect to see EMU playing FBS football in 20 years. Or Akron. Now WMU and CMU have a stronger base and history. And CMU might be merged with one of the many Division II Michigan schools to strengthen both. But we just started the enrollment cliff and they have already had big losses in number of students.

The MAC will still be around, but it will likely absorb schools from CUSA which is a mish-mash. And anyone in CUSA would jump to the American or Sun Belt in a minute. And NMSU has begged the MWC and Pac. There is a decent chance CUSA goes the way of the WAC and Big West football.

This simply could not be further from the truth. Bowling Green has had two consecutive years of record freshman enrollment classes. This is on top of 5 years of freshman class growth. This is on top of a retention rate that's increased over the past 5 years. Enrollment broke 20k this year. Bowling Green State University has some Big Mo going on and has been staying ahead of the enrollment cliff. We are one of three MAC schools in the state that have exhibited growth over the past 5-7 years (Ohio and Miami being the other two) and much of this growth has been at the expense of those cretins 25 miles north of us.

It is true that Toledo is in the crapper. They appear to have bottomed out at an enrollment of 13k this year but that's down from 25k a decade ago. They also suck balls in general.

Maybe BG has turned it around, but they dipped from around 19k down to about 15k a few years back. Akron and the 3 Michigan schools are close to 40% up to 50% declines.

If by “a few years back” you mean a decade back, then fine. However, for the purposes of the topic being discussed in this thread, your comment about BG wasn’t accurate. It was accurate about Toledo.
In 2023, Bowling Green had 15,089. 2011 they had 18,773. 2023 is pretty recent.
They had issues and have clearly done things to turn it around.


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - rtist - 09-30-2026 01:04 PM

How about the University of Illinois at Chicago? If the Chicago Bears left Soldier Field (and they still may) UIC could start a football program using Soldier Field as a base. They could then argue for MAC membership (Chicago market, Illinois presence, above-average academics).


RE: What's going to happen to the MAC? - BirdstheWord - 09-30-2026 01:29 PM

(09-30-2026 01:04 PM)rtist Wrote:  How about the University of Illinois at Chicago? If the Chicago Bears left Soldier Field (and rhey still may) UIC could start a football program using Soldier Field as a base. They could then argue for MAC membership (Chicago market, Illinois presence, above-average academics).

UIC will not start a football program.