(09-30-2026 09:01 AM)BirdHawkEagle Wrote: (09-30-2026 08:52 AM)PicksUp Wrote: What are the reasons it would implode? Bad TV deal? Are teams like Akron and Kent St really in danger of dropping to FCS? Do Miami, Ohio and Toledo actually have other conferences interested in them?
What you just posted is why asked the question.
People seem to be all over the place in regards to the MAC and their future.
That is because most of the people are just throwing different ideas out there which is fine but the larger landscape is going to be the primary driver.
1. I am less confident every month that passes we will see the P2 expand. I know the PCSA has increased the P4 limit to 20 and the independent clause sunsets after 6 years BUT 6 years is a long time and brand value could shift to the point the P2 doesn't feel compelled to expand. Thus its kind of a distant threat.
2. 24 team playoff and a 12 game FBS requirement. If FCS games were eliminated to be eligible for the playoff that would create a huge incentive for FCS schools to accept a move up to a conference like the MAC rather than be cutout of paydays in FCS. Granted the MAC paydays are already better than FCS but if you can't have them at all that may be the breaking point for Illinois State, South Dakota State etc.
3. The main reason Miami didn't get into the American with a 40 million offer in my estimation has to do with the AC having its eyes set on decapitating the PAC as its first target. Its unclear if there are G6 call ups who will get hit the worst the PAC or the AC and perhaps both would merge post P4 expansion.
4. If nothing happens to the AC/PAC by the end of the AC TV contract I fully expect Memphis, North Texas, Tulane, USF will try to make a run at joining the PAC. Keep in mind the PAC does not have an exit fee so its a relatively low risk move to be able to increase the FB/BB performance. A loss of four programs likely causes the AC TV deal to collapse. This may not happen but it certianly could.
5. Enrollment isn't a real problem until the main campus freshman class size falls below 1,000 students. At this point no MAC school is down below that threshold but enrollment is becoming critical at a few of the schools.
2026 Freshman classes courtesy of AI.
Eastern Michigan 1,315
Akron 1,800
Toledo 1,850
Central Michigan 1,956
I have to wonder if Eastern Michigan's program will outlast the current coach Chris Creighton who is 63-86 (1-5 bowls) since 2014 but has pulled out several P4 victories. If he cannot win at EMU I doubt the next coach can.
I also question interest in a larger conference for Toledo given their enrollment is not too strong and have to wonder if Miami hasn't taken their slot recently in some of the conference discussions due to having a healthy enrollment. However it didn't stop Northern Illinois with its 2,301 freshman class from moving over to the MWC.
Overall the MAC is a long way from enrollment issues knocking it out of FBS as none of the weakest schools have folded yet. As long as they are able to keep freshman enrollment above 1,000. Louisiana-Monroe is at 1,250 which is the lowest for a public school in FBS but I think they've always been the lowest.