(09-27-2026 07:25 PM)3DogNight Wrote: How in the world did you get that I believe Miami would pay CUSA anything to join?
I didn't say that. I merely said the fact they're allegedly willing to pay the AAC doesn't mean they're willing to pay CUSA.
I then pointed out that while the AAC would represent a move up, CUSA would be a mostly lateral move, further dampening any enthusiasm (or urgency) for the RedHawks to move. Or the Bobcats, for that matter.
(Thanks for catching that mistake. I was tired and mistyped. It's been corrected.)
Quote:My point is don’t limit yourself to what’s possibly out there. I don’t know if a MAC school would be interested in CUSA any more than you know they wouldn’t. How do you 100% know that they wouldn’t listen to an offer from CUSA? I doubt you have inside knowledge.
You read my post closely enough to catch the mistake, but not closely enough to catch this:
(09-27-2026 05:36 PM)whupemall Wrote: If Miami is that anxious to escape the MAC, then by all means, we should be courting them. I don't think too many folks would argue with that.
These was literally the two sentences before the part where I ticked off the entire southern half of the state of Ohio by calling the RedHawks the Bobcats.
I'll say it again:
I don't think too many folks would argue against actively courting a school willing to pay tens of millions to escape their current conference.
The fact I don't believe they'd make a lateral move doesn't mean we shouldn't try.
Likewise, the fact we have a thread in which we're vetting FCS prospects doesn't mean we should ignore SOLID FBS prospects.
There are times when an FCS prospect is better than any realistic FBS prospect.
If NDSU had been closer to our footprint, they certainly would've qualified. And as much as it pains me to say it, JMU is proving they would've been a top-tier addition as well.
Tarleton, at worst, appears to be on par with Jax State, Delaware, and Kennesaw. (I think SHSU is a better addition than they've appeared so far, but they've had to deal with a few different obstacles since moving up. They'll be back.)
At best, Tarleton could come in and mop the floor with all of us.
But the reason we haven't invited them is that moving to 11 is not as good for us as standing pat at 10. And there's no one else in our footprint at the FCS level who's ready to make a move.
And there are not any obvious choices at the FBS level for teams willing to cost themselves several million dollars for a lateral move from the MAC or SBC to CUSA.
Again, this is realistic.
I can speculate with the best of them when it comes to imaginary scenarios in which the perfect FBS school(s) fall into our laps thanks to some wild combination of falling dominoes and frustration with their current conference home(s).
But the FCS prospect thread isn't there for wild speculation (though some seeps in from time to time). It's meant for sharing data and
realistic opinions and analysis of potential prospects.
And right now, the consensus is, Tarleton is ready, and no one else is.
At the FBS level, there are no "realistic" candidates. The MAC, MWC, and SBC don't have any teams stuck on a geographic island away from all their historical rivals in CUSA. (Though the reverse is true.)
If we were to go team-by-team in the SBC, the school most likely to move to CUSA to be among old rivals would probably be troy state. But 95% of the troy nation would laugh at that suggestion. Sure, they have old heated rivalries with JSU and MTSU, but their current rivalry with South is pretty strong, and they're hoping a solid one can be started with Southern Miss. And that's just in the West. Over in the East, Ga Southern and Ga State are both nearby. That's four schools within 300 miles. The trojans aren't going anywhere, unless the Belt fractures and disintegrates.
In the MAC, both Ohio U and Miami-OH are worth looking at. Even Toledo and Akron would be worth pursuing if the MAC appears to be disintegrating. They obviously would want to move up to the AAC (or possibly an eastern division of the PAC) if given a choice, but there's no guarantee either option would be available to them.
There's absolutely nothing wrong with setting ourselves up for success by positioning CUSA to poach any of these schools when the time comes.
No one's arguing against doing so. Absolutely no one.
But many of us DO have an issue with taking low-end, struggling schools, even if they're already FBS. And it's precisely because they ARE already FBS and have proven they can't cut it.
I used ULM and Kent State as examples of this, and you said I picked two of the worst FBS schools out there. Yes. That was precisely my point.
There is no strict hierarchy that says FBS > FCS in all cases.
It's much more like "High-end FBS > High-end FCS > Mid-tier FBS > Mid-tier FCS > Let's not waste our time."
The deals we offer teams wanting to move to CUSA should reflect this.
An FCS school out of the footprint should be prepared to pay tens of millions to move into CUSA.
We should NOT demand the same (though we should be willing to accept it) from an solid, established FBS program looking to leave the MAC or SBC.
I don't think we should pursue struggling schools (like ULM or Kent State) under any circumstances, no matter how much money they dangle in front of us.
At some point, we'd need to say, "Why don't you take that $20M and put it directly into your own athletic program? Then call us again in 5 years."
We need to have standards to grow stronger, and growing stronger is the only reason for expansion.