Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,092
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 10:52 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote: (09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote: (09-10-2026 09:02 AM)quo vadis Wrote: FWIW, I think the SEC victory will be relatively short-lived. IMO, and of course IANAL, but I think the players who filed the suits and who Kiffin wanted to roster will eventually definitively win in court. I don't see how conference rules saying if you sign an NFL contract you cannot return to college athletics, etc., pass any kind of restraint of trade muster. It's like a consortium of bakeries declaring you can only work for one of our member bakeries for 5 years, and if you ever sign a deal with an I don't know, foreign bakery, you can never come back to the consortium.
But maybe (a) the conferences will get protection on this from Congress, or (b) if that ruling arrives, then everyone will be doing it at the same time, so no competitive advantage to a rogue front-runner willing to do it while the consortium cabal is still able to enforce its rules.
It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?
Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.
I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.
From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.
Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.
I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.
Well first, I think it obvious that to play for a school you have to enrolled in the school, and had LSU decided to roster them they would have been enrolled, so IMO that is a meaningless technicality. I mean, what if the SEC had come out and said that LSU could not roster these guys because they weren't enrolled? That this was the only objection? If that was all it took to mollify the SEC, LSU would have or could have enrolled them on the spot, I think, so to me that means that was no kind of barrier.
Second, to me, I just googled the definition of a professional athlete and got this:
"A professional athlete is an individual who competes in sports for compensation, participating in official events that can attract varying audience sizes..." (ref below).
This seems to exactly comport with what is happening in FBS athletics these days. Athletes are fielding offers of payment from schools, NIL and House payments, and signing offers of payment from them for specific amounts. IMO that makes someone a professional athlete regardless of W4s and the like. FWIW, my readings of the second reference below says the IRS considers all NIL and House payments to be taxable income.
As for "unfair" competition or whatever, well that is what life is about. I mean it might be unfair that Aaron Rodgers continues to linger on an NFL roster for 20 years taking a spot that might give an opportunity for a 22 year old who needs it more, but that's life, IMO, people aren't sheltered from competition.
BTW, FWIW, I do NOT like this state of affairs AT ALL. I wish we could go back to 10 years ago, or really 5 years ago, when NIL first hit and simply meant that the local BBQ joint could offer free ribs on Mondays to the local college's offensive line, or that hot female athletes could monetize their cheesecake Instagram photos. But the logic that allowed those quaint Fall of 2021 things directly leads to what we have now, IMO.
https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/...al-athlete
https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-bus...ess-income
Instead of Google, try the NCAA bylaws:
12.02.4 Professional Athlete. A professional athlete is one who receives any kind of payment, directly or indirectly, for
athletics participation, except as permitted by the governing legislation of the Association.
There you have it. The governing body of CFB disagrees with you as NIL and revenue sharing are permitted and NFL paychecks are not.
• • •
It's not unfair competition, it is directly opposite to the SPIRIT of college athletics. Opportunity turnover is exactly what higher education's extracurricular activities were created for. Alas, I don't really expect people unfamiliar with campus life to understand the spirit of college athletics and campus activities designed for a finite window in life.
|
|