Hello There, Guest! Registered users see far less ads! Register today and join our virtual tailgate. (Login — Register)

Post Reply 
SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
Author Message
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,970
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #361
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-10-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 11:04 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:02 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  FWIW, I think the SEC victory will be relatively short-lived. IMO, and of course IANAL, but I think the players who filed the suits and who Kiffin wanted to roster will eventually definitively win in court. I don't see how conference rules saying if you sign an NFL contract you cannot return to college athletics, etc., pass any kind of restraint of trade muster. It's like a consortium of bakeries declaring you can only work for one of our member bakeries for 5 years, and if you ever sign a deal with an I don't know, foreign bakery, you can never come back to the consortium.

But maybe (a) the conferences will get protection on this from Congress, or (b) if that ruling arrives, then everyone will be doing it at the same time, so no competitive advantage to a rogue front-runner willing to do it while the consortium cabal is still able to enforce its rules.

It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

But your opinion hardly matters here, does it? Neither does mine. What matters is that the actual decision makers don't want gamblers or NFL player suiting up on Saturdays.

These lawsuits will now go nowhere, and they'll likely be dropped. The players in question will end up on NFL rosters again, or playing in Canada/Germany/etc etc etc. Kiffin was trying to take advantage of a potential one year loophole in the transition from 4 years to 5 years for players, and he roped a couple of kids and his College into his shenanigans, with predictably disastrous results for everyone.

Rather than clamoring for more lawsuits, I think that a bit of accountability is in order. I wonder how much of that first year goodwill Kiffin has used up at LSU? He's managed to piss off the SEC more than any other coach in the Conference's long and storied history. I don't think that 34-14 in his first 4 years will be enough, he needs to make the CFP every year and win some titles, SEC or National or both, to justify the sort of heat that he attracts.

What the decision makers want only has limited applicability. Its what the courts will allow them to do.

All the gambler or pro has to do is get an injunction. They will have played before the case goes to trial. And I really don't think the idea that there is much of a difference between someone who got paid to go to training camp in the NFL being different than an athlete paid to play for LSU passes the laugh test. That is 20th century thinking when most of the athletes were amateurs in fact and all were in appearance (only money under the table for the elite).

Their 5 year eligibility rule does make sense, but it probably doesn't hold without congressional anti-trust exemptions.

Let’s game it out:

Pavia couldn’t get an injunction for a 7th year from an friendly Tennessee court, and his case was wild, with all sorts of twists and turns, and lots of people were getting exceptions for lots of reasons. If NOBODY is allowed more than 5 playing years or to play after turning 24, I don’t expect anyone to successfully get an injunction.
09-10-2026 11:32 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,931
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5070
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #362
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-10-2026 11:32 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 11:04 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

But your opinion hardly matters here, does it? Neither does mine. What matters is that the actual decision makers don't want gamblers or NFL player suiting up on Saturdays.

These lawsuits will now go nowhere, and they'll likely be dropped. The players in question will end up on NFL rosters again, or playing in Canada/Germany/etc etc etc. Kiffin was trying to take advantage of a potential one year loophole in the transition from 4 years to 5 years for players, and he roped a couple of kids and his College into his shenanigans, with predictably disastrous results for everyone.

Rather than clamoring for more lawsuits, I think that a bit of accountability is in order. I wonder how much of that first year goodwill Kiffin has used up at LSU? He's managed to piss off the SEC more than any other coach in the Conference's long and storied history. I don't think that 34-14 in his first 4 years will be enough, he needs to make the CFP every year and win some titles, SEC or National or both, to justify the sort of heat that he attracts.

What the decision makers want only has limited applicability. Its what the courts will allow them to do.

All the gambler or pro has to do is get an injunction. They will have played before the case goes to trial. And I really don't think the idea that there is much of a difference between someone who got paid to go to training camp in the NFL being different than an athlete paid to play for LSU passes the laugh test. That is 20th century thinking when most of the athletes were amateurs in fact and all were in appearance (only money under the table for the elite).

Their 5 year eligibility rule does make sense, but it probably doesn't hold without congressional anti-trust exemptions.

Let’s game it out:

Pavia couldn’t get an injunction for a 7th year from an friendly Tennessee court, and his case was wild, with all sorts of twists and turns, and lots of people were getting exceptions for lots of reasons. If NOBODY is allowed more than 5 playing years or to play after turning 24, I don’t expect anyone to successfully get an injunction.

Wasn't it the 8th season he couldn't get? He played more than 5 college seasons, just not in the NCAA. He played in JC or NAIA where he couldn't get NIL.

Sorsby violated an obvious rule that has almost unanimous support and he got an injunction. The courts are consistently ruling that the athletes have a potential anti-trust case when they could be harmed by a joint agreement by schools to set rules limiting them.
09-10-2026 11:39 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,970
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #363
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-10-2026 11:39 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 11:32 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 11:16 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 11:04 AM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

But your opinion hardly matters here, does it? Neither does mine. What matters is that the actual decision makers don't want gamblers or NFL player suiting up on Saturdays.

These lawsuits will now go nowhere, and they'll likely be dropped. The players in question will end up on NFL rosters again, or playing in Canada/Germany/etc etc etc. Kiffin was trying to take advantage of a potential one year loophole in the transition from 4 years to 5 years for players, and he roped a couple of kids and his College into his shenanigans, with predictably disastrous results for everyone.

Rather than clamoring for more lawsuits, I think that a bit of accountability is in order. I wonder how much of that first year goodwill Kiffin has used up at LSU? He's managed to piss off the SEC more than any other coach in the Conference's long and storied history. I don't think that 34-14 in his first 4 years will be enough, he needs to make the CFP every year and win some titles, SEC or National or both, to justify the sort of heat that he attracts.

What the decision makers want only has limited applicability. Its what the courts will allow them to do.

All the gambler or pro has to do is get an injunction. They will have played before the case goes to trial. And I really don't think the idea that there is much of a difference between someone who got paid to go to training camp in the NFL being different than an athlete paid to play for LSU passes the laugh test. That is 20th century thinking when most of the athletes were amateurs in fact and all were in appearance (only money under the table for the elite).

Their 5 year eligibility rule does make sense, but it probably doesn't hold without congressional anti-trust exemptions.

Let’s game it out:

Pavia couldn’t get an injunction for a 7th year from an friendly Tennessee court, and his case was wild, with all sorts of twists and turns, and lots of people were getting exceptions for lots of reasons. If NOBODY is allowed more than 5 playing years or to play after turning 24, I don’t expect anyone to successfully get an injunction.

Wasn't it the 8th season he couldn't get? He played more than 5 college seasons, just not in the NCAA. He played in JC or NAIA where he couldn't get NIL.

Sorsby violated an obvious rule that has almost unanimous support and he got an injunction. The courts are consistently ruling that the athletes have a potential anti-trust case when they could be harmed by a joint agreement by schools to set rules limiting them.

But that's the point. Somewhere between the current 5 years and Pavia's 8 years was deemed a bridge too far even by judges with every excuse to find a reason to give him the injunction. Thus, there is a limit, and as long as it's enforced fairly for every single person, I think it will be extremely hard for anybody to get an injunction on that point of law in the future. And Sorsby got an injunction, but so did the Big 12, and the Big 12's injunction was in Federal rather than State Court. Is this the preferred method of creating and enforcing rules? Ofc not, hence the desperate decision to get the US Congress of all entities involved.
09-10-2026 11:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Acres Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,156
Joined: Nov 2015
Reputation: 96
I Root For: Houston, Texas Southern
Location:
Post: #364
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-08-2026 04:49 PM)Acres Wrote:  On the contrary I don’t think Landry is in a weak position here. Pretty sure Senator Kennedy will haul Sankey before his appropriations committee next week if the SEC even slaps LSU on the wrist. Talk about opening the books and revealing how much his schools spent recruiting “student athletes”.

Predicting this meeting won’t happen and if it does, Sankey will issue another toothless resolution

Talking about resolutions( statements)and quoting your own posts. Here is the SEC statement

09-10-2026 11:27 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,092
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #365
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-10-2026 08:37 AM)b2b Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 11:38 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote:  
(09-09-2026 10:31 PM)Acres Wrote:  The narrative from all the talking head out there was that LSU caved Not really, I believe LSU called their bluff and the SEC blinked. Not rostering the players allowed the SEC to save face.

There was no way the LSU was going to be expelled from the conference. The idea was rather silly.

03-lmfao

So you believe the SEC was really going to expel LSU? Kiffin is ahead of the curve. This is similar to FSU being the bad-guy challenging the ACC GOR. Multiple schools would do it but somebody's got to be a big enough A-hole to put the wheels into motion. Eventually everybody's going to be doing exactly what Kiffin tried.

Everybody is agreeing not to do it, including LSU. Not sure how you got there in this reality.

Basketball is what we turn our attention to now because there are multiple suits ending in different ways concerning a fifth year.
09-11-2026 07:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,092
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #366
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:02 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  FWIW, I think the SEC victory will be relatively short-lived. IMO, and of course IANAL, but I think the players who filed the suits and who Kiffin wanted to roster will eventually definitively win in court. I don't see how conference rules saying if you sign an NFL contract you cannot return to college athletics, etc., pass any kind of restraint of trade muster. It's like a consortium of bakeries declaring you can only work for one of our member bakeries for 5 years, and if you ever sign a deal with an I don't know, foreign bakery, you can never come back to the consortium.

But maybe (a) the conferences will get protection on this from Congress, or (b) if that ruling arrives, then everyone will be doing it at the same time, so no competitive advantage to a rogue front-runner willing to do it while the consortium cabal is still able to enforce its rules.

It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.
(This post was last modified: 09-11-2026 07:34 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
09-11-2026 07:33 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,931
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5070
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #367
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:02 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  FWIW, I think the SEC victory will be relatively short-lived. IMO, and of course IANAL, but I think the players who filed the suits and who Kiffin wanted to roster will eventually definitively win in court. I don't see how conference rules saying if you sign an NFL contract you cannot return to college athletics, etc., pass any kind of restraint of trade muster. It's like a consortium of bakeries declaring you can only work for one of our member bakeries for 5 years, and if you ever sign a deal with an I don't know, foreign bakery, you can never come back to the consortium.

But maybe (a) the conferences will get protection on this from Congress, or (b) if that ruling arrives, then everyone will be doing it at the same time, so no competitive advantage to a rogue front-runner willing to do it while the consortium cabal is still able to enforce its rules.

It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

These players had not exhausted their eligibility. They left early.

The college players are professionals and are being paid. They are just pretending it isn't salary when they pay them for allowing the game to be broadcast that they are playing in. At best, its like an actor in a movie, who clearly is a professional. Not calling these college football and basketball players professionals is just a word game.
09-11-2026 10:25 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,092
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #368
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 10:25 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:02 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  FWIW, I think the SEC victory will be relatively short-lived. IMO, and of course IANAL, but I think the players who filed the suits and who Kiffin wanted to roster will eventually definitively win in court. I don't see how conference rules saying if you sign an NFL contract you cannot return to college athletics, etc., pass any kind of restraint of trade muster. It's like a consortium of bakeries declaring you can only work for one of our member bakeries for 5 years, and if you ever sign a deal with an I don't know, foreign bakery, you can never come back to the consortium.

But maybe (a) the conferences will get protection on this from Congress, or (b) if that ruling arrives, then everyone will be doing it at the same time, so no competitive advantage to a rogue front-runner willing to do it while the consortium cabal is still able to enforce its rules.

It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

These players had not exhausted their eligibility. They left early.

The college players are professionals and are being paid. They are just pretending it isn't salary when they pay them for allowing the game to be broadcast that they are playing in. At best, its like an actor in a movie, who clearly is a professional. Not calling these college football and basketball players professionals is just a word game.

It has been a known rule when you turn professional and hire an agent you exhaust eligibility. Fact. There are waivers like being drafted and not hiring an agent etc.

They technically aren't defined as professionals. Look it up. They are student athletes and are not considered as professionals making a living off their NIL etc and are not employees of the university. 1% is making six figures, the other 99% (of a half million student athletes) are not anywhere near that.

It may be a "word game" to you, but if there isn't a W4 being filed, then we are leaving the "word games" on the playground and establishing facts regarding the absence of employment. They fill out 1099s and are independent contractors. Anyone can do that. In fact, I've turned down three NIL deals this week due to being an elite message board poster. I do it for the love of the game. 04-wine
(This post was last modified: 09-11-2026 10:40 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
09-11-2026 10:39 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #369
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:02 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  FWIW, I think the SEC victory will be relatively short-lived. IMO, and of course IANAL, but I think the players who filed the suits and who Kiffin wanted to roster will eventually definitively win in court. I don't see how conference rules saying if you sign an NFL contract you cannot return to college athletics, etc., pass any kind of restraint of trade muster. It's like a consortium of bakeries declaring you can only work for one of our member bakeries for 5 years, and if you ever sign a deal with an I don't know, foreign bakery, you can never come back to the consortium.

But maybe (a) the conferences will get protection on this from Congress, or (b) if that ruling arrives, then everyone will be doing it at the same time, so no competitive advantage to a rogue front-runner willing to do it while the consortium cabal is still able to enforce its rules.

It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

Well first, I think it obvious that to play for a school you have to enrolled in the school, and had LSU decided to roster them they would have been enrolled, so IMO that is a meaningless technicality. I mean, what if the SEC had come out and said that LSU could not roster these guys because they weren't enrolled? That this was the only objection? If that was all it took to mollify the SEC, LSU would have or could have enrolled them on the spot, I think, so to me that means that was no kind of barrier.

Second, to me, I just googled the definition of a professional athlete and got this:

"A professional athlete is an individual who competes in sports for compensation, participating in official events that can attract varying audience sizes..." (ref below).

This seems to exactly comport with what is happening in FBS athletics these days. Athletes are fielding offers of payment from schools, NIL and House payments, and signing offers of payment from them for specific amounts. IMO that makes someone a professional athlete regardless of W4s and the like. FWIW, my readings of the second reference below says the IRS considers all NIL and House payments to be taxable income.

As for "unfair" competition or whatever, well that is what life is about. I mean it might be unfair that Aaron Rodgers continues to linger on an NFL roster for 20 years taking a spot that might give an opportunity for a 22 year old who needs it more, but that's life, IMO, people aren't sheltered from competition.

BTW, FWIW, I do NOT like this state of affairs AT ALL. I wish we could go back to 10 years ago, or really 5 years ago, when NIL first hit and simply meant that the local BBQ joint could offer free ribs on Mondays to the local college's offensive line, or that hot female athletes could monetize their cheesecake Instagram photos. But the logic that allowed those quaint Fall of 2021 things directly leads to what we have now, IMO.

https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/...al-athlete

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-bus...ess-income
(This post was last modified: 09-11-2026 10:56 AM by quo vadis.)
09-11-2026 10:52 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bullet Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 83,931
Joined: Apr 2012
Reputation: 5070
I Root For: Texas, UK, UGA
Location:
Post: #370
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 10:39 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 10:25 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

These players had not exhausted their eligibility. They left early.

The college players are professionals and are being paid. They are just pretending it isn't salary when they pay them for allowing the game to be broadcast that they are playing in. At best, its like an actor in a movie, who clearly is a professional. Not calling these college football and basketball players professionals is just a word game.

It has been a known rule when you turn professional and hire an agent you exhaust eligibility. Fact. There are waivers like being drafted and not hiring an agent etc.

They technically aren't defined as professionals. Look it up. They are student athletes and are not considered as professionals making a living off their NIL etc and are not employees of the university. 1% is making six figures, the other 99% (of a half million student athletes) are not anywhere near that.

It may be a "word game" to you, but if there isn't a W4 being filed, then we are leaving the "word games" on the playground and establishing facts regarding the absence of employment. They fill out 1099s and are independent contractors. Anyone can do that. In fact, I've turned down three NIL deals this week due to being an elite message board poster. I do it for the love of the game. 04-wine

There are a lot of people who don't get a W4. They get a 1099. And these people are getting 1099s. Independent contractors are every bit as much "professionals" as full employees. FBS football players are professionals now. They weren't 5 years ago. You are still living in the past. That's why you only got 3 small NIL deals. 04-cheers
09-11-2026 11:29 AM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
DavidSt Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 27,078
Joined: Dec 2013
Reputation: 1157
I Root For: ATU, P7
Location:
Post: #371
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
Lane kiffin got away with it again. he will continue to do these things knowing he would not get punished.
09-11-2026 06:07 PM
Visit this user's website Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Just Joe Offline
1st String
*

Posts: 1,884
Joined: Oct 2020
Reputation: 397
I Root For: Bama
Location:
Post: #372
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 06:07 PM)DavidSt Wrote:  Lane kiffin got away with it again. he will continue to do these things knowing he would not get punished.

I don’t like him either but at the end of the day he didn’t really “do” anything here. He threatened to play guys who were on NFL preseason rosters, he was then threatened with various dramatic punishments, and he and the school backed down and didn’t include the players. He wasn’t punished but he definitely lost.
09-11-2026 06:53 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,092
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #373
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 10:52 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:02 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  FWIW, I think the SEC victory will be relatively short-lived. IMO, and of course IANAL, but I think the players who filed the suits and who Kiffin wanted to roster will eventually definitively win in court. I don't see how conference rules saying if you sign an NFL contract you cannot return to college athletics, etc., pass any kind of restraint of trade muster. It's like a consortium of bakeries declaring you can only work for one of our member bakeries for 5 years, and if you ever sign a deal with an I don't know, foreign bakery, you can never come back to the consortium.

But maybe (a) the conferences will get protection on this from Congress, or (b) if that ruling arrives, then everyone will be doing it at the same time, so no competitive advantage to a rogue front-runner willing to do it while the consortium cabal is still able to enforce its rules.

It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

Well first, I think it obvious that to play for a school you have to enrolled in the school, and had LSU decided to roster them they would have been enrolled, so IMO that is a meaningless technicality. I mean, what if the SEC had come out and said that LSU could not roster these guys because they weren't enrolled? That this was the only objection? If that was all it took to mollify the SEC, LSU would have or could have enrolled them on the spot, I think, so to me that means that was no kind of barrier.

Second, to me, I just googled the definition of a professional athlete and got this:

"A professional athlete is an individual who competes in sports for compensation, participating in official events that can attract varying audience sizes..." (ref below).

This seems to exactly comport with what is happening in FBS athletics these days. Athletes are fielding offers of payment from schools, NIL and House payments, and signing offers of payment from them for specific amounts. IMO that makes someone a professional athlete regardless of W4s and the like. FWIW, my readings of the second reference below says the IRS considers all NIL and House payments to be taxable income.

As for "unfair" competition or whatever, well that is what life is about. I mean it might be unfair that Aaron Rodgers continues to linger on an NFL roster for 20 years taking a spot that might give an opportunity for a 22 year old who needs it more, but that's life, IMO, people aren't sheltered from competition.

BTW, FWIW, I do NOT like this state of affairs AT ALL. I wish we could go back to 10 years ago, or really 5 years ago, when NIL first hit and simply meant that the local BBQ joint could offer free ribs on Mondays to the local college's offensive line, or that hot female athletes could monetize their cheesecake Instagram photos. But the logic that allowed those quaint Fall of 2021 things directly leads to what we have now, IMO.

https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/...al-athlete

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-bus...ess-income

Instead of Google, try the NCAA bylaws:

12.02.4 Professional Athlete. A professional athlete is one who receives any kind of payment, directly or indirectly, for
athletics participation, except as permitted by the governing legislation of the Association.


There you have it. The governing body of CFB disagrees with you as NIL and revenue sharing are permitted and NFL paychecks are not.

• • •

It's not unfair competition, it is directly opposite to the SPIRIT of college athletics. Opportunity turnover is exactly what higher education's extracurricular activities were created for. Alas, I don't really expect people unfamiliar with campus life to understand the spirit of college athletics and campus activities designed for a finite window in life.
09-11-2026 07:18 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Dr Dawgma III Offline
Hark the Sound
*

Posts: 26,092
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2774
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
Post: #374
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 11:29 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 10:39 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 10:25 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

These players had not exhausted their eligibility. They left early.

The college players are professionals and are being paid. They are just pretending it isn't salary when they pay them for allowing the game to be broadcast that they are playing in. At best, its like an actor in a movie, who clearly is a professional. Not calling these college football and basketball players professionals is just a word game.

It has been a known rule when you turn professional and hire an agent you exhaust eligibility. Fact. There are waivers like being drafted and not hiring an agent etc.

They technically aren't defined as professionals. Look it up. They are student athletes and are not considered as professionals making a living off their NIL etc and are not employees of the university. 1% is making six figures, the other 99% (of a half million student athletes) are not anywhere near that.

It may be a "word game" to you, but if there isn't a W4 being filed, then we are leaving the "word games" on the playground and establishing facts regarding the absence of employment. They fill out 1099s and are independent contractors. Anyone can do that. In fact, I've turned down three NIL deals this week due to being an elite message board poster. I do it for the love of the game. 04-wine

There are a lot of people who don't get a W4. They get a 1099. And these people are getting 1099s. Independent contractors are every bit as much "professionals" as full employees. FBS football players are professionals now. They weren't 5 years ago. You are still living in the past. That's why you only got 3 small NIL deals. 04-cheers

See the NCAA definition above. The NCAA is the governing body of CFB, just an FYI 04-wine

I'll have a bier later
09-11-2026 07:19 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
quo vadis Offline
Legend
*

Posts: 56,029
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
Post: #375
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 07:18 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 10:52 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

Well first, I think it obvious that to play for a school you have to enrolled in the school, and had LSU decided to roster them they would have been enrolled, so IMO that is a meaningless technicality. I mean, what if the SEC had come out and said that LSU could not roster these guys because they weren't enrolled? That this was the only objection? If that was all it took to mollify the SEC, LSU would have or could have enrolled them on the spot, I think, so to me that means that was no kind of barrier.

Second, to me, I just googled the definition of a professional athlete and got this:

"A professional athlete is an individual who competes in sports for compensation, participating in official events that can attract varying audience sizes..." (ref below).

This seems to exactly comport with what is happening in FBS athletics these days. Athletes are fielding offers of payment from schools, NIL and House payments, and signing offers of payment from them for specific amounts. IMO that makes someone a professional athlete regardless of W4s and the like. FWIW, my readings of the second reference below says the IRS considers all NIL and House payments to be taxable income.

As for "unfair" competition or whatever, well that is what life is about. I mean it might be unfair that Aaron Rodgers continues to linger on an NFL roster for 20 years taking a spot that might give an opportunity for a 22 year old who needs it more, but that's life, IMO, people aren't sheltered from competition.

BTW, FWIW, I do NOT like this state of affairs AT ALL. I wish we could go back to 10 years ago, or really 5 years ago, when NIL first hit and simply meant that the local BBQ joint could offer free ribs on Mondays to the local college's offensive line, or that hot female athletes could monetize their cheesecake Instagram photos. But the logic that allowed those quaint Fall of 2021 things directly leads to what we have now, IMO.

https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/...al-athlete

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-bus...ess-income

Instead of Google, try the NCAA bylaws:

12.02.4 Professional Athlete. A professional athlete is one who receives any kind of payment, directly or indirectly, for
athletics participation, except as permitted by the governing legislation of the Association.


There you have it. The governing body of CFB disagrees with you as NIL and revenue sharing are permitted and NFL paychecks are not.

• • •

It's not unfair competition, it is directly opposite to the SPIRIT of college athletics. Opportunity turnover is exactly what higher education's extracurricular activities were created for. Alas, I don't really expect people unfamiliar with campus life to understand the spirit of college athletics and campus activities designed for a finite window in life.

The reason I posted a google found definition of professional athlete is because I wanted a universal reference point, not something from within the NCAA ecosystem. My point is that by commonly acceptes understandings of what it means to be a professional athlete all FBS football players are obviously professional athletes.

But thanks for posting that NCAA definition, I got an enormous laugh reading it., since IMO it basically says "yes professional athletes are athletes who receive payments for participation in sports except when we the NCAA say the payment does not make you a professional", a completely farcical and LOL notion, imo.
(This post was last modified: 09-11-2026 11:16 PM by quo vadis.)
09-11-2026 11:08 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
jimrtex Offline
All American
*

Posts: 4,848
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 653
I Root For: Houston, Tulsa, Colorado
Location:
Post: #376
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 11:08 PM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:18 PM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 10:52 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

Well first, I think it obvious that to play for a school you have to enrolled in the school, and had LSU decided to roster them they would have been enrolled, so IMO that is a meaningless technicality. I mean, what if the SEC had come out and said that LSU could not roster these guys because they weren't enrolled? That this was the only objection? If that was all it took to mollify the SEC, LSU would have or could have enrolled them on the spot, I think, so to me that means that was no kind of barrier.

Second, to me, I just googled the definition of a professional athlete and got this:

"A professional athlete is an individual who competes in sports for compensation, participating in official events that can attract varying audience sizes..." (ref below).

This seems to exactly comport with what is happening in FBS athletics these days. Athletes are fielding offers of payment from schools, NIL and House payments, and signing offers of payment from them for specific amounts. IMO that makes someone a professional athlete regardless of W4s and the like. FWIW, my readings of the second reference below says the IRS considers all NIL and House payments to be taxable income.

As for "unfair" competition or whatever, well that is what life is about. I mean it might be unfair that Aaron Rodgers continues to linger on an NFL roster for 20 years taking a spot that might give an opportunity for a 22 year old who needs it more, but that's life, IMO, people aren't sheltered from competition.

BTW, FWIW, I do NOT like this state of affairs AT ALL. I wish we could go back to 10 years ago, or really 5 years ago, when NIL first hit and simply meant that the local BBQ joint could offer free ribs on Mondays to the local college's offensive line, or that hot female athletes could monetize their cheesecake Instagram photos. But the logic that allowed those quaint Fall of 2021 things directly leads to what we have now, IMO.

https://www.ebsco.com/research-starters/...al-athlete

https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-bus...ess-income

Instead of Google, try the NCAA bylaws:

12.02.4 Professional Athlete. A professional athlete is one who receives any kind of payment, directly or indirectly, for
athletics participation, except as permitted by the governing legislation of the Association.


There you have it. The governing body of CFB disagrees with you as NIL and revenue sharing are permitted and NFL paychecks are not.

• • •

It's not unfair competition, it is directly opposite to the SPIRIT of college athletics. Opportunity turnover is exactly what higher education's extracurricular activities were created for. Alas, I don't really expect people unfamiliar with campus life to understand the spirit of college athletics and campus activities designed for a finite window in life.

The reason I posted a google found definition of professional athlete is because I wanted a universal reference point, not something from within the NCAA ecosystem. My point is that by commonly acceptes understandings of what it means to be a professional athlete all FBS football players are obviously professional athletes.

But thanks for posting that NCAA definition, I got an enormous laugh reading it., since IMO it basically says "yes professional athletes are athletes who receive payments for participation in sports except when we the NCAA say the payment does not make you a professional", a completely farcical and LOL notion, imo.
The prospective LSU players had exhausted their eligibility under the old rule since they had played four years (no redshirt). The litigation over the new rule is players who claim that they are being treated differently than players who started a year after they did.

There was (is) a player who graduated from Notre Dame and had not tried out with the NFL. Marcus Freeman told him it was too late to enroll in graduate school (and besides didn't have a roster spot for him). He enrolled as a graduate student at LSU, and played against Clemson (5th rusher and special teams).

The "NFL" players might not have tried for the NFL but for the perfidy of the NCAA
09-12-2026 08:00 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
bryanw1995 Offline
+12 Hackmaster
*

Posts: 26,970
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3768
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
Post: #377
RE: SEC Schools Reportingly To Boycott LSU or Boot Them From The conference
(09-11-2026 10:39 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 10:25 AM)bullet Wrote:  
(09-11-2026 07:33 AM)Dr Dawgma III Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:29 AM)quo vadis Wrote:  
(09-10-2026 09:24 AM)Smedly02 Wrote:  It is interesting that when certain NCAA hockey teams added players with YEARS of professional experience there was hardly any outcry. Is the indignation aroused by the LSU attempt due to the fact it is football, or because it’s Lane Kiffin behind this attempt?

Good point. And additionally, IMO all FBS football players, or nearly all, are professional athletes, as they are all or nearly all getting directly paid by their schools from the $20m House settlement money. I fail to see how that is different from getting a check from the San Diego Chargers or Atlanta Hawks.

I expect the date to finalize rosters will move up in the calendar. The NFL rejects weren’t even enrolled at LSU, so right off the bat I’m not understanding how you don’t see that as being different lol. They weren’t even going to the school.

From a moral standpoint, it’s totally unfair to inject a professional player who has exhausted eligibility onto a roster and take playing time from somebody who is actually a student and waiting their turn. This is called opportunity turnover and it should be protected and is unique for student activities.

Your definition of professional athlete isn’t accepted because they are students and not making a living from revenue sharing and NIL. They are not filling out W4’s. Do you see how that’s different from a legal standpoint? They are not employees like NFL players.

I expect situations like this to fast forward the PCSA or something similar.

These players had not exhausted their eligibility. They left early.

The college players are professionals and are being paid. They are just pretending it isn't salary when they pay them for allowing the game to be broadcast that they are playing in. At best, its like an actor in a movie, who clearly is a professional. Not calling these college football and basketball players professionals is just a word game.

It has been a known rule when you turn professional and hire an agent you exhaust eligibility. Fact. There are waivers like being drafted and not hiring an agent etc.

They technically aren't defined as professionals. Look it up. They are student athletes and are not considered as professionals making a living off their NIL etc and are not employees of the university. 1% is making six figures, the other 99% (of a half million student athletes) are not anywhere near that.

It may be a "word game" to you, but if there isn't a W4 being filed, then we are leaving the "word games" on the playground and establishing facts regarding the absence of employment. They fill out 1099s and are independent contractors. Anyone can do that. In fact, I've turned down three NIL deals this week due to being an elite message board poster. I do it for the love of the game. 04-wine

04-bow
09-12-2026 09:05 PM
Find all posts by this user Quote this message in a reply
Post Reply 




User(s) browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)


Copyright © 2002-2026 Collegiate Sports Nation Bulletin Board System (CSNbbs), All Rights Reserved.
CSNbbs is an independent fan site and is in no way affiliated to the NCAA or any of the schools and conferences it represents.
This site monetizes links. FTC Disclosure.
We allow third-party companies to serve ads and/or collect certain anonymous information when you visit our web site. These companies may use non-personally identifiable information (e.g., click stream information, browser type, time and date, subject of advertisements clicked or scrolled over) during your visits to this and other Web sites in order to provide advertisements about goods and services likely to be of greater interest to you. These companies typically use a cookie or third party web beacon to collect this information. To learn more about this behavioral advertising practice or to opt-out of this type of advertising, you can visit http://www.networkadvertising.org.
Powered By MyBB, © 2002-2026 MyBB Group.