(09-09-2026 03:57 PM)quo vadis Wrote: (09-08-2026 01:24 PM)The Beaver Wrote: WV has always had the "small and poor (and hard to travel to)" problem. They fixed the travel issue but are now smaller and poorer than ever, far more so than when conferences were being created. They're lucky to have the history they have already, it would be very hard to rebuild what they have already there.
I kind of feel for WV. Before the ACC raid, they had a really good football program, a national program. Basketball was formidable too. Then for reasons you mention, the ACC passed them over, and so out of desperation they lunged at the Big 12 offer, an offer I agree they absolutely had to jump at, as the alternative was sinking to the G-level with UConn, USF and Cincy, an unthinkable outcome.
But, they have been a fish out of water in the Big 12/nB12 since day one, and their sports have withered on the vine there.
Corporate sports thinking is national reach.
Fan sports thinking is regional.
Every conference member outlier from the region of the conference they have joined proves this for college sports. West Virginia was just one of the first. The Big Ten is looking at numbers drop offs for the 4 former PAC schools. Stanford and Cal just aren't what they need to be for the ACC. West Virginia in the Big 12 like Central Florida to a lesser extent isn't piquing the interest of their own fans like Pitt, Syracuse, B.C., and Va Tech once did.
When all of this fails, regional relationships will remain.
Therefore, if you abandon what fans like in order to adopt a more corporate model you will ultimately wither and die.
The Bible verse is you can't serve God and mammon.
The College sports Gospel proves you can't serve fan interest and corporate interests at the same time.
It is why I like the SEC's position in spite of the current histrionics at LSU. Regionality is the healthiest approach to growth because schools which are neighbors have a synergy that drives fan interest.
Setting up airport conferences might reach specific markets but it doesn't ultimately bring the fans along with the schedule.
This is why I've had a belly full of the crap the Big Ten is pushing. It might work for the pros because their appeal is local, usually to a city, so site to site may work for that. Colleges are rival dependent and regional because they are more like extended family.
Converting to a professional setup for college sports will only lead to the death of college sports. College sports fans love their alma mater, hate their rivals, and enjoy all of it because their family members represent a larger allegiance to schools in the region and the rivalry is present at every holiday and family gathering. It is simply woven into the fabric of our lives. Corporate and Professional models have never understood this and because of it miss the points on how to maximize it.
It is for this reason the SEC will succeed, will likely never kick out a member (save for private equity involvement) and will continue to succeed no matter what happens outside the SE/SW marriage which is now the SEC.
We need our own larger conference playoff. What nobody needs is a CFP of 24 or more schools. Our regular season is fabulously successful because every game matters. Cheapening that for a fast buck is corporate thinking and it will tank the championship playoff if it balloons the numbers of entrants.