Fighting Muskie
Senior Chief Realignmentologist

Posts: 15,089
Joined: Sep 2016
Reputation: 1214
I Root For: Bishop Sycamore
Location: Secret Lair
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
I figured there was some quid pro quo with ESPN going on. I recall now that one official slipping up and saying that ESPN directed the ACC to do it.
It’s sad—the deal the Big East rejected from ESPN was a pretty low ball offer. I totally get why they wanted to go to open market. I really think if they had brought UCF in as a full member and BYU, Boise State, and SDSU as football affiliates combined with the 8 from 2005, they would have had a pretty stellar league.
Instead they got taken to the woodshed by Mickey.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 04:13 PM |
|
ccbfan
Special Teams

Posts: 792
Joined: Aug 2005
Reputation: 71
I Root For:
Location:
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
Cause espn told them so. BE had the audacity of not accepting espns low ball offer and go to an open market so espn told acc to take out the big east.
Big east was actually being proactive at that time grabbing tcu, Boise, sdsu and one more, forgot who.
ESPN gave the execution orders and that killed what would have been a pretty good conference.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 04:27 PM |
|
DFW HOYA
Heisman

Posts: 7,306
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
ESPN had right of first refusal for the Big East media contract. In 2011, its contract paid Big East football schools $3.1 million per year and $1.5 million for the basketball schools, or $38.4 million per year. Its offer increased that amount to $13.8 million a year for football but just $2.4 million a year for basketball schools. Paul Tagliabue, a Georgetown alumnus, former NFL commissioner, and the Big East's media consultant, told the presidents he considered the bid undervalued given the rise in fees coming to other BCS conferences--at this time, the Pac-12 was being offered $225 million per year ($18.75 million per school). The Big East presidents voted 16-0 to decline ESPN's offer.
The right of first refusal got interesting when NBC showed interest in a major rights offer somewhere between $18-20 million per school, which meant ESPN would have to match a much larger number. They decided that the only way to pay lower rights fees would be to gut the Big East and pay much less to whatever was left. Using its media muscle with the ACC over the proposed ACC cable network, the ACC presidents voted to add Syracuse and Pitt, and then led Notre Dame to follow suit. West Virginia, shunned once again by the ACC, went after a Big 12 offer. NBC backed off the bid, and the value of the Big East extension, taking effect in the fall of 2013, plummeted.
ESPN then took their eyes off the stumbling Big East, and apparently paid little heed when seven of its non-FBS schools announced they were leaving in 2013. Reincorporating under the Big East name in New York state (a crafty IP trade with the remnant FBS schools), Tagliabue put the conference in touch with representatives from a new cable network under the auspices of Fox Sports, who almost doubled the offer ESPN had made to the basketball schools in 2011, with 100% carriage of all conference games and no streaming. As the new Big East corporation was not subject to contracts signed by the former entity incorporated in Rhode Island, ESPN had no legal claim to exercise first refusal on the Fox offer.
With that right of first refusal, ESPN assumed the media rights of the American Athletic Conference at just $8.3 million per school, a 37% cut from what ESPN would have offered to pay the Big East before the split and 59% less than what ESPN would pay each ACC school after the split.
(This post was last modified: 09-07-2026 06:43 PM by DFW HOYA.)
|
|
| 09-07-2026 06:25 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,992
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 12:56 PM)Garrettabc Wrote: The ACC had just trapped themselves with a bad 13 year deal with ESPN. This move allowed the ACC to go from $13m each to $17m each (average over the length of the contract). Where the ACC screwed up was not adding WVU and probably Rutgers. Could have had 2 divisions of the oBE and Classic ACC with some very large ACCN markets with ND also joining the fold.
It's amazing looking back on that. The ACC was at $13m, the BE was offered $11m and turned that down.
Pitt and Syracuse were both good market adds, and I seem to recall that the B1G also looked at Syracuse before settling on Rutgers (lol).
|
|
| 09-07-2026 08:36 PM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,992
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
I think that if the ACC would have taken Louisville, then they'd probably have taken WVU if Louisville was already in the Big 12. That WVU-over-Louisville decision by the Big 12 sure seems like a head-scratcher today, though it seemed like the right idea at the time, even to me at a time when my dislike for all things Big 12 was at an all time high.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 08:39 PM |
|
XOVERX
Bench Warmer

Posts: 164
Joined: Aug 2021
Reputation: 73
I Root For: Texas
Location:
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 08:39 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
I think that if the ACC would have taken Louisville, then they'd probably have taken WVU if Louisville was already in the Big 12. That WVU-over-Louisville decision by the Big 12 sure seems like a head-scratcher today, though it seemed like the right idea at the time, even to me at a time when my dislike for all things Big 12 was at an all time high.
WVU is a flagship. That carries a lot of weight. Plus, WVU guaranteed the B12 they would show up immediately, no matter what, which was critical in stabilizing the B12’s TV payout.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 09:02 PM |
|
JRsec
Super Moderator

Posts: 44,999
Joined: Mar 2012
Reputation: 13547
I Root For: SEC
Location:
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 08:39 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
I think that if the ACC would have taken Louisville, then they'd probably have taken WVU if Louisville was already in the Big 12. That WVU-over-Louisville decision by the Big 12 sure seems like a head-scratcher today, though it seemed like the right idea at the time, even to me at a time when my dislike for all things Big 12 was at an all time high.
Folks need to remember at the time Aresco and the Big East were considering raiding the ACC. ESPN liked what it was building in the ACC and took what they wanted from the Big East effectively eliminating them as a football conference. The ACC actually built football branding with B.C. & Virginia Tech, both of which were pretty solid on the gridiron at the time. Pitt & Syracuse were too. Miami was the finishing touch to a building of football branding that really started with the taking of FSU in '91-2. When Maryland left Louisville was logical. The problem that West Virginia always had was that their market was so small and the two Virginia schools reached into the Beltway already and covered much of what departed with Maryland. That made Louisville's reach into Southern Ohio and throughout Kentucky a solid addition. It was never that WVU wasn't good enough. It was all about market reach and most importantly market reach at the time of the cable subscription model which didn't calculate WVU's draw outside of West Virginia.
And Muskie, when ESPN lowballs an offer, that's a tell that they have already backdoored some of the product they want from your conference.
(This post was last modified: 09-07-2026 09:21 PM by JRsec.)
|
|
| 09-07-2026 09:09 PM |
|
DFW HOYA
Heisman

Posts: 7,306
Joined: May 2004
Reputation: 533
I Root For: Georgetown
Location: Dallas, TX
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 09:09 PM)JRsec Wrote: Folks need to remember at the time Aresco and the Big East were considering raiding the ACC.
With whom?
Mike Aresco wasn't the Big East commissioner until 2012, and the schools had already given notice by that time.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 10:07 PM |
|
Frank the Tank
Hall of Famer

Posts: 23,564
Joined: Jun 2008
Reputation: 3294
I Root For: Illinois/DePaul
Location: Chicago
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
No - West Virginia did not make a mistake. UConn or Cincinnati would have been taken by the ACC ahead of WVU. They needed to make the move to the Big 12 lifeboat immediately.
Louisville was (and is) still way ahead academically compared to WVU. There’s still a very wide gap there.
WVU to the ACC is one of the moves that everyone *thinks* should happen, but the ACC simply doesn’t want them. Maybe it’s academic snobbery, maybe it’s the market, maybe it’s a whole host of other reasons, but the “WVU to the ACC” is the Mean Girls “Stop trying to make ‘fetch’ happen” meme of conference realignment. It might be one of the clearest examples where fans always see “fit” as geographic fit, but WVU is absolutely not an *institutional* fit with the ACC. And *institutional* fit is what matters at the top levels of conference realignment.
|
|
| 09-07-2026 10:16 PM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,119
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2775
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 10:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
No - West Virginia did not make a mistake. UConn or Cincinnati would have been taken by the ACC ahead of WVU. They needed to make the move to the Big 12 lifeboat immediately.
Louisville was (and is) still way ahead academically compared to WVU. There’s still a very wide gap there.
WVU to the ACC is one of the moves that everyone *thinks* should happen, but the ACC simply doesn’t want them. Maybe it’s academic snobbery, maybe it’s the market, maybe it’s a whole host of other reasons, but the “WVU to the ACC” is the Mean Girls “Stop trying to make ‘fetch’ happen” meme of conference realignment. It might be one of the clearest examples where fans always see “fit” as geographic fit, but WVU is absolutely not an *institutional* fit with the ACC. And *institutional* fit is what matters at the top levels of conference realignment.
Yes, that has been true in the past but as evidenced by David Hale’s reporting the ACC drew up expansion models incorporating WVU just a few years ago. One major issue now is the cost/logistics to depart a conference. Still, that’s the closest they’ve been considered since the 1950’s.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 02:29 AM |
|
Dr Dawgma III
Hark the Sound

Posts: 26,119
Joined: Feb 2007
Reputation: 2775
I Root For: The SoCon
Location: The 19th Hole
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
Also the obvious reason nobody has mentioned for some reason: new markets for the creation of the ACCN. This add wasn’t that long ago, if the search function is working you can see all our reactions instead of reading everyone’s revisionist history.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2026 07:39 AM by Dr Dawgma III.)
|
|
| 09-08-2026 02:30 AM |
|
bryanw1995
+12 Hackmaster

Posts: 26,992
Joined: Jul 2022
Reputation: 3774
I Root For: A&M
Location: San Antonio
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 09:09 PM)JRsec Wrote: (09-07-2026 08:39 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
I think that if the ACC would have taken Louisville, then they'd probably have taken WVU if Louisville was already in the Big 12. That WVU-over-Louisville decision by the Big 12 sure seems like a head-scratcher today, though it seemed like the right idea at the time, even to me at a time when my dislike for all things Big 12 was at an all time high.
Folks need to remember at the time Aresco and the Big East were considering raiding the ACC. ESPN liked what it was building in the ACC and took what they wanted from the Big East effectively eliminating them as a football conference. The ACC actually built football branding with B.C. & Virginia Tech, both of which were pretty solid on the gridiron at the time. Pitt & Syracuse were too. Miami was the finishing touch to a building of football branding that really started with the taking of FSU in '91-2. When Maryland left Louisville was logical. The problem that West Virginia always had was that their market was so small and the two Virginia schools reached into the Beltway already and covered much of what departed with Maryland. That made Louisville's reach into Southern Ohio and throughout Kentucky a solid addition. It was never that WVU wasn't good enough. It was all about market reach and most importantly market reach at the time of the cable subscription model which didn't calculate WVU's draw outside of West Virginia.
And Muskie, when ESPN lowballs an offer, that's a tell that they have already backdoored some of the product they want from your conference.
In retrospect, $11m wasn't really a lowball, especially since the ACC was only getting $13m. Not unlike how that $30m offer in fall 2022 to the Pac 12-2 seems like it was a quite reasonable offer now, considering what happened when the Pac decided they wanted to set up a bidding war with no bidders in a Quixotic attempt at $50m.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 06:41 AM |
|
quo vadis
Legend

Posts: 56,035
Joined: Aug 2008
Reputation: 3198
I Root For: Notre Dame/USF/G'Town
Location: New Orleans
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
At the time I thought there were multiple motivations, purely speculative of course because I couldn't then or now read the minds of ACC officials. FWIW, 15 years on I still think this way:
1) ACC second swipe at "gutting" the Big East. IMO the ACC must have felt that when they swiped Miami, BC and VT in 2003, that they had eliminated the Big East as an "Atlantic coast" competitor, north and south. I felt they were shocked when the rump BE replaced these schools with relative nobodies and yet remained very competitive on the field and court. So taking Cuse and Pitt was supposed to be the knockout blow, which it turned out to be. BTW, I have no problem with the ACC doing this, even though it wrecked my USF. Conferences have to think strategically, and knocking out competitors is an aspect of that. IMO the Big East was asleep at the switch, didn't realize the ACC danger.
2) At around that time it became apparent that the B1G had northeast aspirations. IMO the ACC move was designed to "head off" the B1G, claim the northeast corridor for itself, or at least ensure that it got its share of that lucrative cable TV market.
FWIW, I have never thought that ESPN worked behind the scenes to "punish" the Big East for turning down its deal. I understand the notion that they would rather have Pitt and Cuse remain under the ESPN umbrella as part of the ACC contract rather than possibly lose them should the Big East sign a deal with another network, but OTOH, they had to pay a lot more for them than they were before, and Pitt and Cuse just weren't that important, IMO.
All just my speculative opinion, might well have been wrong then and now.
(This post was last modified: 09-08-2026 07:01 AM by quo vadis.)
|
|
| 09-08-2026 07:00 AM |
|
The Cutter of Bish
Heisman

Posts: 8,837
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 364
I Root For: the little guy
Location:
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-08-2026 07:00 AM)quo vadis Wrote: FWIW, I have never thought that ESPN worked behind the scenes to "punish" the Big East for turning down its deal. I understand the notion that they would rather have Pitt and Cuse remain under the ESPN umbrella as part of the ACC contract rather than possibly lose them should the Big East sign a deal with another network, but OTOH, they had to pay a lot more for them than they were before, and Pitt and Cuse just weren't that important, IMO.
There were so many moving parts that a revenge angle seemed silly. Hurt feelings with an opportunity to take advantage? Sure. The context of the Big East's formation was to aim for a northeast version of the ACC in basketball. In a time when travel still mattered a lot, the idea of the ACC creeping northward wasn't an option, until it was. It's not surprising that original or early members of the conference that looked to the ACC as its aspirant may actually want to be a member of said aspirant conference. So, now the ACC is on the line wants to hang out...and you want to still chill with Rutgers, USF, UConn, and this welfare Villanova issue?
And, again, it's not like the two weren't looking around. The Big East almost lost Syracuse once before. Both Pitt and Cuse were allegedly getting looks from the Big Ten. They held value. Just not enough to prop up the Big East to other major/AQ conference levels monetarily.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 07:10 AM |
|
Ned Low
Heisman

Posts: 6,481
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 09:09 PM)JRsec Wrote: (09-07-2026 08:39 PM)bryanw1995 Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
I think that if the ACC would have taken Louisville, then they'd probably have taken WVU if Louisville was already in the Big 12. That WVU-over-Louisville decision by the Big 12 sure seems like a head-scratcher today, though it seemed like the right idea at the time, even to me at a time when my dislike for all things Big 12 was at an all time high.
Folks need to remember at the time Aresco and the Big East were considering raiding the ACC. ESPN liked what it was building in the ACC and took what they wanted from the Big East effectively eliminating them as a football conference. The ACC actually built football branding with B.C. & Virginia Tech, both of which were pretty solid on the gridiron at the time. Pitt & Syracuse were too. Miami was the finishing touch to a building of football branding that really started with the taking of FSU in '91-2. When Maryland left Louisville was logical. The problem that West Virginia always had was that their market was so small and the two Virginia schools reached into the Beltway already and covered much of what departed with Maryland. That made Louisville's reach into Southern Ohio and throughout Kentucky a solid addition. It was never that WVU wasn't good enough. It was all about market reach and most importantly market reach at the time of the cable subscription model which didn't calculate WVU's draw outside of West Virginia.
And Muskie, when ESPN lowballs an offer, that's a tell that they have already backdoored some of the product they want from your conference.
I need to see a source for this. The schools had announced they were leaving the conference prior to Mike Aresco leaving CBS to become commisioner of the Big East to the best of my knowledge.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 07:11 AM |
|
Ned Low
Heisman

Posts: 6,481
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-07-2026 10:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
No - West Virginia did not make a mistake. UConn or Cincinnati would have been taken by the ACC ahead of WVU. They needed to make the move to the Big 12 lifeboat immediately.
Louisville was (and is) still way ahead academically compared to WVU. There’s still a very wide gap there.
WVU to the ACC is one of the moves that everyone *thinks* should happen, but the ACC simply doesn’t want them. Maybe it’s academic snobbery, maybe it’s the market, maybe it’s a whole host of other reasons, but the “WVU to the ACC” is the Mean Girls “Stop trying to make ‘fetch’ happen” meme of conference realignment. It might be one of the clearest examples where fans always see “fit” as geographic fit, but WVU is absolutely not an *institutional* fit with the ACC. And *institutional* fit is what matters at the top levels of conference realignment.
I won't say that it would never happen but there are schools out there that the ACC would only take as a last resort, otherwise they would have no chance of joining.
In my opinion, WVU is in that camp even though they have a fine athletic program and better football viewership than many in the ACC.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 07:19 AM |
|
Blust3
1st String

Posts: 1,187
Joined: Aug 2023
Reputation: 130
I Root For: Pitt/BC/Cuse/Louisville
Location: Pittsburgh
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-08-2026 07:19 AM)Ned Low Wrote: (09-07-2026 10:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
No - West Virginia did not make a mistake. UConn or Cincinnati would have been taken by the ACC ahead of WVU. They needed to make the move to the Big 12 lifeboat immediately.
Louisville was (and is) still way ahead academically compared to WVU. There’s still a very wide gap there.
WVU to the ACC is one of the moves that everyone *thinks* should happen, but the ACC simply doesn’t want them. Maybe it’s academic snobbery, maybe it’s the market, maybe it’s a whole host of other reasons, but the “WVU to the ACC” is the Mean Girls “Stop trying to make ‘fetch’ happen” meme of conference realignment. It might be one of the clearest examples where fans always see “fit” as geographic fit, but WVU is absolutely not an *institutional* fit with the ACC. And *institutional* fit is what matters at the top levels of conference realignment.
I won't say that it would never happen but there are schools out there that the ACC would only take as a last resort, otherwise they would have no chance of joining.
In my opinion, WVU is in that camp even though they have a fine athletic program and better football viewership than many in the ACC.
The bottom line is that West Virginia is one of the smallest states and the academics is way subpar than other ACC schools. Also the population has low incomes. Not a good fit to ACC.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 07:46 AM |
|
Ned Low
Heisman

Posts: 6,481
Joined: Nov 2010
Reputation: 561
I Root For: ECU
Location: Durham, NC
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-08-2026 07:46 AM)Blust3 Wrote: (09-08-2026 07:19 AM)Ned Low Wrote: (09-07-2026 10:16 PM)Frank the Tank Wrote: (09-07-2026 02:30 PM)schmolik Wrote: West Virginia and UConn were mentioned in this thread.
You wonder if West Virginia made a mistake going to the Big 12 instead of waiting for the ACC opening that Louisville got? Or would North Carolina, Duke, or the other academic snobs had blocked them and they did the right thing grabbing the Big 12 slot (of course had they stayed in the Big East/eventually AAC they could have had a Cincinnati or UCF type season, had a NY6 or even a CFP bid, and wound up in the Big 12 anyway).
What if the Big 12 had taken Louisville instead of West Virginia and the ACC was forced to choose between West Virginia and Connecticut? If the ACC had accepted Louisville they would've taken West Virginia. But West Virginia is a lot lower academically than Louisville. Then again Cincinnati was still out there.
Is the ACC or Big 12 better considering the possibility the ACC gets raided by the SEC and Big Ten in case the Protect College Sports cap doesn't get implemented? I have to believe West Virginia in the Big 12 was a bad thing being in a conference with mostly western schools. It's pretty clear West Virginia isn't as successful in the Big 12 in both football and men's basketball as they were in the Big East. Could all that travel have played a part? Likely. Then again, if the ACC collapses, the Big 12 could wind up with more Eastern schools anyway.
No - West Virginia did not make a mistake. UConn or Cincinnati would have been taken by the ACC ahead of WVU. They needed to make the move to the Big 12 lifeboat immediately.
Louisville was (and is) still way ahead academically compared to WVU. There’s still a very wide gap there.
WVU to the ACC is one of the moves that everyone *thinks* should happen, but the ACC simply doesn’t want them. Maybe it’s academic snobbery, maybe it’s the market, maybe it’s a whole host of other reasons, but the “WVU to the ACC” is the Mean Girls “Stop trying to make ‘fetch’ happen” meme of conference realignment. It might be one of the clearest examples where fans always see “fit” as geographic fit, but WVU is absolutely not an *institutional* fit with the ACC. And *institutional* fit is what matters at the top levels of conference realignment.
I won't say that it would never happen but there are schools out there that the ACC would only take as a last resort, otherwise they would have no chance of joining.
In my opinion, WVU is in that camp even though they have a fine athletic program and better football viewership than many in the ACC.
The bottom line is that West Virginia is one of the smallest states and the academics is way subpar than other ACC schools. Also the population has low incomes. Not a good fit to ACC.
I should add that again, they have more viewers, more traveling fans and higher home attendence than many in the ACC now. They also have a high number of out-of-state enrollees who move out of the area after graduation, meaning that their reach is spread well outside of their borders.
These may be reasons why they would be added in the future, depending on certain factors.
Who knows what will happen?
|
|
| 09-08-2026 08:19 AM |
|
tf8693
All American

Posts: 2,904
Joined: Jul 2023
Reputation: 333
I Root For: Notre Dame
Location:
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
It was basically a kill shot of the old Big East. Remember, this got both West Virginia and TCU (who hadn't yet joined the Big East but had committed to doing so in 2012) scared and looking for another home. To a lesser extent, Boston College was grumbling a little about being the only northern school in a southern-facing conference, and the move placated them.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 08:22 AM |
|
ccbfan
Special Teams

Posts: 792
Joined: Aug 2005
Reputation: 71
I Root For:
Location:
|
RE: What was the impetus for the ACC adding Pitt and Syracuse?
(09-08-2026 07:00 AM)quo vadis Wrote: At the time I thought there were multiple motivations, purely speculative of course because I couldn't then or now read the minds of ACC officials. FWIW, 15 years on I still think this way:
1) ACC second swipe at "gutting" the Big East. IMO the ACC must have felt that when they swiped Miami, BC and VT in 2003, that they had eliminated the Big East as an "Atlantic coast" competitor, north and south. I felt they were shocked when the rump BE replaced these schools with relative nobodies and yet remained very competitive on the field and court. So taking Cuse and Pitt was supposed to be the knockout blow, which it turned out to be. BTW, I have no problem with the ACC doing this, even though it wrecked my USF. Conferences have to think strategically, and knocking out competitors is an aspect of that. IMO the Big East was asleep at the switch, didn't realize the ACC danger.
2) At around that time it became apparent that the B1G had northeast aspirations. IMO the ACC move was designed to "head off" the B1G, claim the northeast corridor for itself, or at least ensure that it got its share of that lucrative cable TV market.
FWIW, I have never thought that ESPN worked behind the scenes to "punish" the Big East for turning down its deal. I understand the notion that they would rather have Pitt and Cuse remain under the ESPN umbrella as part of the ACC contract rather than possibly lose them should the Big East sign a deal with another network, but OTOH, they had to pay a lot more for them than they were before, and Pitt and Cuse just weren't that important, IMO.
All just my speculative opinion, might well have been wrong then and now.
Yeah, I think its less punish the big east but more.
I'm willing to pay you x for your product regardless of how undervalued you think it is.
What? You got feelers from NBC that you can get more and want to go open market to increase our right to first refusal offer?
Hey ACC, take these two school we think is most valuable in the BE.
|
|
| 09-08-2026 08:42 AM |
|