Was SoMs Eagle
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,337
Joined: Oct 2020
Reputation: 1682
I Root For: Mustard Buzzard
Location:
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-06-2026 06:31 PM)HarborPointe Wrote: (09-06-2026 04:26 PM)MonarchManiac Wrote: What penalty? I never saw a flag??
It was the special flag no one else but the replay officials are allowed to see. They keep it next to that special clock only the replay officials are allowed to see.
We’re on a path toward somebody getting screwed on a play call, then 2 hours after the game ends, they’ll roll out an AI-modified view that they’ll claim was a special camera angle to which only the replay officials had access.
It’s their officials. And I’ve said for years that if they’ll pay an 18 year-old $1 million to play football they will sure as hell give the refs $10,000 to ‘keep it fair’.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 06:59 AM |
|
gdunn
Repping E-Gang Colors

Posts: 34,759
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation: 3144
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location: In The Moment
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
Question is, the next play was a HM.. If Michigan wouldn't had caught it, would the refs called PI?
|
|
| 09-09-2026 07:30 AM |
|
Was SoMs Eagle
Hall of Famer

Posts: 15,337
Joined: Oct 2020
Reputation: 1682
I Root For: Mustard Buzzard
Location:
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-09-2026 07:30 AM)gdunn Wrote: Question is, the next play was a HM.. If Michigan wouldn't had caught it, would the refs called PI?
You don’t remember back in the day when we played Auburn? Like three past interferences in a row in the last minute of the game to move them all the way down the field to the 1 yard line. Back in those days hardly any of the games were broadcast so you just had to sit there and take the reaming.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 08:32 AM |
|
Porcine
All American

Posts: 2,645
Joined: Oct 2021
Reputation: 406
I Root For: Arkansas, SBC
Location: Northern Arkansas
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-09-2026 08:32 AM)Was SoMs Eagle Wrote: (09-09-2026 07:30 AM)gdunn Wrote: Question is, the next play was a HM.. If Michigan wouldn't had caught it, would the refs called PI?
You don’t remember back in the day when we played Auburn? Like three past interferences in a row in the last minute of the game to move them all the way down the field to the 1 yard line. Back in those days hardly any of the games were broadcast so you just had to sit there and take the reaming.
An unforeseen consequence of all games being on TV. The fixes are there for everyone to see.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 12:05 PM |
|
banker
Hall of Famer

Posts: 14,696
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 2138
I Root For: Marshall
Location:
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-08-2026 08:51 PM)banker Wrote: (09-06-2026 10:52 AM)banker Wrote: I hate Michigan, but there was a second left. The effort they went to to prove that would not have been afforded WMU if the roles were reversed, but there was a second left.
The WMU player that touched the ball first had jumped from out of bounds which means the ball is dead the moment he touches it, not when it hits the ground. There was a second when he touched it.
After full research, I wish to recant my earlier statement. The photo put out showing the 0:01 on the clock when the player touched the ball can not be correct unless the Big Ten lied about the syncing of the clocks. Since the clocks were reset before the play (ref instructed the clock operator to put the clock at 9 seconds) all clocks would have started with exactly 9 seconds before the snap, meaning they would all have to hit zero at the same time.
Now I am recanting my recantment. I can now fully explain fully what went wrong.
On the play before the first Hail Mary, Michigan picks up the first down and the clock stops with 11 seconds and will start when the sticks are moved and the ref signals ready for play. When this happens Michigan immediately spikes the ball with the clock reading 10 seconds. However, rules require a two second runoff for a spike. The ref notes this but the clock operator runs it to 8. So the ref corrects and said the clock needs to be 9 seconds. So now everyone should have a full 9 seconds on the clock..
This is where the problem occurs. Go watch any replay from that snap and pay close attention to the clock and the snap. What you will see is the displayed game clock on the TV screen goes from 9 to 8 almost immediately, less than 1/3 of a second. So the TV camera hit zero in 8.32 seconds, not 9. The replay clock would still have 0.68 seconds on it when the TV clock had zero.
This wasn’t a one second issue, this was about a .18 second issue since the TV clock would have been reading 1 if more than .5 was left. The replay clock was right, the stadium/TV clicked to 8 prematurely.
With all that said, they probably should have deferred to the stadium clock, but technically it was not correct. My guess is we will see tenths on game clocks in the near future.
|
|
| 09-09-2026 10:15 PM |
|
debragga
All American

Posts: 2,516
Joined: Nov 2017
Reputation: 212
I Root For: ULM
Location: Ruston, LA
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-09-2026 10:15 PM)banker Wrote: (09-08-2026 08:51 PM)banker Wrote: (09-06-2026 10:52 AM)banker Wrote: I hate Michigan, but there was a second left. The effort they went to to prove that would not have been afforded WMU if the roles were reversed, but there was a second left.
The WMU player that touched the ball first had jumped from out of bounds which means the ball is dead the moment he touches it, not when it hits the ground. There was a second when he touched it.
After full research, I wish to recant my earlier statement. The photo put out showing the 0:01 on the clock when the player touched the ball can not be correct unless the Big Ten lied about the syncing of the clocks. Since the clocks were reset before the play (ref instructed the clock operator to put the clock at 9 seconds) all clocks would have started with exactly 9 seconds before the snap, meaning they would all have to hit zero at the same time.
Now I am recanting my recantment. I can now fully explain fully what went wrong.
On the play before the first Hail Mary, Michigan picks up the first down and the clock stops with 11 seconds and will start when the sticks are moved and the ref signals ready for play. When this happens Michigan immediately spikes the ball with the clock reading 10 seconds. However, rules require a two second runoff for a spike. The ref notes this but the clock operator runs it to 8. So the ref corrects and said the clock needs to be 9 seconds. So now everyone should have a full 9 seconds on the clock..
This is where the problem occurs. Go watch any replay from that snap and pay close attention to the clock and the snap. What you will see is the displayed game clock on the TV screen goes from 9 to 8 almost immediately, less than 1/3 of a second. So the TV camera hit zero in 8.32 seconds, not 9. The replay clock would still have 0.68 seconds on it when the TV clock had zero.
This wasn’t a one second issue, this was about a .18 second issue since the TV clock would have been reading 1 if more than .5 was left. The replay clock was right, the stadium/TV clicked to 8 prematurely.
With all that said, they probably should have deferred to the stadium clock, but technically it was not correct. My guess is we will see tenths on game clocks in the near future.
There are videos from people in the stadium that show 1 second still on the stadium clock when the ball gets touched by the WMU player that jumped from out of bounds
|
|
| 09-09-2026 10:44 PM |
|
Purplehazed
Heisman

Posts: 8,825
Joined: Mar 2013
Reputation: 211
I Root For: James Madison Dukes
Location: Virginia
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
Say any if this from now until kingdom come...
Would WMU have gotten the same call?
No!
|
|
| 09-10-2026 06:20 AM |
|
banker
Hall of Famer

Posts: 14,696
Joined: Oct 2009
Reputation: 2138
I Root For: Marshall
Location:
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-10-2026 06:20 AM)Purplehazed Wrote: Say any if this from now until kingdom come...
Would WMU have gotten the same call?
No!
Of course not, but that’s not the debate. I’m curious about the truth and I’m pretty sure my last post details accurately why what happened was correct, just not smart.
|
|
| 09-10-2026 01:46 PM |
|
ericsaid
Heisman

Posts: 9,827
Joined: May 2013
Reputation: 258
I Root For: App. State/ECU
Location: High Point, NC
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-06-2026 12:31 PM)Luckyshot Wrote: It doesn't matter if the clock read zero. The play wasn't over and a game can't end on a Defensive foul. I wish WMU had won, but they didn't.
There was no foul, my man. The clock was 00:00 with the ball in the air. The replay was clear as day. Then the Big 10 broke review protocol by using a clock, which was already supposed to have been synced as they had synced the clock to 9 seconds before that play even happened. Big 10 was supposed to use the broadcast cameras and clock, to avoid this exact situation, and they didn't.
No idea what crack you're smoking to think the clock wasn't at 00:00 because it was obvious to everyone that it was.
|
|
| 09-10-2026 02:36 PM |
|
Luckyshot
Heisman

Posts: 8,389
Joined: Nov 2003
Reputation: 282
I Root For: Southern Miss
Location:
|
RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp
(09-10-2026 02:36 PM)ericsaid Wrote: (09-06-2026 12:31 PM)Luckyshot Wrote: It doesn't matter if the clock read zero. The play wasn't over and a game can't end on a Defensive foul. I wish WMU had won, but they didn't.
There was no foul, my man. The clock was 00:00 with the ball in the air. The replay was clear as day. Then the Big 10 broke review protocol by using a clock, which was already supposed to have been synced as they had synced the clock to 9 seconds before that play even happened. Big 10 was supposed to use the broadcast cameras and clock, to avoid this exact situation, and they didn't.
No idea what crack you're smoking to think the clock wasn't at 00:00 because it was obvious to everyone that it was.
Whose smoking crack? I said NOTHING about the clock not being zero. It clearly was. My misunderstanding (that I clearly posted later in the thread) was I thought the player touching the ball from out of bounds was a penalty. I went to the NCAA rule site and saw that it just caused a dead ball (incomplete pass). Honestly, it's weird to me that a defensive player who is out of bounds can end the play and not cause a penalty, but there it is!
|
|
| 09-10-2026 04:08 PM |
|