CSNbbs
Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Printable Version

+- CSNbbs (https://csnbbs.com)
+-- Forum: Active Boards (/forum-769.html)
+--- Forum: SunBeltbbs (/forum-317.html)
+---- Forum: Sun Belt Conference Talk (/forum-296.html)
+---- Thread: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp (/thread-1032474.html)

Pages: 1 2


Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Purplehazed - 09-06-2026 10:32 AM

...about how the P conference cartel raped western michigan or his whine only flows one direction?

The game was over!!!!!


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - debragga - 09-06-2026 10:43 AM

He’d be talking if SMU was still in the American. But now? No chance


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - banker - 09-06-2026 10:52 AM

I hate Michigan, but there was a second left. The effort they went to to prove that would not have been afforded WMU if the roles were reversed, but there was a second left.

The WMU player that touched the ball first had jumped from out of bounds which means the ball is dead the moment he touches it, not when it hits the ground. There was a second when he touched it.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Purplehazed - 09-06-2026 11:07 AM

I have seen still shots of the play, millions have seen it.
There were 00:00 on the clock well before the wmu player touched the ball.
The game was over but the refs gave Michigan another play


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Luckyshot - 09-06-2026 12:31 PM

It doesn't matter if the clock read zero. The play wasn't over and a game can't end on a Defensive foul. I wish WMU had won, but they didn't.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Purplehazed - 09-06-2026 01:24 PM

(09-06-2026 12:31 PM)Luckyshot Wrote:  It doesn't matter if the clock read zero. The play wasn't over and a game can't end on a Defensive foul. I wish WMU had won, but they didn't.

Would WMU have gotten that call?


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - WinstonTheWolf - 09-06-2026 01:30 PM

I don't know how the replay officials' clock can be that far off from the stadium clock. That's messed up, as was the result.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - TTT - 09-06-2026 02:45 PM

WMU got hosed. They won that game, plain and simple. The actual field play clock—not the picture-in-picture TV clock—showed ZERO before the ball was touched. People can argue about other clocks all they want, but the field clock is the standard. It’s the clock visible to the players, coaches, officials, and 120,000 fans in the stadium. Field clocks don’t just magically become unsynced.

The bottom line: as a G5 playing a P4, you often feel like you have to beat both the team and the officials. Last night was a perfect example.

That said, WMU still cannot let that ball get caught. That was an epic failure on their part. Both things can be true: WMU got hosed, and WMU still blew it.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Luckyshot - 09-06-2026 03:42 PM

(09-06-2026 02:45 PM)TTT Wrote:  WMU got hosed. They won that game, plain and simple. The actual field play clock—not the picture-in-picture TV clock—showed ZERO before the ball was touched. People can argue about other clocks all they want, but the field clock is the standard. It’s the clock visible to the players, coaches, officials, and 120,000 fans in the stadium. Field clocks don’t just magically become unsynced.

The bottom line: as a G5 playing a P4, you often feel like you have to beat both the team and the officials. Last night was a perfect example.

That said, WMU still cannot let that ball get caught. That was an epic failure on their part. Both things can be true: WMU got hosed, and WMU still blew it.

The game doesn't EVER end at zero on the clock if a play is already underway; and the rules of college football say the game can't end on a Defensive penalty. The clock only mattered when the ball was hiked. Was it above zero then? If so, the entire play counts. If during that play a Defender causes a penalty, then the Offense gets another play.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - SkullyMaroo - 09-06-2026 04:21 PM

I have seen some try and defend the refs adding one second back to the clock saying the WMU player went out of bounds and touched the ball first. But if that was the case, then why didn’t the refs call illegal touching and move the ball up 5 yards? And if that is their reasoning, why not call the penalty and then play an untimed down? I think it’s because the intent of the refs was to give Michigan another chance, plain and simple.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - MonarchManiac - 09-06-2026 04:26 PM

(09-06-2026 03:42 PM)Luckyshot Wrote:  
(09-06-2026 02:45 PM)TTT Wrote:  WMU got hosed. They won that game, plain and simple. The actual field play clock—not the picture-in-picture TV clock—showed ZERO before the ball was touched. People can argue about other clocks all they want, but the field clock is the standard. It’s the clock visible to the players, coaches, officials, and 120,000 fans in the stadium. Field clocks don’t just magically become unsynced.

The bottom line: as a G5 playing a P4, you often feel like you have to beat both the team and the officials. Last night was a perfect example.

That said, WMU still cannot let that ball get caught. That was an epic failure on their part. Both things can be true: WMU got hosed, and WMU still blew it.

The game doesn't EVER end at zero on the clock if a play is already underway; and the rules of college football say the game can't end on a Defensive penalty. The clock only mattered when the ball was hiked. Was it above zero then? If so, the entire play counts. If during that play a Defender causes a penalty, then the Offense gets another play.
What penalty? I never saw a flag??

Sent from my SM-G781V using Tapatalk


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Xeonon - 09-06-2026 04:28 PM

(09-06-2026 04:21 PM)SkullyMaroo Wrote:  I have seen some try and defend the refs adding one second back to the clock saying the WMU player went out of bounds and touched the ball first. But if that was the case, then why didn’t the refs call illegal touching and move the ball up 5 yards? And if that is their reasoning, why not call the penalty and then play an untimed down? I think it’s because the intent of the refs was to give Michigan another chance, plain and simple.

I can't believe there are people who can't see that the B1G didn't slide the MAC money to stfu. WMU won the game, plain and simple. Anything else is nonsense.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Big Buds - 09-06-2026 05:41 PM

I’m still sick for the WMU faithful. What an awful feeling they all must be experiencing today.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - HarborPointe - 09-06-2026 06:31 PM

(09-06-2026 04:26 PM)MonarchManiac Wrote:  What penalty? I never saw a flag??

It was the special flag no one else but the replay officials are allowed to see. They keep it next to that special clock only the replay officials are allowed to see.

We’re on a path toward somebody getting screwed on a play call, then 2 hours after the game ends, they’ll roll out an AI-modified view that they’ll claim was a special camera angle to which only the replay officials had access.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - SlickRick12 - 09-06-2026 08:14 PM

(09-06-2026 04:26 PM)MonarchManiac Wrote:  
(09-06-2026 03:42 PM)Luckyshot Wrote:  
(09-06-2026 02:45 PM)TTT Wrote:  WMU got hosed. They won that game, plain and simple. The actual field play clock—not the picture-in-picture TV clock—showed ZERO before the ball was touched. People can argue about other clocks all they want, but the field clock is the standard. It’s the clock visible to the players, coaches, officials, and 120,000 fans in the stadium. Field clocks don’t just magically become unsynced.

The bottom line: as a G5 playing a P4, you often feel like you have to beat both the team and the officials. Last night was a perfect example.

That said, WMU still cannot let that ball get caught. That was an epic failure on their part. Both things can be true: WMU got hosed, and WMU still blew it.

The game doesn't EVER end at zero on the clock if a play is already underway; and the rules of college football say the game can't end on a Defensive penalty. The clock only mattered when the ball was hiked. Was it above zero then? If so, the entire play counts. If during that play a Defender causes a penalty, then the Offense gets another play.
What penalty? I never saw a flag??

Sent from my SM-G781V using Tapatalk
Me either, WMU won that game.

Sent from my SM-S931U using Tapatalk


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Luckyshot - 09-06-2026 10:43 PM

I thought the D player touching the ball while out of bounds was a penalty, but checked the NCAA site and it doesn't call it a penalty and just calls it a dead ball. That makes the "secret clock no one else has access to" seem a bit suspect. I've switched sides on this one.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - Usajags - 09-07-2026 08:29 PM

If SMU losses this game in the dark, will he ***ch about it after agreeing to play?


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - GoBigRed26 - 09-08-2026 11:25 AM

(09-06-2026 04:21 PM)SkullyMaroo Wrote:  I have seen some try and defend the refs adding one second back to the clock saying the WMU player went out of bounds and touched the ball first. But if that was the case, then why didn’t the refs call illegal touching and move the ball up 5 yards? And if that is their reasoning, why not call the penalty and then play an untimed down? I think it’s because the intent of the refs was to give Michigan another chance, plain and simple.

Illegal touching doesn't exist for defensive players. Just offensive.

But the refs may have still intended to give Michigan another chance. Seems that mistakes like those only favor the "Power" school when they are down to the wire with a G5 (6) school. Happened to us years ago when we recovered an onsides against Texas to try and tie the game up. All because the ref couldn't count to 4. Big XII apologized for botching the call after the game, but that didn't do us any good.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - banker - 09-08-2026 08:51 PM

(09-06-2026 10:52 AM)banker Wrote:  I hate Michigan, but there was a second left. The effort they went to to prove that would not have been afforded WMU if the roles were reversed, but there was a second left.

The WMU player that touched the ball first had jumped from out of bounds which means the ball is dead the moment he touches it, not when it hits the ground. There was a second when he touched it.

After full research, I wish to recant my earlier statement. The photo put out showing the 0:01 on the clock when the player touched the ball can not be correct unless the Big Ten lied about the syncing of the clocks. Since the clocks were reset before the play (ref instructed the clock operator to put the clock at 9 seconds) all clocks would have started with exactly 9 seconds before the snap, meaning they would all have to hit zero at the same time.


RE: Is the SMU ###ch A## puzz# coach gonna chirp - WinstonTheWolf - 09-09-2026 04:16 AM

(09-08-2026 08:51 PM)banker Wrote:  
(09-06-2026 10:52 AM)banker Wrote:  I hate Michigan, but there was a second left. The effort they went to to prove that would not have been afforded WMU if the roles were reversed, but there was a second left.

The WMU player that touched the ball first had jumped from out of bounds which means the ball is dead the moment he touches it, not when it hits the ground. There was a second when he touched it.

After full research, I wish to recant my earlier statement. The photo put out showing the 0:01 on the clock when the player touched the ball can not be correct unless the Big Ten lied about the syncing of the clocks. Since the clocks were reset before the play (ref instructed the clock operator to put the clock at 9 seconds) all clocks would have started with exactly 9 seconds before the snap, meaning they would all have to hit zero at the same time.

This is the first I've heard about clock sync before the play.

I've heard through various podcasts and read in articles the following:
1. The sync issue between stadium, TV, and replay booth is a real and known issue.
2. Clocks were last synced by NBC broadcast and TV booth to stadium clocks 85 minutes before the game on the WMU Michigan game.
3. Fox syncs the clocks after each quarter.
4. Both broadcast cameras and Replay booth cameras are synced to stadium clocks separately - and the video/clock sync travels through different electronic data paths and to difference video systems.
5. This couldn't happen in the NFL because they will only put two or more seconds back on the clock, never just one. They acknowledge human latency between field whistle/referee signals and clock keeper's hands.
6. Main Fox rules analyst says it is protocol (not rule book) for Replay officials to recognize when broadcast video is off from replay video wrt clock sync, and in those cases replay officials are supposed to use the broadcast clock that we all see on TV to avoid the issue that just happened.

Feldman and Russo among others are sources for this.

Solution is transparency - need live broadcasts of replays like ACC. Big 10 evidently does that this season on Friday games only.

Related - I heard someone say that the video syncing BETWEEN cameras (like when you see 2 angles of a replay on TV and in video replay center at the same time) is difficult and sometimes there are frame drops.